般若心經 般若波羅蜜多心經 · 全經白話(通讀)
二百六十個字,漢地千年來誦得最多的一部經。它這麼短,是因為它本來就是濃縮的——把浩瀚的《大般若》最堅實、最精要的那顆心,抽出來,別成一部。所以「心」不是心理的心,是核心、樞要的心:讀它,等於讀整個般若的心臟。
它一開口就沒有客套,劈頭是一位菩薩照見「五蘊皆空」、當下度過一切苦厄。接著它做一件看似矛盾的事:把五蘊、十八界、十二緣起、四聖諦,連「智慧」和「所得」,一樣一樣地「無」掉——一路無到一無所得。
可就在這「一無所得」的盡頭,翻出了全經最深的祕密:捨到什麼都不抓,得到的竟是心無罣礙、無有恐怖、究竟涅槃,乃至三世諸佛的無上覺悟。
空,原來不是叫你否定這個世界,是叫你看破壓在它上頭那層「實有」的幻覺——世界仍在,而心已自在。
且推開這扇門,從「觀自在」三個字起。
Two hundred sixty characters — across a thousand years the most recited of all sūtras in the Chinese tradition. It is this short because it was condensed to begin with: the most solid, most essential heart of the vast Mahā-prajñāpāramitā (般若), drawn out and made into a single sūtra. So 「心」 (hṛdaya) is not the "heart" of psychology, but the heart as core, as pivotal essence: to read it is to read the very heart of the whole of Prajñā.
It opens with no pleasantries; head-on, a bodhisattva sees that 「五蘊皆空」 ("the five aggregates are all empty") and right then crosses beyond all suffering and calamity. Then it does a thing that seems self-contradicting: the five aggregates, the eighteen elements, the twelvefold dependent origination, the Four Noble Truths, and even "wisdom" and "attainment" — one by one it "no's" them all away, on and on until nothing at all is attained.
Yet right there, at the dead end of this "nothing attained," the deepest secret of the whole sūtra is turned out: let go until you grasp at nothing whatever, and what is gained turns out to be a heart with no snag, with no fear, in final nirvāṇa — and even the supreme awakening of the buddhas of all three times.
Emptiness, it turns out, is not telling you to negate this world; it is telling you to see through that layer of "substantial existence" pressing down on top of it — the world is still here, and the heart is already sovereign and free.
So push open this gate, beginning with the three words "Avalokiteśvara."
觀自在菩薩行深般若波羅蜜多時,照見五蘊皆空,度一切苦厄。
舍利子!色不異空,空不異色,色即是空,空即是色;受、想、行、識,亦復如是。
舍利子!是諸法空相,不生不滅,不垢不淨,不增不減。是故,空中無色,無受、想、行、識;無眼、耳、鼻、舌、身、意;無色、聲、香、味、觸、法;無眼界,乃至無意識界;無無明亦無無明盡,乃至無老死亦無老死盡;無苦、集、滅、道;無智,亦無得。
以無所得故,菩提薩埵依般若波羅蜜多故,心無罣礙;無罣礙故,無有恐怖,遠離顛倒夢想,究竟涅槃。三世諸佛依般若波羅蜜多故,得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。
故知般若波羅蜜多是大神咒、是大明咒、是無上咒、是無等等咒,能除一切苦,真實不虛,故說般若波羅蜜多咒。即說咒曰:
揭帝 揭帝 般羅揭帝 般羅僧揭帝 菩提 莎婆訶
The canonical text stands in Chinese only. This edition renders the essence, the plain reading, the exposition and the apparatus into English — never the sūtra itself. Switch to 漢讀本 or 並行雙語 above to read it.
