大乘莊嚴經論 歸依品
歸依,不只是低頭求庇護,更是抬頭認家
趕路人遇上風雨,奔到屋簷下避身——這是一般的歸依:求一個依靠。大乘的歸依,卻是在避雨的同時立下一個志:我也要成為一座屋,讓天下趕路的人都有處可避。所以它不只是『找一個依靠』,更是『發願自己去做一切眾生的依靠』——這就是成佛。
本品說的,正是這『大乘的歸依』為什麼最殊勝。它的心量最廣(要度的是一切眾生),它的願行最剛健,它所得的果最宏大,是別的修行趕不上的。難發、難成,正因為它分量最重;越難,越該立大志。
本論還打了個貼切的比方:歸依大乘的菩薩像生在王家的王子——雖還未登位,作佛的種子已不斷絕。這是本品對已發心歸依者所作的譬說,不是對每位讀者預定成佛的宣告。
且抬起頭,認一認這個家。
Taking refuge is not only bowing your head to beg for shelter — it is lifting your head to recognize your home
A traveler caught in wind and rain runs to the eaves of a house to take cover — this is refuge as most people know it: seeking something to lean on. But the refuge of the great vehicle, even while sheltering from the rain, makes a vow: I too will become a house, so that every traveler under heaven has a place to take cover. So it is not merely "finding something to lean on" — it is "vowing to become, oneself, the refuge for all sentient beings." And this is to become a Buddha.
What this chapter tells is precisely why this "refuge of the great vehicle" is the most supreme. Its heart's reach is the widest (what it would deliver is all sentient beings); its vow and practice are the most robust; the fruit it attains is the most vast — a thing the other paths cannot catch up to. Hard to arouse, hard to accomplish: precisely because its weight is the heaviest. The harder it is, the greater the resolve one should set.
The treatise adds a fitting comparison: a bodhisattva who has taken refuge in the Great Vehicle is like a prince born into the royal house — though not yet enthroned, the seed of becoming a buddha is not cut off. This is the chapter's simile for one who has aroused the mind and taken refuge, not a declaration that every reader is predestined for buddhahood.
Lift your head, then, and recognize this home.
〔釋〕如此已成立大乘。次依大乘攝勝歸依。
【偈】
若人歸三寶, 大乘歸第一,
一切遍勇猛, 得果不及故。
〔釋〕一切歸依三寶中,應知大乘歸依最為第一。何以故?由四種大義自性勝故。何者四義?一者一切遍義、二者勇猛義、三者得果義、四者不及義。此義後當說。由此四義多有留難,諸歸依者或能不能,能者為勝。已說歸依勝,次勸勝歸依。
【偈】
難起亦難成, 應須大志意,
為成自他利, 當作勝歸依。
〔釋〕難起者,所謂勝願,由弘誓故。難成者,所謂勝行,由經無量劫故。由如此難,應須發大志意。何以故?為欲成就他利與自利故。他利者,所謂願行,由願行是名聞因故。自利者,所謂大義,由大義是自體果故。前說四義,今當先說一切遍義。
【偈】
眾生遍乘遍, 智遍寂滅遍,
是名智慧者, 四種一切遍。
〔釋〕大乘歸依者,有四種一切遍:一者眾生一切遍,欲度一切眾生故。二者乘一切遍,善解三乘故。三者智一切遍,通達二無我故。四者寂滅一切遍,生死涅槃體是一味,過惡功德不分別故。已說一切遍義,次說勇猛義。
【偈】
悕望佛菩提, 不退難行行,
諸佛平等覺, 勇猛勝有三。
〔釋〕大乘歸依,有三種勝勇猛:一願勝勇猛,歸依佛時求大菩提多生歡喜,知勝功德故。二者行勝勇猛,起修行時不退不屈,難行行故。三者果勝勇猛,至成佛時與一切諸佛平等覺故。復次由此勇猛,彼諸佛子恒得善生。
【偈】
發心與智度, 聚滿亦大慈,
種子及生母, 胎藏乳母勝。
〔釋〕菩薩善生,有四義:一者種子勝,以菩提心為種子故。二者生母勝,以般若波羅蜜為生母故。三者胎藏勝,以福智二聚住持為胎藏故。四者乳母勝,以大悲長養為乳母故。復次善生者,由勇猛故恒得勝身。
【偈】
妙相成生力, 大樂大方便,
如此四成就, 是名為勝身。
〔釋〕菩薩身勝,有四種:一者色勝,得妙相嚴身,勝轉輪王等相故。二者力勝,得成熟眾生自在力故。三者樂勝,得寂滅上品佛地無邊樂故。四者智勝,得救一切眾生大巧方便故。此四成就,是名佛子善生,所謂色成就、力成就、樂成就、智成就。復次由此勇猛,得與王子相似。
【偈】
光授法自在, 巧說善治攝,
由此四因故, 佛種則不斷。
〔釋〕由四因緣,王種不斷:一者入位受職、二者增上無違、三者善能決判、四者分明賞罰。善生佛子亦爾。一者蒙光授,謂一切諸佛與大光明令受職故。二者法自在,謂於一切法中智慧自在他無違故。三者能巧說,謂對佛眾中善說法故。四者善治罰,謂於學戒者過惡能治功德能攝故。復次由此勇猛,得與大臣相似。
【偈】
入度見覺分, 持密利眾生,
由此四因故, 得似於大臣。
〔釋〕有四種因,是大臣功德:一者入王禁宮、二者見王妙寶、三者祕王密語、四者自在賞賜。勇猛菩薩亦爾,一者常得善入諸波羅蜜;二者常見處處經中大菩提分寶,由不忘法故;三者常持如來身口意密;四者常能利益無邊眾生。已說勇猛義,次說得果義。
【偈】
福德及尊重, 有樂亦苦滅,
證樂證法陰, 習盡有滅捨。
〔釋〕大乘歸依者,得此八果:一者信解時得大福德聚。二者發心時得三有尊重。三者故意受生時得三有中樂。四者解自他平等時得大苦聚滅,亦得滅一切眾生苦力。五者入無生忍時覺證最上樂。六者得菩提時證大法陰。法陰者所謂法身,如此法身名為大、名為勝、名為常、名為善聚。是無邊修多羅等法藏故名大,一切法中最上故名勝,永無有盡故名常,為力無畏等善法積聚故名善聚。七者得熏習聚盡永滅無餘。八者得有滅捨。有捨者,不住生死;滅捨者,不住涅槃。已說得果義,次說不及義。
【偈】
大體及大義, 無邊及無盡,
由善世出世, 成熟神通故。
〔釋〕大乘歸依者所有善根,由四因故,一切聲聞辟支佛所不能及。一者大體、二者大義、三者無邊、四者無盡。問:此云何?答:大體者,謂世間善根,已得超過二乘故。大義者,謂出世善根,二乘出世但自利故。無邊者,謂成熟善根,能成熟無邊眾生故。無盡者,謂神通善根,至無餘涅槃亦無盡故。已說歸依勝義,次說歸依差別。
【偈】
希望及大悲, 種智亦不退,
三出及二得, 差別有六種。
〔釋〕歸依差別,有六種:一自性、二因、三果、四業、五相應、六品類。悕望為自性,至心求佛體故。大悲為因,為一切眾生故。種智為果,得無上菩提故。不退為業,行利他難行行不退不屈故。三出為相應,具足三乘出離行故。二得為品類,世俗得、法性得,麁細差別故。已說功德差別,次說行差別。
【偈】
歸依有大義, 功德聚增長,
意悲遍世間, 廣流大聖法。
〔釋〕大義謂自他利行。自利行者,謂功德增長。復有多種,若思度、若數數、若時節,皆無有量,由不可思度故、不可數知故。畢竟恒行,時無分齊故。他利行者,作意及悲遍一切眾生故、廣勤方便流大聖法故。大聖法者,大乘法故。歸依品究竟。
The canonical text stands in Chinese only. This edition renders the essence, the plain reading, the exposition and the apparatus into English — never the sūtra itself. Switch to 漢讀本 or 並行雙語 above to read it.
