般若 Prajñā · 書目Bibliography
本書目唯列本譯注實際依憑之典據——底本、漢譯異本、古德註疏,及唯識系互讀諸論。所載皆藏經現存之本,逐字徵引有據;現代校勘本、現代學者重構之說、現代英譯家之作,俱不入本書目(依本書體例:引據唯經與古德)。
一、底本(根本經)
| 題名 | 譯者·朝代 | 藏經號 | 卷·體 | 角色 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 般若波羅蜜多心經 | 唐 · 玄奘 奉詔譯(永徽元年 650 CE) | T08n0251 | 一卷·略本 268 字 | 底本(漢傳誦持最廣之本,無序分、無流通分) |
九段脊樑:觀自在 · 行深般若 · 照見五蘊皆空 · 度一切苦厄 · 色空相即 · 顯空六相 · 遣六門法 · 以無所得故 · 顯所得果+歎德咒。
藏內前冠明太祖御製序、唐釋慧忠序,非經文,verbatim 已除。
二、異譯(漢譯諸本·對勘校本)
異譯逐字對勘為考據之硬據;異文即義之所在。底本之外,漢譯七本並陳:
| 題名 | 譯者·朝代 | 藏經號 | 略/廣 | 對校角色 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 摩訶般若波羅蜜大明呪經 | 姚秦 · 鳩摩羅什 | T08n0250 | 略 | 「觀世音」「五陰」異文·獨有「色空故無惱壞相」節 |
| 普遍智藏般若波羅蜜多心經 | 唐 · 法月(重譯) | T08n0252 | 廣 | 廣本(具序分流通分) |
| 般若波羅蜜多心經 | 唐 · 般若共利言等 | T08n0253 | 廣 | 廣本·核心句近底本 |
| 般若波羅蜜多心經 | 唐 · 智慧輪 | T08n0254 | 廣 | 廣本 |
| 般若波羅蜜多心經 | 唐 · 法成 | T08n0255 | 廣 | 廣本 |
| 唐梵翻對字音般若波羅蜜多心經 | 唐 · 慈恩錄出(石壁本) | T08n0256 | 音寫對照 | 音寫對照本 |
| 佛說聖佛母般若波羅蜜多經 | 宋 · 施護 | T08n0257 | 廣(密咒型) | 「即色是空」型·獨冠「怛𭔞他唵」 |
略本二(羅什 T0250·玄奘 T0251,無「如是我聞」「信受奉行」);廣本五具序分+流通分。T0258(天息災 小字)、T0259(觀想佛母)有「觀自在」而無「色不異空」核心串,係別經,排除。
三、古德註疏(經與古德·唯一引據之師說)
漢地現存涉本經之古德疏,較他經遠富;本書目四取與各段義理直涉之古德逐字錄為主,唯識二疏為主錨:
| 撰者·朝代 | 著作 | 藏經號 | 宗 | 角色 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 唐 · 窺基 | 般若波羅蜜多心經幽贊(2 卷) | T33n1710 | 唯識(慈恩) | 主錨:以三性·三無性·八識·五重唯識觀·轉依讀心經 |
| 唐 · 圓測 | 般若波羅蜜多心經贊(1 卷) | T33n1711 | 唯識(西明) | 主錨:四門釋經·三分科判·清辨護法二宗·護法正義 |
| 唐 · 法藏 | 般若波羅蜜多心經略疏 | T33n1712 | 華嚴 | 旁參(般若·性起一路) |
| 宋 · 師會 述 | (記·釋法藏略疏) | T33n1713 | 華嚴 | 旁參 |
| 明 · 宗泐等 | 般若波羅蜜多心經註解 | T33n1714 | — | 旁參 |
| 唐宋 · 法雲·灌頂·湛然 等 | 諸家疏 | T33n1715–1717 | 天台等 | 旁參 |
心經疏豐,目四只取與本段義理直接相涉之古德 verbatim,唯識二疏(窺基·圓測)為主,餘家為旁證;不湊數、不為列名而引。
四、梵本
| 項 | 現況 |
|---|---|
| 現代校本 | 諸現代學者重構之梵·藏校勘本——列名不引,本書梵讀不以之為據。 |
| 古德所傳梵 | 玄奘·窺基·圓測 之音寫義譯(舍利子=奢利富多羅·涅槃=波利匿縛𠲸·般若=慧 等)為座標;圓測自有勘梵(「撿勘梵本,有『等』言故」)。 |
本書梵文唯依古德所傳為座標;現代重構之梵·藏校本不作經文出處。術語羅馬字一律標為發音輔助,繫於古德漢譯所還原之讀音,不立現代梵文校本目;無古德音可徵者從闕。
五、互讀(般若平行·唯識系下游·穩定徵引)
心經以唯識為鏡讀,其平行與下游論本如次;掛鏈依穩定徵引(藏經號·品號·頌號·loc):
| 題名 | 撰者·譯者 | 藏經號 | 承用/平行之義 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 大般若波羅蜜多經(相應品·觀照品) | 玄奘 譯 | T05n0220a·T07n0220c | 「色不異空…是諸法空相」最密 verbatim 平行〔0022b03·0011c03〕 |
| 金剛般若波羅蜜經 | 鳩摩羅什 譯 | T08n0235 | 般若姊妹·「即非」三性讀(唯識為鏡·已封 32 分) |
| 辯中邊論 | 世親(彌勒本頌) | T31n1600 | 三性蘊·空三種(護法四句之論本)·空相六義 |
| 唯識三十論頌 | 世親 | T31n1586 | 遍計所執性·圓成於依他遠離前性·轉依 |
| 唯識二十論 | 世親 | T31n1590 | 唯識無境·入法空(遣十二處之論本) |
| 攝大乘論 | 無著 | T31n1594 | 三性·二取·轉依 |
| 成唯識論 | 護法等·玄奘譯 | T31n1585 | 三性三無性·二取·四智轉依 |
| 大乘百法明門論 | 天親(世親) | T31n1614 | 五蘊·心心所(五蘊善巧所攝) |
| 解深密經 | 玄奘 譯 | T16n0676 | 三性·三無性·三時教之經源(圓測同註) |
掛鏈以穩定徵引為主;硬鏈只連已封單元(金剛經 ratified)。每互讀只列與本經義理實相關之平行/下游作,不湊數。
