華嚴經 品三十八 離世間品 · 因圓果滿行五十一門Avataṃsaka Sūtra · Detachment from the World · The Fifty-One Gates of the Practice of the Perfected Cause and the Fulfilled Fruit

〔T10 0304a11〕
心要Essence

門開了五十一道,最後一道通向涅槃。

普賢答的最後一番,從「有十種觀察」起,到「示般涅槃」止。前面教你怎麼看、怎麼行、怎麼避開障礙,後面演一遍成道的全程。位名一個都沒有——十信十住十地那些名目,是古德依《度世經》立的科,澄觀承下來用,經文自己不說。坐標可以拿掉,門還在。

五十一門裡最刺人的是十魔:善根魔、三昧魔、善知識魔、菩提法智魔。善根怎麼會是魔?澄觀答得斬釘截鐵——「蘊魔之名特由取著」,魔的名字不落在物上,落在取。他還推一句:「以心分別萬法皆魔,何但此十。」

最溫的一句在微笑那一門。十個念頭之後,都是同一句「熙怡微笑心自誓」。念裡有『除我一人無能免濟』的擔當,也有看見舊日同行的人落在原處的悵然。慈悲若無一點欣悅撐不住,欣悅若無一點悲會走偏。

最後一門講入滅,十義沒有一義說佛真的走了,全部是「示」。

門是走的,不是看的。

Fifty-one gates stand open, and the last of them opens through to nirvāṇa.

This is the last of the rounds of Samantabhadra’s answering, running from “there are ten kinds of contemplation” to “manifesting parinirvāṇa.” The earlier part teaches you how to look, how to practice, and how to keep clear of obstruction; the later part plays through the whole course of accomplishing the Way. Not one stage-name occurs — the ten faiths, the ten abodes, the ten grounds, and names of that sort are an outline the ancient worthies set up on the basis of the Dushi jing, which Chengguan carried on and used; the scripture itself does not say them. The coordinates can be taken away, and the gates are still there.

The most piercing thing among the fifty-one gates is the ten māras: the māra of the roots of good, the māra of samādhi, the māra of the good friend, the māra of the wisdom of the dharma of awakening. How can roots of good be a māra? Chengguan answers without the least hesitation — “the name māra of the aggregates comes solely from grasping and attachment” — the name māra does not fall upon the thing, it falls upon the grasping. And he pushes it one sentence further: “when the mind discriminates, the ten thousand dharmas are all māra; how should it be only these ten?”

The warmest sentence is in the gate on the smile. After each of the ten thoughts comes the same sentence, “with glad delight he smiles and inwardly vows.” Within the thoughts there is the shouldering of ‘apart from me alone, none is able to save them,’ and there is also the sadness of seeing those who once walked with him left standing where they were. Compassion, with not a trace of gladness, cannot be sustained; gladness, with not a trace of sorrow, goes astray.

The last gate speaks of entering extinction, and among the ten senses not one says that the Buddha really went away; every one of them is “manifesting.”

A gate is for walking through, not for looking at.

原典Canonical · verbatim

〔T10 0304〕 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種觀察。何等為十?所謂:知諸業觀察,微細悉見故;知諸趣觀察,不取眾生故;知諸根觀察,了達無根故;知諸法觀察,不壞法界故;見佛法觀察,勤修佛眼故;得智慧觀察,如理說法故;無生忍觀察,決了佛法故;不退地觀察,滅一切煩惱,超出三界、二乘地故;灌頂地觀察,於一切佛法自在不動故;善覺智三昧觀察,於一切十方施作佛事故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來無上大觀察智。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種普觀察。何等為十?所謂:普觀一切諸來求者,以無違心滿其意故;普觀一切犯戒眾生,安置如來淨戒中故;普觀一切害心眾生,安置如來忍力中故;普觀一切懈怠眾生,勸令精勤不捨荷負大乘擔故;普觀一切亂心眾生,令住如來一切智地無散動故;普觀一切惡慧眾生,令除疑惑破有見故;普觀一切平等善友,順其教命住佛法故;普觀一切所聞之法,疾得證見最上義故;普觀一切無邊眾生,常不捨離大悲力故;普觀一切諸佛之法,速得成就一切智故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來無上大智慧普觀察。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種奮迅。何等為十?所謂:牛王奮迅,映蔽一切天、龍、夜叉、乾闥婆等諸大眾故;象王奮迅,心善調柔,荷負一切諸眾生故;龍王奮迅,興大法密雲,耀解脫電光,震如實義雷,降諸根、力、覺分、禪定、解脫、三昧甘露雨故;大金翅鳥王奮迅,竭貪愛水,破愚癡㲉,搏撮煩惱諸惡毒龍,令出生死大苦海故;大師子王奮迅,安住無畏平等大智以為器仗,摧伏眾魔及外道故;勇健奮迅,能於生死大戰陣中摧滅一切煩惱怨故;大智奮迅,知蘊、界、處及諸緣起,自在開示一切法故;陀羅尼奮迅,以念慧力持法不忘,隨眾生根為宣說故;辯才奮迅,無礙迅疾分別一切,咸令受益心歡喜故;如來奮迅,一切智智助道之法皆悉成滿,以一念相應慧,所應得者一切皆得,所應悟者一切皆悟,坐師子座降魔怨敵,成阿耨多羅三藐三菩提故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得諸佛於一切法無上自在奮迅。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種師子吼。何等為十?所謂:唱言:『我當必定成正等覺。』是菩提心大師子吼。『我當令一切眾生,未度者度,未脫者脫,未安者安,未涅槃者令得涅槃。』是大悲大師子吼。『我當令佛、法、僧種無有斷絕。』是報如來恩大師子吼。『我當嚴淨一切佛剎。』是究竟堅誓大師子吼。『我當除滅一切惡道及諸難處。』是自持淨戒大師子吼。『我當滿足一切諸佛身、語及意相好莊嚴。』是求福無厭大師子吼。『我當成滿一切諸佛所有智慧。』是求智無厭大師子吼。『我當除滅一切眾魔及諸魔業。』是修正行斷諸煩惱大師子吼。『我當了知一切諸法無我,無眾生、無壽命、無補伽羅,空、無相、無願,淨如虛空。』是無生法忍大師子吼。最後生菩薩震動一切諸佛國土悉令嚴淨,是時,一切釋、梵、四王咸來讚請:『唯願菩薩以無生法而現受生!』菩薩則以無礙慧眼普觀世間:『一切眾生無如我者。』即於王宮示現誕生,自行七步大師子吼:『我於世間最勝第一,我當永盡生死邊際。』是如說而作大師子吼。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來無上大師子吼。