有一位名叫觀自在的菩薩,當祂深深地運用那能渡到彼岸的大智慧的時候,清清楚楚地照見了:構成身心的五樣東西——色、受、想、行、識——通通是空的;就這樣,渡過了一切的苦難災厄。
舍利子啊!我們看得見摸得著的形色,與那空,並不是兩回事——形色不在空之外,空也不在形色之外;而且這形色當下就是空,這空也當下就是形色。受、想、行、識這四樣,也都和色一個樣。
舍利子啊!這一切法那個「空」的真相,是這樣的:它不曾生、不曾滅,不曾染、不曾淨,不會多、不會少。正因如此,在這空的真相裡:沒有那實在的色,也沒有實在的受、想、行、識;沒有實在的眼、耳、鼻、舌、身、意這六根,也沒有實在的色、聲、香、味、觸、法這六境;從眼界一路到意識界,這十八界沒有一個是實在的;沒有實在的無明,也沒有實在的無明滅盡,這樣下去,到沒有實在的老死,也沒有實在的老死滅盡;沒有實在的苦、集、滅、道這四諦;連那能證的智、所得的果,也都不是實在可得的。
正因為到了這一無所得的地步——菩薩們依著這份般若智慧,心裡再沒有任何牽掛障礙;正因無牽掛,所以也沒有恐懼,遠遠離開了一切顛倒的想法、虛幻的夢,徹底到達了寂滅清涼。過去、現在、未來三世的一切佛,也都是依著這份般若智慧,才證得了那無上的、正確而平等的徹底覺悟。
所以該知道:這般若波羅蜜多,是有大威神的咒、有大光明的咒、至高無上的咒、無可比擬的咒;它能除滅一切苦,真實不虛。因此就來宣說這般若波羅蜜多的咒。隨即說咒:
揭帝 揭帝 般羅揭帝 般羅僧揭帝 菩提 莎婆訶。
(咒語自古多存其梵音持誦;古德於此,或存梵音不翻,或解作「去吧、去吧,到彼岸去,大家都到彼岸,覺悟,圓滿成就」——皆古德所傳,誦者隨之。)
觀自在菩薩行深般若波羅蜜多時,照見五蘊皆空,度一切苦厄。
There was a bodhisattva named Avalokiteśvara. When he was coursing deeply in that great wisdom which can carry one across to the far shore, he saw — clearly and plainly — that the five things which make up body and mind (form, feeling, perception, formations, consciousness) are, every one of them, empty; and just so, he crossed beyond all suffering and calamity.
舍利子!色不異空,空不異色,色即是空,空即是色;受、想、行、識,亦復如是。
Śāriputra! The visible, tangible form that we see and touch, and that emptiness, are not two separate things — form does not stand outside emptiness, nor does emptiness stand outside form; what is more, this form right here is itself emptiness, and this emptiness right here is itself form. And the other four — feeling, perception, formations, consciousness — are every one of them just the same as form.
舍利子!是諸法空相,不生不滅,不垢不淨,不增不減。是故,空中無色,無受、想、行、識;無眼、耳、鼻、舌、身、意;無色、聲、香、味、觸、法;無眼界,乃至無意識界;無無明亦無無明盡,乃至無老死亦無老死盡;無苦、集、滅、道;無智,亦無得。
Śāriputra! As for that "emptiness" which is the true mark of all these dharmas, it is like this: it has never arisen and never ceased, it has never been defiled and never been purified, it never increases and never decreases. And therefore, within this true mark of emptiness: there is no substantial form, and no substantial feeling, perception, formations, or consciousness; there are none of the six faculties — no substantial eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, or mind; there are none of the six objects — no substantial form, sound, smell, taste, touch, or mental object; from the eye-element all the way to the mind-consciousness-element, not one of the eighteen elements is substantial; there is no substantial ignorance and no substantial ending of ignorance, and so on down to no substantial aging-and-death and no substantial ending of aging-and-death; there are none of the Four Truths — no substantial suffering, origin, cessation, or path; and even the cognition that realizes and the fruit that is gained — these too are not substantial, not anything that can be gained.
以無所得故,菩提薩埵依般若波羅蜜多故,心無罣礙;無罣礙故,無有恐怖,遠離顛倒夢想,究竟涅槃。三世諸佛依般若波羅蜜多故,得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。
It is precisely because one arrives at this point of nothing-being-gained — the bodhisattvas, relying on this prajñā wisdom, have in their hearts no more snag and no more hindrance of any kind; and because there is no snag, there is therefore no fear, and they leave far behind every upside-down notion and illusory dream, and reach, all the way through, that cool stillness of final extinction. And the buddhas of all three times — past, present, and future — also rely on this very prajñā wisdom, and so they realize that supreme, right, and even and complete awakening.