This bibliography lists only the sources this edition actually rests on — the base text, the alternate Chinese translations, the ancient-master commentaries, and the Yogācāra treatises read across. All are texts extant in the canon, cited character by character with a locus; modern critical editions, modern scholars' reconstructions, and modern English translations are not admitted (per this edition's convention: the cited authorities are scripture and the ancient masters only).
I. Base Text (Root Sūtra)
| Title | Translator · Dynasty | Canon no. | Fascicles · form | Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 般若波羅蜜多心經 Heart Sūtra | Tang · Xuanzang, by imperial commission (Yonghui 1, 650 CE) | T08n0251 | 1 fascicle · short recension, 268 characters | Base text (the most widely recited; no opening or circulation section) |
The nine-movement spine: Avalokiteśvara · coursing in the deep Prajñā · illuminating the emptiness of the five aggregates · crossing beyond all suffering · the mutual identity of form and emptiness · the six marks of emptiness · sweeping away the six gates · because there is nothing to attain · the Fruit attained plus the mantra of praise.
The imperial prefaces of the Ming founder and of Huizhong of the Tang, prefixed in the canon, are not the sūtra's words and have been removed verbatim.
II. Alternate Translations (the Chinese witnesses · for collation)
Word-by-word collation of the alternate translations is the hard ground of the apparatus; the variant readings are where the meaning lies. Beyond the base text, seven Chinese renderings are set side by side:
| Title | Translator · Dynasty | Canon no. | Short/long | Collation role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 摩訶般若波羅蜜大明呪經 | Later Qin · Kumārajīva | T08n0250 | short | "Guanshiyin" / "five heaps" variants · own passage "form being empty, there is no mark of ruin" |
| 普遍智藏般若波羅蜜多心經 | Tang · Dharmacandra (re-translation) | T08n0252 | long | long recension (with opening and circulation) |
| 般若波羅蜜多心經 | Tang · Prajñā-and-Liyan and others | T08n0253 | long | long recension · core lines close to Xuanzang's |
| 般若波羅蜜多心經 | Tang · Prajñācakra | T08n0254 | long | long recension |
| 般若波羅蜜多心經 | Tang · Dharmatāla | T08n0255 | long | long recension |
| 唐梵翻對字音般若波羅蜜多心經 | Tang · Ci'en (Shibi text) | T08n0256 | transliteration | Sanskrit-Chinese transliteration text |
| 佛說聖佛母般若波羅蜜多經 | Song · Dānapāla | T08n0257 | long (esoteric-mantra type) | "form itself is emptiness" order · mantra prefixed with "tadyathā oṃ" |
Two short recensions (Kumārajīva T0250 · Xuanzang T0251, lacking "thus have I heard" and "received and upheld"); five long recensions with opening and circulation sections. T0258 (Dānapāla, small-character) and T0259 (Contemplation Mother-of-Buddhas), which have "Avalokiteśvara" but not the "form is not other than emptiness" core string, are separate texts and excluded.