〔卷58〕 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨施。何等為十?所謂:平等施,不揀眾生故;隨意施,滿其所願故;不亂施,令得利益故;隨宜施,知上、中、下故;不住施,不求果報故;開捨施,心不戀著故;一切施,究竟清淨故;迴向菩提施,遠離有為、無為故;教化眾生施,乃至道場不捨故;三輪清淨施,於施者、受者及以施物正念觀察如虛空故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來無上清淨廣大施。 〔T10 0305〕 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨戒。何等為十?所謂:身清淨戒,護身三惡故;語清淨戒,離語四過故;心清淨戒,永離貪、瞋、邪見故;不破一切學處清淨戒,於一切人、天中作尊主故;守護菩提心清淨戒,不樂小乘故;守護如來所制清淨戒,乃至微細罪生大怖畏故;隱密護持清淨戒,善拔犯戒眾生故;不作一切惡清淨戒,誓修一切善法故;遠離一切有見清淨戒,於戒無著故;守護一切眾生清淨戒,發起大悲故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來無上無過失清淨戒。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨忍。何等為十?所謂:安受呰辱清淨忍,護諸眾生故;安受刀杖清淨忍,善護自他故;不生恚害清淨忍,其心不動故;不責卑賤清淨忍,為上能寬故;有歸咸救清淨忍,捨自身命故;遠離我慢清淨忍,不輕未學故;殘毀不瞋清淨忍,觀察如幻故;有犯無報清淨忍,不見自他故;不隨煩惱清淨忍,離諸境界故;隨順菩薩真實智知一切法無生清淨忍,不由他教,入一切智境界故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住其中,則得一切諸佛不由他悟無上法忍。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨精進。何等為十?所謂:身清淨精進,承事供養諸佛菩薩及諸師長,尊重福田不退轉故;語清淨精進,隨所聞法廣為他說,讚佛功德無疲倦故;意清淨精進,善能入出慈、悲、喜、捨、禪定、解脫及諸三昧無休息故;正直心清淨精進,無誑無諂,無曲無偽,一切勤修無退轉故;增勝心清淨精進,志常趣求上上智慧,願具一切白淨法故;不唐捐清淨精進,攝取布施、戒、忍、多聞及不放逸乃至菩提無中息故;摧伏一切魔清淨精進,悉能除滅貪欲、瞋恚、愚癡、邪見、一切煩惱、諸纏蓋故;成滿智慧光清淨精進,有所施為悉善觀察,咸使究竟,不令後悔,得一切佛不共法故;無來無去清淨精進,得如實智,入法界門,身、語及心皆悉平等,了相非相,無所著故;成就法光清淨精進,超過諸地,得佛灌頂,以無漏身而示歿生、出家、成道、說法、滅度,具足如是普賢事故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來無上大清淨精進。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨禪。何等為十?所謂:常樂出家清淨禪,捨一切所有故;得真善友清淨禪,示教正道故;住阿蘭若忍風雨等清淨禪,離我、我所故;離憒閙眾生清淨禪,常樂寂靜故;心業調柔清淨禪,守護諸根故;心智寂滅清淨禪,一切音聲、諸禪定刺不能亂故;覺道方便清淨禪,觀察一切皆現證故;離於味著清淨禪,不捨欲界故;發起通明清淨禪,知一切眾生根性故;自在遊戲清淨禪,入佛三昧,知無我故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住其中,則得如來無上大清淨禪。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨慧。何等為十?所謂:知一切因清淨慧,不壞果報故;知一切緣清淨慧,不違和合故;知不斷不常清淨慧,了達緣起皆如實故;拔一切見清淨慧,於眾生相無取捨故;觀一切眾生心行清淨慧,了知如幻故;廣大辯才清淨慧,分別諸法、問答無礙故;一切諸魔、外道、聲聞、獨覺所不能知清淨慧,深入一切如來智故;見一切佛微妙法身、見一切眾生本性清淨、見一切法皆悉寂滅、見一切剎同於虛空清淨慧,知一切相皆無礙故;一切總持、辯才、方便波羅蜜清淨慧,令得一切最勝智故;一念相應金剛智了一切法平等清淨慧,得一切法最尊智故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住其中,則得如來無障礙大智慧。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨慈。何等為十?所謂:等心清淨慈,普攝眾生無所揀擇故;饒益清淨慈,隨有所作皆令歡喜故;攝物同己清淨慈,究竟皆令出生死故;不捨世間清淨慈,心常緣念集善根故;能至解脫清淨慈,普使眾生除滅一切諸煩惱故;出生菩提清淨慈,普使眾生發求一切智心故;世間無礙清淨慈,放大光明平等普照故;充滿虛空清淨慈,救護眾生無處不至故;法緣清淨慈,證於如如真實法故;無緣清淨慈,入於菩薩離生性故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來無上廣大清淨慈。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨悲。何等為十?所謂:無儔伴清淨悲,獨發其心故。無疲厭清淨悲,代一切眾生受苦,不以為勞故。難處受生清淨悲,為度眾生故。善趣受生清淨悲,示現無常故。為邪定眾生清淨悲,歷劫不捨弘誓故。不著己樂清淨悲,普與眾生快樂故。不求恩報清淨悲,修潔其心故。能除顛倒清淨悲,說如實法故。菩薩摩訶薩知一切法本性清淨、無染著、無熱惱,以客塵煩惱故而受眾苦;如是知已,於諸眾生而起大悲,名:本性清淨,為說無垢清淨光明法故。菩薩摩訶薩知一切法如空中鳥迹,眾生癡翳不能照了;觀察於彼,起大悲心,名:真實智,為其開示涅槃法故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來無上廣大清淨悲。 〔T10 0306〕 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨喜。何等為十?所謂:發菩提心清淨喜;悉捨所有清淨喜;不嫌棄破戒眾生而教化成就清淨喜;能忍受造惡眾生,誓願救度清淨喜;捨身求法不生悔心清淨喜;自捨欲樂,常樂法樂清淨喜;令一切眾生捨資生樂,常樂法樂清淨喜;見一切佛恭敬供養無有厭足,法界平等清淨喜;令一切眾生愛樂禪定、解脫、三昧遊戲入出清淨喜;心樂具行順菩薩道一切苦行,證得牟尼寂靜不動無上定慧清淨喜。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來無上廣大清淨喜。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨捨。何等為十?所謂:一切眾生恭敬供養,不生愛著清淨捨;一切眾生輕慢毀辱,不生瞋恚清淨捨;常行世間,不為世間八法所染清淨捨;於法器眾生待時而化,於無法器亦不生嫌清淨捨;不求二乘學、無學法清淨捨;心常遠離一切欲樂、順煩惱法清淨捨;不歎二乘、厭離生死清淨捨;遠離一切世間語,非涅槃語、非離欲語、不順理語、惱亂他語、聲聞獨覺語,略說乃至一切障菩薩道語皆悉遠離清淨捨;或有眾生,根已成熟發生念慧而未能知最上之法,待時方化清淨捨;或有眾生,菩薩往昔已曾教化至於佛地方可調伏,彼亦待時清淨捨;菩薩摩訶薩於彼二人,無高無下,無取無捨,遠離一切種種分別,恒住正定,入如實法,心得堪忍清淨捨。是為十。若諸菩薩安住其中,則得如來無上廣大清淨捨。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種義。何等為十?所謂:多聞義,堅固修行故;法義,善巧思擇故;空義,第一義空故;寂靜義,離諸眾生諠憒故;不可說義,不著一切語言故;如實義,了達三世平等故;法界義,一切諸法一味故;真如義,一切如來順入故;實際義,了知究竟如實故;大般涅槃義,滅一切苦而修菩薩諸行故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得一切智無上義。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種法。何等為十?所謂:真實法,如說修行故;離取法,能取、所取悉離故;無諍法,無有一切惑諍故;寂滅法,滅除一切熱惱故;離欲法,一切貪欲皆斷故;無分別法,攀緣分別永息故;無生法,猶如虛空不動故;無為法,離生、住、滅諸相故;本性法,自性無染清淨故;捨一切烏波提涅槃法,能生一切菩薩行,修習不斷故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住其中,則得如來無上廣大法。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種福德助道具。何等為十?所謂:勸眾生起菩提心,是菩薩福德助道具;不斷三寶種故。隨順十種迴向,是菩薩福德助道具;斷一切不善法,集一切善法故。智慧誘誨,是菩薩福德助道具;超過三界福德故。心無疲倦,是菩薩福德助道具;究竟度脫一切眾生故。悉捨內外一切所有,是菩薩福德助道具;於一切物無所著故。為滿足相好精進不退,是菩薩福德助道具;開門大施無所限故。上、中、下三品善根,悉以迴向無上菩提,心無所輕,是菩薩福德助道具;善巧方便相應故。於邪定、下劣、不善眾生,皆生大悲,不懷輕賤,是菩薩福德助道具;常起大人弘誓心故。恭敬供養一切如來,於一切菩薩起如來想,令一切眾生皆生歡喜,是菩薩福德助道具;守本志願極堅牢故。菩薩摩訶薩於阿僧祇劫積集善根,自欲取證無上菩提如在掌中,然悉捨與一切眾生,心無憂惱亦無悔恨,其心廣大等虛空界,此是菩薩福德助道具;起大智慧證大法故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住其中,則具足如來無上廣大福德聚。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種智慧助道具。何等為十?所謂:親近多聞真善知識,恭敬供養,尊重禮拜,種種隨順,不違其教,是為一;一切正直無虛矯故。永離憍慢,常行謙敬,身、語、意業無有麁獷,柔和善順,不偽不曲,是為二;其身堪作佛法器故。念慧隨覺未曾散亂,慚愧柔和,心安不動,常憶六念,常行六敬,常隨順住六堅固法,是為三;與十種智為方便故。樂法、樂義,以法為樂,常樂聽聞無有厭足,捨離世論及世言說,專心聽受出世間語,遠離小乘,入大乘慧,是為四;一心憶念無散動故。六波羅蜜心專荷負,四種梵住行已成熟,隨順明法悉善修行,聰敏智人皆勤請問,遠離惡趣,歸向善道,心常愛樂,正念觀察,調伏己情,守護他意,是為五;堅固修行真實行故。常樂出離,不著三有,恒覺自心,曾無惡念,三覺已絕,三業皆善,決定了知心之自性,是為六;能令自他心清淨故。觀察五蘊皆如幻事,界如毒蛇,處如空聚,一切諸法如幻、如焰、如水中月、如夢、如影、如響、如像、如空中畫、如旋火輪、如虹霓色、如日月光,無相無形,非常非斷,不來不去,亦無所住,如是觀察,知一切法無生無滅,是為七;知一切法性空寂故。菩薩摩訶薩聞一切法無我、無眾生、無壽者、無補伽羅、無心、無境、無貪瞋癡、無身、無物、無主、無待、無著、無行,如是一切皆無所有、悉歸寂滅,聞已深信,不疑不謗,是為八;以能成就圓滿解故。菩薩摩訶薩善調諸根,如理修行,恒住止觀,心意寂靜,一切動念皆悉不生,無我、無人、無作、無行、無計我想、無計我業、無有瘡疣、無有瘢痕,亦無於此所得之忍,身、語、意業無來無去,無有精進亦無勇猛,觀一切眾生、一切諸法,心皆平等而無所住,非此岸、非彼岸,此彼性離,無所從來,無所至去,常以智慧如是思惟,是為九;到分別相彼岸處故。菩薩摩訶薩見緣起法故見法清淨,見法清淨故見國土清淨,見國土清淨故見虛空清淨,見虛空清淨故見法界清淨,見法界清淨故見智慧清淨,是為十;修行積集一切智故。佛子!是為菩薩摩訶薩十種智慧助道具。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來一切法無障礙清淨微妙智慧聚。 〔T10 0307〕 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種明足。何等為十?所謂:善分別諸法明足;不取著諸法明足;離顛倒見明足;智慧光照諸根明足;巧發起正精進明足;能深入真諦智明足;滅煩惱業成就盡智無生智明足;天眼智普觀察明足;宿住念知前際清淨明足;漏盡神通智斷眾生諸漏明足。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來於一切佛法無上大光明。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種求法。何等為十?所謂:直心求法,無有諂誑故;精進求法,遠離懈慢故;一向求法,不惜身命故;為斷一切眾生煩惱求法,不為名利恭敬故;為饒益自他一切眾生求法,不但自利故;為入智慧求法,不樂文字故;為出生死求法,不貪世樂故;為度眾生求法,發菩提心故;為斷一切眾生疑求法,令無猶豫故;為滿足佛法求法,不樂餘乘故。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得不由他教一切佛法大智慧。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種明了法。何等為十?所謂:隨順世俗生長善根,是童蒙凡夫明了法;得無礙不壞信,覺法自性,是隨信行人明了法;勤修習法,隨順法住,是隨法行人明了法;遠離八邪,向八正道,是第八人明了法;除滅眾結,斷生死漏,見真實諦,是須陀洹人明了法;觀味是患,知無往來,是斯陀含人明了法;不樂三界,求盡有漏,於受生法乃至一念不生愛著,是阿那含人明了法;獲六神通,得八解脫,九定、四辯悉皆成就,是阿羅漢人明了法;性樂觀察一味緣起,心常寂靜,知足少事,解因自得,悟不由他,成就種種神通智慧,是辟支佛人明了法;智慧廣大,諸根明利,常樂度脫一切眾生,勤修福智助道之法,如來所有十力、無畏、一切功德具足圓滿,是菩薩人明了法。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來無上大智明了法。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種修行法。何等為十?所謂:恭敬尊重諸善知識修行法;常為諸天之所覺悟修行法;於諸佛所常懷慚愧修行法;哀愍眾生不捨生死修行法;事必究竟心無變動修行法;專念隨逐發大乘心諸菩薩眾精勤修學修行法;遠離邪見勤求正道修行法;摧破眾魔及煩惱業修行法;知諸眾生根性勝劣而為說法令住佛地修行法;安住無邊廣大法界除滅煩惱令身清淨修行法。是為十。若諸菩薩安住其中,則得如來無上修行法。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種魔。何等為十?所謂:蘊魔,生諸取故;煩惱魔,恒雜染故;業魔,能障礙故;心魔,起高慢故;死魔,捨生處故;天魔,自憍縱故;善根魔,恒執取故;三昧魔,久耽味故;善知識魔,起著心故;菩提法智魔,不願捨離故。是為十。菩薩摩訶薩應作方便,速求遠離。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種魔業。何等為十?所謂:忘失菩提心修諸善根,是為魔業;惡心布施,瞋心持戒,捨惡性人,遠懈怠者,輕慢亂意,譏嫌惡慧,是為魔業;於甚深法心生慳吝,有堪化者而不為說,若得財利恭敬供養,雖非法器而強為說,是為魔業;不樂聽聞諸波羅蜜,假使聞說而不修行,雖亦修行多生懈怠,以懈怠故,志意狹劣,不求無上大菩提法,是為魔業;遠善知識,近惡知識,樂求二乘,不樂受生,志尚涅槃離欲寂靜,是為魔業;於菩薩所起瞋恚心,惡眼視之,求其罪釁,說其過惡,斷彼所有財利供養,是為魔業;誹謗正法不樂聽聞,假使得聞便生毀呰,見人說法不生尊重,言自說是,餘說悉非,是為魔業;樂學世論巧術文詞,開闡二乘,隱覆深法,或以妙義授非其人,遠離菩提住於邪道,是為魔業;已得解脫、已安隱者常樂親近而供養之,未得解脫、未安隱者不肯親近亦不教化,是為魔業;增長我慢,無有恭敬,於諸眾生多行惱害,不求正法真實智慧,其心弊惡難可開悟,是為魔業。是為十。菩薩摩訶薩應速遠離,勤求佛業。 〔T10 0308〕 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種捨離魔業。何等為十?所謂:近善知識恭敬供養,捨離魔業;不自尊舉,不自讚歎,捨離魔業;於佛深法信解不謗,捨離魔業;未曾忘失一切智心,捨離魔業;勤修妙行恒不放逸,捨離魔業;常求一切菩薩藏法,捨離魔業;恒演說法,心無疲倦,捨離魔業;歸依十方一切諸佛,起救護想,捨離魔業;信受憶念一切諸佛,神力加持,捨離魔業;與一切菩薩同種善根,平等無二,捨離魔業。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則能出離一切魔道。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種見佛。何等為十?所謂:於安住世間成正覺佛無著見;願佛出生見;業報佛深信見;住持佛隨順見;涅槃佛深入見;法界佛普至見;心佛安住見;三昧佛無量無依見;本性佛明了見;隨樂佛普受見。是為十。若諸菩薩安住此法,則常得見無上如來。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種佛業。何等為十?所謂:隨時開導,是佛業;令正修行故。夢中令見,是佛業;覺昔善根故。為他演說所未聞經,是佛業;令生智斷疑故。為悔纏所纏者說出離法,是佛業;令離疑心故。若有眾生起慳吝心,乃至惡慧心、二乘心、損害心、疑惑心、散動心、憍慢心,為現如來眾相莊嚴身,是佛業;生長過去善根故。於正法難遇時,廣為說法,令其聞已,得陀羅尼智、神通智,普能利益無量眾生,是佛業;勝解清淨故。若有魔事起,能以方便現虛空界等聲,說不損惱他法以為對治,令其開悟,眾魔聞已威光歇滅,是佛業;志樂殊勝,威德大故。其心無間,常自守護,不令證入二乘正位,若有眾生根性未熟,終不為說解脫境界,是佛業;本願所作故。生死結漏一切皆離,修菩薩行相續不斷,以大悲心攝取眾生,令其起行究竟解脫,是佛業;不斷修行菩薩行故。菩薩摩訶薩了達自身及以眾生本來寂滅不驚不怖而勤修福智無有厭足,雖知一切法無有造作而亦不捨諸法自相,雖於諸境界永離貪欲而常樂瞻奉諸佛色身,雖知不由他悟入於法而種種方便求一切智,雖知諸國土皆如虛空而常樂莊嚴一切佛剎,雖恒觀察無人無我而教化眾生無有疲厭,雖於法界本來不動而以神通智力現眾變化,雖已成就一切智智而修菩薩行無有休息,雖知諸法不可言說而轉淨法輪令眾心喜,雖能示現諸佛神力而不厭捨菩薩之身,雖現入於大般涅槃而一切處示現受生,能作如是權實雙行法,是佛業。是為十。若諸菩薩安住其中,則得不由他教無上無師廣大業。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種慢業。何等為十?所謂:於師、僧、父母、沙門、婆羅門、住於正道向正道者,尊重福田所而不恭敬,是慢業;或有法師獲最勝法,乘於大乘,知出要道,得陀羅尼,演說契經廣大之法無有休息,而於其所起高慢心,及於所說法不生恭敬,是慢業;於眾會中聞說妙法,不肯歎美令人信受,是慢業;好起過慢,自高陵物,不見己失,不知自短,是慢業;好起過過慢,見有德人應讚不讚,見他讚歎不生歡喜,是慢業;見有法師為人說法,知是法、是律、是真實、是佛語,為嫌其人亦嫌其法,自起誹謗亦令他謗,是慢業;自求高座,自稱法師,應受供給,不應執事,見有耆舊久修行人不起逢迎、不肯承事,是慢業;見有德人,顰蹙不喜,言辭麁獷,伺其過失,是慢業;見有聰慧知法之人,不肯親近恭敬供養,不肯諮問:『何等為善?何等不善?何等應作?何等不應作?作何等業,於長夜中而得種種利益安樂?』愚癡頑很,我慢所吞,終不能見出要之道,是慢業;復有眾生慢心所覆,諸佛出世不能親近恭敬供養,新善不起,舊善消滅,不應說而說,不應諍而諍,未來必墮險難深坑,於百千劫尚不值佛,何況聞法!但以曾發菩提心故,終自醒悟,是慢業。是為十。 「若諸菩薩離此慢業,則得十種智業。何等為十?所謂:信解業報,不壞因果,是智業;不捨菩提心,常念諸佛,是智業;近善知識恭敬供養,其心尊重終無厭怠,是智業;樂法、樂義無有厭足,遠離邪念,勤修正念,是智業;於一切眾生離於我慢,於諸菩薩起如來想,愛重正法如惜己身,尊奉如來如護己命,於修行者生諸佛想,是智業;身、語、意業無諸不善,讚美賢聖,隨順菩提,是智業;不壞緣起,離諸邪見,破闇得明,照一切法,是智業;十種迴向隨順修行,於諸波羅蜜起慈母想,於善巧方便起慈父想,以深淨心入菩提舍,是智業;施、戒、多聞、止觀、福慧,如是一切助道之法常勤積集無有厭倦,是智業;若有一業為佛所讚,能破眾魔煩惱鬪諍,能離一切障、蓋、纏、縛,能教化調伏一切眾生,能隨順智慧攝取正法,能嚴淨佛剎,能發起通明,皆勤修習無有懈退,是智業。是為十。若諸菩薩安住其中,則得如來一切善巧方便無上大智業。 〔T10 0309〕 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種魔所攝持。何等為十?所謂:懈怠心,魔所攝持;志樂狹劣,魔所攝持;於少行生足,魔所攝持;受一非餘,魔所攝持;不發大願,魔所攝持;樂處寂滅,斷除煩惱,魔所攝持;永斷生死,魔所攝持;捨菩薩行,魔所攝持;不化眾生,魔所攝持;疑謗正法,魔所攝持。是為十。 「若諸菩薩能棄捨此魔所攝持,則得十種佛所攝持。何等為十?所謂:初始能發菩提之心,佛所攝持;於生生中持菩提心不令忘失,佛所攝持;覺諸魔事,悉能遠離,佛所攝持;聞諸波羅蜜,如說修行,佛所攝持;知生死苦而不厭惡,佛所攝持;觀甚深法,得無量果,佛所攝持;為諸眾生說二乘法,而不證取彼乘解脫,佛所攝持;樂觀無為法而不住其中,於有為、無為不生二想,佛所攝持;至無生處而現受生,佛所攝持;雖證得一切智,而起菩薩行,不斷菩薩種,佛所攝持。是為十。若諸菩薩安住其中,則得諸佛無上攝持力。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種法所攝持。何等為十?所謂:知一切行無常,法所攝持;知一切行苦,法所攝持;知一切行無我,法所攝持;知一切法寂滅涅槃,法所攝持;知諸法從緣起,無緣則不起,法所攝持;知不正思惟故起於無明,無明起故乃至老死起,不正思惟滅故無明滅,無明滅故乃至老死滅,法所攝持;知三解脫門出生聲聞乘,證無諍法出生獨覺乘,法所攝持;知六波羅蜜、四攝法出生大乘,法所攝持;知一切剎、一切法、一切眾生、一切世是佛智境界,法所攝持;知斷一切念,捨一切取,離前後際,隨順涅槃,法所攝持。是為十。若諸菩薩安住其中,則得一切諸佛無上法所攝持。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩住兜率天,有十種所作業。何等為十?所謂:為欲界諸天子說厭離法言:『一切自在皆是無常,一切快樂悉當衰謝。』勸彼諸天發菩提心。是為第一所作業。為色界諸天說入出諸禪解脫三昧,若於其中而生愛著,因愛復起身見、邪見、無明等者,則為其說如實智慧;若於一切色、非色法起顛倒想,以為清淨,為說不淨皆是無常,勸其令發菩提之心。是為第二所作業。菩薩摩訶薩住兜率天,入三昧,名:光明莊嚴,身放光明,遍照三千大千世界,隨眾生心,以種種音而為說法;眾生聞已,信心清淨,命終生於兜率天中,勸其令發菩提之心。是為第三所作業。菩薩摩訶薩在兜率天,以無障礙眼普見十方兜率天中一切菩薩,彼諸菩薩皆亦見此;互相見已,論說妙法,謂:降神母胎、初生、出家、往詣道場、具大莊嚴;而復示現往昔已來所行之行,以彼行故成此大智;所有功德不離本處,而能示現如是等事。是為第四所作業。菩薩摩訶薩住兜率天,十方一切兜率天宮諸菩薩眾,皆悉來集,恭敬圍遶;爾時,菩薩摩訶薩欲令彼諸菩薩皆滿其願生歡喜故,隨彼菩薩所應住地、所行所斷、所修所證,演說法門;彼諸菩薩聞說法已,皆大歡喜,得未曾有,各還本土所住宮殿。是為第五所作業。菩薩摩訶薩住兜率天時,欲界主天魔波旬,為欲壞亂菩薩業故,眷屬圍遶詣菩薩所;爾時,菩薩為摧伏魔軍故,住金剛道所攝般若波羅蜜方便善巧智慧門,以柔軟、麁獷二種語而為說法,令魔波旬不得其便;魔見菩薩自在威力,皆發阿耨多羅三藐三菩提心。是為第六所作業。菩薩摩訶薩住兜率天,知欲界諸天子不樂聞法;爾時,菩薩出大音聲,遍告之言:『今日菩薩當於宮中現希有事,若欲見者宜速往詣。』時,諸天子聞是語已,無量百千億那由他皆來集會;爾時,菩薩見諸天眾皆來集已,為現宮中諸希有事;彼諸天子曾未見聞,既得見已,皆大歡喜,其心醉沒;又於樂中出聲告言:『諸仁者!一切諸行皆悉無常,一切諸行皆悉是苦,一切諸法皆悉無我,涅槃寂滅。』又復告言:『汝等皆應修菩薩行,皆當圓滿一切智智。』彼諸天子聞此法音,憂歎諮嗟而生厭離,靡不皆發菩提之心。是為第七所作業。菩薩摩訶薩住兜率宮,不捨本處,悉能往詣十方無量一切佛所,見諸如來親近禮拜恭敬聽法;爾時,諸佛欲令菩薩獲得最上灌頂法故,為說菩薩地,名:一切神通,以一念相應慧,具足一切最勝功德,入一切智智位。是為第八所作業。菩薩摩訶薩住兜率宮,為欲供養諸如來故,以大神力興起種種諸供養具,名:殊勝可樂,遍法界、虛空界、一切世界供養諸佛;彼世界中無量眾生見此供養,皆發阿耨多羅三藐三菩提心。是為第九所作業。菩薩摩訶薩住兜率天,出無量無邊如幻如影法門,周遍十方一切世界,示現種種色、種種相、種種形體、種種威儀、種種事業、種種方便、種種譬諭、種種言說,隨眾生心皆令歡喜。是為第十所作業。佛子!是為菩薩摩訶薩住兜率天十種所作業。若諸菩薩成就此法,則能於後下生人間。 〔T10 0310〕 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩於兜率天將下生時,現十種事。何等為十?佛子!菩薩摩訶薩於兜率天下生之時,從於足下放大光明,名:安樂莊嚴,普照三千大千世界一切惡趣諸難眾生;觸斯光者,莫不皆得離苦安樂;得安樂已,悉知將有奇特大人出興于世。是為第一所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩於兜率天下生之時,從於眉間白毫相中放大光明,名曰:覺悟,普照三千大千世界,照彼宿世一切同行諸菩薩身;彼諸菩薩蒙光照已,咸知菩薩將欲下生,各各出興無量供具,詣菩薩所而為供養。是為第二所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩於兜率天將下生時,於右掌中放大光明,名:清淨境界,悉能嚴淨一切三千大千世界,其中若有已得無漏諸辟支佛覺斯光者,即捨壽命;若不覺者,光明力故,徙置他方餘世界中;一切諸魔及諸外道、有見眾生,皆亦徙置他方世界,唯除諸佛神力所持應化眾生。是為第三所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩於兜率天將下生時,從其兩膝放大光明,名:清淨莊嚴,普照一切諸天宮殿,下從護世,上至淨居,靡不周遍;彼諸天等,咸知菩薩於兜率天將欲下生,俱懷戀慕,悲歎憂惱,各持種種華鬘、衣服、塗香、末香、幡蓋、妓樂,詣菩薩所恭敬供養,隨逐下生乃至涅槃。是為第四所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩在兜率天將下生時,於卍字金剛莊嚴心藏中放大光明,名:無能勝幢,普照十方一切世界金剛力士;時,有百億金剛力士皆悉來集,隨逐侍衛,始於下生,乃至涅槃。是為第五所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩於兜率天將下生時,從其身上一切毛孔放大光明,名:分別眾生,普照一切大千世界,遍觸一切諸菩薩身,復觸一切諸天世人;諸菩薩等咸作是念:『我應住此,供養如來,教化眾生。』是為第六所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩於兜率天將下生時,從大摩尼寶藏殿中放大光明,名:善住觀察,照此菩薩當生之處所託王宮;其光照已,諸餘菩薩皆共隨逐下閻浮提,若於其家、若其聚落、若其城邑而現受生,為欲教化諸眾生故。是為第七所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩於兜率天臨下生時,從天宮殿及大樓閣諸莊嚴中放大光明,名:一切宮殿清淨莊嚴,照所生母腹;光明照已,令菩薩母安隱快樂,具足成就一切功德,其母腹中自然而有廣大樓閣大摩尼寶而為莊嚴,為欲安處菩薩身故。是為第八所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩於兜率天臨下生時,從兩足下放大光明,名為:善住;若諸天子及諸梵天其命將終,蒙光照觸皆得住壽,供養菩薩從初下生乃至涅槃。是為第九所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩於兜率天臨下生時,從隨好中放大光明,名曰:眼莊嚴,示現菩薩種種諸業;時,諸人、天或見菩薩住兜率天,或見入胎,或見初生,或見出家,或見成道,或見降魔,或見轉法輪,或見入涅槃。是為第十所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩於身、於座、於宮殿、於樓閣中,放如是等百萬阿僧祇光明,悉現種種諸菩薩業;現是業已,具足一切功德法故,從兜率天下生人間。