像前面那樣,已經成立了大乘(成宗品已立)。接著,就依大乘來攝取『最殊勝的歸依』。
若人歸三寶,大乘歸第一, 一切遍勇猛,得果不及故。
在一切歸依三寶之中,當知大乘的歸依最為第一。為什麼?因為它的自性,由四種「大」的義理而殊勝。是哪四種義?一、一切遍義;二、勇猛義;三、得果義;四、不及義。這四義,後文會一一說明。正因有這四義,所以多有種種留難(障難),歸依的人,有的能、有的不能;能的,便為殊勝。
已經說了『歸依的殊勝』,接著勸人作這殊勝的歸依。
難起亦難成,應須大志意, 為成自他利,當作勝歸依。
難起,指的是那殊勝的「願」——因為它是弘大的誓願(難以發起)。難成,指的是那殊勝的「行」——因為它須經歷無量劫(難以成辦)。正因有這樣的難,才更應當發起廣大的志意。為什麼?因為是要成就利他與自利的緣故。利他,指的是「願行」——因為願行是「名聞」(美名遠播)的因。自利,指的是「大義」——因為大義是「自體」(自身佛果之體)所得的果。
前面說了那四義,現在就先說「一切遍義」。
眾生遍乘遍,智遍寂滅遍, 是名智慧者,四種一切遍。
大乘的歸依者,有四種「一切遍」:一、眾生一切遍——因為要度盡一切眾生。二、乘一切遍——因為善能通解三乘(聲聞、緣覺、菩薩)之法。三、智一切遍——因為通達人、法二種無我。四、寂滅一切遍——因為了知生死與涅槃,其體是一味(同一不二),不在「過惡」(生死之過)與「功德」(涅槃之德)上妄作分別。
已經說了「一切遍義」,接著說「勇猛義」。
悕望佛菩提,不退難行行, 諸佛平等覺,勇猛勝有三。
大乘的歸依,有三種殊勝的勇猛:一、願勝勇猛——歸依佛時,希求大菩提而多生歡喜,因為深知它殊勝的功德。二、行勝勇猛——起而修行之時,不退、不屈,因為行的是難行之行。三、果勝勇猛——到了成佛之時,與一切諸佛平等而覺。再者,由於這樣的勇猛,那諸佛之子(菩薩),便恆常得到「善生」(殊勝的出生)。
發心與智度,聚滿亦大慈, 種子及生母,胎藏乳母勝。
菩薩的「善生」,有四義:一、種子勝——以菩提心為種子。二、生母勝——以般若波羅蜜為生母。三、胎藏勝——以福德、智慧二聚的住持為胎藏。四、乳母勝——以大悲的長養為乳母。再者,這「善生」的人,由於勇猛的緣故,恆常得到「勝身」(殊勝之身)。
妙相成生力,大樂大方便, 如此四成就,是名為勝身。
菩薩的「身勝」,有四種:一、色勝——得妙相莊嚴其身,勝過轉輪聖王等的相。二、力勝——得「成熟眾生」的自在力。三、樂勝——得寂滅上品、佛地的無邊之樂。四、智勝——得救度一切眾生的大巧方便。這四種成就,就名為佛子的「善生」,所謂色成就、力成就、樂成就、智成就。再者,由於這樣的勇猛,得與「王子」相似。
光授法自在,巧說善治攝, 由此四因故,佛種則不斷。
由四種因緣,使世間的王種不斷:一、入位受職(入太子位、受灌頂職);二、增上無違(位高而眾無能違);三、善能決判(善於裁斷政事);四、分明賞罰(賞罰分明)。「善生」的佛子也是這樣(由四因使佛種不斷):一、蒙光授——所謂一切諸佛放大光明,令他受灌頂之職。二、法自在——所謂於一切法之中智慧自在,他人無能違逆。三、能巧說——所謂在佛眾之中,善能宣說正法。四、善治罰(善治攝)——所謂對於持學戒的人,能治其過惡、能攝其功德。再者,由於這樣的勇猛,得與「大臣」相似。
入度見覺分,持密利眾生, 由此四因故,得似於大臣。
有四種因,是大臣的功德:一、入王的禁宮;二、見王的妙寶;三、祕守王的密語;四、自在地賞賜。勇猛的菩薩也是這樣:一、常能善入諸波羅蜜(如入禁宮)。二、因為不忘失法,常見到處處經中「大菩提分」之寶(如見妙寶)。三、常受持如來的身、口、意三密(如祕守密語)。四、常能利益無邊的眾生(如自在賞賜)。
已經說了「勇猛義」,接著說「得果義」。
福德及尊重,有樂亦苦滅, 證樂證法陰,習盡有滅捨。
大乘的歸依者,得這八種果:一、信解之時,得大福德之聚。二、發心之時,得三有(三界生死)中的尊重。三、(為度生而)故意受生之時,得三有之中的安樂。四、解了自他平等之時,得「大苦聚滅」(自身大苦聚的息滅),也得『能滅一切眾生苦』之力。五、入無生忍之時,覺證最上之樂。六、得菩提之時,證「大法陰」(法陰〔法身/法蘊〕)。所謂法陰,就是法身。這樣的法身,名為「大」、名為「勝」、名為「常」、名為「善聚」:因為是無邊契經等法藏(之所依),所以名為大;於一切法中最為上,所以名為勝;永遠沒有窮盡,所以名為常;為力、無畏等善法的積聚,所以名為善聚。七、得「熏習聚盡」——所熏習的聚永滅而無餘。八、得「有滅捨」——「有捨」,是不住於生死;「滅捨」,是不住於涅槃。
已經說了「得果義」,接著說「不及義」。
大體及大義,無邊及無盡, 由善世出世,成熟神通故。
大乘的歸依者所有的善根,由四種因,一切聲聞、辟支佛都不能企及:一、大體;二、大義;三、無邊;四、無盡。〔問〕這是怎麼說呢?〔答〕大體,指的是世間的善根,已經得以超過二乘。大義,指的是出世的善根——二乘的出世只是自利(這善根則能利他)。無邊,指的是「成熟」的善根,能成熟無邊的眾生。無盡,指的是「神通」的善根,直到無餘涅槃也不窮盡。
已經說了『歸依的殊勝義』,接著說『歸依的差別』。
希望及大悲,種智亦不退, 三出及二得,差別有六種。
歸依的差別,有六種:一、自性;二、因;三、果;四、業;五、相應;六、品類。以悕望為自性——因為至心希求佛體(佛果之體)。以大悲為因——因為是為了一切眾生。以種智(一切種智)為果——因為要得無上菩提。以不退為業——因為行利他的難行之行而不退、不屈。以三出為相應——因為具足三乘的出離行。以二得為品類——「世俗得」與「法性得」,是粗、細的差別。
已經說了『功德的差別』,接著說『行的差別』。
歸依有大義,功德聚增長, 意悲遍世間,廣流大聖法。
所謂「大義」,就是自利、利他之行。自利行,指的是功德的增長。這增長又有多種:無論是「思度」(思量)、「數數」(計數)、或「時節」(時分),都沒有限量——因為不可思度、不可數知,並且畢竟恆行、時無分齊(沒有時間的界限)。他利行,指的是以作意與悲心遍及一切眾生,並且廣大勤勉地以方便流布「大聖法」。所謂大聖法,就是大乘之法。
歸依品到此究竟(圓滿結束)。
As before, the great vehicle (大乘, mahāyāna) has now been established (the chapter Establishing the Teaching has set it up). Next, relying on the great vehicle, the text takes up "the most supreme refuge."