III. Ancient-Master Commentaries (scripture and the ancient masters · the sole cited authorities)
The surviving Han-land commentaries on this sūtra are far richer than for most texts; heading four of the apparatus takes those bearing directly on each movement's sense, verbatim, with the two Yogācāra commentaries as the main anchors:
| Author · Dynasty | Work | Canon no. | School | Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tang · Kuiji | 般若波羅蜜多心經幽贊 Youzan (2 fasc.) | T33n1710 | Yogācāra (Ci'en) | Main anchor: reads the Heart Sūtra through the three natures · three non-natures · eight consciousnesses · fivefold Consciousness-Only contemplation · transformation of the basis |
| Tang · Woncheuk | 般若波羅蜜多心經贊 Zan (1 fasc.) | T33n1711 | Yogācāra (Ximing) | Main anchor: four-gate exposition · three-part outline · the Bhāvaviveka/Dharmapāla tenets · Dharmapāla's settled sense |
| Tang · Fazang | 般若波羅蜜多心經略疏 Lüeshu | T33n1712 | Huayan | secondary reference (Prajñā · nature-origination) |
| Song · Shihui (recorded) | (a record on Fazang's Lüeshu) | T33n1713 | Huayan | secondary reference |
| Ming · Zonglei and others | 般若波羅蜜多心經註解 | T33n1714 | — | secondary reference |
| Tang–Song · Fayun · Guanding · Zhanran, etc. | various commentaries | T33n1715–1717 | Tiantai etc. | secondary reference |
The Heart Sūtra commentaries are abundant; heading four takes only ancient-master verbatim bearing directly on the movement's sense, with the two Yogācāra commentaries (Kuiji · Woncheuk) as the main matter, the rest as corroboration; nothing added, nothing cited for the sake of a name.
IV. Sanskrit
| Item | State |
|---|---|
| Modern editions | The modern scholars' reconstructed Sanskrit/Tibetan critical editions — named only, not cited; this edition's Sanskrit reading does not rest on them. |
| Ancient-master-transmitted Sanskrit | The transliterations and sense-renderings of Xuanzang, Kuiji, and Woncheuk (Śāriputra = 奢利富多羅 · parinirvāṇa = 波利匿縛𠲸 · prajñā = wisdom, and the like) as the coordinate; Woncheuk's own collation ("checking the Sanskrit text, there is the word 'and so forth'"). |
This edition's Sanskrit rests solely on what the ancient masters transmitted; modern reconstructed Sanskrit/Tibetan editions are not a source for the scripture's wording. Romanized terms are marked as a pronunciation aid, anchored to the readings recovered by the ancient masters' Chinese renderings; no modern Sanskrit-edition heading is set up, and where no ancient-master transliteration is attested the entry is left wanting.
V. Cross-Reading (Prajñā parallels · the Yogācāra downstream · stable citations)
The Heart Sūtra is read through the Yogācāra mirror; its parallels and downstream treatises are as follows, hung by stable citation (canon-number · chapter · verse · locus):
| Title | Author · Translator | Canon no. | The sense inherited / paralleled |
|---|---|---|---|
| 大般若波羅蜜多經 (Xiangying · Guanzhao chapters) | Xuanzang | T05n0220a · T07n0220c | the closest verbatim parallel to "form is not other than emptiness… all dharmas are marked with emptiness" 〔0022b03 · 0011c03〕 |
| 金剛般若波羅蜜經 Diamond Sūtra | Kumārajīva | T08n0235 | Prajñā sister · the "is not, therefore is" three-natures reading (Yogācāra mirror · sealed, 32 divisions) |
| 辯中邊論 Madhyāntavibhāga | Vasubandhu (Maitreya's root verses) | T31n1600 | three-natured aggregates · the three emptinesses (the treatise-ground of Dharmapāla's four-fold statement) · the six marks of emptiness |
| 唯識三十論頌 Triṃśikā | Vasubandhu | T31n1586 | the wholly-imagined nature · the perfectly-accomplished as ever apart, upon the other-dependent, from the prior nature · the transformation of the basis |
| 唯識二十論 Viṃśatikā | Vasubandhu | T31n1590 | Consciousness-Only without object · entering the emptiness of dharmas (the treatise-ground of sweeping away the twelve bases) |
| 攝大乘論 Mahāyāna-saṃgraha | Asaṅga | T31n1594 | the three natures · the two graspings · the transformation of the basis |
| 成唯識論 Cheng Weishi Lun | Dharmapāla et al. · tr. Xuanzang | T31n1585 | the three natures and three non-natures · the two graspings · the four wisdoms and the transformation of the basis |
| 大乘百法明門論 Śata-dharma treatise | Vasubandhu | T31n1614 | the five aggregates · the mind and mental factors (subsumed under the aggregate-skill) |
| 解深密經 Saṃdhinirmocana | Xuanzang | T16n0676 | the scriptural source of the three natures · three non-natures · three turnings (also annotated by Woncheuk) |
The hanging is by stable citation; hard links join only sealed units (the Diamond Sūtra is ratified). Each cross-reading lists only parallels or downstream works genuinely bearing on the sūtra's sense; nothing added for its own sake.