〔卷59〕 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩示現處胎,有十種事。何等為十?佛子!菩薩摩訶薩為欲成就小心劣解諸眾生故,不欲令彼起如是念:『今此菩薩自然化生,智慧善根不從修得。』是故菩薩示現處胎。是為第一事。菩薩摩訶薩為成熟父母及諸眷屬、宿世同行眾生善根,示現處胎。何以故?彼皆應以見於處胎成熟所有諸善根故。是為第二事。菩薩摩訶薩入母胎時,正念正知,無有迷惑;住母胎已,心恒正念,亦無錯亂。是為第三事。菩薩摩訶薩在母胎中常演說法,十方世界諸大菩薩、釋、梵、四王皆來集會,悉令獲得無量神力、無邊智慧,菩薩處胎成就如是辯才、勝用。是為第四事。菩薩摩訶薩在母胎中集大眾會,以本願力教化一切諸菩薩眾。是為第五事。菩薩摩訶薩於人中成佛,應具人間最勝受生,以此示現處於母胎。是為第六事。菩薩摩訶薩在母胎中,三千大千世界眾生悉見菩薩,如明鏡中見其面像;爾時,大心天、龍、夜叉、乾闥婆、阿脩羅、迦樓羅、緊那羅、摩睺羅伽、人、非人等,皆詣菩薩,恭敬供養。是為第七事。菩薩摩訶薩在母胎中,他方世界一切最後生菩薩在母胎者,皆來共會,說大集法門,名:廣大智慧藏。是為第八事。菩薩摩訶薩在母胎時,入離垢藏三昧,以三昧力,於母胎中現大宮殿,種種嚴飾悉皆妙好,兜率天宮不可為比,而令母身安隱無患。是為第九事。菩薩摩訶薩住母胎時,以大威力興供養具,名:開大福德離垢藏,普遍十方一切世界,供養一切諸佛如來,彼諸如來咸為演說無邊菩薩住處法界藏。是為第十事。佛子!是為菩薩摩訶薩示現處胎十種事。若諸菩薩了達此法,則能示現甚微細趣。 〔T10 0311〕 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種甚微細趣。何等為十?所謂:在母胎中,示現初發菩提心,乃至灌頂地;在母胎中,示現住兜率天;在母胎中,示現初生;在母胎中,示現童子地;在母胎中,示現處王宮;在母胎中,示現出家;在母胎中,示現苦行,往詣道場,成等正覺;在母胎中,示現轉法輪;在母胎中,示現般涅槃;在母胎中,示現大微細,謂:一切菩薩行一切如來自在神力無量差別門。佛子!是為菩薩摩訶薩在母胎中十種微細趣。若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來無上大智慧微細趣。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種生。何等為十?所謂:遠離愚癡正念正知生;放大光明網普照三千大千世界生;住最後有更不受後身生;不生不起生;知三界如幻生;於十方世界普現身生;證一切智智身生;放一切佛光明普覺悟一切眾生身生;入大智觀察三昧身生;佛子!菩薩生時,震動一切佛剎,解脫一切眾生,除滅一切惡道,映蔽一切諸魔,無量菩薩皆來集會。佛子!是為菩薩摩訶薩十種生,為調伏眾生故,如是示現。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩以十事故,示現微笑心自誓。何等為十?所謂:菩薩摩訶薩念言:『一切世間沒在欲泥,除我一人無能免濟。』如是知已,熙怡微笑心自誓。復念言:『一切世間煩惱所盲,唯我今者具足智慧。』如是知已,熙怡微笑心自誓。又念言:『我今因此假名身故,當得如來充滿三世無上法身。』如是知已,熙怡微笑心自誓。菩薩爾時,以無障礙眼,遍觀十方所有梵天,乃至一切大自在天,作是念言:『此等眾生,皆自謂為有大智力。』如是知已,熙怡微笑心自誓。菩薩爾時觀諸眾生,久種善根,今皆退沒;如是知已,熙怡微笑心自誓。菩薩觀見世間種子,所種雖少,獲果甚多;如是知已,熙怡微笑心自誓。菩薩觀見一切眾生,蒙佛所教,必得利益;如是知已,熙怡微笑心自誓。菩薩觀見過去世中同行菩薩,染著餘事,不得佛法廣大功德;如是知已,熙怡微笑心自誓。菩薩觀見過去世中同共集會諸天人等,至今猶在凡夫之地,不能捨離,亦不疲厭;如是知已,熙怡微笑心自誓。菩薩爾時,為一切如來光明所觸,倍加欣慰,熙怡微笑心自誓。是為十。佛子!菩薩為調伏眾生故,如是示現。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩以十事故,示行七步。何等為十?所謂:現菩薩力故,示行七步;現施七財故,示行七步;滿地神願故,示行七步;現超三界相故,示行七步;現菩薩最勝行超過象王、牛王、師子王行故,示行七步;現金剛地相故,示行七步;現欲與眾生勇猛力故,示行七步;現修行七覺寶故,示行七步;現所得法不由他教故,示行七步;現於世間最勝無比故,示行七步。是為十。佛子!菩薩為調伏眾生故,如是示現。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩以十事故,現處童子地。何等為十?所謂:為現通達一切世間文字、算計、圖書、印璽種種業故,處童子地;為現通達一切世間象馬、車乘、弧矢、劍戟種種業故,處童子地;為現通達一切世間文筆、談論、博弈、嬉戲種種事故,處童子地;為現遠離身、語、意業諸過失故,處童子地;為現入定住涅槃門,周遍十方無量世界故,處童子地;為現其力超過一切天、龍、夜叉、乾闥婆、阿脩羅、迦樓羅、緊那羅、摩睺羅伽、釋、梵、護世、人、非人等故,處童子地;為現菩薩色相威光超過一切釋、梵、護世故,處童子地;為令耽著欲樂眾生歡喜樂法故,處童子地;為尊重正法,勤供養佛,周遍十方一切世界故,處童子地;為現得佛加被蒙法光明故,處童子地。是為十。 〔T10 0312〕 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩現童子地已,以十事故現處王宮。何等為十?所謂:為令宿世同行眾生善根成熟故,現處王宮;為顯示菩薩善根力故,現處王宮;為諸人、天耽著樂具,示現菩薩大威德樂具故,現處王宮;順五濁世眾生心故,現處王宮;為現菩薩大威德力能於深宮入三昧故,現處王宮;為令宿世同願眾生滿其意故,現處王宮;欲令父母、親戚、眷屬滿所願故,現處王宮;欲以妓樂出妙法音供養一切諸如來故,現處王宮;欲於宮內住微妙三昧,始從成佛乃至涅槃皆示現故,現處王宮;為隨順守護諸佛法故,現處王宮。是為十。最後身菩薩如是示現處王宮已,然後出家。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩以十事故,示現出家。何等為十?所謂:為厭居家故,示現出家;為著家眾生令捨離故,示現出家;為隨順信樂聖人道故,示現出家;為宣揚讚歎出家功德故,示現出家;為顯永離二邊見故,示現出家;為令眾生離欲樂、我樂故,示現出家;為先現出三界相故,示現出家;為現自在不屬他故,示現出家;為顯當得如來十力、無畏法故,示現出家;最後菩薩法應爾故,示現出家。是為十。菩薩以此調伏眾生。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩為十種事故,示行苦行。何等為十?所謂:為成就劣解眾生故,示行苦行;為拔邪見眾生故,示行苦行;為不信業報眾生令見業報故,示行苦行;為隨順雜染世界法應爾故,示行苦行;示能忍劬勞勤修道故,示行苦行;為令眾生樂求法故,示行苦行;為著欲樂、我樂眾生故,示行苦行;為顯菩薩起行殊勝,乃至最後生猶不捨勤精進故,示行苦行;為令眾生樂寂靜法,增長善根故,示行苦行;為諸天、世人諸根未熟,待時成熟故,示行苦行。是為十。菩薩以此方便調伏一切眾生。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩往詣道場有十種事。何等為十?所謂:詣道場時,照耀一切世界;詣道場時,震動一切世界;詣道場時,於一切世界普現其身;詣道場時,覺悟一切菩薩及一切宿世同行眾生;詣道場時,示現道場一切莊嚴;詣道場時,隨諸眾生心之所欲,而為現身種種威儀,及菩提樹一切莊嚴;詣道場時,現見十方一切如來;詣道場時,舉足、下足常入三昧,念念成佛無有超隔;詣道場時,一切天、龍、夜叉、乾闥婆、阿脩羅、迦樓羅、緊那羅、摩睺羅伽、釋、梵、護世一切諸王各不相知,而興種種上妙供養;詣道場時,以無礙智,普觀一切諸佛如來於一切世界修菩薩行而成正覺。是為十。菩薩以此教化眾生。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩坐道場有十種事。何等為十?所謂:坐道場時,種種震動一切世界;坐道場時,平等照耀一切世界;坐道場時,除滅一切諸惡趣苦;坐道場時,令一切世界金剛所成;坐道場時,普觀一切諸佛如來師子之座;坐道場時,心如虛空,無所分別;坐道場時,隨其所應,現身威儀;坐道場時,隨順安住金剛三昧;坐道場時,受一切如來神力所持清淨妙處;坐道場時,自善根力悉能加被一切眾生。是為十。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,有十種奇特未曾有事。何等為十?佛子!菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,十方世界一切如來皆現其前,咸舉右手而稱讚言:『善哉善哉!無上導師!』是為第一未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,一切如來皆悉護念,與其威力,是為第二未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,宿世同行諸菩薩眾悉來圍遶,以種種莊嚴具恭敬供養,是為第三未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,一切世界草木、叢林諸無情物,皆曲身低影,歸向道場,是為第四未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,入三昧,名:觀察法界,此三昧力能令菩薩一切諸行悉得圓滿,是為第五未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,得陀羅尼,名:最上離垢妙光海藏,能受一切諸佛如來大雲法雨,是為第六未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,以威德力興上妙供具,遍一切世界供養諸佛,是為第七未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,住最勝智,悉現了知一切眾生諸根意行,是為第八未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,入三昧,名:善覺,此三昧力能令其身充滿三世盡虛空界一切世界,是為第九未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,得離垢光明無礙大智,令其身業普入三世,是為第十未曾有事。佛子!是為菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,十種奇特未曾有事。 〔T10 0313〕 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,觀十種義故,示現降魔。何等為十?所謂:為濁世眾生樂於鬪戰,欲顯菩薩威德力故,示現降魔;為諸天、世人有懷疑者,斷彼疑故,示現降魔;為教化調伏諸魔軍故,示現降魔;為欲令諸天、世人樂軍陣者,咸來聚觀,心調伏故,示現降魔;為顯示菩薩所有威力世無能敵故,示現降魔;為欲發起一切眾生勇猛力故,示現降魔;為哀愍末世諸眾生故,示現降魔;為欲顯示乃至道場猶有魔軍而來觸惱,此後乃得超魔境界故,示現降魔;為顯煩惱業用羸劣,大慈善根勢力強盛故,示現降魔;為欲隨順濁惡世界所行法故,示現降魔。是為十。 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種成如來力。何等為十?所謂:超過一切眾魔煩惱業故,成如來力;具足一切菩薩行,遊戲一切菩薩三昧門故,成如來力;具足一切菩薩廣大禪定故,成如來力;圓滿一切白淨助道法故,成如來力;得一切法智慧光明,善思惟分別故,成如來力;其身周遍一切世界故,成如來力;所出言音悉與一切眾生心等故,成如來力;能以神力加持一切故,成如來力;與三世諸佛身、語、意業等無有異,於一念中了三世法故,成如來力;得善覺智三昧,具如來十力,所謂:是處非處智力乃至漏盡智力故,成如來力。是為十。若諸菩薩具此十力,則名:如來、應、正等覺。 「佛子!如來、應、正等覺轉大法輪有十種事。何等為十?一者,具足清淨四無畏智;二者,出生四辯隨順音聲;三者,善能開闡四真諦相;四者,隨順諸佛無礙解脫;五者,能令眾生心皆淨信;六者,所有言說皆不唐捐,能拔眾生諸苦毒箭;七者,大悲願力之所加持;八者,隨出音聲普遍十方一切世界;九者,於阿僧祇劫說法不斷;十者,隨所說法皆能生起根、力、覺道、禪定、解脫、三昧等法。佛子!諸佛如來轉於法輪,有如是等無量種事。 「佛子!如來、應、正等覺轉法輪時,以十事故,於眾生心中種白淨法,無空過者。何等為十?所謂:過去願力故;大悲所持故;不捨眾生故;智慧自在,隨其所樂為說法故;必應其時,未曾失故;隨其所宜,無妄說故;知三世智,善了知故;其身最勝,無與等故;言辭自在,無能測故;智慧自在,隨所發言悉開悟故。是為十。 「佛子!如來、應、正等覺作佛事已,觀十種義故,示般涅槃。何等為十?所謂:示一切行實無常故;示一切有為非安隱故;示大涅槃是安隱處,無怖畏故;以諸人、天樂著色身,為現色身是無常法,令其願住淨法身故;示無常力不可轉故;示一切有為不隨心住,不自在故;示一切三有皆如幻化,不堅牢故;示涅槃性究竟堅牢,不可壞故;示一切法無生無起而有聚集、散壞相故;佛子!諸佛世尊作佛事已,所願滿已,轉法輪已,應化度者皆化度已,有諸菩薩應受尊號成記別已,法應如是入於不變大般涅槃。佛子!是為如來、應、正等覺觀十義故,示般涅槃。

The canonical text stands in Chinese only. This edition renders the essence, the plain reading, the exposition and the apparatus into English — never the sūtra itself. Switch to 漢讀本 or 並行雙語 above to read it.