If a person takes refuge in the Three Jewels, to take refuge in the great vehicle is the first; all-pervading and valiant, [yet] in the fruit attained none can match it.
Among all refuges in the Three Jewels, know that taking refuge in the great vehicle is the very first. Why? Because its own nature is supreme through fourfold "great" meaning. Which four meanings? First, the meaning of being all-pervading; second, the meaning of valor; third, the meaning of the fruit attained; fourth, the meaning of being beyond reach. These four meanings will be explained one by one below. Precisely because it holds these four meanings, there are many hindrances of every kind; of those who would take this refuge, some are able and some are not — those who are able are the supreme ones.
Having spoken of the supremacy of this refuge, the text next exhorts one to make this supreme refuge.
Hard to arouse and hard to accomplish, it calls for great resolve; to accomplish the benefit of self and others, one should make the supreme refuge.
Hard to arouse refers to the supreme vow — for it is a vast pledge (and so hard to give rise to). Hard to accomplish refers to the supreme practice — for it must pass through immeasurable eons (and so is hard to bring to completion). Precisely because of such difficulty, one should all the more arouse a great and vast resolve. Why? Because it is in order to accomplish the benefit of others and the benefit of self. Benefit of others refers to the vow-and-practice — for vow-and-practice is the cause of good renown (a fine name spreading far). Benefit of self refers to the great purpose — for the great purpose is the fruit attained as one's own substance (the substance of one's own Buddha-fruit).
The four meanings were named above; now the text first speaks of the meaning of being all-pervading.
Beings all-pervading, the vehicles all-pervading, wisdom all-pervading, quiescence all-pervading — this is called the one of wisdom's fourfold all-pervading.
The one who takes refuge in the great vehicle has four kinds of "all-pervading": first, beings all-pervading — because one would deliver all sentient beings without exception. Second, the vehicles all-pervading — because one skillfully comprehends the dharma of the three vehicles (the listeners [śrāvaka], the solitary awakeners [pratyekabuddha], and the bodhisattvas). Third, wisdom all-pervading — because one penetrates the twofold no-self (the no-self of persons and the no-self of dharmas). Fourth, quiescence all-pervading — because one knows that saṃsāra [birth-and-death] and nirvāṇa are one in substance, of a single flavor (identical, not two), and does not falsely discriminate between "faults" (the faults of saṃsāra) and "qualities" (the qualities of nirvāṇa).
Having spoken of the meaning of being all-pervading, the text next speaks of the meaning of valor.
Aspiring to the Buddha's awakening, unretreating in practice hard to practice, the equal awakening of all Buddhas — valor supreme is threefold.
The refuge in the great vehicle has three kinds of supreme valor: first, valor supreme in vow — when taking refuge in the Buddha, one aspires to great awakening (大菩提, bodhi) and gives rise again and again to gladness, because one knows deeply its supreme qualities. Second, valor supreme in practice — when one rises up and cultivates practice, one does not retreat and does not bend, because what one practices is practice hard to practice. Third, valor supreme in fruit — when one reaches Buddhahood, one is awakened equal to all Buddhas. Further, by such valor, those children of the Buddhas (the bodhisattvas) constantly attain "the good birth" (a supreme birth).
Arousing the mind and the perfection of wisdom, the fullness of the stores and great compassion — as seed and as birth-mother, as womb and nurse, [these are] supreme.
The bodhisattva's "good birth" has four meanings: first, supremacy of seed — the mind of awakening (菩提心, bodhicitta) is the seed. Second, supremacy of birth-mother — the perfection of wisdom (般若波羅蜜, prajñā-pāramitā) is the birth-mother. Third, supremacy of womb — the upholding of the two stores of merit and wisdom is the womb. Fourth, supremacy of nurse — the nurturing of great compassion is the nurse. Further, this one of "good birth," by reason of valor, constantly attains "the supreme body" (a supreme body).
Wondrous marks, accomplishment, birth, and power, great bliss and great skillful means — these four accomplishments are what is called the supreme body.
The bodhisattva's "supremacy of body" is of four kinds: first, supremacy of form — one attains the wondrous marks that adorn the body, surpassing the marks of a wheel-turning king and the like. Second, supremacy of power — one attains the sovereign power to "ripen sentient beings." Third, supremacy of bliss — one attains the boundless bliss of the highest quiescence, the bliss of the Buddha-ground. Fourth, supremacy of wisdom — one attains the great skillful means to rescue and deliver all sentient beings. These four accomplishments are what is called the Buddha-child's "good birth" — namely, accomplishment of form, accomplishment of power, accomplishment of bliss, and accomplishment of wisdom. Further, by reason of such valor, one comes to resemble a "prince."
Radiance conferred, mastery of the dharma, skillful in speech and good at governing and gathering — by these four causes the Buddha-lineage is then unbroken.
By four causes the royal lineage of the world is kept unbroken: first, entering the [heir's] position and receiving investiture (entering the position of crown prince, receiving the office of consecration); second, being pre-eminent and unopposed (high in position, with none able to oppose); third, being skilled at deciding and judging (skilled in adjudicating affairs of state); fourth, being clear in reward and punishment (reward and punishment made plain). The Buddha-child of "good birth" is just so (by four causes the Buddha-lineage is kept unbroken): first, receiving the conferred radiance — namely, all the Buddhas send forth great radiance and grant him the office of consecration. Second, mastery of the dharma — namely, within all dharmas his wisdom is sovereign, and no other can oppose it. Third, skill in speech — namely, within the assembly of Buddhas, he is skilled at proclaiming the true dharma. Fourth, good at governing and gathering [善治罰;the verse reads 善治攝] — namely, toward those who uphold the training-precepts, he can govern their faults and gather in their qualities. Further, by reason of such valor, one comes to resemble a "great minister."
Entering the perfections, seeing the factors of awakening, upholding the secrets, benefiting beings — by these four causes one comes to resemble a great minister.
There are four causes that are the qualities of a great minister: first, entering the king's forbidden palace; second, seeing the king's wondrous treasures; third, keeping secret the king's confidential words; fourth, bestowing gifts at will. The valiant bodhisattva is just so: first, one is ever able to enter well into the perfections [波羅蜜, pāramitā] (as entering the forbidden palace). Second, because one does not forget the dharma, one ever sees, throughout the scriptures everywhere, the treasure of "the great factors of awakening" (as seeing the wondrous treasures). Third, one ever upholds the three secrets of the Tathāgata — of body, speech, and mind (as keeping secret the confidential words). Fourth, one is ever able to benefit boundless sentient beings (as bestowing gifts at will).
Having spoken of the meaning of valor, the text next speaks of the meaning of the fruit attained.
Merit and honor, existence-bliss and also the cessation of suffering, realized bliss and the realized store of dharmas, the exhaustion of perfuming, and the relinquishing of both existence and cessation.