本書徵引唯經與古德——藏經(佛語)· 印度古德論(瑜伽行派祖師親注)· 漢地古德疏(諸宗競釋)· 經錄(譯史著錄)· 般若系互讀之經。梵本唯據古德所傳(玄奘・義淨・笈多之音寫義譯),不取現代刊本。全卷考據層之逐字徵引,悉出於下列藏內典籍。
一、原典與異譯(藏經・漢地六譯)
| 藏經號 | 書名 | 譯主 | 朝代 |
|---|---|---|---|
| T08n0235(原典) | 金剛般若波羅蜜經 | 鳩摩羅什 譯 | 後秦(初出) |
| T08n0236 | 金剛般若波羅蜜經 | 菩提流支 譯 | 元魏 |
| T08n0237 | 金剛般若波羅蜜經 | 真諦 譯 | 陳 |
| T08n0238 | 金剛能斷般若波羅蜜經 | 達摩笈多 譯 | 隋(大業年中) |
| T07n0220h | 大般若波羅蜜多經・第九會〈能斷金剛分〉(卷五七七) | 玄奘 譯 | 唐 |
| T08n0239 | 佛說能斷金剛般若波羅蜜多經 | 義淨 譯 | 唐 |
二、印度古德論(瑜伽行派祖師親注)
| 藏經號 | 書名 | 撰者 | 譯主・朝代 |
|---|---|---|---|
| T25n1510 | 金剛般若論 | 無著菩薩 造 | 達磨笈多 譯・隋 |
| T25n1511 | 金剛般若波羅蜜經論 | 世親(天親)菩薩 造 | 菩提流支 譯・元魏 |
| T25n1512 | 金剛仙論 | 世親菩薩 造・金剛仙論師 釋 | 菩提流支 譯・元魏 |
| T25n1513 | 能斷金剛般若波羅蜜多經論釋 | 無著菩薩 造頌・世親菩薩 釋 | 義淨 譯・唐 |
| T25n1514 | 能斷金剛般若波羅蜜多經論頌 | 無著菩薩 造 | 義淨 譯・唐 |
三、漢地古德疏(諸宗競釋)
| 藏經號 | 書名 | 撰者・朝代 | 宗 |
|---|---|---|---|
| T33n1698 | 金剛般若經疏 | 智顗 說・隋 | 天台 |
| T33n1699 | 金剛般若疏 | 吉藏 撰・隋 | 三論 |
| T33n1700 | 金剛般若經贊述 | 窺基 撰・唐 | 唯識(慈恩) |
| T33n1701 | 金剛般若經疏論纂要 | 宗密 述・唐(宋 子璿 治定) | 華嚴・禪 |
四、經錄(譯史)
| 藏經號 | 書名 | 撰者・朝代 |
|---|---|---|
| T55n2154 | 開元釋教錄 | 智昇 撰・唐 |
| T55n2145 | 出三藏記集 | 僧祐 撰・梁 |
五、般若系互讀(經)
| 藏經號 | 書名 | 譯主・朝代 |
|---|---|---|
| T07n0220 | 大般若波羅蜜多經 | 玄奘 譯・唐 |
| T08n0251 | 般若波羅蜜多心經 | 玄奘 譯・唐 |
This volume cites only scripture and the ancient masters — the canon (Buddha-word), the Indian treatises of the ancient masters (the Yogācāra patriarchs' own annotation), the commentaries of the ancient Chinese masters (the contending schools), the scriptural catalogues (records of the transmission), and the cross-reading sūtras of the Prajñā corpus. The Sanskrit is taken only as transmitted by the ancient masters (the transliterations and renderings of Xuanzang, Yijing, and Gupta); no modern edition is drawn upon. The word-for-word citations throughout the volume's apparatus all derive from the canonical works listed below.