故知般若波羅蜜多是大神咒、是大明咒、是無上咒、是無等等咒,能除一切苦,真實不虛,故說般若波羅蜜多咒。即說咒曰:
So one should know: this prajñā-pāramitā is the mantra of great spiritual power, the mantra of great radiance, the supreme mantra, the mantra beyond all equal — it can remove all suffering; it is true and not empty. Therefore the mantra of this prajñā-pāramitā is proclaimed. And forthwith the mantra is spoken:
揭帝 揭帝 般羅揭帝 般羅僧揭帝 菩提 莎婆訶。
揭帝 揭帝 般羅揭帝 般羅僧揭帝 菩提 莎婆訶 (gate gate pāragate pārasaṃgate bodhi svāhā).
(From of old the mantra has mostly been kept in its Sanskrit sound for recitation; here the ancient masters either keep the Sanskrit sound untranslated, or render it as "Go, go, go over to the far shore, everyone together go over to the far shore, awakening, perfect accomplishment" — all of this is what the ancient masters have transmitted, and the reciter follows along.)
一部「濃縮到只剩心」的經
《般若波羅蜜多心經》只有二百六十字,是漢傳佛教誦得最多的一部經。它這麼短,是因為它本來就是濃縮的——古德說,《大般若經》卷帙浩繁,怕人讀著生退心,於是把其中最堅實、最精要的旨趣抽出來,別成這一部。「心」字就是這個意思:不是「心理」的心,是「核心、樞要」的心。所以讀心經,等於讀整個般若的心臟。
也正因為是撮要,它沒有一般經典的「序分」(如是我聞…)和「流通分」(信受奉行…)。三家古德——窺基、圓測、法藏——都這樣判。它一開口就是正題,乾淨利落。
一條從「能觀」到「得果」的路
別看它短,它是一條完整的路。順著圓測的科判,全經分三段、九節:
先立能觀(初分)。 觀自在菩薩(誰在觀)→ 行深般若(用什麼觀:無分別的深智)→ 照見五蘊皆空(觀見了什麼:身心的空)→ 度一切苦厄(觀的結果:出離了苦)。四句,把一位修行者如何提起般若、照破實執、脫出苦海,一氣呵成。
再說所觀(次分)。 接著放慢,細說那「空」到底是什麼:色不異空、色即是空(空不是把色取消)→ 是諸法空相,不生不滅(連生滅垢淨都安不上)→ 一連串的「無」,把五蘊、十二處、十八界、十二緣起、四諦、乃至「智」與「得」,一門一門地遣盡。
終顯得果(後分)。 最後收束:以無所得故(鬆開最後一隻手)→ 心無罣礙、究竟涅槃(菩薩的果)→ 三世諸佛得無上菩提(諸佛的果)→ 一句咒(把全經凝成一聲,送你上路)。
捨到一無所得,得到的卻是大自在與徹底的覺悟——這就是心經要告訴你的那件事。
為什麼用「唯識」這面鏡來讀
本書的義疏層,以唯識為鏡讀心經。這需要說明,免得誤會。
般若講「空」,唯識講「三性、三無性、轉依」,看似兩家;其實照見的是同一樁實相。心經一句「色即是空」,落到唯識的話,就是「遣遍計所執、存依他圓成」——空掉的是你硬安上去的「實有」,不是把因緣現起的世界抹掉。這樣讀,「空」就不會被誤聽成斷滅,而是一份看破實執、世界依舊鮮活的清涼。
而且,這面鏡是古德磨的,不是今人附會的。漢地最精的兩部心經疏——窺基《幽贊》、圓測《贊》——本來就是以唯識讀心經(圓測甚至引護法、清辨二宗論空有)。所以用唯識讀心經,腳下有古德的論本為地。
但要記住一句:鏡非經。唯識是讀心經的一面鏡,不是心經的源頭;般若才是經,唯識是鏡。我們用鏡照經,是為了把經看得更清,不是拿鏡來取代經、也不是把心經改寫成唯識論。照見了,鏡就可以放下。
這部書怎麼讀:五層
每一段,本書備了五層,由淺入深,各取所需:
- 原典:玄奘的逐字經文,一字不易。
- 白話:把文言說成今語,忠實好讀,不加義理。
- 義疏:以唯識為鏡,領著一個活問,把這一段講活——這是給願意深入的人。
- 考據:六種漢譯對勘、古德逐字徵引、術語梵音——這是給研究者、校勘家。
- 心要:一段登陸短文,懸念加一問,給只想先嚐一口的人。
你可以只讀白話,也可以一路讀到考據;可以從心要入門,也可以拿原典對著義疏細嚼。路有寬窄,門有深淺,隨你。
且推開這扇門,從「觀自在」三個字起。
A Sūtra "Condensed Down to Nothing but Its Heart"
The Heart Sūtra (Prajñā-pāramitā-hṛdaya-sūtra) is only two hundred sixty characters, and it is the most recited of all sūtras in the Chinese tradition. It is this short because it was condensed to begin with — the ancient masters say that the Mahā-prajñāpāramitā-sūtra is vast in its many fascicles, and, fearing that readers might lose heart at the size of it, the most solid and most essential purport within it was drawn out and made into this separate sūtra. The word 「心」 ("heart") means exactly this: not the "heart" of psychology, but the heart as core, as pivotal essence. So to read the Heart Sūtra is to read the very heart of the whole of Prajñā.