The one who takes refuge in the great vehicle attains these eight fruits: first, at the time of confident understanding, one attains the great store of merit. Second, at the time of arousing the mind, one attains honor within the three existences [the birth-and-death of the three realms]. Third, at the time of deliberately taking birth (for the sake of delivering beings), one attains bliss within the three existences. Fourth, at the time of understanding the equality of self and other, one attains the "cessation of the great mass of suffering" (the stilling of one's own great mass of suffering), and also attains the power to "extinguish the suffering of all sentient beings." Fifth, at the time of entering the forbearance of the non-arising [of dharmas], one awakens to and realizes the highest bliss. Sixth, at the time of attaining awakening, one realizes the "great store of dharmas" (法陰 [the dharma-body / the dharma-mass]). This store of dharmas is the dharma-body. Such a dharma-body is called "great," called "supreme," called "constant," and called "the good aggregation": because it is the ground of the treasury of dharmas — boundless sūtras and the rest — it is called great; because it is the highest among all dharmas, it is called supreme; because it is forever without end, it is called constant; because it is the aggregation of wholesome dharmas such as the powers and the fearlessnesses, it is called the good aggregation. Seventh, one attains "the exhaustion of the aggregation of perfuming" — the perfumed aggregation [the store of latent impressions] is forever extinguished without remainder. Eighth, one attains "the relinquishing of both existence and cessation" — "relinquishing existence" is not abiding in saṃsāra; "relinquishing cessation" is not abiding in nirvāṇa.
Having spoken of the meaning of the fruit attained, the text next speaks of the meaning of being beyond reach.
Great substance and great purpose, boundless and inexhaustible, through the wholesome, worldly and world-transcending, and through ripening and supernormal power.
The wholesome roots possessed by the one who takes refuge in the great vehicle, by four causes, no listener or solitary Buddha [pratyekabuddha] can match: first, great substance; second, great purpose; third, boundless; fourth, inexhaustible. 〔Question〕 How is this so? 〔Answer〕 Great substance refers to the worldly wholesome roots, which already come to surpass those of the two vehicles. Great purpose refers to the world-transcending wholesome roots — for the world-transcendence of the two vehicles is merely for their own benefit (whereas these wholesome roots can benefit others). Boundless refers to the wholesome roots of "ripening," which can ripen boundless sentient beings. Inexhaustible refers to the wholesome roots of "supernormal power," which do not run dry even up to the nirvāṇa without remainder.
Having spoken of the supreme meaning of the refuge, the text next speaks of the divisions of the refuge.
Aspiration and great compassion, all-kinds-of-knowledge and non-retreat, the threefold going-forth and the twofold attainment — the divisions are of six kinds.
The refuge has six divisions: first, its own nature; second, its cause; third, its fruit; fourth, its work; fifth, its concomitance; sixth, its class. It takes aspiration [悕望] as its own nature — because with whole-hearted mind one seeks the Buddha-substance (the substance of the Buddha-fruit). It takes great compassion as its cause — because it is for the sake of all sentient beings. It takes all-kinds-of-knowledge (種智, sarvajñatā, the knowledge of all modes) as its fruit — because one would attain unsurpassed awakening. It takes non-retreat as its work — because in practicing the hard-to-practice practice of benefiting others one does not retreat and does not bend. It takes the threefold going-forth as its concomitance — because one is complete in the going-forth practice of the three vehicles. It takes the twofold attainment as its class — "conventional attainment" and "dharma-nature attainment," which are the difference between coarse and subtle.
Having spoken of the divisions of the qualities, the text next speaks of the divisions of practice.
Taking refuge holds a great purpose: the store of qualities grows and increases; with intention and compassion pervading the world, one broadly spreads the great and holy dharma.
The "great purpose" is the practice of benefiting self and other. The practice of benefiting self refers to the growth of qualities. This growth is again of many kinds: whether by "reckoning" (measuring), by "counting" (numbering), or by "time-span" (duration), it is without any limit — because it cannot be reckoned and cannot be known by counting, and because it is practiced constantly to the very end, its time without any bound. The practice of benefiting others refers to pervading all sentient beings with intention and compassion, and to spreading, broadly and diligently and by skillful means, the "great and holy dharma." The "great and holy dharma" is the dharma of the great vehicle.
Here the chapter on Taking Refuge reaches its consummation (comes to its complete fulfillment).
成宗品成立了大乘,學人既已信得過,第一步要做的事,就是「歸依」。但本品講的不是泛泛的歸依,而是『大乘的歸依』——它與一般的歸依,有一層根本的不同。
打個比方:一般的歸依,像一個趕路人遇上風雨,奔去一座屋簷下避身——求的是『自己有個依靠』。大乘的歸依,卻是趕路人在避雨的同時,立下一個志:我自己也要成為一座屋,讓天下趕路的人都有處可避。 所以大乘歸依,不只是『找一個依靠』,更是『發願自己去做一切眾生的依靠』(這就是成佛)。本品先說它為什麼最殊勝,再一路說到歸依者如何像王子般出生、長成,終得佛果。
一、大乘歸依為什麼最殊勝:四義
若人歸三寶,大乘歸第一, 一切遍勇猛,得果不及故。
在一切歸依三寶之中,本論說大乘的歸依最為第一,憑的是四種「大」:一切遍(心量周遍)、勇猛(願行剛健)、得果(所得宏大)、不及(餘乘趕不上)。也正因為它這樣高,發起來、走下去都難,能歸依的人不多;正因難能,才見其勝。