I. Source text and variant renderings (canon · six Han renderings)
| Taishō no. | Title | Translator | Dynasty |
|---|---|---|---|
| T08n0235 (source) | Jingang bore boluomi jing 金剛般若波羅蜜經 | Kumārajīva | Later Qin (first issued) |
| T08n0236 | Jingang bore boluomi jing 金剛般若波羅蜜經 | Bodhiruci | Northern Wei |
| T08n0237 | Jingang bore boluomi jing 金剛般若波羅蜜經 | Paramārtha | Chen |
| T08n0238 | Jingang nengduan bore boluomi jing 金剛能斷般若波羅蜜經 | Dharmagupta | Sui (Daye era) |
| T07n0220h | Da bore boluomiduo jing, Ninth Assembly, "Nengduan jingang fen" 大般若波羅蜜多經・第九會〈能斷金剛分〉 (fasc. 577) | Xuanzang | Tang |
| T08n0239 | Foshuo nengduan jingang bore boluomiduo jing 佛說能斷金剛般若波羅蜜多經 | Yijing | Tang |
II. Indian treatises of the ancient masters (the Yogācāra patriarchs' own annotation)
| Taishō no. | Title | Author | Translator · Dynasty |
|---|---|---|---|
| T25n1510 | Jingang bore lun 金剛般若論 | Asaṅga 無著 | Dharmagupta · Sui |
| T25n1511 | Jingang bore boluomi jing lun 金剛般若波羅蜜經論 | Vasubandhu (Tianqin) 世親(天親) | Bodhiruci · Northern Wei |
| T25n1512 | Jingang xian lun 金剛仙論 | Vasubandhu 世親, expounded by the master Jingangxian 金剛仙 | Bodhiruci · Northern Wei |
| T25n1513 | Nengduan jingang bore boluomiduo jing lun shi 能斷金剛般若波羅蜜多經論釋 | verses by Asaṅga 無著, commentary by Vasubandhu 世親 | Yijing · Tang |
| T25n1514 | Nengduan jingang bore boluomiduo jing lun song 能斷金剛般若波羅蜜多經論頌 | Asaṅga 無著 | Yijing · Tang |
III. Commentaries of the ancient Chinese masters (the contending schools)
| Taishō no. | Title | Author · Dynasty | School |
|---|---|---|---|
| T33n1698 | Jingang bore jing shu 金剛般若經疏 | Zhiyi 智顗, spoken · Sui | Tiantai |
| T33n1699 | Jingang bore shu 金剛般若疏 | Jizang 吉藏, composed · Sui | Sanlun |
| T33n1700 | Jingang bore jing zanshu 金剛般若經贊述 | Kuiji 窺基, composed · Tang | Yogācāra (Ci'en) |
| T33n1701 | Jingang bore jing shulun zuanyao 金剛般若經疏論纂要 | Zongmi 宗密, narrated · Tang (redacted by Zixuan 子璿 · Song) | Huayan · Chan |
IV. Scriptural catalogues (records of the transmission)
| Taishō no. | Title | Author · Dynasty |
|---|---|---|
| T55n2154 | Kaiyuan shijiao lu 開元釋教錄 | Zhisheng 智昇 · Tang |
| T55n2145 | Chu sanzang jiji 出三藏記集 | Sengyou 僧祐 · Liang |
V. Cross-reading within the Prajñā corpus (sūtra)
| Taishō no. | Title | Translator · Dynasty |
|---|---|---|
| T07n0220 | Da bore boluomiduo jing 大般若波羅蜜多經 | Xuanzang · Tang |
| T08n0251 | Bore boluomiduo xin jing 般若波羅蜜多心經 | Xuanzang · Tang |
Shi Huijing · Zhiyue · jingang · Bibliography · Spring 2026
本書目只列本編實際依憑的底本、異譯、藏內勘同、經錄、僧傳與古來受容文獻。頁欄範圍均為本編所用之處,不表示全書只有這些內容。
一、底本與對讀經本
| 藏經號 | 題名 | 譯者·時代 | 本編所用頁欄 | 用途 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| T08n0232 | 文殊師利所說摩訶般若波羅蜜經 | 梁 · 曼陀羅仙譯 | 0726a23–0732c09 | 二卷底本,十三單元原典所據 |
| T08n0233 | 文殊師利所說般若波羅蜜經 | 梁 · 僧伽婆羅譯 | 0732c10–0739c28 | 同代異譯;卷下部分義段高度相承,卷末附文一併保存 |
| T07n0220 | 大般若波羅蜜多經 · 第七曼殊室利分 | 唐 · 玄奘奉詔譯 | 0964a–0974b | 卷五百七十四至五百七十五;後譯對讀 |
| T11n0310 | 大寶積經 · 文殊說般若會第四十六 | 唐 · 菩提流志奉詔譯之大寶積經編次;智昇錄明本會為曼陀羅仙第一譯勘同編入 | 0651a–0652a;0654b–0656c | 藏內勘同編入與整段承錄見證 |
二、譯史經錄與僧傳
| 藏經號 | 題名 | 撰者·時代 | 本編所用頁欄 | 用途 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| T49n2034 | 歷代三寶紀 | 隋 · 費長房撰 | 0098b01–0098c08 | 曼陀羅攜梵本、與僧伽婆羅共譯及兩本著錄 |
| T50n2060 | 續高僧傳 | 唐 · 道宣撰 | 0426a03–0426a26 | 僧伽婆羅傳與曼陀羅共譯《文殊般若》明文 |
| T55n2145 | 出三藏記集 | 梁 · 僧祐撰 | 0001a01–0114a23 | 全帙檢索;指定人名與經名無命中,如實記錄 |