And precisely because it is a distillation of essentials, it has neither the "opening section" (序分, 「如是我聞…」, "Thus have I heard…") nor the "circulation section" (流通分, 「信受奉行…」, "received it in faith and put it into practice…") that ordinary sūtras carry. The three houses of ancient masters — Kuiji, Woncheuk, Fazang — all judge it so. It opens its mouth straight onto the main matter, clean and direct.
One Path, from "the Cognition that Observes" to "the Fruit Attained"
Do not be misled by its brevity: it is a complete path. Following Woncheuk's textual division, the whole sūtra falls into three divisions and nine sections:
First, it establishes the cognition that observes (the first division). Avalokiteśvara the bodhisattva (who is observing) → coursing in the deep prajñā (what one observes with: the deep cognition that is nondiscriminating, nirvikalpa) → seeing the five aggregates as all empty (what is seen: the emptiness of body and mind) → crossing beyond all suffering (the result of the observing: deliverance from suffering). Four lines, sweeping in one breath through how a practitioner takes up prajñā, illumines and breaks through the grasping at the substantial, and escapes the sea of suffering.
Next, it speaks of the object observed (the second division). Then it slows down and tells in detail what that "emptiness" actually is: 「色不異空」, 「色即是空」 ("form is not different from emptiness," "form itself is emptiness" — emptiness does not cancel form away) → 「是諸法空相,不生不滅」 ("these dharmas have the mark of emptiness, neither arising nor ceasing" — even arising and ceasing, defilement and purity, find no footing on it) → a string of "no's" that negate, one gate at a time, the five aggregates, the twelve sense-fields, the eighteen elements, the twelvefold dependent origination, the Four Truths, and at last even "cognition" and "attainment."
Finally, it discloses the fruit attained (the third division). At the last it draws everything to a close: 「以無所得故」 ("because nothing is attained" — releasing the very last hand's grip) → 「心無罣礙」, 「究竟涅槃」 ("the heart with no snag and no hindrance," "final nirvāṇa" — the bodhisattva's fruit) → the buddhas of all three times realizing supreme awakening (the buddhas' fruit) → a single mantra (compressing the whole sūtra into one utterance and sending you off down the road).
To let go down to nothing-being-gained, and yet what is gained is great sovereign freedom and a thoroughgoing awakening — this is the very thing the Heart Sūtra means to tell you.