二、難起、難成,正該發大志
難起亦難成,應須大志意, 為成自他利,當作勝歸依。
本論坦言這條路的難:「願」難發(弘誓深廣,難起),「行」難圓(須經無量劫,難成)。但本論不是要人退,而是要人正因其難,越發要立大志。為什麼值得?因為這一歸依,成就的是『自他兩利』——對外,是利他的願行(願行是好名聲的因);對內,是自證的大義(大義是自身的果)。難,正是它分量重的證明。
三、一切遍:心量遍到哪裡
眾生遍乘遍,智遍寂滅遍, 是名智慧者,四種一切遍。
大乘歸依的第一個「大」,是心量的『周遍』,遍到四處:眾生遍(要度的是「一切」眾生,不揀親疏)、乘遍(三乘之法都通達,好應種種根機)、智遍(通達人、法二種無我,不留死角)、寂滅遍(了知生死與涅槃「體是一味」,不在這邊那邊妄分過惡與功德)。 這第四「寂滅遍」最深。本論的措辭是:生死與涅槃「體是一味」,於二者的過惡、功德不作分別。本疏據此傳述「寂滅遍」之義,不另加『同一實體因迷悟而有兩名』的判語。
四、勇猛與善生:佛子的出生
悕望佛菩提,不退難行行, 諸佛平等覺,勇猛勝有三。
第二個「大」是勇猛,有三段:願勝(歸依佛時求大菩提、滿心歡喜,因深知這覺的勝德)、行勝(一上路便不退不屈,專行難行之行)、果勝(成佛之時,與一切諸佛平等而覺——不是低一等的覺)。由這股勇猛,佛子便『恆得善生』——一次次得到殊勝的出生。
這「善生」,本論用一組入胎四喻來說,把成佛之道講成一場最自然的『生養』:
發心與智度,聚滿亦大慈, 種子及生母,胎藏乳母勝。
菩提心是種子、般若是生母、福智二聚是胎藏、大悲是乳母——信願種下、智慧孕育、福智養胎、大悲哺乳,一個覺者就這樣被生養出來。(這四喻與發心品所說相通,只「胎藏」一支,發心品取「大禪定樂」、本品取「福智二聚」,取譬略異而意一貫。)
妙相成生力,大樂大方便, 如此四成就,是名為勝身。
既已善生,便得「勝身」四成就:色勝(妙相莊嚴,勝過轉輪王)、力勝(成熟眾生的自在力)、樂勝(佛地無邊的寂滅之樂)、智勝(救度眾生的大巧方便)。色、力、樂、智俱足——這便是佛子善生之相。
五、佛子如王子、如大臣:佛種不斷
光授法自在,巧說善治攝, 由此四因故,佛種則不斷。
本論接著用一個極貼切的比方:佛子像「王子」。世間的王種所以不斷,靠四件事——受職即位、增上無人能違、善能裁斷、賞罰分明。佛子也有相對的四因,使『佛種不斷』:蒙光受職(諸佛放大光明、為他灌頂授位,如太子受冊)、法自在(於一切法智慧自在、無人能違)、能巧說(在佛眾中善能說法,如王子臨朝決事)、善治攝(對持戒的人,能治其過、能攝其德,如賞罰分明)。 這『蒙光受職』的景象,《華嚴經》十地品說得最明白:轉輪聖王正后所生的太子,王令他坐白象寶座,「取四大海水置金瓶內,王執此瓶灌太子頂」,水一灌頂,當下即名「受王職位」,列入灌頂剎利王的數中——「菩薩受職亦復如是,諸佛智水灌其頂故,名為受職」,便墮入佛數。〔疏借喻·《華嚴經》十地品(法雲地)〕世間以四大海水灌頂而立王,佛家以諸佛智水灌頂而授覺位——『蒙光受職』正是這一灌。
這比方的深意是:佛子雖還未成佛,卻已生在佛家,註定要登上覺位。 歸依大乘,就是『認得自己生在佛家、是紹繼佛位的王子』——不是寄人籬下的求庇者。
入度見覺分,持密利眾生, 由此四因故,得似於大臣。
不只像王子,還像「大臣」——能親預機要、辦得了大事。大臣有四能:入王禁宮、得見王家妙寶、與聞王之密語、自在頒行賞賜。勇猛的菩薩也有四能:常入諸波羅蜜(如入禁宮)、常見諸經中的大菩提分之寶(因不忘法,如見妙寶)、常持如來身口意三密(如與聞密語)、常利益無邊眾生(如自在賞賜)。既是紹位的王子,又是辦事的大臣——歸依大乘者,於佛家是這樣的身分。
六、歸依所得的果:八種果與法身
福德及尊重,有樂亦苦滅, 證樂證法陰,習盡有滅捨。
本論數出大乘歸依的八種果,由淺入深,像一條成佛的路標:信解時得大福德聚→發心時得三界中的尊重→(為度生而)受生時得三有中的安樂→解自他平等時得大苦滅、兼得「滅一切眾生苦」之力→入無生忍時覺證最上樂→得菩提時證得法身→所熏之染永滅無餘→終得有滅捨。 其中第六的「法身」,本論特別讚它四名:大(為無邊契經法藏所依,如大海納百川)、勝(一切法中最上)、常(永無有盡)、善聚(力、無畏等一切善法的積聚)。而最後的「有滅捨」最堪玩味:「有捨」是不住生死、「滅捨」是不住涅槃——兩邊都不停住。這正是大悲者的歸宿:能安住涅槃而不肯獨住,為眾生長在生死中行——歸依的果,落在這『不住兩邊』的悲智上。
七、餘乘不及、六種差別、自他之行
大體及大義,無邊及無盡, 由善世出世,成熟神通故。
第四個「大」是「不及」:大乘歸依者的善根,二乘趕不上——世間善根已超過二乘(大體)、出世善根能利他而非只自利(大義)、成熟善根能成熟無邊眾生(無邊)、神通善根至無餘涅槃也不盡(無盡)。
希望及大悲,種智亦不退, 三出及二得,差別有六種。
本論再從六個角度給歸依分判:以悕望為自性(至心求佛)、以大悲為因(為一切眾生)、以種智為果(得無上覺)、以不退為業(利他難行而不屈)、以三出為相應(具足三乘出離)、以二得為品類(世俗得、法性得之粗細)。一個「歸依」,原來有這麼多層次。
歸依有大義,功德聚增長, 意悲遍世間,廣流大聖法。
末了點出歸依的「大義」就是自利利他之行:對內,功德不斷增長,無量無邊(怎麼思量、計數、論時節都量不盡,因它畢竟恆行);對外,以作意與悲心遍及一切眾生,廣興方便、流布「大聖法」(即大乘)。歸依之為「大」,最終要落在這『悲遍世間、廣流正法』的實行上。
結:歸依,是抬頭認家
通看全品,歸依品說的是『大乘的歸依』之所以為大:它遍(心量周遍眾生、乘、智、寂滅)、勇(願行果三勝)、得大果(八果終於法身、不住兩邊)、餘乘不及(四種超勝),中間以入胎四喻、王子大臣之譬,顯歸依者是『生在佛家、紹繼佛位』的佛子。
一句話收束:大乘的歸依,不只是低頭求一個庇護,更是抬頭認得自己生在佛家、立志去做一切眾生的依靠。 有了這樣的歸依,下文的發心、二利、乃至全副菩薩道,才都有了立足的根。
The Chapter on Establishing the Teaching established the great vehicle; and now that the student can trust it, the very first thing to be done is to "take refuge." But what this chapter treats is not refuge in the ordinary sense — it is the "refuge of the great vehicle," which differs from ordinary refuge at one root point.
Here is a comparison. Ordinary refuge is like a traveler caught in wind and rain who runs to shelter under some eaves — what he seeks is "a support for himself." The refuge of the great vehicle, however, is a traveler who, even as he shelters from the rain, sets up a resolve: I too will become a house, so that every traveler under heaven may have a place to shelter. So the great vehicle's refuge is not merely "finding a support"; it is "vowing to make oneself the support of all sentient beings" (which is just becoming a buddha). This chapter first tells why it is the most supreme of refuges, and then goes on, step by step, to how the one who takes refuge is born and grows up like a prince, and at last attains the buddha-fruit.
I. Why the great vehicle's refuge is the most supreme: the four marks
If a person takes refuge in the Three Jewels, the great vehicle's refuge is the first; for it is all-pervading and valorous, and in its fruit attained none can match it.
Among all refuges in the Three Jewels, the treatise says the great vehicle's refuge is the very first, and this rests on four kinds of "greatness": all-pervading (a boundless breadth of mind), valorous (vow and practice both robust), fruit attained (what is gained is vast), and unmatched (the other vehicles cannot catch up). And precisely because it stands so high, it is hard both to arouse and to carry through, and those able to take it are few; precisely because it is so hard, its supremacy shows.
II. Hard to arouse and hard to accomplish — all the more should one set up a great resolve
Hard to arouse and hard to accomplish; one must have a great resolve of mind; in order to accomplish the benefit of self and others, one should make the supreme refuge.
The treatise states plainly how hard this road is: the "vow" is hard to arouse (for the great vow runs deep and wide), and the "practice" is hard to bring to fullness (for it must pass through measureless eons). Yet its point is not that one should draw back, but that precisely because it is hard, all the more should one set up a great resolve. Why is it worth it? Because this one refuge accomplishes "the twofold benefit of self and others" — outwardly, the vow-and-practice of benefiting others (vow-and-practice is the cause of good renown); inwardly, the great meaning realized for oneself (the great meaning is the fruit of one's own substance). Its very difficulty is proof of how much it weighs.
III. The all-pervading: how far the breadth of mind reaches
Pervading beings, pervading the vehicles, pervading in wisdom, pervading in the quelling, this is called, of the one of wisdom, the fourfold all-pervading.