白話Plain reading

本段自始至終是普賢菩薩一人在說,聽的是普慧等諸菩薩。四十九門的開頭都是普賢對大眾的一聲呼喚「佛子」(門29、門31承前作「若諸菩薩」起)。末三門(門49–51)語法主語轉成「如來、應、正等覺」,說的是佛的事,仍是普賢在說,不是佛自己在場開口。


第一門 觀察:十種看事情的眼力

(普賢菩薩對普慧等諸菩薩說:)

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種觀察。哪十種呢?就是:知道一切業的觀察——因為連最細微的業也全看得見;知道一切趣向的觀察——因為看見了眾生流轉的去處,卻不執取有一個實在的眾生;知道一切根器的觀察——因為通達了根器本無定性;知道一切法的觀察——因為觀察時不破壞法界;見佛法的觀察——因為勤修佛眼;得智慧的觀察——因為能如理說法;無生忍的觀察——因為對佛法已決斷明了;不退地的觀察——因為滅了一切煩惱,超出三界和二乘的地位;灌頂地的觀察——因為對一切佛法自在而不動搖;善覺智三昧的觀察——因為在十方一切處都能施作佛事。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到如來無上的大觀察智。

第二門 普觀察:十種周遍地看

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種普觀察。哪十種呢?就是:普遍觀照一切前來乞求的人——以不違逆的心滿他們的願;普遍觀照一切犯戒的眾生——把他們安置在如來的淨戒中;普遍觀照一切懷著害心的眾生——把他們安置在如來的忍力中;普遍觀照一切懈怠的眾生——勸他們精勤,不放下大乘這副擔子;普遍觀照一切心散亂的眾生——使他們住在如來一切智地而不再散動;普遍觀照一切惡慧的眾生——為他們除去疑惑、破掉有見;普遍觀照一切平等的善友——順從他們的教誨而住於佛法;普遍觀照一切所聽聞的法——好快快證見最上的義;普遍觀照一切無邊的眾生——常不捨離大悲之力;普遍觀照一切諸佛之法——好快快成就一切智。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到如來無上的大智慧普觀察。

第三門 奮迅:十種威勢頓發之相

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種奮迅。哪十種呢?就是:牛王的奮迅——因為映蔽了一切天、龍、夜叉、乾闥婆等大眾;象王的奮迅——因為心性善於調柔,能荷負一切眾生;龍王的奮迅——因為興起大法的密雲,閃耀解脫的電光,震動如實義的雷聲,降下諸根、力、覺分、禪定、解脫、三昧的甘露雨;大金翅鳥王的奮迅——因為竭盡貪愛之水,破開愚癡之殼,抓取煩惱這些惡毒龍,令牠們出離生死大苦海;大師子王的奮迅——因為安住在無畏的平等大智上,拿它當器仗,摧伏眾魔和外道;勇健的奮迅——因為能在生死這座大戰陣中摧滅一切煩惱之怨;大智的奮迅——因為知道蘊、界、處以及諸緣起,能自在地開示一切法;陀羅尼的奮迅——因為以念力慧力持法不忘,隨眾生的根器為他們宣說;辯才的奮迅——因為無礙迅疾地分別一切,都令聽者受益而心生歡喜;如來的奮迅——因為一切智智的助道之法全部圓滿,以一念相應的慧,該得的全得,該悟的全悟,坐上師子座降伏魔怨,成就阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到諸佛在一切法上無上自在的奮迅。

第四門 師子吼:十句決定無畏的宣唱

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種師子吼。哪十種呢?就是:唱說:『我一定要成就正等覺。』這是菩提心的大師子吼。『我要令一切眾生,沒得度的得度,沒解脫的解脫,沒得安穩的得安穩,沒得涅槃的令他得涅槃。』這是大悲的大師子吼。『我要令佛、法、僧三種姓永不斷絕。』這是報如來恩的大師子吼。『我要嚴淨一切佛剎。』這是究竟堅誓的大師子吼。『我要除滅一切惡道和一切難處。』這是自持淨戒的大師子吼。『我要滿足一切諸佛身、語、意的相好莊嚴。』這是求福無厭的大師子吼。『我要成滿一切諸佛所有的智慧。』這是求智無厭的大師子吼。『我要除滅一切眾魔和一切魔業。』這是修正行斷煩惱的大師子吼。『我要了知一切諸法無我,沒有眾生、沒有壽命、沒有補伽羅,空、無相、無願,清淨得像虛空一樣。』這是無生法忍的大師子吼。最後身的菩薩震動一切諸佛國土,使它們全都嚴淨;這時候,一切帝釋、梵王、四天王都來讚歎勸請:『唯願菩薩以無生之法而示現受生!』菩薩就用無礙的慧眼普遍觀看世間,說:『一切眾生沒有能和我相比的。』隨即在王宮示現誕生,自行七步作大師子吼:『我在世間最勝第一,我要永盡生死的邊際。』這是說到做到的大師子吼。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到如來無上的大師子吼。

第五門 清淨施:十種不夾雜的布施

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨施。哪十種呢?就是:平等施——因為不挑揀眾生;隨意施——因為滿他所願;不亂施——因為要令他真得利益;隨宜施——因為知道上、中、下之別;不住施——因為不求果報;開捨施——因為心不戀著;一切施——因為究竟清淨;迴向菩提施——因為遠離了有為和無為兩邊;教化眾生施——因為直到道場都不捨棄;三輪清淨施——因為對施的人、受的人以及所施之物都正念觀察,如同虛空。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到如來無上清淨廣大的布施。

第六門 清淨戒:十種不夾雜的持戒

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨戒。哪十種呢?就是:身清淨戒——因為守護身上的三種惡;語清淨戒——因為離開口上的四種過;心清淨戒——因為永離貪、瞋、邪見;不破一切學處的清淨戒——因為要在一切人、天中作尊主;守護菩提心的清淨戒——因為不愛樂小乘;守護如來所制的清淨戒——因為連細微的罪都生起大怖畏;隱密護持的清淨戒——因為要善巧地拔救犯戒的眾生;不作一切惡的清淨戒——因為誓願修一切善法;遠離一切有見的清淨戒——因為對戒本身也不執著;守護一切眾生的清淨戒——因為由此發起大悲。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到如來無上無過失的清淨戒。

第七門 清淨忍:十種不夾雜的忍

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨忍。哪十種呢?就是:安然承受詆毀羞辱的清淨忍——因為要護念眾生;安然承受刀杖的清淨忍——因為要善護自己和他人;不生恚害的清淨忍——因為心不動;不責備卑賤者的清淨忍——因為居上位的人本該寬容;有來歸投就全都救護的清淨忍——因為連自己的身命都能捨;遠離我慢的清淨忍——因為不輕視還沒學的人;被殘害毀辱也不瞋的清淨忍——因為觀察這一切如幻;他人有犯而不報復的清淨忍——因為不見有自也不見有他;不隨煩惱的清淨忍——因為離開了諸境界;隨順菩薩真實智、了知一切法無生的清淨忍——因為不由他人教導,就入了一切智的境界。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這裡面,就能得到一切諸佛不由他悟的無上法忍。

第八門 清淨精進:十種不夾雜的精進

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨精進。哪十種呢?就是:身的清淨精進——承事供養諸佛菩薩和諸位師長,尊重福田而不退轉;語的清淨精進——隨所聽到的法廣為他人宣說,讚佛功德而不疲倦;意的清淨精進——善能出入慈、悲、喜、捨、禪定、解脫以及諸三昧,沒有休息;正直心的清淨精進——不欺誑不諂媚,不彎曲不虛偽,一切都勤修而不退轉;增勝心的清淨精進——志向常趣求上上的智慧,願具足一切白淨之法;不唐捐的清淨精進——攝取布施、持戒、忍辱、多聞以及不放逸,一直到菩提中間都不停歇;摧伏一切魔的清淨精進——能全部除滅貪欲、瞋恚、愚癡、邪見、一切煩惱和諸纏蓋;成滿智慧光的清淨精進——凡有所作都善加觀察,都使它究竟,不令自己後悔,得到一切佛的不共法;無來無去的清淨精進——得到如實之智,入法界之門,身、語和心全都平等,了知相即非相,無所執著;成就法光的清淨精進——超過諸地,得佛灌頂,以無漏之身而示現歿、生、出家、成道、說法、滅度,具足這樣的普賢事。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到如來無上的大清淨精進。

第九門 清淨禪:十種不夾雜的禪

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨禪。哪十種呢?就是:常樂出家的清淨禪——因為捨了一切所有;得到真善友的清淨禪——因為有人示教正道;住在阿蘭若、能忍風雨等的清淨禪——因為離了我和我所;離開喧鬧眾生的清淨禪——因為常愛樂寂靜;心的作用調柔的清淨禪——因為守護諸根;心智寂滅的清淨禪——因為一切音聲、諸禪定之刺都擾亂不了;覺道方便的清淨禪——因為觀察一切都是現前所證;離於味著的清淨禪——因為不捨欲界;發起神通與明的清淨禪——因為知道一切眾生的根性;自在遊戲的清淨禪——因為入佛三昧,知道無我。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這裡面,就能得到如來無上的大清淨禪。

第十門 清淨慧:十種不夾雜的智慧

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨慧。哪十種呢?就是:知道一切因的清淨慧——因為不壞果報;知道一切緣的清淨慧——因為不違背和合之理;知道不斷不常的清淨慧——因為對緣起全都如實了達;拔除一切見的清淨慧——因為對眾生之相無取無捨;觀察一切眾生心行的清淨慧——因為了知它如幻;廣大辯才的清淨慧——因為分別諸法、問答無礙;一切諸魔、外道、聲聞、獨覺都不能知的清淨慧——因為深入了一切如來之智;見一切佛微妙法身、見一切眾生本性清淨、見一切法全都寂滅、見一切剎土等同虛空的清淨慧——因為知道一切相都無障礙;一切總持、辯才、方便波羅蜜的清淨慧——因為令人得到一切最勝之智;一念相應的金剛智、了知一切法平等的清淨慧——因為得到一切法中最尊之智。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這裡面,就能得到如來無障礙的大智慧。

第十一門 清淨慈:十種不夾雜的慈

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨慈。哪十種呢?就是:等心的清淨慈——因為普遍攝受眾生而不加挑揀;饒益的清淨慈——因為隨所作為都令人歡喜;把別人當成自己的清淨慈——因為究竟要令他們出離生死;不捨世間的清淨慈——因為心常緣念著積集善根;能到解脫的清淨慈——因為普遍使眾生除滅一切煩惱;出生菩提的清淨慈——因為普遍使眾生發起求一切智的心;世間無礙的清淨慈——因為放大光明平等普照;充滿虛空的清淨慈——因為救護眾生無處不到;法緣的清淨慈——因為證於如如的真實法;無緣的清淨慈——因為入於菩薩的離生之性。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到如來無上廣大的清淨慈。

第十二門 清淨悲:十種不夾雜的悲

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨悲。哪十種呢?就是:沒有同伴的清淨悲——因為是自己獨自發起這個心。不疲厭的清淨悲——因為代一切眾生受苦,不以為勞。在難處受生的清淨悲——因為是為度眾生。在善趣受生的清淨悲——因為要示現無常。為邪定眾生而起的清淨悲——因為歷劫都不捨棄弘誓。不貪著自己安樂的清淨悲——因為要普遍給眾生快樂。不求報恩的清淨悲——因為只是修潔自己的心。能除顛倒的清淨悲——因為要說如實之法。菩薩摩訶薩知道一切法本性清淨、無染著、無熱惱,只因為客塵煩惱才受種種苦;這樣知道以後,對眾生生起大悲,名為『本性清淨』——因為要為他們宣說無垢清淨光明之法。菩薩摩訶薩知道一切法如同空中鳥飛過的痕跡,眾生被癡翳障蔽而照不明白;觀察他們而起大悲心,名為『真實智』——因為要為他們開示涅槃之法。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到如來無上廣大的清淨悲。

第十三門 清淨喜:十種不夾雜的歡喜

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨喜。哪十種呢?就是:發菩提心的清淨喜;把所有的全捨出去的清淨喜;不嫌棄破戒眾生而教化成就他們的清淨喜;能忍受造惡的眾生、並且誓願救度他們的清淨喜;捨身求法而不生後悔的清淨喜;自己捨掉欲樂、常樂於法樂的清淨喜;令一切眾生捨掉資生之樂、常樂於法樂的清淨喜;見一切佛恭敬供養而沒有厭足、法界平等的清淨喜;令一切眾生愛樂禪定、解脫、三昧、出入遊戲的清淨喜;心中樂於具足修行順菩薩道的一切苦行、證得寂默寂靜不動的無上定慧的清淨喜。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到如來無上廣大的清淨喜。

第十四門 清淨捨:十種不夾雜的平等捨

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種清淨捨。哪十種呢?就是:一切眾生恭敬供養而不生愛著的清淨捨;一切眾生輕慢毀辱而不生瞋恚的清淨捨;常行走在世間而不被世間八法所染的清淨捨;對堪受法的眾生等待時機而化度、對不堪受法的也不生嫌棄的清淨捨;不求二乘有學、無學之法的清淨捨;心常遠離一切欲樂和隨順煩惱之法的清淨捨;不讚歎二乘、不厭離生死的清淨捨;遠離一切世間的言語,凡是非涅槃之語、非離欲之語、不順理之語、惱亂他人之語、聲聞獨覺之語,簡要地說,一切障礙菩薩道的言語全都遠離的清淨捨;有的眾生根器已經成熟、發生了念與慧卻還不能知曉最上之法,就等待時機再化度的清淨捨;有的眾生是菩薩往昔已經教化過、要到佛地才可調伏的,對他也一樣等待時機的清淨捨;菩薩摩訶薩對這兩種人,無高無下,無取無捨,遠離一切種種分別,恒住正定,入如實之法,心得堪忍的清淨捨。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這裡面,就能得到如來無上廣大的清淨捨。

第十五門 義:十種所詮之義

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種義。哪十種呢?就是:多聞的義——因為在於堅固地修行;法的義——因為在於善巧地思擇;空的義——因為是第一義空;寂靜的義——因為離了眾生的喧鬧;不可說的義——因為不執著一切語言;如實的義——因為了達三世平等;法界的義——因為一切諸法一味;真如的義——因為一切如來都順此而入;實際的義——因為了知究竟如實;大般涅槃的義——因為滅一切苦而仍修菩薩諸行。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到一切智的無上之義。

第十六門 法:十種能持之法

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種法。哪十種呢?就是:真實法——因為如所說而修行;離取法——因為能取和所取全都離了;無諍法——因為沒有一切惑亂之諍;寂滅法——因為滅除一切熱惱;離欲法——因為一切貪欲都斷了;無分別法——因為攀緣分別永遠止息;無生法——因為如同虛空不動;無為法——因為離了生、住、滅諸相;本性法——因為自性無染而清淨;捨一切烏波提(此云有苦)涅槃法——因為捨了它才能生起一切菩薩行,修習不斷。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這裡面,就能得到如來無上廣大之法。

第十七門 福德助道具:十種成福之資具

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種福德助道具。哪十種呢?就是:勸眾生發起菩提心,這是菩薩的福德助道具——因為由此三寶之種不斷。隨順十種迴向,這是菩薩的福德助道具——因為由此斷一切不善法、集一切善法。以智慧誘導教誨,這是菩薩的福德助道具——因為它超過三界的福德。心無疲倦,這是菩薩的福德助道具——因為要究竟度脫一切眾生。捨盡內外一切所有,這是菩薩的福德助道具——因為對一切物無所執著。為滿足相好而精進不退,這是菩薩的福德助道具——因為門戶大開地布施,沒有限量。上、中、下三品的善根,全都迴向無上菩提,心中不輕視任何一分,這是菩薩的福德助道具——因為與善巧方便相應。對邪定的、下劣的、不善的眾生都生大悲,不懷輕賤之心,這是菩薩的福德助道具——因為常起大人的弘誓之心。恭敬供養一切如來,對一切菩薩生起如來之想,令一切眾生都生歡喜,這是菩薩的福德助道具——因為守住本願極其堅牢。菩薩摩訶薩在阿僧祇劫中積集善根,自己要取證無上菩提本已如在掌中,卻全部捨給一切眾生,心中沒有憂惱也沒有悔恨,那心廣大得等同虛空界,這是菩薩的福德助道具——因為由此起大智慧、證大法。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這裡面,就能具足如來無上廣大的福德聚。

第十八門 智慧助道具:十種成智之資具

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種智慧助道具。哪十種呢?就是:親近多聞的真善知識,恭敬供養,尊重禮拜,種種隨順,不違背他的教導,這是第一——因為一切正直而沒有虛矯。永離憍慢,常行謙敬,身、語、意業沒有粗獷,柔和善順,不虛偽不彎曲,這是第二——因為這樣的身才堪作佛法之器。念與慧隨時覺照而未曾散亂,有慚有愧,柔和,心安不動,常憶六念,常行六敬,常隨順住於六種堅固之法,這是第三——因為它是成就十種智的方便。愛樂法、愛樂義,以法為樂,常樂聽聞而沒有厭足,捨離世間的議論和世間的言說,專心聽受出世間之語,遠離小乘,入大乘之慧,這是第四——因為一心憶念而沒有散動。對六波羅蜜專心荷負,四種梵住已修行成熟,隨順明法都善加修行,聰敏的智者都勤加請問,遠離惡趣,歸向善道,心常愛樂,正念觀察,調伏自己的情,守護他人的意,這是第五——因為堅固修行真實之行。常樂於出離,不執著三有,恒常覺照自心,不曾有惡念,欲、恚、害三種覺已經斷絕,三業都善,決定了知心的自性,這是第六——因為能令自己和他人的心都清淨。觀察五蘊都如幻事,十八界如毒蛇,十二處如空聚落,一切諸法如幻、如陽焰、如水中月、如夢、如影、如回響、如鏡像、如空中畫、如旋轉的火輪、如虹霓之色、如日月之光,無相無形,非常非斷,不來不去,也沒有所住,這樣觀察,知道一切法無生無滅,這是第七——因為知道一切法的體性空寂。菩薩摩訶薩聽到一切法無我、無眾生、無壽者、無補伽羅、無心、無境、無貪瞋癡、無身、無物、無主、無待、無著、無行,這一切都無所有、全都歸於寂滅,聽了以後深深信受,不疑惑不毀謗,這是第八——因為由此能成就圓滿的勝解。菩薩摩訶薩善調諸根,如理修行,恒住止觀,心意寂靜,一切動念都不生起,無我、無人、無作、無行、不計我想、不計我業、沒有瘡疣、沒有瘢痕,也沒有一個在此所得的忍,身、語、意業無來無去,沒有精進也沒有勇猛,觀一切眾生、一切諸法,心都平等而無所住,非此岸、非彼岸,此與彼的體性都離,無所從來,無所至去,常以智慧這樣思惟,這是第九——因為到了分別相的彼岸。菩薩摩訶薩因為見緣起法而見法清淨,因為見法清淨而見國土清淨,因為見國土清淨而見虛空清淨,因為見虛空清淨而見法界清淨,因為見法界清淨而見智慧清淨,這是第十——因為由此修行積集一切智。佛子!這就是菩薩摩訶薩的十種智慧助道具。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到如來對一切法無障礙的清淨微妙智慧聚。

第十九門 明足:十種明與足

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種明足。哪十種呢?就是:善於分別諸法的明足;不取著諸法的明足;離顛倒見的明足;以智慧之光照察諸根的明足;善巧發起正精進的明足;能深入真諦之智的明足;滅煩惱業、成就盡智與無生智的明足;天眼智普遍觀察的明足;宿住念、知前際清淨的明足;漏盡神通智、斷眾生諸漏的明足。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到如來在一切佛法上無上的大光明。