Why Read Through the Mirror of "Yogācāra"
This book's exposition layer reads the Heart Sūtra through the mirror of Yogācāra. This needs explaining, lest it be misunderstood.
Prajñā speaks of "emptiness"; Yogācāra speaks of "the three natures (trisvabhāva), the three non-natures (niḥsvabhāvatā), the transformation of the basis (āśraya-parāvṛtti)" — seemingly two houses, yet what they illumine is one and the same reality. The Heart Sūtra's single line 「色即是空」 ("form itself is emptiness"), put into the words of Yogācāra, becomes "negate the wholly-imagined nature (parikalpita), keep the other-dependent (paratantra) and the perfectly-accomplished (pariniṣpanna)" — what is emptied is the "substantial existence" you yourself force onto things, not a wiping away of the world that arises through conditions. Read this way, "emptiness" cannot be misheard as annihilation; it is rather a coolness in which the grasping at the substantial is seen through while the world stays vividly alive.
And this mirror was ground by the ancient masters, not contrived by people of today. The two finest Heart Sūtra commentaries in the Chinese tradition — Kuiji's 《幽贊》 and Woncheuk's 《贊》 — are themselves readings through Yogācāra (Woncheuk even cites the two houses of Dharmapāla and Bhāviveka discussing emptiness and existence). So in reading the Heart Sūtra through Yogācāra, there is, underfoot, the ground of the ancient masters' treatise-roots.
But one line must be kept in mind: the mirror is not the sūtra. Yogācāra is one mirror in which to read the Heart Sūtra, not the source of the Heart Sūtra; Prajñā is the sūtra, Yogācāra is the mirror. We use the mirror to illumine the sūtra so as to see the sūtra more clearly — not to let the mirror usurp the sūtra, and not to rewrite the Heart Sūtra into a Yogācāra treatise. Once the seeing is done, the mirror can be set down.
How to Read This Book: Five Layers
For each segment this book provides five layers, from shallow to deep, each to take what it needs:
- Source (原典): Xuanzang's word-for-word sūtra text, with not a character altered.
- Vernacular (白話): the classical Chinese said in today's language, faithful and readable, adding no doctrine.
- Exposition (義疏): through the mirror of Yogācāra, led by one live question, bringing this segment to life — this is for those willing to go deep.
- Apparatus (考據): collation across six Chinese translations, word-for-word citation of the ancient masters, terminology and Sanskrit sound — this is for scholars and collators.
- Essence (心要): one landing-piece of short prose, a held suspense plus one question, for those who only want a first taste.
You may read the vernacular alone, or read all the way through to the apparatus; you may enter through the essence, or take up the source text and chew on it carefully against the exposition. The road has its broad stretches and its narrow ones, the gates their depths and their shallows — as you please.
So push open this gate, beginning with the three words "Avalokiteśvara."