The first "greatness" of the great vehicle's refuge is the "pervasion" of the breadth of mind, pervading to four places: pervading beings (what one would deliver is "all" sentient beings, with no picking of near from far), pervading the vehicles (one is versed in the dharmas of all three vehicles, the better to meet every kind of capacity), pervading in wisdom (one has penetrated both kinds of no-self — of persons and of dharmas — leaving no dead corner), and pervading in the quelling (one knows that saṃsāra and nirvāṇa are "one taste in substance," and no longer falsely parcels out fault on the one side and merit on the other).
This fourth, "pervading in the quelling," is the deepest. The treatise's wording is that saṃsāra and nirvāṇa are "one taste in substance" and that fault and merit are not discriminated between them. This exposition reports that account of "pervading in the quelling" without adding that they are one identical substance bearing two names according to delusion and awakening.
IV. The valorous and the good birth: the birth of a child of the Buddha
Longing for the buddha-awakening, the arduous practice never turning back, the awakening equal with all the buddhas — the valorous supremacy has three.
The second "greatness" is the valorous, in three parts: supreme vow (when taking refuge in the Buddha one seeks the great awakening and is filled with joy, for one knows well the surpassing virtue of that awakening), supreme practice (once on the road one neither turns back nor bends, but singly practices the arduous practices), and supreme fruit (in becoming a buddha, one is awakened equal with all the buddhas — not an awakening a rank lower). By this valor, the child of the Buddha "ever attains a good birth" — again and again receiving an excellent birth.
This "good birth" the treatise sets out through a set of four womb-similes, telling the road to buddhahood as a most natural "bearing and rearing":
Arousing the mind and the perfection of wisdom, the store filled to fullness, and great loving-kindness — the seed and the birth-mother, the womb and the nurse, are excellent.
The mind of awakening is the seed, the perfection of wisdom is the birth-mother, the two stores of merit and wisdom are the womb, and great compassion is the nurse — faith and vow are sown, wisdom conceives, merit-and-wisdom nourishes the womb, great compassion gives suck; and just so is an awakened one borne and reared. (These four similes accord with what the Chapter on Arousing the Mind says; only in the one item "womb" do they differ — the Chapter on Arousing the Mind takes "the great bliss of meditative concentration," this chapter takes "the two stores of merit and wisdom" — the figure taken differing a little, the sense running through as one.)
The excellent marks accomplish the power of birth, great bliss and great skillful means: these four accomplishments — this is called the excellent body.
Having been well born, one gains the four accomplishments of the "excellent body": supremacy of form (the body adorned with excellent marks, surpassing that of a wheel-turning king), supremacy of power (the sovereign power to bring sentient beings to maturity), supremacy of bliss (the boundless bliss of quelling at the buddha-ground, of the highest kind), and supremacy of wisdom (the great skillful means to save sentient beings). Form, power, bliss, and wisdom all complete — this is the mark of the Buddha's child being well born.
V. The child of the Buddha as prince and as great minister: the buddha-lineage unbroken
Light and installation, sovereignty in the Dharma, skill in teaching, good governance and gathering: by these four causes, the buddha-lineage is not cut off.
The treatise next draws an apt comparison: the child of the Buddha is like a "prince." In the world, the royal lineage is unbroken because of four things — receiving the office and ascending the throne, an ascendancy that none can defy, skill in judging and deciding, and clear reward and punishment. The child of the Buddha has four corresponding causes that keep "the buddha-lineage unbroken": receiving light and being installed (all the buddhas send forth a great light and, consecrating him, install him in his office, as the crown prince receives his investiture), sovereignty in the Dharma (in all dharmas his wisdom is sovereign and none can defy him), skill in teaching (amid the assembly of buddhas he skillfully expounds the Dharma, as a prince decides affairs before the court), and good governance and gathering (toward those who keep the precepts, he can govern their faults and gather in their merits, as reward and punishment are made clear).
The scene of this "receiving light and being installed" is set out most plainly in the Avataṃsaka Sūtra, Chapter on the Ten Grounds: the crown prince born of the chief queen of a wheel-turning sacred king is set by the king's command upon a white-elephant throne; "one takes the water of the four great oceans and puts it in a golden vase, and the king takes this vase and pours it over the crown prince's head," and the moment the water is poured over his head, he is at once said to "receive the royal office," and is counted among the anointed kṣatriya kings — "the bodhisattva's receiving of office is likewise: because the buddhas' water of wisdom is poured over his head, it is called receiving office," and he falls thereby into the number of the buddhas.〔exposition-borrowed simile · Avataṃsaka Sūtra, Chapter on the Ten Grounds (the Dharma-Cloud ground)〕The world, by the water of the four great oceans poured over the head, sets up a king; the house of the Buddha, by the buddhas' water of wisdom poured over the head, confers the office of awakening — "receiving light and being installed" is just this pouring.
The deep sense of this comparison is: though the child of the Buddha has not yet become a buddha, he is already born into the house of the Buddha and destined to ascend the seat of awakening. To take refuge in the great vehicle is to "recognize that one is born into the house of the Buddha, a prince who succeeds to the buddha-throne" — not a shelter-seeker lodging under another's roof.
Entering the perfections, seeing the factors of awakening, holding the secrets, benefiting sentient beings: by these four causes, he comes to resemble a great minister.
Not only like a prince, but also like a "great minister" — one who can take part in the vital business and get great things done. A great minister has four capacities: to enter the king's forbidden palace, to behold the royal house's wondrous treasures, to be privy to the king's secret words, and to bestow rewards at will. The valorous bodhisattva has four capacities too: ever entering well the perfections (as one enters the forbidden palace), ever beholding, in scripture after scripture, the treasure of the factors of the great awakening (because he does not forget the Dharma, as one beholds the wondrous treasures), ever holding the three secrets of the Tathāgata's body, speech, and mind (as one is privy to the secret words), and ever benefiting boundless sentient beings (as one bestows rewards at will). Both a prince who succeeds to the throne and a minister who handles affairs — such is the standing, in the house of the Buddha, of one who takes refuge in the great vehicle.
VI. The fruit gained by taking refuge: the eight fruits and the dharma-body
Merit and honor, the bliss of existence and the ending of suffering, the realized bliss and the realized dharma-mass, the perfuming exhausted, existence-relinquished and cessation-relinquished.
The treatise counts out the eight fruits of the great vehicle's refuge, from shallow to deep, like a set of milestones on the road to buddhahood: at the time of resolute faith one gains a great store of merit → at the time of arousing the mind one gains honor within the three realms → when (for the sake of delivering beings) one takes birth, one gains bliss within the three modes of existence → when one understands the equality of self and others one gains the ending of the great mass of suffering, and gains too the power to "end the suffering of all sentient beings" → when one enters the acceptance of the non-arising of dharmas one realizes the highest bliss → when one attains awakening one realizes the dharma-body → the perfuming one has undergone, being defiled, is forever ended without remainder → and at last one gains the relinquishing of existence and of cessation.
Of these, the sixth, the "dharma-body," the treatise especially praises with four names: great (for it is the ground on which the boundless treasury of scriptural dharma rests, as the great ocean takes in the hundred rivers), supreme (the highest among all dharmas), constant (never coming to an end), and the store of the good (the amassing of all good dharmas — the powers, the fearlessnesses, and the rest). And the last, "existence-relinquished and cessation-relinquished," is most worth pondering: "relinquishing existence" is not abiding in saṃsāra, "relinquishing cessation" is not abiding in nirvāṇa — one halts at neither side. This is precisely the resting-place of the greatly compassionate one: able to abide in nirvāṇa yet unwilling to abide there alone, he stays long in saṃsāra for the sake of sentient beings — the fruit of refuge comes to rest on this compassion-and-wisdom of "not abiding at either side."