| T55n2154 | 開元釋教錄 | 唐 · 智昇撰 | 0537b02–0537b17;0583b21–0583c01;0586b04–0586b08 | 二譯著錄、前後文有無一行三昧、寶積第四十六會勘同編入及誤題判語 |
三、禪、天台與起信疏系受容
| 藏經號 | 題名 | 撰者·時代 | 本編所用頁欄 | 用途 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| T85n2837 | 楞伽師資記 | 唐 · 淨覺集 | 1286c22–1287a05 | 道信法門明言依《文殊說般若經》一行三昧,並長引定義與修法 |
| T46n1911 | 摩訶止觀 | 隋 · 智顗說,灌頂記 | 0011a28–0011b01 | 常坐三昧出兩部文殊般若之明文 |
| T48n2008 | 六祖大師法寶壇經 | 唐 · 惠能說,元 · 宗寶編 | 0352c25–0353a01;0361a27–0361b03 | 正文六處一行三昧;前置契嵩〈贊〉另見 0346c05–0347a17 |
| T44n1846 | 大乘起信論義記 | 唐 · 法藏撰 | 0284a10–0284a13 | 引《文殊般若經》一行三昧定義 |
| T44n1844 | 起信論疏 | 新羅 · 元曉撰 | 0223b16–0223b19 | 引《文殊般若經》一行三昧問答 |
四、後世徵引
| 藏經號 | 題名 | 撰錄者·時代 | 本編所用頁欄 | 用途 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| X13n0287 | 楞嚴經疏解蒙鈔 | 明 · 錢謙益撰 | 0916a11–0916a14 | 徵引「汝坐道場乎」問答;只作後世會釋誌錄 |
| X24 | 金剛經註解 | 明 · 洪蓮編,錄陳雄說 | 0769c17–0769c21 | 徵引不住法、無住相問答;不倒灌為本經本義 |
| L164n1669 | 御錄經海一滴 | 清 · 胤禛錄 | 0401a06–0401a10 | 承錄菩提自在三昧及其照明、知名、達世界之文 |
五、梵本與藏譯
七百頌般若梵本與藏譯傳世,本編只列其存在,不取現代校刊本文字為經文出處。IAST 依漢傳古德所傳音寫作發音輔助;全詞無古德音寫可徵者從闕。
This bibliography lists only the base text, alternate translations, within-canon collation, catalogues, monastic biographies, and ancient reception literature actually used in this edition. The page-and-column ranges give the portions used here; they do not imply that the works contain nothing beyond those passages.
I. Base Text and Parallel Sūtra Witnesses
| Canon no. | Title | Translator · Period | Loci used | Use in this edition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| T08n0232 | 文殊師利所說摩訶般若波羅蜜經 · Mañjuśrī’s Teaching of the Mahā-Prajñāpāramitā Sūtra | Mandrasena 曼陀羅仙 · Liang | 0726a23–0732c09 | two-scroll base text; source for the thirteen reading units |
| T08n0233 | 文殊師利所說般若波羅蜜經 · Mañjuśrī’s Teaching of the Prajñāpāramitā Sūtra | Saṅghabhara 僧伽婆羅 · Liang | 0732c10–0739c28 | contemporaneous alternate translation; parts of the lower scroll share dense sense-unit parallels, and the appended ending is preserved with the text |
| T07n0220 | 大般若波羅蜜多經 · 第七曼殊室利分 · Mahā-Prajñāpāramitā Sūtra, Seventh Assembly, Mañjuśrī Division | Xuanzang 玄奘, translated under imperial decree · Tang | 0964a–0974b | fascicles 574–575; later translation used for parallel reading |
| T11n0310 | 大寶積經 · 文殊說般若會第四十六 · Mahāratnakūṭa Sūtra, Assembly 46, Mañjuśrī’s Teaching of Prajñā | the Mahāratnakūṭa collection translated under imperial decree by Bodhiruci 菩提流志 · Tang; Zhisheng’s catalogue identifies this assembly as Mandrasena’s first translation, collated as the same and incorporated | 0651a–0652a; 0654b–0656c | witness to within-canon collation and incorporation of extended passages |
II. Translation Histories, Catalogues, and Monastic Biography
| Canon no. | Title | Author · Period | Loci used | Use in this edition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| T49n2034 | 歷代三寶紀 · Records of the Three Treasures Throughout the Successive Dynasties (translation mine) | Fei Changfang 費長房 · Sui | 0098b01–0098c08 | Mandrasena’s bringing of the Sanskrit manuscript, collaboration with Saṅghabhara, and catalogue entries for the two translations |
| T50n2060 | 續高僧傳 · Continued Biographies of Eminent Monks | Daoxuan 道宣 · Tang | 0426a03–0426a26 | Saṅghabhara’s biography and the explicit record of his joint translation of the Mañjuśrī Prajñāpāramitā Sūtra with Mandrasena |