第二十門 求法:十種求法之心

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種求法。哪十種呢?就是:以直心求法——因為沒有諂媚欺誑;精進求法——因為遠離懈怠傲慢;一向求法——因為不吝惜身命;為斷一切眾生的煩惱而求法——因為不是為了名利恭敬;為饒益自他一切眾生而求法——因為不只是自利;為入智慧而求法——因為不愛樂文字;為出生死而求法——因為不貪世間之樂;為度眾生而求法——因為已發菩提心;為斷一切眾生的疑而求法——因為要令他們沒有猶豫;為滿足佛法而求法——因為不愛樂其餘之乘。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到不由他人教導的一切佛法大智慧。

第二十一門 明了法:十類人各自明了之法

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種明了法。哪十種呢?就是:隨順世俗而生長善根,這是童蒙凡夫的明了法;得到無礙不壞的信、覺察法的自性,這是隨信行人的明了法;勤修習法、隨順法而住,這是隨法行人的明了法;遠離八邪、趣向八正道,這是第八人的明了法——第八人即初果向;除滅眾結、斷生死漏、見真實諦,這是須陀洹人的明了法;觀察欲味即是過患、知道無有往來,這是斯陀含人的明了法;不樂三界、求盡有漏,對受生之法乃至一念都不生愛著,這是阿那含人的明了法;獲得六神通、得八解脫,九次第定、四無礙辯全都成就,這是阿羅漢人的明了法;生性樂於觀察一味緣起,心常寂靜,知足少事,因自己而解、悟不由他,成就種種神通智慧,這是辟支佛人的明了法;智慧廣大,諸根明利,常樂度脫一切眾生,勤修福智助道之法,如來所有的十力、無畏、一切功德具足圓滿,這是菩薩人的明了法。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到如來無上大智的明了法。

第二十二門 修行法:十種行門

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種修行法。哪十種呢?就是:恭敬尊重諸善知識的修行法;常被諸天所覺悟的修行法;在諸佛之處常懷慚愧的修行法;哀愍眾生而不捨生死的修行法;做事一定做到究竟、心無變動的修行法;專心憶念、隨逐發大乘心的諸菩薩眾而精勤修學的修行法;遠離邪見、勤求正道的修行法;摧破眾魔和煩惱之業的修行法;知道眾生根性的勝與劣而為他們說法、令他們住於佛地的修行法;安住無邊廣大法界、除滅煩惱令身清淨的修行法。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這裡面,就能得到如來無上的修行法。

第二十三門 魔:十種障道之魔

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種魔。哪十種呢?就是:蘊魔——因為由此生起種種取著;煩惱魔——因為恒常雜染;業魔——因為能作障礙;心魔——因為由它生起高慢;死魔——因為捨棄所生之處;天魔——因為自己憍慢放縱;善根魔——因為對善根恒常執取;三昧魔——因為久久耽著其味;善知識魔——因為對善知識起了執著之心;菩提法智魔——因為對它不願捨離。這就是十種。菩薩摩訶薩應當作方便,速速求得遠離。

第二十四門 魔業:十種訛敗善根之業

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種魔業。哪十種呢?就是:忘失了菩提心而修諸善根,這是魔業;以惡心行布施,以瞋心持戒,捨棄性情惡的人,遠離懈怠的人,輕慢心亂的人,譏嫌惡慧的人,這是魔業;對甚深之法心生慳吝,有堪受化度的人卻不為他說,若得了財利恭敬供養,雖然對方不是法器也硬要為他說,這是魔業;不樂於聽聞諸波羅蜜,即使聽了也不修行,雖然也修行卻多生懈怠,因為懈怠的緣故,志意狹劣,不求無上大菩提之法,這是魔業;遠離善知識,親近惡知識,樂求二乘,不樂受生,志向崇尚涅槃離欲寂靜,這是魔業;對菩薩起瞋恚之心,用惡眼看他,尋求他的罪過,宣說他的過惡,斷絕他所有的財利供養,這是魔業;誹謗正法而不樂聽聞,即使聽到了就生毀訾,見人說法不生尊重,說自己講的才對、別人講的全錯,這是魔業;樂於學習世間的議論、巧術、文詞,開闡二乘而隱覆深法,或者把妙義授給不是那個人的人,遠離菩提而住於邪道,這是魔業;對已經解脫、已經安隱的人常樂親近而供養,對還沒解脫、還沒安隱的人卻不肯親近也不教化,這是魔業;增長我慢,沒有恭敬,對眾生多行惱害,不求正法真實智慧,那心弊惡而難以開悟,這是魔業。這就是十種。菩薩摩訶薩應當速速遠離,勤求佛業。

第二十五門 捨離魔業:十種正對治

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種捨離魔業。哪十種呢?就是:親近善知識、恭敬供養,是捨離魔業;不自己抬舉、不自己讚歎,是捨離魔業;對佛的深法信解而不毀謗,是捨離魔業;未曾忘失一切智之心,是捨離魔業;勤修妙行、恒不放逸,是捨離魔業;常求一切菩薩藏之法,是捨離魔業;恒常演說法而心無疲倦,是捨離魔業;歸依十方一切諸佛、生起救護之想,是捨離魔業;信受憶念一切諸佛、蒙神力加持,是捨離魔業;與一切菩薩同種善根、平等無二,是捨離魔業。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能出離一切魔道。

第二十六門 見佛:十種見佛之法

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種見佛。哪十種呢?就是:對安住世間成正覺的佛,以無著而見;對願佛,以出生而見;對業報佛,以深信而見;對住持佛,以隨順而見;對涅槃佛,以深入而見;對法界佛,以普至而見;對心佛,以安住而見;對三昧佛,以無量無依而見;對本性佛,以明了而見;對隨樂佛,以普受而見。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就常能見到無上如來。

第二十七門 佛業:十種佛所作之事

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種佛業。哪十種呢?就是:隨時開示引導,這是佛業——因為要令人正確修行。在夢中令他見到,這是佛業——因為要覺醒他往昔的善根。為他人演說他還沒聽過的經,這是佛業——因為要令他生智慧、斷疑惑。為被追悔纏縛的人說出離之法,這是佛業——因為要令他離開疑心。若有眾生起了慳吝之心,乃至惡慧心、二乘心、損害心、疑惑心、散動心、憍慢心,就為他示現如來眾相莊嚴之身,這是佛業——因為要生長他過去的善根。在正法難以值遇的時候廣為說法,令他聽了以後得陀羅尼智、神通智,普能利益無量眾生,這是佛業——因為勝解清淨。若有魔事生起,能用方便示現如虛空界一般的聲音,說不損惱他人之法以為對治,令他開悟,眾魔聽了威光就熄滅了,這是佛業——因為志樂殊勝、威德廣大。那心相續不間斷,常自守護,不令自己證入二乘的正位,若有眾生根性還沒成熟,終究不為他說解脫的境界,這是佛業——因為這是本願所作。生死的結與漏一切都離,修菩薩行相續不斷,以大悲心攝取眾生,令他們起行而究竟解脫,這是佛業——因為修菩薩行不斷。菩薩摩訶薩了達自身以及眾生本來寂滅,不驚不怖,而仍勤修福智沒有厭足;雖然知道一切法沒有造作,卻也不捨諸法的自相;雖然對諸境界永離貪欲,卻常樂瞻仰奉事諸佛的色身;雖然知道悟入於法不由他人,卻用種種方便求一切智;雖然知道諸國土都如虛空,卻常樂莊嚴一切佛剎;雖然恒常觀察無人無我,卻教化眾生沒有疲厭;雖然對法界本來不動,卻以神通智力示現種種變化;雖然已經成就一切智智,卻修菩薩行沒有休息;雖然知道諸法不可言說,卻轉清淨法輪令大眾心生歡喜;雖然能示現諸佛的神力,卻不厭捨菩薩之身;雖然示現入於大般涅槃,卻在一切處示現受生——能作這樣權實雙行之法,這是佛業。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這裡面,就能得到不由他人教導的無上無師廣大之業。

第二十八門 慢業:十種由慢而成之業

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種慢業。哪十種呢?就是:對師長、僧眾、父母、沙門、婆羅門、住於正道和趣向正道的人,這些尊重福田之處卻不恭敬,這是慢業;或有法師獲得最勝之法,乘於大乘,知道出要之道,得了陀羅尼,演說契經廣大之法而沒有休息,卻對他起高慢之心、對他所說之法不生恭敬,這是慢業;在大眾集會中聽到說妙法,不肯讚美、不肯令人信受,這是慢業;喜歡起過慢,自高而欺凌他人,看不見自己的過失,不知道自己的短處,這是慢業;喜歡起過過慢,見到有德的人該讚而不讚,見別人讚歎也不生歡喜,這是慢業;見有法師為人說法,明知這是法、是律、是真實、是佛所說,卻因為嫌那個人也連帶嫌那個法,自己起誹謗還教別人誹謗,這是慢業;自己求高座,自稱法師,認為理應受人供給、不該做事,見到耆舊久修行的人不起身迎接、不肯承事,這是慢業;見到有德的人就皺眉不喜,言辭粗獷,窺伺他的過失,這是慢業;見到聰慧知法的人,不肯親近恭敬供養,不肯請問:『什麼是善?什麼是不善?什麼應當做?什麼不應當做?做什麼樣的業,在長夜之中能得種種利益安樂?』愚癡頑固,被我慢所吞沒,終究不能見到出要之道,這是慢業;還有眾生被慢心所覆蓋,諸佛出世卻不能親近恭敬供養,新的善不生起,舊的善也消滅了,不該說的偏說,不該諍的偏諍,未來一定墮入險難的深坑,經百千劫尚且值不到佛,何況聞法!只因為曾經發過菩提心的緣故,終究自己會醒悟——這是慢業。這就是十種。

第二十九門 智業:離慢之後所得的十種智業

「若菩薩離了這些慢業,就得到十種智業。哪十種呢?就是:信解業報,不壞因果,這是智業;不捨菩提心,常念諸佛,這是智業;親近善知識恭敬供養,那心尊重而始終沒有厭倦,這是智業;樂法、樂義而沒有厭足,遠離邪念,勤修正念,這是智業;對一切眾生離開我慢,對諸菩薩起如來之想,愛重正法如同愛惜自己的身,尊奉如來如同護惜自己的命,對修行的人生起諸佛之想,這是智業;身、語、意業沒有種種不善,讚美賢聖,隨順菩提,這是智業;不壞緣起,離諸邪見,破暗得明,照見一切法,這是智業;對十種迴向隨順修行,對諸波羅蜜起慈母之想,對善巧方便起慈父之想,以深淨之心進入菩提之舍,這是智業;布施、持戒、多聞、止觀、福慧,這一切助道之法常勤積集而沒有厭倦,這是智業;若有一種業是佛所讚歎的,能破眾魔煩惱的鬪諍,能離一切障、蓋、纏、縛,能教化調伏一切眾生,能隨順智慧攝取正法,能嚴淨佛剎,能發起神通與明,都勤加修習而沒有懈退,這是智業。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這裡面,就能得到如來一切善巧方便的無上大智業。

第三十門 魔所攝持:十種被魔把持之相

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種魔所攝持。哪十種呢?就是:懈怠之心,是魔所攝持;志向樂欲狹劣,是魔所攝持;在少分的修行上就生滿足,是魔所攝持;只接受一種而不受其餘,是魔所攝持;不發大願,是魔所攝持;樂於處在寂滅、只求斷除煩惱,是魔所攝持;永斷生死,是魔所攝持;捨棄菩薩行,是魔所攝持;不化度眾生,是魔所攝持;懷疑毀謗正法,是魔所攝持。這就是十種。

第三十一門 佛所攝持:棄捨魔持之後的十種佛持

「若菩薩能棄捨這些魔所攝持,就得到十種佛所攝持。哪十種呢?就是:最初能發菩提之心,是佛所攝持;在生生世世中持守菩提心不令忘失,是佛所攝持;覺察諸魔之事而能全部遠離,是佛所攝持;聽聞諸波羅蜜而如所說修行,是佛所攝持;知道生死之苦卻不厭惡,是佛所攝持;觀甚深之法而得無量之果,是佛所攝持;為眾生說二乘之法,自己卻不證取那一乘的解脫,是佛所攝持;樂觀無為之法卻不住在其中,對有為、無為不生二種想,是佛所攝持;到了無生之處卻仍示現受生,是佛所攝持;雖然證得一切智,卻仍起菩薩行、不斷菩薩之種,是佛所攝持。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這裡面,就能得到諸佛無上的攝持之力。

第三十二門 法所攝持:十種被法把持之處

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種法所攝持。哪十種呢?就是:知道一切行無常,是法所攝持;知道一切行是苦,是法所攝持;知道一切行無我,是法所攝持;知道一切法寂滅涅槃,是法所攝持;知道諸法從緣而起,沒有緣就不起,是法所攝持;知道因為不正思惟才生起無明,無明起了才乃至老死起,不正思惟滅了無明就滅,無明滅了才乃至老死滅,是法所攝持;知道三解脫門出生聲聞乘,證無諍之法出生獨覺乘,是法所攝持;知道六波羅蜜、四攝法出生大乘,是法所攝持;知道一切剎土、一切法、一切眾生、一切世都是佛智的境界,是法所攝持;知道要斷一切念、捨一切取、離前際後際、隨順涅槃,是法所攝持。這就是十種。菩薩若安住在這裡面,就能得到一切諸佛無上的法所攝持。

第三十三門 住兜率天所作業:八相之第一相

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩住在兜率天,有十種所作之業。哪十種呢?就是:為欲界諸天子說厭離之法,說:『一切自在都是無常,一切快樂終將衰謝。』勸那些天人發菩提心。這是第一所作業。為色界諸天宣說出入諸禪解脫三昧;若他們在其中生了愛著,因為愛著又生起身見、邪見、無明等,就為他們說如實的智慧;若他們對一切色法、非色法起顛倒之想、以為那是清淨,就為他們說不淨、說這都是無常,勸他們發菩提之心。這是第二所作業。菩薩摩訶薩住在兜率天,入一種三昧,名叫光明莊嚴,身上放光明遍照三千大千世界,隨眾生的心以種種音聲為他們說法;眾生聽了以後信心清淨,命終便生在兜率天中,菩薩勸他們發菩提之心。這是第三所作業。菩薩摩訶薩在兜率天,用無障礙的眼普遍看見十方兜率天中的一切菩薩,那些菩薩也都看見這位菩薩;互相見了以後,論說妙法,就是:降神入母胎、初生、出家、前往道場、具大莊嚴;又示現往昔以來所行之行,因為那些行才成就這樣的大智;所有功德都不離開本處,卻能示現這樣種種之事。這是第四所作業。菩薩摩訶薩住在兜率天,十方一切兜率天宮的諸菩薩眾都來聚集,恭敬圍繞;這時候,菩薩摩訶薩為了令那些菩薩都滿其願、生歡喜,就隨他們所應住的地、所行所斷、所修所證而演說法門;那些菩薩聽了說法以後都大歡喜,得未曾有,各自回到本土所住的宮殿。這是第五所作業。菩薩摩訶薩住在兜率天的時候,欲界之主天魔波旬為了壞亂菩薩之業,帶著眷屬圍繞來到菩薩之處;這時候,菩薩為了摧伏魔軍,安住在金剛道所攝的般若波羅蜜方便善巧智慧之門,用柔軟和粗獷兩種語言為他說法,令魔波旬得不到機會;魔看見菩薩的自在威力,都發了阿耨多羅三藐三菩提心。這是第六所作業。菩薩摩訶薩住在兜率天,知道欲界諸天子不樂聞法;這時候,菩薩發出大音聲遍告他們說:『今天菩薩要在宮中示現希有之事,想看的人趕快前來。』那時諸天子聽了這話,無量百千億那由他都來集會;這時候,菩薩見天眾都已來集,就為他們示現宮中的種種希有之事;那些天子從來不曾見聞,見了以後都大歡喜,那心陶醉沉沒;菩薩又在音樂中發出聲音告訴他們:『諸位仁者!一切諸行都是無常,一切諸行都是苦,一切諸法都是無我,涅槃寂滅。』又告訴他們:『你們都應當修菩薩行,都應當圓滿一切智智。』那些天子聽到這法音,憂歎嗟嘆而生起厭離,沒有一個不發菩提之心。這是第七所作業。菩薩摩訶薩住在兜率宮,不捨離本處,卻全都能前往十方無量一切佛所,見諸如來、親近禮拜恭敬聽法;這時候,諸佛為了令菩薩獲得最上的灌頂之法,為他宣說一種菩薩地,名叫一切神通,使他以一念相應的慧具足一切最勝功德,入一切智智之位。這是第八所作業。菩薩摩訶薩住在兜率宮,為了供養諸如來,用大神力興起種種供養之具,名叫殊勝可樂,遍法界、虛空界、一切世界供養諸佛;那些世界中的無量眾生見了這供養,都發阿耨多羅三藐三菩提心。這是第九所作業。菩薩摩訶薩住在兜率天,出生無量無邊如幻如影的法門,周遍十方一切世界,示現種種色、種種相、種種形體、種種威儀、種種事業、種種方便、種種譬喻、種種言說,隨眾生的心都令他們歡喜。這是第十所作業。佛子!這就是菩薩摩訶薩住兜率天的十種所作業。菩薩若成就這個法,就能在此之後下生人間。