VII. The other vehicles cannot match it, the sixfold distinction, the practice of self and others
Great in substance and great in meaning, boundless and inexhaustible, by the good, mundane and supramundane, by maturing and by supernormal powers.
The fourth "greatness" is "unmatched": the roots of good of one who takes refuge in the great vehicle are such that the two vehicles cannot catch up — his mundane roots of good already surpass those of the two vehicles (great in substance), his supramundane roots of good can benefit others and not only himself (great in meaning), his maturing roots of good can bring boundless sentient beings to maturity (boundless), and his supernormal-power roots of good are inexhaustible even up to the nirvāṇa without remainder (inexhaustible).
Longing and great compassion, all-kinds-of-knowledge and non-retrogression, the threefold going-forth and the twofold attainment: the distinction has six kinds.
The treatise then distinguishes refuge from six angles: with longing as its own nature (seeking buddhahood with the whole heart), with great compassion as its cause (for the sake of all sentient beings), with all-kinds-of-knowledge (種智, the omniscient knowledge of the buddha-fruit) as its fruit (attaining the unsurpassed awakening), with non-retrogression as its function (never bending in the arduous, others-benefiting practice), with the threefold going-forth as its correspondence (complete in the going-forth of all three vehicles), and with the twofold attainment as its class (the mundane attainment and the dharma-nature attainment, coarse and fine). One "refuge," it turns out, has this many layers.
Refuge holds a great meaning, the store of merit grows and increases, with mind and compassion pervading the world, broadly spreading the great sacred Dharma.
Finally he points out that the "great meaning" of refuge is just the practice of benefiting self and others: inwardly, the merit grows without ceasing, measureless and boundless (however one ponders it, counts it, or reckons its span of time, it cannot be measured out, for it runs on to the very end); outwardly, with an intending mind and with compassion it pervades all sentient beings, broadly raising up skillful means and spreading abroad the "great sacred Dharma" (which is the great vehicle). That refuge is "great" comes at last to rest on this actual practice of "compassion pervading the world, broadly spreading the true Dharma."
Conclusion: taking refuge is lifting one's head and recognizing one's home
Read whole, the Chapter on Taking Refuge tells why the "refuge of the great vehicle" is great: it pervades (the breadth of mind pervading beings, the vehicles, wisdom, and the quelling), it is valorous (supreme in vow, practice, and fruit), it gains a great fruit (the eight fruits ending in the dharma-body, abiding at neither side), and the other vehicles cannot match it (four kinds of surpassing); and in between, through the four womb-similes and the figures of the prince and the great minister, it shows that the one who takes refuge is a child of the Buddha, "born into the house of the Buddha and succeeding to the buddha-throne."
To close in one line: the refuge of the great vehicle is not merely bowing the head to beg a shelter, but lifting the head to recognize that one is born into the house of the Buddha, and resolving to become oneself the support of all sentient beings. With a refuge like this, all that follows below — arousing the mind, the twofold benefit, and the whole of the bodhisattva path — finds the ground on which to stand.
考據Apparatus
一 科判定位
歸依品居脊樑第三,承成宗品(「已成立大乘,次依大乘攝勝歸依」)。品內:標勝(大乘歸依第一·四義)→ 勸(難起難成·應發大志意)→ 四義詳釋〔一切遍4 · 勇猛3(附善生四義·勝身四·似王子四·似大臣四)· 得果8 · 不及4〕→ 差別六 → 行差別(自利·他利)。
二 譯名對校(本論無別譯·與玄奘系同義對列)
| 本品(波羅頗譯) | 玄奘系同義 | 說 |
|---|---|---|
| 歸依 | 歸依(śaraṇa-gamana) | 投誠依止 |
| 法陰 | 法身(dharma-kāya) | 本品「大法陰」即法身 |
| 二乘 | 聲聞·辟支佛乘 | 不及義之對顯 |
| 無生忍 | 無生法忍 | 通 |
| 轉輪王 | 轉輪聖王 | 妙相之對顯 |
三 義之所立(眼)
本品立大乘歸依為最勝(別於通說之三寶歸依),以四義顯之:一切遍(眾生·乘·智·寂滅)· 勇猛(願·行·果)· 得果(八果)· 不及(餘乘所不及四)。中以「善生」一脈(入胎四喻→勝身→似王子→似大臣)顯佛子之尊貴與「佛種不斷」;得果義收於法身(大·勝·常·善聚)與「有滅捨」(有捨=不住生死·滅捨=不住涅槃)。系內承用:攝大乘論(歸依)· 瑜伽·菩薩地。
四 徵引(系內互見)
- 入胎四喻 系內互見:本品(種子=菩提心·生母=般若·胎藏=福智二聚住持·乳母=大悲)與發心品(胎藏=大禪定樂)同喻而「胎藏」一支取譬有異——並錄其變異,不強齊,亦不判優劣。
五 名相(首見·義)
- 歸依:至心投誠、依止三寶;本品專顯「大乘歸依」之勝。
- 一切遍:周遍無遺(眾生·乘·智·寂滅四處皆遍)。
- 善生:由勝勇猛而得之殊勝出生(佛子之生)。
- 法陰/法身:證菩提所得之身,名大·勝·常·善聚。
- 無生忍:安忍諸法無生之理。
- 有滅捨:有捨——不住生死;滅捨——不住涅槃(無住處涅槃之雙離)。
- 二得:世俗得·法性得(歸依之粗細二品)。三出:具足三乘出離行。
六 譬喻
- 入胎四喻:種子(菩提心)· 生母(般若)· 胎藏(福智二聚住持)· 乳母(大悲)——喻佛子之孕育長養。
- 似王子四:蒙光受職· 法自在· 能巧說· 善治攝——喻「佛種不斷」(如王種以受職·無違·決判·賞罰而不斷)。
- 似大臣四:入諸度(如入禁宮)· 見菩提分寶(如見妙寶)· 持如來三密(如知密語)· 利無邊眾生(如自在賞賜)。 全屬王室·孕育之潔淨喻。
義疏跨品互證
- 〔大禪定樂〕:本論發心品 T31n1604 0596b06 —「大禪定樂為胎藏故」。義疏以其中「大禪定樂」回釋本品入胎四喻。
義疏借喻坐實(非本論自有)
義疏為助開解所引之他經譬喻/經證,本論無此文;坐實出處如下,與本論自有諸喻區別,並錄以對等底料。
- 〔蒙光受職·灌頂王子喻〕:《大方廣佛華嚴經》(八十華嚴)T10n0279 卷三十九·十地品·法雲地 0206a23–a27 —「取四大海水置金瓶內,王執此瓶灌太子頂,是時即名受王職位,墮在灌頂剎利王數……菩薩受職亦復如是,諸佛智水灌其頂故,名為受職」。義疏用於〔§五 似王子四·釋『蒙光受職』義——以世間四大海水灌頂立王,對顯佛家諸佛智水灌頂授覺位〕。(按:義疏 note 原標 0442a26,CBETA 核對實為 0206a23–a27,從校碼正。)
七 互讀
- 發心品:入胎四喻·善生(胎藏一支取譬有異,§四已誌)。
- 攝大乘論(歸依)· 瑜伽·菩薩地。
八 校本定位
本品 T31n1604 0593a03–0594a25(歸依品究竟)。
I. Doctrinal-structural placement (科判定位)
The Chapter on Taking Refuge stands third along the spine; it succeeds the Chapter on Establishing the Teaching ("the great vehicle having been established, next, in reliance on the great vehicle, the supreme refuge is embraced"). Within the chapter: marking the supremacy (the refuge of the great vehicle is foremost · the four meanings) → exhortation (hard to arouse and hard to accomplish · one should arouse the great resolve of mind) → detailed exposition of the four meanings 〔all-pervading, four · valiant, three (with the four meanings of the good birth appended · the four of the supreme body · the four of resembling the prince · the four of resembling the great minister) · the fruits obtained, eight · what is not matched, four〕 → the six differentiations → the differentiation of practice (self-benefit · benefit of others).