考據Apparatus
一 · 經題定位
「般若波羅蜜多心經」:般若,慧(圓測「梵音般若,此翻名智」〔T1711 0543c23〕;窺基「慧義」〔T1710 0524a08〕);波羅蜜多,到彼岸(圓測「智到彼岸…因智斷障至涅槃城」〔T1711 0543c24〕);心,樞要——此經乃《大般若》撮其堅實妙最之旨而別出,故名「心」。窺基「《大經》隨機,義文俱廣…別出此經」〔T1710 0524a27〕。
二 · 底本與異譯
底本:玄奘譯 T08n0251(永徽元年 650 CE)· 一卷 · 略本 268 字(無序分、無流通分)· 起「觀自在菩薩」〔0848c06〕訖「菩提莎婆訶」〔0848c23〕。前冠明太祖御製序、唐釋慧忠序(非經文,verbatim 已除)。
漢譯共八號(T0250–0257):略本二(羅什 T0250《摩訶般若波羅蜜大明呪經》· 玄奘 T0251);廣本五(法月 T0252 · 般若共利言 T0253 · 智慧輪 T0254 · 法成 T0255 · 施護 T0257,皆具序分流通分);音寫本一(慈恩石壁 T0256)。要異:觀自在/觀世音(羅什)· 五蘊/五陰(羅什)· 色不異空型/即色是空型(施護)· 咒名四/三(羅什、施護唯三)· 咒字 揭帝/竭帝/誐帝。逐段對勘見各段考據「目二」。
三 · 結構(圓測三分 × 窺基科文)
三家古德(窺基《幽贊》· 圓測《贊》· 法藏《略疏》)一致判心經無序分、無流通分,唯存正宗(圓測「於諸般若簡集綱要,故唯正宗」〔T1711 0543b16〕)。故本書依圓測三分為脊樑,分九段:
- 初分 明能觀智:① 觀自在(標能觀人)② 行深般若(辨觀智體)③ 照見五蘊皆空(顯所觀空)④ 度一切苦厄(利他度苦)
- 次分 辨所觀境:⑤ 色空相即 ⑥ 顯空六相 ⑦ 遣六門法(蘊處界緣諦智)
- 後分 顯所得果:⑧ 通結無得(以無所得故)⑨ 顯所得果+歎德咒
四 · 古德源
唯識二疏為主:窺基《般若波羅蜜多心經幽贊》T33n1710(慈恩)· 圓測《般若波羅蜜多心經贊》T33n1711(西明)——二師皆以唯識讀心經(三性·三無性·八識·轉依·五重唯識觀)。圓測並引護法(立有撥空)·清辨(執空撥有)二師論空有之異,以護法為正〔T1711 0544a19·0546a19;詳見段五、段六〕。旁參:法藏《略疏》T33n1712(華嚴)等。論本在唯識六部(辯中邊·三十頌·二十論·攝論·成唯識)。
五 · 讀法:唯識為鏡(鏡非經)
本書義疏層以唯識為鏡讀此經——非謂唯識是心經之源,乃以三性、二空、轉依為照心經「色即是空」「無智亦無得」之一面鏡。其據在:心經之印度造論背景與唯識同源,而漢地最精之心經疏(窺基、圓測)本即唯識讀,故以唯識讀心經有古德為地,非後人附會。鏡非經:唯識為鏡,般若為經,不以鏡奪經。
六 · 梵本(Rule 9a)
梵讀唯據古德所傳(玄奘·窺基·圓測 音寫義譯,如舍利子=奢利富多羅、涅槃=波利匿縛𠲸〔玄奘音,圓測 T1711 0549a22〕),IAST 為發音輔助;不立現代校訂本。圓測自有勘梵:「撿勘梵本,有『等』言故」(「照見五蘊等皆空」之「等」)〔T1711 0544c13〕。
七 · 互讀
- 般若部:大般若經(T0220)相應品〔T05n0220a 卷4 0022b06〕「色不異空…是諸法空相」最密平行;金剛經姊妹(唯識為鏡 32 分·已封)。
- 唯識六部:百法→三十頌→二十論→辯中邊→攝論→成唯識;解深密經(三性三無性三時教之所立·圓測同註)。
八 · 校本定位
底本 玄奘 T08n0251〔0848c06–c23〕;異譯 T0250·0252–0257;古德 窺基 T33n1710·圓測 T33n1711·法藏 T33n1712;互讀 T05n0220a〔0022b06〕。逐段校本見各段「目八」。
This layer carries only canonical source text (scripture · ancient masters · the Sanskrit as transmitted by the ancient masters · the structural division 科判). Reading text fully in 漢. Fine-grained collation lives in each segment's apparatus; this is the book-level outline.