第三十四門 下生現十事:十道光明各作一事

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩從兜率天將要下生的時候,示現十種事。哪十種呢?佛子!菩薩摩訶薩從兜率天下生之時,從足底放大光明,名叫安樂莊嚴,普照三千大千世界中一切惡趣諸難的眾生;被這光觸到的,沒有不離苦得安樂的;得了安樂以後,都知道將有奇特的大人出興於世。這是第一所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩從兜率天下生之時,從眉間白毫相中放大光明,名叫覺悟,普照三千大千世界,照到宿世一切同行諸菩薩的身;那些菩薩蒙光照了以後,都知道菩薩將要下生,各各興起無量供具,來到菩薩之處而作供養。這是第二所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩從兜率天將要下生的時候,從右掌中放大光明,名叫清淨境界,能全部嚴淨一切三千大千世界;其中若有已得無漏的辟支佛覺察到這光,就捨去壽命;若沒有覺察的,因光明之力被遷移安置到他方的其餘世界中;一切諸魔以及諸外道、有見的眾生,也都被遷置到他方世界,唯獨除去被諸佛神力所持的應化眾生。這是第三所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩從兜率天將要下生的時候,從兩膝放大光明,名叫清淨莊嚴,普照一切諸天的宮殿,下從護世四王天、上到淨居天,沒有不周遍的;那些天人都知道菩薩要從兜率天下生,都懷著戀慕,悲歎憂惱,各自拿著種種華鬘、衣服、塗香、末香、幡蓋、妓樂,來到菩薩之處恭敬供養,隨逐他下生一直到涅槃。這是第四所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩在兜率天將要下生的時候,從卍字金剛莊嚴心藏中放大光明,名叫無能勝幢,普照十方一切世界的金剛力士;那時有百億金剛力士都來聚集,隨逐侍衛,從下生開始一直到涅槃。這是第五所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩從兜率天將要下生的時候,從身上一切毛孔放大光明,名叫分別眾生,普照一切大千世界,遍觸一切諸菩薩之身,又觸一切諸天世人;諸菩薩都這樣想:『我應當住在這裡,供養如來,教化眾生。』這是第六所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩從兜率天將要下生的時候,從大摩尼寶藏殿中放大光明,名叫善住觀察,照這位菩薩將要出生之處所託的王宮;那光照過以後,其餘諸菩薩都一同隨逐下到閻浮提,或在他家、或在他的聚落、或在他的城邑而示現受生,為的是教化眾生。這是第七所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩從兜率天臨下生的時候,從天宮殿以及大樓閣的諸莊嚴中放大光明,名叫一切宮殿清淨莊嚴,照所生之母的腹;光明照過以後,令菩薩的母親安隱快樂,具足成就一切功德,母腹之中自然有廣大樓閣、以大摩尼寶而為莊嚴,為的是安處菩薩之身。這是第八所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩從兜率天臨下生的時候,從兩足底下放大光明,名叫善住;若諸天子和諸梵天壽命將盡,蒙這光照觸都能延住壽命,供養菩薩從最初下生一直到涅槃。這是第九所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩從兜率天臨下生的時候,從隨好中放大光明,名叫眼莊嚴,示現菩薩的種種諸業;那時候諸人、天,有的見菩薩住兜率天,有的見他入胎,有的見他初生,有的見他出家,有的見他成道,有的見他降魔,有的見他轉法輪,有的見他入涅槃。這是第十所示現事。佛子!菩薩摩訶薩在身上、在座上、在宮殿中、在樓閣中,放這樣的百萬阿僧祇光明,全都示現種種諸菩薩業;示現了這些業以後,因為具足了一切功德法,就從兜率天下生人間。

第三十五門 處胎十事:為什麼要示現住胎

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩示現處胎,有十種事。哪十種呢?佛子!菩薩摩訶薩為了成就小心劣解的眾生,不想令他們起這樣的念頭:『現在這位菩薩是自然化生的,他的智慧善根不是從修行得來的。』所以菩薩示現處胎。這是第一事。菩薩摩訶薩為了成熟父母以及諸眷屬、宿世同行眾生的善根而示現處胎。為什麼呢?因為他們都應當藉著見到處胎才成熟所有的善根。這是第二事。菩薩摩訶薩入母胎的時候,正念正知,沒有迷惑;住在母胎裡以後,心恒常正念,也沒有錯亂。這是第三事。菩薩摩訶薩在母胎中常常說法,十方世界的諸大菩薩、帝釋、梵王、四天王都來集會,全都令他們獲得無量神力、無邊智慧;菩薩處胎成就這樣的辯才和勝用。這是第四事。菩薩摩訶薩在母胎中聚集大眾之會,以本願之力教化一切諸菩薩眾。這是第五事。菩薩摩訶薩在人中成佛,理應具備人間最殊勝的受生,因此示現處於母胎。這是第六事。菩薩摩訶薩在母胎中,三千大千世界的眾生都看見菩薩,如同在明鏡中看見自己的面像;這時候,大心的天、龍、夜叉、乾闥婆、阿脩羅、迦樓羅、緊那羅、摩睺羅伽、人、非人等,都來到菩薩之處恭敬供養。這是第七事。菩薩摩訶薩在母胎中,他方世界一切在母胎中的最後生菩薩都來共會,宣說大集法門,名叫廣大智慧藏。這是第八事。菩薩摩訶薩在母胎時,入一種三昧,名叫離垢藏,以三昧之力在母胎中示現大宮殿,種種嚴飾都極妙好,兜率天宮都不能相比,而且令母身安隱無患。這是第九事。菩薩摩訶薩住母胎時,以大威力興起供養之具,名叫開大福德離垢藏,普遍十方一切世界供養一切諸佛如來,那些如來都為他演說無邊菩薩住處法界藏。這是第十事。佛子!這就是菩薩摩訶薩示現處胎的十種事。菩薩若了達這個法,就能示現甚微細趣。

第三十六門 甚微細趣:在胎中同時現盡一生

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種甚微細趣。哪十種呢?就是:在母胎中,示現初發菩提心一直到灌頂地;在母胎中,示現住兜率天;在母胎中,示現初生;在母胎中,示現童子地;在母胎中,示現處王宮;在母胎中,示現出家;在母胎中,示現苦行、前往道場、成等正覺;在母胎中,示現轉法輪;在母胎中,示現般涅槃;在母胎中,示現大微細,就是:一切菩薩行、一切如來自在神力的無量差別之門。佛子!這就是菩薩摩訶薩在母胎中的十種微細趣。菩薩若安住在這個法上,就能得到如來無上大智慧的微細趣。

第三十七門 十種生:初生之相

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種生。哪十種呢?就是:遠離愚癡、正念正知而生;放大光明網普照三千大千世界而生;住最後有、更不受後身而生;不生不起而生;知三界如幻而生;於十方世界普現其身而生;證一切智智之身而生;放一切佛光明普遍覺悟一切眾生之身而生;入大智觀察三昧之身而生;佛子!菩薩出生的時候,震動一切佛剎,解脫一切眾生,除滅一切惡道,映蔽一切諸魔,無量菩薩都來集會。佛子!這就是菩薩摩訶薩的十種生,為了調伏眾生才這樣示現。

第三十八門 微笑心自誓:十念之後的微笑

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩因為十件事,示現微笑而心中自誓。哪十件呢?就是:菩薩摩訶薩心想:『一切世間都沉沒在欲泥中,除了我一人沒有誰能救濟。』這樣知道以後,欣悅微笑而心中自誓。又想:『一切世間被煩惱弄瞎了眼,唯有我今天具足智慧。』這樣知道以後,欣悅微笑而心中自誓。又想:『我今天憑著這個假名之身,將要得到充滿三世的如來無上法身。』這樣知道以後,欣悅微笑而心中自誓。菩薩那時用無障礙的眼遍觀十方所有梵天乃至一切大自在天,這樣想:『這些眾生都自以為有大智力。』這樣知道以後,欣悅微笑而心中自誓。菩薩那時觀見眾生久久種下善根,如今卻都退失了;這樣知道以後,欣悅微笑而心中自誓。菩薩觀見世間的種子,所種的雖少,得的果卻很多;這樣知道以後,欣悅微笑而心中自誓。菩薩觀見一切眾生蒙受佛的教導必定得利益;這樣知道以後,欣悅微笑而心中自誓。菩薩觀見過去世中同行的菩薩染著在其餘之事上,得不到佛法的廣大功德;這樣知道以後,欣悅微笑而心中自誓。菩薩觀見過去世中一同集會的諸天人等,到今天還在凡夫之地,不能捨離,卻也不感疲厭;這樣知道以後,欣悅微笑而心中自誓。菩薩那時被一切如來的光明所觸,倍加欣慰,欣悅微笑而心中自誓。這就是十種。佛子!菩薩為了調伏眾生才這樣示現。

第三十九門 行七步:走那七步的十個緣故

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩因為十件事,示現行七步。哪十件呢?就是:為顯現菩薩之力,所以示現行七步;為顯現布施七種聖財,所以示現行七步;為滿地神之願,所以示現行七步;為顯現超越三界之相,所以示現行七步;為顯現菩薩最勝之行超過象王、牛王、師子王之行,所以示現行七步;為顯現金剛地之相,所以示現行七步;為顯現要給眾生勇猛之力,所以示現行七步;為顯現修行七覺之寶,所以示現行七步;為顯現所得之法不由他人教導,所以示現行七步;為顯現在世間最勝無比,所以示現行七步。這就是十種。佛子!菩薩為了調伏眾生才這樣示現。

第四十門 處童子地:作童子的十個緣故

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩因為十件事,示現處在童子之地。哪十件呢?就是:為顯現通達一切世間的文字、算計、圖書、印璽種種業,所以處童子地;為顯現通達一切世間的象馬、車乘、弓矢、劍戟種種業,所以處童子地;為顯現通達一切世間的文筆、談論、博弈、嬉戲種種事,所以處童子地;為顯現遠離身、語、意業的種種過失,所以處童子地;為顯現入定住涅槃之門、周遍十方無量世界,所以處童子地;為顯現他的力超過一切天、龍、夜叉、乾闥婆、阿脩羅、迦樓羅、緊那羅、摩睺羅伽、帝釋、梵王、護世、人、非人等,所以處童子地;為顯現菩薩的色相威光超過一切帝釋、梵王、護世,所以處童子地;為令耽著欲樂的眾生歡喜而樂法,所以處童子地;為尊重正法、勤加供養佛、周遍十方一切世界,所以處童子地;為顯現得佛加被、蒙受法的光明,所以處童子地。這就是十種。

第四十一門 現處王宮:住在宮中的十個緣故

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩示現童子地以後,因為十件事而示現處在王宮。哪十件呢?就是:為令宿世同行的眾生善根成熟,所以現處王宮;為顯示菩薩的善根之力,所以現處王宮;因為諸人、天耽著樂具,要示現菩薩大威德的樂具,所以現處王宮;為隨順五濁世眾生的心,所以現處王宮;為顯現菩薩的大威德力能在深宮之中入三昧,所以現處王宮;為令宿世同願的眾生滿其心意,所以現處王宮;為令父母、親戚、眷屬滿其所願,所以現處王宮;為想用妓樂發出妙法之音供養一切諸如來,所以現處王宮;為想在宮內住微妙三昧、從成佛一直到涅槃都示現出來,所以現處王宮;為隨順守護諸佛之法,所以現處王宮。這就是十種。最後身的菩薩這樣示現處王宮以後,然後才出家。

第四十二門 示現出家:出家的十個緣故

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩因為十件事,示現出家。哪十件呢?就是:為厭離居家,所以示現出家;為令執著家的眾生捨離,所以示現出家;為隨順信樂聖人之道,所以示現出家;為宣揚讚歎出家的功德,所以示現出家;為顯示永離兩邊之見,所以示現出家;為令眾生離開欲樂和我樂,所以示現出家;為先顯現出離三界之相,所以示現出家;為顯現自在而不屬於他人,所以示現出家;為顯示將要得如來的十力、無畏之法,所以示現出家;因為最後身的菩薩法理應如此,所以示現出家。這就是十種。菩薩以此調伏眾生。

第四十三門 示行苦行:修苦行的十個緣故

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩為了十種事,示現修行苦行。哪十種呢?就是:為成就劣解的眾生,所以示行苦行;為拔除眾生的邪見,所以示行苦行;為令不信業報的眾生見到業報,所以示行苦行;因為隨順雜染世界之法理應如此,所以示行苦行;為顯示能忍劬勞、勤修於道,所以示行苦行;為令眾生樂於求法,所以示行苦行;為執著欲樂、我樂的眾生,所以示行苦行;為顯示菩薩起行殊勝、一直到最後生仍不捨勤精進,所以示行苦行;為令眾生樂於寂靜之法、增長善根,所以示行苦行;因為諸天、世人的諸根還沒成熟,要等待時機使他們成熟,所以示行苦行。這就是十種。菩薩用這個方便調伏一切眾生。

第四十四門 詣道場:前往菩提樹下的十事

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩前往道場有十種事。哪十種呢?就是:前往道場時,照耀一切世界;前往道場時,震動一切世界;前往道場時,在一切世界普現其身;前往道場時,覺悟一切菩薩以及一切宿世同行的眾生;前往道場時,示現道場的一切莊嚴;前往道場時,隨諸眾生心中所欲而為他們現身種種威儀以及菩提樹的一切莊嚴;前往道場時,現前見到十方一切如來;前往道場時,舉足、下足常入三昧,念念成佛而沒有間隔;前往道場時,一切天、龍、夜叉、乾闥婆、阿脩羅、迦樓羅、緊那羅、摩睺羅伽、帝釋、梵王、護世的一切諸王彼此互不相知,卻各自興起種種上妙供養;前往道場時,以無礙之智普遍觀見一切諸佛如來在一切世界修菩薩行而成正覺。這就是十種。菩薩以此教化眾生。

第四十五門 坐道場:坐上金剛座的十事

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩坐道場有十種事。哪十種呢?就是:坐道場時,種種震動一切世界;坐道場時,平等照耀一切世界;坐道場時,除滅一切諸惡趣之苦;坐道場時,令一切世界都由金剛所成;坐道場時,普遍觀見一切諸佛如來的師子之座;坐道場時,心如虛空、無所分別;坐道場時,隨他所應而現身的威儀;坐道場時,隨順安住金剛三昧;坐道場時,受一切如來神力所持的清淨妙處;坐道場時,以自己的善根之力全都能加被一切眾生。這就是十種。

第四十六門 坐道場未曾有事:十件從未有過的奇特事

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,有十種奇特未曾有的事。哪十種呢?佛子!菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,十方世界一切如來都現在他面前,都舉起右手而稱讚說:『善哉善哉!無上導師!』這是第一未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,一切如來全都護念、給予威力,這是第二未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,宿世同行的諸菩薩眾都來圍繞,用種種莊嚴之具恭敬供養,這是第三未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,一切世界的草木叢林等無情之物都彎身低影、歸向道場,這是第四未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,入一種三昧,名叫觀察法界,這三昧之力能令菩薩的一切諸行全都圓滿,這是第五未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,得一種陀羅尼,名叫最上離垢妙光海藏,能領受一切諸佛如來的大雲法雨,這是第六未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,以威德之力興起上妙的供具,遍一切世界供養諸佛,這是第七未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,住在最勝之智中,全都現前了知一切眾生的諸根意行,這是第八未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,入一種三昧,名叫善覺,這三昧之力能令他的身充滿三世盡虛空界的一切世界,這是第九未曾有事。菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,得離垢光明的無礙大智,令他的身業普入三世,這是第十未曾有事。佛子!這就是菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時的十種奇特未曾有事。

第四十七門 示現降魔:降魔的十個緣故

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,觀察十種義而示現降魔。哪十種呢?就是:因為濁世的眾生樂於鬪戰,要顯出菩薩的威德之力,所以示現降魔;因為諸天、世人有懷疑的,要斷他們的疑,所以示現降魔;為教化調伏諸魔軍,所以示現降魔;為令諸天、世人中樂於軍陣的人都來聚觀而心得調伏,所以示現降魔;為顯示菩薩所有的威力世上無人能敵,所以示現降魔;為想發起一切眾生的勇猛之力,所以示現降魔;為哀愍末世的諸眾生,所以示現降魔;為想顯示直到道場都還有魔軍前來觸惱、此後才得超越魔的境界,所以示現降魔;為顯示煩惱的業用羸劣、大慈善根的勢力強盛,所以示現降魔;為想隨順濁惡世界所行之法,所以示現降魔。這就是十種。

第四十八門 成如來力:因圓轉入果滿

「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種成如來力。哪十種呢?就是:因為超過一切眾魔煩惱之業,所以成如來力;因為具足一切菩薩行、遊戲一切菩薩三昧之門,所以成如來力;因為具足一切菩薩的廣大禪定,所以成如來力;因為圓滿一切白淨的助道之法,所以成如來力;因為得一切法的智慧光明、善於思惟分別,所以成如來力;因為他的身周遍一切世界,所以成如來力;因為所出的言音全都與一切眾生的心相等,所以成如來力;因為能以神力加持一切,所以成如來力;因為與三世諸佛的身、語、意業相等而沒有差異,在一念之中了知三世之法,所以成如來力;因為得善覺智三昧,具足如來十力——就是從是處非處智力一直到漏盡智力,所以成如來力。這就是十種。菩薩若具足這十力,就名為如來、應、正等覺。

第四十九門 轉大法輪:如來轉法輪的十事

「佛子!如來、應、正等覺轉大法輪有十種事。哪十種呢?第一,具足清淨的四無畏智;第二,出生四種辯才、隨順的音聲;第三,善能開闡四真諦之相;第四,隨順諸佛的無礙解脫;第五,能令眾生心中都生淨信;第六,所有的言說都不空過,能拔出眾生諸苦的毒箭;第七,被大悲願力所加持;第八,隨所發出的音聲普遍十方一切世界;第九,在阿僧祇劫中說法不斷;第十,隨所說之法都能生起根、力、覺道、禪定、解脫、三昧等法。佛子!諸佛如來轉於法輪,有這樣等等無量種事。

第五十門 種白淨法:說法無空過的十個緣故

「佛子!如來、應、正等覺轉法輪的時候,因為十件事,在眾生心中種下白淨之法,沒有一句空過的。哪十件呢?就是:因為過去的願力;因為被大悲所持;因為不捨眾生;因為智慧自在,隨他們所樂而為他們說法;因為必定應其時機,未曾錯失;因為隨他們所宜,沒有虛妄之說;因為知三世之智善能了知;因為他的身最勝、無人能與相等;因為言辭自在、無人能測;因為智慧自在,隨所發出的言語都能令人開悟。這就是十種。

第五十一門 示般涅槃:入滅的十種義

「佛子!如來、應、正等覺作完佛事以後,觀察十種義而示現般涅槃。哪十種呢?就是:為顯示一切行確實無常;為顯示一切有為都不安隱;為顯示大涅槃才是安隱之處、沒有怖畏;因為諸人、天樂著色身,就為他們顯現色身是無常之法,令他們發願安住於清淨法身;為顯示無常之力不可轉;為顯示一切有為不隨心而住、不自在;為顯示一切三有都如幻化、不堅牢;為顯示涅槃之性究竟堅牢、不可破壞;為顯示一切法無生無起,卻有聚集、散壞之相;佛子!諸佛世尊作完佛事、滿足所願、轉了法輪、應當化度的都已化度、有應受尊號的諸菩薩也都已成就記別,依法理應如此入於不變的大般涅槃。佛子!這就是如來、應、正等覺觀察十義而示現般涅槃。

From beginning to end this stretch is Samantabhadra Bodhisattva speaking alone, and those who listen are Universal Wisdom and the other bodhisattvas. Forty-nine of the gates all open with one call from Samantabhadra to the great assembly, “Sons of the Buddha” (gates 29 and 31, carrying on from what precedes them, begin instead with “if the bodhisattvas”). In the last three gates (gates 49 to 51) the grammatical subject shifts to “the Tathāgata, the Worthy One, the Perfectly Awakened One,” and what is spoken of is the affair of a buddha; yet it is still Samantabhadra who is speaking, and not the Buddha himself present and opening his mouth.