| T55n2145 | 出三藏記集 · Collection of Records on the Tripiṭaka | Sengyou 僧祐 · Liang | 0001a01–0114a23 | complete-text search; the specified personal names and sūtra titles do not occur, an absence recorded within the limits of this text |
| T55n2154 | 開元釋教錄 · Kaiyuan Catalogue of the Teaching | Zhisheng 智昇 · Tang | 0537b02–0537b17; 0583b21–0583c01; 0586b04–0586b08 | entries for the two translations, the presence or absence of single-practice samādhi in the surrounding recensions, incorporation as Assembly 46 of the Mahāratnakūṭa, and the statement concerning the mistaken translator attribution |
III. Reception in Chan, Tiantai, and the Awakening of Faith Commentarial Lineage
| Canon no. | Title | Author · Period | Loci used | Use in this edition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| T85n2837 | 楞伽師資記 · Record of the Masters and Disciples of the Laṅkā | Jingjue 淨覺, compiler · Tang | 1286c22–1287a05 | Daoxin’s Dharma-gate explicitly relies on the single-practice samādhi of the Mañjuśrī Teaching of Prajñā Sūtra and quotes its definition and practice at length |
| T46n1911 | 摩訶止觀 · Great Calming and Contemplation | Zhiyi 智顗, taught; Guanding 灌頂, recorded · Sui | 0011a28–0011b01 | explicit statement that the constant-sitting samādhi derives from two Mañjuśrī prajñā texts |
| T48n2008 | 六祖大師法寶壇經 · Platform Sūtra of the Sixth Patriarch | Huineng 惠能, taught; Zongbao 宗寶, compiled · Tang / Yuan recension | 0352c25–0353a01; 0361a27–0361b03 | six occurrences of single-practice samādhi in the canonical body; Qisong’s 契嵩 prefatory “Eulogy” is separately located at 0346c05–0347a17 |
| T44n1846 | 大乘起信論義記 · Record of the Meaning of the Awakening of Faith in the Great Vehicle | Fazang 法藏 · Tang | 0284a10–0284a13 | quotes the definition of single-practice samādhi from the Mañjuśrī Prajñāpāramitā Sūtra |
| T44n1844 | 起信論疏 · Commentary on the Awakening of Faith | Wonhyo 元曉 · Silla | 0223b16–0223b19 | quotes the question and opening of the single-practice-samādhi passage from the Mañjuśrī Prajñāpāramitā Sūtra |
IV. Later Citations
| Canon no. | Title | Compiler · Period | Loci used | Use in this edition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| X13n0287 | 楞嚴經疏解蒙鈔 · Collected Notes for Beginners on Explanations from Commentaries on the Śūraṅgama Sūtra (translation mine) | Qian Qianyi 錢謙益 · Ming | 0916a11–0916a14 | cites the exchange 「汝坐道場乎」— “Do you sit at the seat of awakening?”; recorded only as a later syncretic explanation |
| X24 | 金剛經註解 · Annotations on the Diamond Sūtra (translation mine) | Honglian 洪蓮, compiler, recording Chen Xiong 陳雄 | 0769c17–0769c21 | cites the exchanges on the dharma of non-abiding and the mark of non-abiding; not read back into the base sūtra as its own meaning |
| L164n1669 | 御錄經海一滴 · A Drop from the Ocean of Sūtras, Imperially Recorded (translation mine) | Yinzhen 胤禛, compiler · Qing | 0401a06–0401a10 | preserves the passage on samādhi of mastery in awakening and its functions as a Qing canonical selection witness |
V. Sanskrit and Tibetan Witnesses
Sanskrit and Tibetan witnesses of the seven-hundred-line Prajñāpāramitā survive. This edition lists their existence but does not treat the wording of a modern Sanskrit edition as the source of the sūtra. IAST is a pronunciation aid grounded in transliterations transmitted by the ancient masters; where no ancient transliteration of a full term can be cited, the form is left absent.