1 · Placement of the Title(經題定位)
「般若波羅蜜多心經」 — 般若 (prajñā), wisdom: Woncheuk, 「梵音般若,此翻名智」 ("the Sanskrit sound prajñā, here translated 'cognition'") 〔T1711 0543c23〕; Kuiji, 「慧義」 ("the sense of wisdom") 〔T1710 0524a08〕. 波羅蜜多 (pāramitā), reaching the far shore: Woncheuk, 「智到彼岸…因智斷障至涅槃城」 ("by cognition reaching the far shore… by cognition severing the obstructions and arriving at the citadel of nirvāṇa") 〔T1711 0543c24〕. 心 (hṛdaya), the pivotal essence — this sūtra draws out from the 《大般若》 (Mahā-prajñāpāramitā) the most solid, subtle, and supreme of its purport and issues it separately, hence named 「心」 ("heart/core"). Kuiji, 「《大經》隨機,義文俱廣…別出此經」 ("the Great Sūtra, responding to capacities, is vast in both sense and text… this sūtra is issued separately from it") 〔T1710 0524a27〕.
2 · Base Text and Variant Translations(底本與異譯)
Base text: Xuanzang's translation T08n0251 (Yonghui 1st year, 650 CE) · one fascicle · abridged recension of 268 characters (no opening section 序分, no concluding-circulation section 流通分) · beginning 「觀自在菩薩」 ("Avalokiteśvara Bodhisattva") 〔0848c06〕 and ending 「菩提莎婆訶」 ("bodhi svāhā") 〔0848c23〕. The Ming Taizu imperial preface and the Tang monk Huizhong's preface that precede it are not sūtra text (the verbatim has already been stripped of them).
There are eight Chinese translations in all (T0250–0257): two abridged recensions (Kumārajīva T0250 《摩訶般若波羅蜜大明呪經》 · Xuanzang T0251); five expanded recensions (Dharmacandra/法月 T0252 · Prajñā with Liyan/般若共利言 T0253 · Prajñācakra/智慧輪 T0254 · Facheng/法成 T0255 · Dānapāla/施護 T0257, all with opening and circulation sections); and one transliteration recension (Ci'en stone-wall/慈恩石壁 T0256). Principal variants: 觀自在/觀世音 (Avalokiteśvara / "Regarder of the World's Sounds," Kumārajīva) · 五蘊/五陰 (the five aggregates, Kumārajīva's older rendering) · the 色不異空 type ("form is not different from emptiness") versus the 即色是空 type ("form itself is emptiness," Dānapāla) · four mantra-epithets versus three (Kumārajīva and Dānapāla give only three) · the mantra graphs 揭帝/竭帝/誐帝. Segment-by-segment collation is given in each segment's apparatus, 「目二」 ("rubric two").
3 · Structure (Woncheuk's three divisions × Kuiji's textual division)(結構)
The three houses of ancient masters (Kuiji 《幽贊》 · Woncheuk 《贊》 · Fazang 《略疏》) agree in judging the Heart Sūtra to have no opening section and no circulation section, retaining only the main body 正宗 (Woncheuk, 「於諸般若簡集綱要,故唯正宗」, "among the Prajñā scriptures it selects and gathers the essentials, hence only the main body" 〔T1711 0543b16〕). This book therefore takes Woncheuk's three divisions as its spine, in nine segments:
- First division, clarifying the cognition that observes(初分 明能觀智): ① 觀自在 Avalokiteśvara (marking the person who observes) ② 行深般若 coursing in the deep prajñā (discerning the body of the observing cognition) ③ 照見五蘊皆空 seeing the five aggregates as all empty (disclosing the emptiness observed) ④ 度一切苦厄 crossing beyond all suffering (the benefiting of others, crossing beyond suffering)
- Second division, discerning the object observed(次分 辨所觀境): ⑤ 色空相即 form and emptiness mutually being ⑥ 顯空六相 disclosing the six marks of emptiness ⑦ 遣六門法 negating the six gates of dharmas (aggregates, sense-fields, elements, dependent origination, the truths, cognition)
- Third division, disclosing the fruit attained(後分 顯所得果): ⑧ 通結無得 the general conclusion of non-attainment (「以無所得故」, "because nothing is attained") ⑨ 顯所得果+歎德咒 disclosing the fruit attained, plus the mantra in praise of its virtue
4 · Sources Among the Ancient Masters(古德源)
The two Yogācāra commentaries are primary: Kuiji 《般若波羅蜜多心經幽贊》 T33n1710 (Ci'en) · Woncheuk 《般若波羅蜜多心經贊》 T33n1711 (Ximing) — both masters read the Heart Sūtra through Yogācāra (the three natures · the three non-natures · the eight consciousnesses · the transformation of the basis · the fivefold Consciousness-Only contemplation 五重唯識觀). Woncheuk further cites the differing positions on emptiness-and-existence of the two masters 護法 (Dharmapāla, who "establishes existence and refutes [one-sided] emptiness," 立有撥空) and 清辨 (Bhāviveka, who "grasps emptiness and refutes existence," 執空撥有), taking Dharmapāla as the correct one 〔T1711 0544a19 · 0546a19; see Parts 5 and 6〕. Consulted alongside: Fazang 《略疏》 T33n1712 (Huayan) and others. The treatise-roots lie in the six Yogācāra works (Madhyānta-vibhāga · the Thirty Verses · the Twenty Verses · the Mahāyāna-saṃgraha · the Cheng-weishi-lun).