Gate 1. Contemplation: Ten Kinds of Eye for Seeing into Things

(Samantabhadra Bodhisattva speaks to Universal Wisdom and the other bodhisattvas:)

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of contemplation. Which are the ten? Namely: the contemplation that knows all deeds — for the reason that even the most subtle of deeds is wholly seen; the contemplation that knows all destinies — for the reason that he sees where sentient beings go as they turn and flow, and yet grasps at no real sentient being; the contemplation that knows all faculties — for the reason that he penetrates through to the faculties having of themselves no fixed nature; the contemplation that knows all dharmas — for the reason that in contemplating he does not destroy the Dharma realm; the contemplation that sees the Buddha-dharma — for the reason that he diligently cultivates the eye of a buddha; the contemplation that obtains wisdom — for the reason that he is able to speak the Dharma in accord with the principle; the contemplation of the forbearance of non-arising — for the reason that with regard to the Buddha-dharma he has decided and understood; the contemplation of the ground of nonretrogression — for the reason that he has extinguished all the afflictions and has passed beyond the three realms and the station of the two vehicles; the contemplation of the ground of consecration — for the reason that with regard to all the dharmas of the buddhas he is master and unshaken; the contemplation of the samādhi of the wisdom of good awakening — for the reason that in all places in the ten directions he is able to do the work of a buddha. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the unsurpassed great wisdom of contemplation of a Tathāgata.

Gate 2. Universal Contemplation: Ten Kinds of Looking That Reaches Everywhere

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of universal contemplation. Which are the ten? Namely: universally contemplating all who come to beg — satisfying their wishes with a mind that does not go against them; universally contemplating all sentient beings who break the precepts — settling them in the pure precepts of a Tathāgata; universally contemplating all sentient beings who harbor a harming mind — settling them in the power of patience of a Tathāgata; universally contemplating all indolent sentient beings — urging them to be diligent and not to set down the burden of the Great Vehicle; universally contemplating all sentient beings whose minds are scattered — causing them to abide in the ground of the all-knowing wisdom of a Tathāgata and be scattered and stirred no more; universally contemplating all sentient beings of evil understanding — removing their doubts for them and demolishing the view that things exist; universally contemplating all good friends who are even-minded — following their instruction and abiding in the Buddha-dharma; universally contemplating all the dharmas that are heard — so as swiftly to realize and see the highest meaning; universally contemplating all boundless sentient beings — never forsaking the power of great compassion; universally contemplating all the dharmas of the buddhas — so as swiftly to accomplish all-knowing wisdom. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the unsurpassed universal contemplation of the great wisdom of a Tathāgata.

Gate 3. Rousing Might: Ten Marks of Majesty Breaking Forth All at Once

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of rousing might. Which are the ten? Namely: the rousing might of the bull-king — for the reason that it outshines and eclipses all the great assemblies of gods, nāgas, yakṣas, gandharvas, and the rest; the rousing might of the elephant-king — for the reason that the nature of his mind is well tamed and gentle, and he is able to bear the burden of all sentient beings; the rousing might of the nāga-king — for the reason that he raises up the dense clouds of the great Dharma, makes the lightning of liberation flash, shakes forth the thunder of the meaning as it truly is, and rains down the sweet-dew rain of the faculties, the powers, the limbs of awakening, meditative concentration, liberation, and samādhi; the rousing might of the great garuḍa-king — for the reason that he dries up the water of craving, breaks open the shell of delusion, seizes and snatches those venomous evil nāgas the afflictions, and makes them come forth from the great sea of the suffering of birth-and-death; the rousing might of the great lion-king — for the reason that he abides securely in the fearless, even-minded great wisdom, and taking it as his weapon crushes and subdues the hosts of māra and the outsiders; the rousing might of bravery and strength — for the reason that in that great battle-array of birth-and-death he is able to crush and destroy all the foes that are the afflictions; the rousing might of great wisdom — for the reason that he knows the aggregates, the elements, and the sense-fields and the various dependent originations, and is able with mastery to open up and reveal all dharmas; the rousing might of the dhāraṇī — for the reason that with the power of mindfulness and the power of wisdom he holds the Dharma and does not forget it, and expounds it for sentient beings according to their faculties; the rousing might of eloquence — for the reason that unobstructed and swift he discriminates all things, and causes all who hear to be benefited and glad at heart; the rousing might of a Tathāgata — for the reason that the dharmas that aid the path toward the wisdom of all-knowing wisdom are all of them complete, and with the wisdom of a single thought-moment’s conjunction he obtains all that is to be obtained and awakens to all that is to be awakened to, mounts the lion-seat, subdues the foes that are māra, and accomplishes unsurpassed perfect awakening. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the unsurpassed and masterful rousing might of the buddhas with regard to all dharmas.

Gate 4. The Lion’s Roar: Ten Phrases of Decisive and Fearless Proclamation

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of lion’s roar. Which are the ten? Namely: proclaiming, ‘I shall surely accomplish perfect awakening.’ This is the great lion’s roar of the mind of awakening. ‘I shall cause all sentient beings — those not crossed over to be crossed over, those not liberated to be liberated, those who have not gained security to gain security, and those who have not gained nirvāṇa to gain nirvāṇa.’ This is the great lion’s roar of great compassion. ‘I shall cause the three lineages of the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Saṅgha never to be cut off.’ This is the great lion’s roar of requiting the kindness of the Tathāgata. ‘I shall adorn and purify all buddha-lands.’ This is the great lion’s roar of the ultimately firm oath. ‘I shall extinguish all the evil destinies and all the places of difficulty.’ This is the great lion’s roar of upholding the pure precepts for oneself. ‘I shall fulfill the adornment of the marks and signs of the body, speech, and mind of all the buddhas.’ This is the great lion’s roar of seeking merit without ever tiring of it. ‘I shall completely accomplish all the wisdom that all the buddhas possess.’ This is the great lion’s roar of seeking wisdom without ever tiring of it. ‘I shall extinguish all the hosts of māra and all the deeds of māra.’ This is the great lion’s roar of cultivating right practice and cutting off the afflictions. ‘I shall fully know that all dharmas are without self, without a sentient being, without a life-span, without a pudgala, empty, without mark, without wish, and pure as empty space.’ This is the great lion’s roar of the forbearance of the non-arising of dharmas. The bodhisattva of the final body shakes all the buddha-lands and causes them all to be adorned and purified; and at that time all the Śakras, the Brahmā kings, and the four heavenly kings come to praise and to entreat him: ‘We only pray that the bodhisattva, by the dharma of non-arising, may manifest the taking on of birth!’ Then the bodhisattva, with the unobstructed eye of wisdom, universally contemplates the world and says: ‘Among all sentient beings there is none that is my equal.’ And straightaway he manifests his birth in the royal palace, walks seven steps of himself, and makes a great lion’s roar: ‘In the world I am the most excellent and the first; I shall forever exhaust the far bound of birth-and-death.’ This is the great lion’s roar of doing as one has said. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the unsurpassed great lion’s roar of a Tathāgata.

Gate 5. Pure Giving: Ten Kinds of Giving with Nothing Mixed In

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of pure giving. Which are the ten? Namely: even-minded giving — for the reason that he does not pick and choose among sentient beings; giving as they wish — for the reason that he satisfies what they desire; giving without disorder — for the reason that he means to make them truly gain benefit; giving as is fitting — for the reason that he knows the difference of higher, middling, and lower; giving that does not abide — for the reason that he seeks no reward; giving that opens and lets go — for the reason that his mind is not fond and attached; giving of everything — for the reason that it is ultimately pure; giving dedicated and directed to awakening — for the reason that he has left far behind the two extremes of the conditioned and the unconditioned; giving that teaches and transforms sentient beings — for the reason that all the way to the place of the Way he does not forsake them; giving with the three spheres pure — for the reason that with regard to the one who gives, the one who receives, and the thing given he rightly and mindfully contemplates, as though they were empty space. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the unsurpassed pure and vast giving of a Tathāgata.

Gate 6. Pure Precepts: Ten Kinds of Keeping the Precepts with Nothing Mixed In

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of pure precepts. Which are the ten? Namely: the pure precept of the body — for the reason that he guards against the three evils of the body; the pure precept of speech — for the reason that he leaves behind the four faults of the mouth; the pure precept of the mind — for the reason that he forever leaves behind greed, anger, and wrong views; the pure precept of not breaking any point of the training — for the reason that he means to be the honored lord among all humans and gods; the pure precept of guarding the mind of awakening — for the reason that he takes no delight in the Lesser Vehicle; the pure precept of guarding what the Tathāgata has laid down — for the reason that toward even the most subtle offense he gives rise to great dread; the pure precept of guarding it in secret — for the reason that he means skillfully to pull out and rescue sentient beings who break the precepts; the pure precept of doing no evil at all — for the reason that he vows to cultivate all the dharmas of good; the pure precept of leaving far behind all views that things exist — for the reason that toward the precepts themselves too he has no attachment; the pure precept of guarding all sentient beings — for the reason that from it great compassion is set going. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the unsurpassed and faultless pure precepts of a Tathāgata.

Gate 7. Pure Patience: Ten Kinds of Patience with Nothing Mixed In

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of pure patience. Which are the ten? Namely: the pure patience that calmly bears slander and humiliation — for the reason that he means to guard sentient beings in his thought; the pure patience that calmly bears the knife and the staff — for the reason that he means well to guard himself and others; the pure patience of giving rise to no anger and harm — for the reason that his mind is unmoved; the pure patience of not reproaching the lowly — for the reason that one who occupies the higher place ought of himself to be forbearing; the pure patience of rescuing and guarding all who come and take refuge — for the reason that he is able to give away even his own body and life; the pure patience of leaving far behind the conceit of self — for the reason that he does not look down on those who have not yet learned; the pure patience of not being angry though maimed and reviled — for the reason that he contemplates all this as an illusion; the pure patience of not repaying the offenses of others — for the reason that he sees neither self nor other; the pure patience of not following the afflictions — for the reason that he has left the various objective realms behind; the pure patience that accords with the true wisdom of a bodhisattva and fully knows that all dharmas are without arising — for the reason that, without being taught by another, he has entered the realm of all-knowing wisdom. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely within this, then he will obtain the unsurpassed forbearance in the Dharma of all the buddhas, awakened to not through another.

Gate 8. Pure Vigor: Ten Kinds of Vigor with Nothing Mixed In

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of pure vigor. Which are the ten? Namely: the pure vigor of the body — serving and making offerings to the buddhas and the bodhisattvas and the various teachers and elders, honoring the fields of merit and not turning back; the pure vigor of speech — expounding at length for others what he has heard of the Dharma, praising the merits of the buddhas without wearying; the pure vigor of the mind — well able to enter and to come forth from loving-kindness, compassion, joy, equanimity, meditative concentration, liberation, and the various samādhis, without any rest; the pure vigor of the upright mind — not deceiving and not flattering, not crooked and not false, diligently cultivating everything and not turning back; the pure vigor of the ascendant mind — his aspiration ever tending toward the wisdom that is higher and higher, wishing to be complete in all the white and pure dharmas; the pure vigor that is not spent in vain — taking in giving, keeping the precepts, patience, much hearing, and non-heedlessness, and all the way to awakening never stopping midway; the pure vigor that crushes and subdues all māras — able wholly to extinguish greed, anger, delusion, wrong views, all the afflictions, and the various entanglements and coverings; the pure vigor that completes the light of wisdom — whatever he does he well contemplates and makes ultimate, not letting himself afterward regret it, and obtaining the dharmas not held in common of all the buddhas; the pure vigor of no coming and no going — obtaining the wisdom of things as they truly are, entering the gate of the Dharma realm, body, speech, and mind all of them even, fully knowing that mark is non-mark, with nothing grasped at; the pure vigor that accomplishes the light of the Dharma — surpassing the various grounds, obtaining the consecration of the buddhas, and with an uncontaminated body manifesting passing away, birth, leaving home, accomplishing the Way, speaking the Dharma, and extinction, complete in affairs of Samantabhadra such as these. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the unsurpassed great pure vigor of a Tathāgata.

Gate 9. Pure Meditation: Ten Kinds of Meditation with Nothing Mixed In

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of pure meditation. Which are the ten? Namely: the pure meditation of ever delighting in leaving home — for the reason that he has given away all that he has; the pure meditation of obtaining a true good friend — for the reason that there is one who shows and teaches the right road; the pure meditation of dwelling in an araṇya and being able to endure wind and rain and the rest — for the reason that he has left behind self and what belongs to self; the pure meditation of leaving behind sentient beings who are clamorous — for the reason that he ever delights in stillness; the pure meditation in which the workings of the mind are tamed and gentle — for the reason that he guards the faculties; the pure meditation in which the mind and wisdom are at rest and extinguished — for the reason that no sound whatever and none of the thorns of the meditative concentrations can disturb him; the pure meditation of the skillful means of the way of awakening — for the reason that he contemplates all as realized before him; the pure meditation of leaving behind the relishing of its taste — for the reason that he does not forsake the realm of desire; the pure meditation that sets going the spiritual penetrations and the clarities — for the reason that he knows the nature of the faculties of all sentient beings; the pure meditation of masterful play — for the reason that entering the samādhi of the buddhas, he knows the absence of self. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely within this, then he will obtain the unsurpassed great pure meditation of a Tathāgata.

Gate 10. Pure Wisdom: Ten Kinds of Wisdom with Nothing Mixed In

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of pure wisdom. Which are the ten? Namely: the pure wisdom that knows all causes — for the reason that he does not destroy the fruit and its recompense; the pure wisdom that knows all conditions — for the reason that he does not go against the principle of coming together; the pure wisdom that knows neither cutting off nor permanence — for the reason that with regard to dependent origination he penetrates through to it all as it truly is; the pure wisdom that pulls out all views — for the reason that toward the marks of sentient beings he neither takes up nor sets down; the pure wisdom that contemplates the movements of the minds of all sentient beings — for the reason that he fully knows them to be like an illusion; the pure wisdom of vast eloquence — for the reason that in discriminating the various dharmas he asks and answers without obstruction; the pure wisdom that none of the māras, the outsiders, the śrāvakas, and the pratyekabuddhas can know — for the reason that he has entered deeply into the wisdom of all the tathāgatas; the pure wisdom that sees the subtle and wondrous dharma-body of all the buddhas, sees the original nature of all sentient beings to be pure, sees all dharmas to be wholly at rest and extinguished, and sees all lands to be the same as empty space — for the reason that he knows all marks to be without obstruction; the pure wisdom of all the holdings-together, the eloquences, and the perfection of skillful means — for the reason that it makes people obtain all the most excellent wisdom; the pure wisdom of the adamantine wisdom of a single thought-moment’s conjunction, fully knowing all dharmas to be even — for the reason that he obtains the most honored wisdom among all dharmas. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely within this, then he will obtain the unobstructed great wisdom of a Tathāgata.