Shi Huijing · Zhiyue · Mañjuśrī Prajñāpāramitā · Bibliography · Summer 2026
本書目只列本編實際使用的漢傳藏內文獻。T475 控制底本文字;異譯與古疏只在所引段落承擔相應證據,不因列入書目而升格為共同底本。
一、底本與異譯
- 鳩摩羅什譯:《維摩詰所說經》,T14n0475,三卷十四品,正文〔0537a02–0557b26〕。本編原典與品界所據。
- 支謙譯:《佛說維摩詰經》,T14n0474,二卷十四品。古譯對讀;各品以實際共文、差異與頁欄為限。
- 玄奘譯:《說無垢稱經》,T14n0476,六卷十四品。後譯對讀,也是窺基 T1782 所依經本。
三本同傳十四品,不表示逐句全同。品名、人名、數量、詳略與有無段落各依傳本保存。
二、兩部主疏
- 《注維摩詰經》,T38n1775,十卷十四品,藏本題僧肇撰。正文保存什曰、肇曰、生曰等不同署名;本編逐條依實際注者分錄。
- 窺基:《說無垢稱經疏》,T38n1782,六卷十四品。依玄奘 T476 品脊、牒文與詞系疏解。
T1775 隨羅什本,T1782 隨玄奘本。兩部古疏在義疏末節並列傳錄,不互相改寫,也不被合成一個假定共同注釋。
三、校勘旁證
- 智顗說、湛然略:《維摩經略疏》,T38n1778。只在第七、九品已列出的校勘字形處作旁證。
- 智圓述:《維摩經略疏垂裕記》,T38n1779。只在第七品已列出的校勘字形處作旁證。
這兩部文獻不構成全帙第三主鏡;本編只在確有實引的校勘列中使用。
四、使用原則
異譯用來對讀實文,古疏用來傳錄古德之讀,校勘旁證用來顯示特定字形。三種證據不互相代位。引文保留作者、典名、藏經號與頁欄;無實文可核者不列。現代梵文校訂本與近現代學者不作羅什底文或義理權威。
This bibliography contains only Chinese canonical works actually used by the edition. T475 controls the base wording. Parallel translations and ancient commentaries bear only the particular evidence cited from them; inclusion here does not make them a common base text.
1. Base text and parallel translations
- Kumārajīva, trans. T14n0475《維摩詰所說經》, three fascicles and fourteen chapters, body〔0537a02–0557b26〕. Base for Source Text and chapter boundaries.
- Zhi Qian, trans. T14n0474《佛說維摩詰經》, two fascicles and fourteen chapters. Early comparison translation, used only for demonstrated shared passages, differences, and coordinates.
- Xuanzang, trans. T14n0476《說無垢稱經》, six fascicles and fourteen chapters. Later comparison translation and the scripture underlying Kuiji's T1782 commentary.
All three transmit fourteen chapters, but this does not establish word-for-word identity. Titles, names, numbers, amplitude, and the presence of passages remain attached to their recensions.
2. Two principal commentaries
- T38n1775《注維摩詰經》, ten fascicles and fourteen chapters, attributed in the canonical header to Sengzhao. The running text preserves comments marked separately as Kumārajīva, Sengzhao, and Daosheng; this edition attributes each passage accordingly.
- Kuiji, T38n1782《說無垢稱經疏》, six fascicles and fourteen chapters. A commentary on the chapter spine, lemmata, and terminology of Xuanzang's T476.
T1775 follows Kumārajīva; T1782 follows Xuanzang. Exposition transmits the two ancient mirrors side by side without rewriting one through the other or merging them into a hypothetical single commentary.
3. Occasional textual witnesses
- Zhiyi, teaching; Zhanran, abridgment: T38n1778《維摩經略疏》. Used only for the documented variant forms in Chapters Seven and Nine.
- Zhiyuan, T38n1779《維摩經略疏垂裕記》. Used only for the documented variant form in Chapter Seven.
These works do not become a third running mirror for the whole sūtra. They are cited only in the textual rows where their wording is actually used.
4. Use of these sources
Parallel translations establish textual comparison, ancient commentaries transmit ancient readings, and occasional witnesses document particular variants. These roles are not interchangeable. Quotations retain author, work, canonical number, and coordinate; no source is listed without actual use. Modern Sanskrit critical editions and modern scholars do not serve as authority for Kumārajīva's Chinese base wording or doctrinal claims.