II. Cross-translation collation (譯名對校 · this treatise has no separate rendering; set out alongside the synonymous Xuanzang-lineage terms)
| This chapter (Prabhākaramitra's rendering) | Xuanzang-lineage synonym | Note |
|---|---|---|
| 歸依 [taking refuge] | 歸依(śaraṇa-gamana)[going for refuge] | giving oneself over and relying upon |
| 法陰 [the dharma-mass] | 法身(dharma-kāya)[the dharma-body] | this chapter's "great dharma-mass" (大法陰) is the dharma-body |
| 二乘 [the two vehicles] | 聲聞·辟支佛乘 [the śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha vehicles] | the foil for "what is not matched" |
| 無生忍 [the acceptance of non-arising] | 無生法忍 [the acceptance of the non-arising of dharmas] | equivalent |
| 轉輪王 [the wheel-turning king] | 轉輪聖王 [the sage wheel-turning king] | the foil for the wondrous marks |
III. What the chapter establishes (義之所立 · the eye)
This chapter establishes the refuge of the great vehicle as the most supreme (as distinct from the common teaching of taking refuge in the three jewels), showing it by four meanings: all-pervading (sentient beings · the vehicles · knowledge · quiescence) · valiant (vow · practice · fruit) · the fruits obtained (the eight fruits) · what is not matched (the four that the remaining vehicles cannot reach). At the centre, by the one strand of the good birth (the four similes of entering the womb → the supreme body → resembling the prince → resembling the great minister), it shows the nobility of the buddha-child and that "the buddha-lineage is unbroken." The meaning of the fruits obtained is gathered up in the dharma-body (great · supreme · constant · a good aggregate) and in "relinquishing existence, relinquishing cessation" (relinquishing existence = not dwelling in birth-and-death · relinquishing cessation = not dwelling in nirvāṇa). Intra-system inheritance: the Mahāyāna-saṃgraha (taking refuge) · the Yogācārabhūmi, Bodhisattva-stage.
IV. Citations (徵引 · intra-system cross-references)
- The four similes of entering the womb · intra-system cross-reference: this chapter (the seed = the awakening-mind · the birth-mother = wisdom · the womb = the upholding by the twofold aggregate of merit and knowledge · the wet-nurse = great compassion) and the Chapter on Arousing the Mind (the womb = the joy of the great meditative concentration) use the same simile, but the one member "the womb" takes its figure differently — the variation is set down together, neither forced into agreement nor judged for superiority. 〔zh: 本品(種子=菩提心·生母=般若·胎藏=福智二聚住持·乳母=大悲)與發心品(胎藏=大禪定樂)同喻而「胎藏」一支取譬有異——並錄其變異,不強齊,亦不判優劣。〕
V. Terms (名相 · first-occurrence · meaning)
- 歸依 [taking refuge]: with utmost mind giving oneself over and relying upon the three jewels; this chapter specifically shows the supremacy of "the refuge of the great vehicle."
- 一切遍 [all-pervading]: pervading throughout without omission (pervading in all four places — sentient beings · the vehicles · knowledge · quiescence).
- 善生 [the good birth]: the surpassing birth obtained through supreme valour (the birth of the buddha-child).
- 法陰/法身 [the dharma-mass / the dharma-body]: the body obtained upon realizing awakening, named great · supreme · constant · a good aggregate.
- 無生忍 [the acceptance of non-arising]: the calm acceptance of the principle that dharmas do not arise.
- 有滅捨 [relinquishing existence, relinquishing cessation]: relinquishing existence — not dwelling in birth-and-death; relinquishing cessation — not dwelling in nirvāṇa (the twofold departure of the non-abiding nirvāṇa).
- 二得 [the two attainments]: the conventional attainment · the attainment by way of the dharma-nature (the coarse and the subtle two grades of the refuge). 三出 [the three departures]: possessing in full the departing-and-transcending practice of the three vehicles.
VI. Similes (譬喻)
- The four similes of entering the womb: the seed (the awakening-mind) · the birth-mother (wisdom) · the womb (the upholding by the twofold aggregate of merit and knowledge) · the wet-nurse (great compassion) — figuring the conception and nurturing of the buddha-child.
- The four of resembling the prince: receiving light and being installed in office · sovereignty over the dharma · skill in expounding · governing well and gathering in — figuring that "the buddha-lineage is unbroken" (as the royal lineage is unbroken through installation in office · non-transgression · adjudication · reward and punishment).
- The four of resembling the great minister: entering the perfections (as one enters the forbidden palace) · beholding the jewel of the factors of awakening (as one beholds a wondrous jewel) · upholding the three secrets of the Tathāgata (as one knows the secret words) · benefiting boundless sentient beings (as one bestows at will). All are pure similes of the royal house and of conception-and-nurture.
Cross-chapter corroboration used by the Exposition
- 〔The great joy of concentration〕: this treatise's Chapter on Arousing the Mind, T31n1604 0596b06 — 「大禪定樂為胎藏故」 ["the great joy of concentration serves as the womb"]. The Exposition reuses the exact phrase 「大禪定樂」 to explain this chapter's four similes of entering the womb.
Similes borrowed by the exposition, fixed to source (not native to this treatise)
The exposition, to aid understanding, draws in similes and scriptural warrants from other scriptures; this treatise has no such text. Their sources are fixed below, kept distinct from the treatise's own similes, and set down together as equivalent underlying material.
- 〔The simile of receiving light and being installed in office · the anointed prince〕: the Avataṃsaka-sūtra (the eighty-scroll Flower-Ornament) T10n0279, scroll 39 · the Chapter on the Ten Grounds · the Ground of the Dharma-Cloud, 0206a23–a27 — 「取四大海水置金瓶內,王執此瓶灌太子頂,是時即名受王職位,墮在灌頂剎利王數……菩薩受職亦復如是,諸佛智水灌其頂故,名為受職」["taking the waters of the four great oceans and placing them within a golden vase, the king holds this vase and anoints the crown of the crown-prince; at that moment it is named receiving the royal office, and he falls within the number of the anointed kṣatriya kings… the bodhisattva's installation in office is likewise: because the waters of the buddhas' knowledge anoint his crown, it is named being installed in office"]. The exposition uses this at 〔§V, the four of resembling the prince · explaining the sense of "receiving light and being installed in office" — with the worldly enthronement by the waters of the four great oceans, showing forth by contrast the buddha-house's conferral of the rank of awakening by the waters of the buddhas' knowledge〕. (Note: the exposition's note originally gave 0442a26; on collation against CBETA it is in fact 0206a23–a27, corrected from the collation-code.)
VII. Cross-readings (互讀)
- The Chapter on Arousing the Mind: the four similes of entering the womb · the good birth (the one member "the womb" takes its figure differently, as recorded in §IV).
- The Mahāyāna-saṃgraha (taking refuge) · the Yogācārabhūmi, Bodhisattva-stage.
VIII. Witness collation (校本定位)
This chapter is T31n1604 0593a03–0594a25 (the Chapter on Taking Refuge complete).