5 · Reading Method: Yogācāra as Mirror (the mirror is not the sūtra)(讀法:唯識為鏡(鏡非經))
This book's exposition layer reads this sūtra through the mirror of Yogācāra — not claiming that Yogācāra is the source of the Heart Sūtra, but using the three natures, the two emptinesses, and the transformation of the basis as one mirror in which to illumine one face of the Heart Sūtra's 「色即是空」 ("form itself is emptiness") and 「無智亦無得」 ("no cognition and no attainment"). The ground for this: the Indian treatise-composition background of the Heart Sūtra is of one source with Yogācāra, and the finest Heart Sūtra commentaries in the Chinese tradition (Kuiji, Woncheuk) are themselves Yogācāra readings — so reading the Heart Sūtra through Yogācāra stands on the ground of the ancient masters and is not a later forced construal. The mirror is not the sūtra: Yogācāra is the mirror, Prajñā is the sūtra; the mirror does not usurp the sūtra.
6 · The Sanskrit (Rule 9a)(梵本)
The Sanskrit reading is grounded solely in what the ancient masters transmitted (Xuanzang · Kuiji · Woncheuk in transliteration and sense-translation — e.g. 舍利子=奢利富多羅 Śāriputra, 涅槃=波利匿縛𠲸 nirvāṇa 〔Xuanzang's transliteration, Woncheuk T1711 0549a22〕); IAST serves as a pronunciation aid; no modern critical edition is set up as authority. Woncheuk has his own collation of the Sanskrit: 「撿勘梵本,有『等』言故」 ("on examining and collating the Sanskrit manuscript, there is the word '等' [-ādi, 'and so forth']") — i.e. 「照見五蘊等皆空」 ("seeing that the five aggregates and so forth are all empty") 〔T1711 0544c13〕.
7 · Cross-Reading(互讀)
- The Prajñā corpus(般若部): the Mahā-prajñāpāramitā-sūtra (T0220), corresponding chapter 〔T05n0220a 卷4 0022b06〕 — 「色不異空…是諸法空相」 ("form is not different from emptiness… these dharmas have the mark of emptiness") is the closest parallel; the Diamond Sūtra is its sister (read through the mirror of Yogācāra, 32 sections, sealed).
- The six Yogācāra works(唯識六部): Baifa → the Thirty Verses → the Twenty Verses → Madhyānta-vibhāga → the Mahāyāna-saṃgraha → the Cheng-weishi-lun; the Saṃdhinirmocana-sūtra (which establishes the three natures, the three non-natures, and the three turnings of the teaching · annotated by the same Woncheuk).
8 · Witnesses(校本定位)
Base text Xuanzang T08n0251 〔0848c06–c23〕; variant translations T0250 · 0252–0257; ancient masters Kuiji T33n1710 · Woncheuk T33n1711 · Fazang T33n1712; cross-reading T05n0220a 〔0022b06〕. Segment-by-segment witnesses are given in each segment's 「目八」 ("rubric eight"). Source files: source/T08n0251_xinjing_verbatim.md + treatise/00_xu/00_xu_source.md (whole-sūtra frontispiece).