Gate 11. Pure Loving-Kindness: Ten Kinds of Loving-Kindness with Nothing Mixed In

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of pure loving-kindness. Which are the ten? Namely: the pure loving-kindness of an even mind — for the reason that he universally takes in sentient beings and does not pick and choose among them; the pure loving-kindness of enriching and benefiting — for the reason that whatever he does makes people glad; the pure loving-kindness that treats others as oneself — for the reason that in the end he means to make them come forth from birth-and-death; the pure loving-kindness that does not forsake the world — for the reason that his mind is ever set upon the amassing of roots of good; the pure loving-kindness that is able to reach liberation — for the reason that he universally causes sentient beings to extinguish all the afflictions; the pure loving-kindness that brings forth awakening — for the reason that he universally causes sentient beings to set going the mind that seeks all-knowing wisdom; the pure loving-kindness unobstructed in the world — for the reason that he sends forth a great light that shines everywhere and evenly; the pure loving-kindness that fills empty space — for the reason that in rescuing and guarding sentient beings there is no place he does not reach; the pure loving-kindness that has dharmas as its ground — for the reason that he realizes the real dharma of suchness; the pure loving-kindness that has no ground — for the reason that he enters into the nature of a bodhisattva’s leaving arising behind. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the unsurpassed and vast pure loving-kindness of a Tathāgata.

Gate 12. Pure Compassion: Ten Kinds of Compassion with Nothing Mixed In

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of pure compassion. Which are the ten? Namely: the pure compassion that has no companion — for the reason that he sets going this mind alone and by himself. The pure compassion that does not weary and tire — for the reason that he undergoes suffering in place of all sentient beings and does not take it for toil. The pure compassion of taking birth in a place of difficulty — for the reason that it is for the sake of crossing sentient beings over. The pure compassion of taking birth in a good destiny — for the reason that he means to manifest impermanence. The pure compassion set going for sentient beings of the wrong fixity — for the reason that through kalpa after kalpa he does not forsake his great vow. The pure compassion that is not greedily attached to his own ease and joy — for the reason that he means universally to give joy to sentient beings. The pure compassion that seeks no requital of kindness — for the reason that he is only purifying his own mind. The pure compassion that is able to remove inversion — for the reason that he means to speak the dharma as it truly is. Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas know that all dharmas are in their original nature pure, without defiling attachment, without burning distress, and that it is only because of the adventitious afflictions that beings undergo the various sufferings; knowing this, they give rise to great compassion toward sentient beings, and this is named ‘the original nature is pure’ — for the reason that they mean to expound for them the dharma of undefiled, pure light. Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas know that all dharmas are like the track of a bird flying through the sky, and that sentient beings are veiled by the film of delusion and cannot see it clearly; contemplating them, they set going the mind of great compassion, and this is named ‘the wisdom of what is real’ — for the reason that they mean to open up and reveal for them the dharma of nirvāṇa. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the unsurpassed and vast pure compassion of a Tathāgata.

Gate 13. Pure Joy: Ten Kinds of Gladness with Nothing Mixed In

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of pure joy. Which are the ten? Namely: the pure joy of giving rise to the aspiration for awakening; the pure joy of giving away all that he has; the pure joy of not disdaining sentient beings who break the precepts but teaching and bringing them to accomplishment; the pure joy of being able to bear with sentient beings who do evil and, moreover, vowing to save and cross them over; the pure joy of giving away his body in seeking the Dharma and giving rise to no regret afterward; the pure joy of casting away the joy of desire for himself and ever delighting in the joy of the Dharma; the pure joy of causing all sentient beings to cast away the joy of the goods of life and ever to delight in the joy of the Dharma; the pure joy of seeing all the buddhas, reverencing and making offerings without ever having enough, the Dharma realm being even; the pure joy of causing all sentient beings to delight in meditative concentration, liberation, and samādhi, entering, coming forth, and playing therein; the pure joy of delighting at heart to be complete in cultivating all the austerities that accord with the way of a bodhisattva, and to realize the unsurpassed concentration and wisdom of silence, stillness, and immovability. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the unsurpassed and vast pure joy of a Tathāgata.

Gate 14. Pure Equanimity: Ten Kinds of Even-Minded Letting Go with Nothing Mixed In

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of pure equanimity. Which are the ten? Namely: the pure equanimity in which all sentient beings reverence and make offerings and yet no fond attachment arises; the pure equanimity in which all sentient beings slight, revile, and humiliate and yet no anger arises; the pure equanimity of ever walking within the world and yet not being stained by the eight dharmas of the world; the pure equanimity of waiting for the time to teach and cross over those sentient beings who are fit vessels for the Dharma, and of not giving rise to disdain toward those who are not fit for it either; the pure equanimity of not seeking the dharmas of the two vehicles, of the learner and of the one beyond learning; the pure equanimity of a mind ever leaving far behind all joys of desire and the dharmas that go along with the afflictions; the pure equanimity of not praising the two vehicles and not being weary of and turning from birth-and-death; the pure equanimity of leaving far behind all the speech of the world — whatever is not the speech of nirvāṇa, not the speech of leaving desire behind, speech not in accord with principle, speech that vexes and disturbs others, and the speech of śrāvakas and pratyekabuddhas: to say it in brief, of leaving far behind all speech that obstructs the way of a bodhisattva; the pure equanimity of waiting for the time to teach and transform those sentient beings whose faculties are already ripe and in whom mindfulness and wisdom have arisen but who still cannot know the highest dharma; the pure equanimity of likewise waiting for the time with those sentient beings whom the bodhisattva has already taught and transformed in former ages and who can be tamed only when they reach the ground of buddhahood; the pure equanimity in which bodhisattva-mahāsattvas, toward these two kinds of persons, are without high and without low, without taking up and without setting down, leaving far behind all the various discriminations, ever abiding in right concentration, entering the dharma of things as they truly are, and gaining a mind that can bear it. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely within this, then he will obtain the unsurpassed and vast pure equanimity of a Tathāgata.

Gate 15. Meaning: Ten Kinds of Meaning That Is Conveyed

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of meaning. Which are the ten? Namely: the meaning of much hearing — for the reason that it lies in cultivating firmly; the meaning of dharma — for the reason that it lies in deliberating and choosing skillfully; the meaning of emptiness — for the reason that it is the emptiness of the highest truth; the meaning of stillness — for the reason that it leaves behind the clamor of sentient beings; the meaning of the unspeakable — for the reason that he is not attached to any speech; the meaning of things as they truly are — for the reason that he penetrates through to the three times being even; the meaning of the Dharma realm — for the reason that all dharmas are of one taste; the meaning of suchness — for the reason that all the tathāgatas enter in accord with it; the meaning of the true limit — for the reason that he fully knows the ultimate as it truly is; the meaning of the great parinirvāṇa — for the reason that he extinguishes all suffering and yet still cultivates the various practices of a bodhisattva. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the unsurpassed meaning of all-knowing wisdom.

Gate 16. Dharma: Ten Dharmas That Are Able to Hold

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of dharma. Which are the ten? Namely: the real dharma — for the reason that he cultivates as it was spoken; the dharma of leaving grasping behind — for the reason that the grasper and the grasped are both of them left behind; the dharma of no contention — for the reason that there is no contention of any confusion; the dharma of being at rest and extinguished — for the reason that it extinguishes all burning distress; the dharma of leaving desire behind — for the reason that all greedy desire is cut off; the dharma of no discrimination — for the reason that clinging and discriminating come forever to rest; the dharma of no arising — for the reason that it is unmoved, like empty space; the unconditioned dharma — for the reason that it has left behind the marks of arising, abiding, and ceasing; the dharma of the original nature — for the reason that its own nature is unstained and pure; the dharma of forsaking all upadhi-nirvāṇa (upadhi, which is to say, having suffering) — for the reason that only by forsaking it can all the practices of a bodhisattva be set going and cultivated without cease. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely within this, then he will obtain the unsurpassed and vast dharma of a Tathāgata.

Gate 17. The Equipment of Merit That Aids the Path: Ten Kinds of Provision for Completing Merit

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of equipment of merit that aids the path. Which are the ten? Namely: urging sentient beings to give rise to the aspiration for awakening — this is a bodhisattva’s equipment of merit that aids the path, for the reason that thereby the lineage of the three jewels is not cut off. Following upon the ten kinds of dedication — this is a bodhisattva’s equipment of merit that aids the path, for the reason that thereby all dharmas that are not good are cut off and all dharmas of good are gathered together. Guiding and instructing with wisdom — this is a bodhisattva’s equipment of merit that aids the path, for the reason that it surpasses the merit of the three realms. A mind that does not weary — this is a bodhisattva’s equipment of merit that aids the path, for the reason that he means ultimately to deliver and liberate all sentient beings. Giving away entirely everything he has, within and without — this is a bodhisattva’s equipment of merit that aids the path, for the reason that toward all things he has nothing grasped at. Being vigorous and not turning back so as to fulfill the marks and signs — this is a bodhisattva’s equipment of merit that aids the path, for the reason that he gives with the gates thrown wide open, without limit. Dedicating and directing to unsurpassed awakening the roots of good of all three grades, the higher, the middling, and the lower, and in his mind slighting not one portion of them — this is a bodhisattva’s equipment of merit that aids the path, for the reason that it accords with skillfulness in means. Giving rise to great compassion toward sentient beings of the wrong fixity, the low and mean, and the not good, and harboring no mind that holds them cheap — this is a bodhisattva’s equipment of merit that aids the path, for the reason that he ever sets going the great vowing mind of a great person. Reverencing and making offerings to all the tathāgatas, giving rise to the thought of a tathāgata toward all bodhisattvas, and causing all sentient beings to be glad — this is a bodhisattva’s equipment of merit that aids the path, for the reason that he holds to his original vow most firmly. That bodhisattva-mahāsattvas amass roots of good through asaṃkhyeya kalpas, and though the realization of unsurpassed awakening for themselves is already as though in the palm of the hand, give it all away to all sentient beings, with no sorrow and distress in their minds and no regret, that mind being vast and the same as the realm of empty space — this is a bodhisattva’s equipment of merit that aids the path, for the reason that thereby great wisdom is set going and the great Dharma is realized. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely within this, then he will be complete in the unsurpassed and vast mass of merit of a Tathāgata.

Gate 18. The Equipment of Wisdom That Aids the Path: Ten Kinds of Provision for Completing Wisdom

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of equipment of wisdom that aids the path. Which are the ten? Namely: to draw near to a true good friend of much hearing, to reverence and make offerings to him, to honor and pay homage to him, to follow along with him in all sorts of ways, and not to go against his instruction — this is the first, for the reason that all is upright and there is nothing false and haughty. To leave arrogance forever behind, ever to act with humility and reverence, to have nothing coarse and rough in the deeds of body, speech, and mind, to be gentle and well accordant, not false and not crooked — this is the second, for the reason that a body such as this is fit to be a vessel of the Buddha-dharma. That mindfulness and wisdom keep watch at all times and have never been scattered, that there is a sense of shame and a sense of blame, gentleness, and a mind at ease and unmoved, that he ever recalls the six recollections, ever practices the six points of harmony, and ever abides in accord with the six firm dharmas — this is the third, for the reason that it is the skillful means for accomplishing the ten kinds of wisdom. To delight in the Dharma and delight in its meaning, to take the Dharma as his joy, ever to delight in hearing it without ever having enough, to cast away the disputations of the world and the speech of the world, to listen and receive with a concentrated mind the speech that goes beyond the world, to leave far behind the Lesser Vehicle and to enter the wisdom of the Great Vehicle — this is the fourth, for the reason that with a single mind he recollects and is not scattered and stirred. To shoulder the six perfections with a concentrated mind, to have cultivated the four dwellings of Brahmā until they are ripe, to cultivate well all the dharmas of clarity in accord with them, diligently to ask questions of all the sharp-witted and wise, to leave the evil destinies far behind and to turn toward the good roads, ever to delight in them at heart, to contemplate rightly and mindfully, to tame his own disposition and to guard the intentions of others — this is the fifth, for the reason that he firmly cultivates the practice of what is real. Ever to delight in coming forth and departing, not to be attached to the three kinds of existence, constantly to keep watch upon his own mind, never to have had an evil thought, to have cut off the three thoughts of desire, of anger, and of harming, to be good in the three kinds of deeds, and to know with decision the own-nature of the mind — this is the sixth, for the reason that it is able to make the minds of himself and others pure. To contemplate the five aggregates as all of them illusory affairs, the eighteen elements as venomous snakes, the twelve sense-fields as an empty village, and all dharmas as like an illusion, like a shimmering heat-haze, like the moon in water, like a dream, like a shadow, like an echo, like the image in a mirror, like a painting in the sky, like a whirling wheel of fire, like the colors of a rainbow, like the light of the sun and the moon — without mark and without shape, neither permanent nor cut off, neither coming nor going, and with nothing abiding either; and contemplating thus, to know that all dharmas are without arising and without ceasing — this is the seventh, for the reason that he knows the substance and nature of all dharmas to be empty and still. That bodhisattva-mahāsattvas hear that all dharmas are without self, without a sentient being, without one who lives, without a pudgala, without mind, without object, without greed, anger, and delusion, without body, without thing, without an owner, without anything to depend on, without attachment, and without activity, that all this is nothing at all and wholly comes to rest and extinction, and that having heard it they deeply believe and accept it, neither doubting nor slandering — this is the eighth, for the reason that thereby he is able to accomplish a full and excellent understanding. That bodhisattva-mahāsattvas well tame the faculties, cultivate in accord with the principle, ever abide in calming and contemplating, are still and quiet in mind and intent, so that no stirring thought whatever arises — without self, without person, without one who acts, without activity, reckoning no thought of self and reckoning no deed of self, without sore or wart, without scar or mark, and without even a forbearance obtained here; the deeds of body, speech, and mind neither coming nor going, without vigor and without bravery; contemplating all sentient beings and all dharmas with a mind even and with nothing abiding, neither this shore nor the far shore, the nature of both this and that being left behind, coming from nowhere and going nowhere, and ever thinking in this way with wisdom — this is the ninth, for the reason that he has reached the far shore of the mark of discrimination. That bodhisattva-mahāsattvas, because they see the dharma of dependent origination, see that dharmas are pure; because they see that dharmas are pure, see that the lands are pure; because they see that the lands are pure, see that empty space is pure; because they see that empty space is pure, see that the Dharma realm is pure; because they see that the Dharma realm is pure, see that wisdom is pure — this is the tenth, for the reason that thereby he cultivates and amasses all-knowing wisdom. Sons of the Buddha! These are bodhisattva-mahāsattvas’ ten kinds of equipment of wisdom that aids the path. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the pure and subtle and wondrous mass of wisdom of a Tathāgata, unobstructed with regard to all dharmas.

Gate 19. Clarity and Footing: Ten Kinds of Clarity and Footing

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of clarity and footing. Which are the ten? Namely: the clarity and footing of discriminating the various dharmas well; the clarity and footing of not grasping at and being attached to the various dharmas; the clarity and footing of leaving inverted views behind; the clarity and footing of examining the faculties with the light of wisdom; the clarity and footing of skillfully setting going right vigor; the clarity and footing of a wisdom able to enter deeply into the truth of what is real; the clarity and footing of extinguishing the deeds of the afflictions and accomplishing the wisdom of exhaustion and the wisdom of non-arising; the clarity and footing of the wisdom of the divine eye universally contemplating; the clarity and footing of the recollection of former abodes and the purity of knowing the earlier bound; the clarity and footing of the wisdom of the spiritual penetration of the exhaustion of the contaminants, cutting off the contaminants of sentient beings. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the unsurpassed great light of a Tathāgata with regard to all the dharmas of a buddha.

Gate 20. Seeking the Dharma: Ten Kinds of Mind That Seeks the Dharma

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of seeking the Dharma. Which are the ten? Namely: seeking the Dharma with an upright mind — for the reason that there is no flattery and deceiving; seeking the Dharma with vigor — for the reason that he leaves indolence and arrogance far behind; seeking the Dharma with a single direction — for the reason that he does not begrudge body and life; seeking the Dharma so as to cut off the afflictions of all sentient beings — for the reason that it is not for the sake of fame, gain, and reverence; seeking the Dharma so as to enrich and benefit all sentient beings, himself and others — for the reason that it is not for his own benefit alone; seeking the Dharma so as to enter wisdom — for the reason that he takes no delight in the letter; seeking the Dharma so as to come forth from birth-and-death — for the reason that he is not greedy for the joys of the world; seeking the Dharma so as to cross sentient beings over — for the reason that he has given rise to the aspiration for awakening; seeking the Dharma so as to cut off the doubts of all sentient beings — for the reason that he means to leave them without hesitation; seeking the Dharma so as to fulfill the Buddha-dharma — for the reason that he takes no delight in the remaining vehicles. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the great wisdom of all the dharmas of a buddha, not taught to him by another.

Gate 21. Dharmas Clearly Understood: The Dharma Each of Ten Classes of Persons Clearly Understands

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of dharma clearly understood. Which are the ten? Namely: following along with the ways of the world and growing roots of good — this is the dharma clearly understood by the ordinary person, the childish and untaught; obtaining a faith unobstructed and unbroken and keeping watch upon the own-nature of dharmas — this is the dharma clearly understood by one who practices in accordance with faith; diligently cultivating the Dharma and abiding in accord with the Dharma — this is the dharma clearly understood by one who practices in accordance with the Dharma; leaving far behind the eight wrong ones and turning toward the eightfold right path — this is the dharma clearly understood by the eighth person — the eighth person is the one directed toward the first fruit; extinguishing the various fetters, cutting off the contaminants of birth-and-death, and seeing the truth of what is real — this is the dharma clearly understood by the person of the stream-enterer; contemplating that the taste of desire is itself a danger, and knowing that there is no going and coming — this is the dharma clearly understood by the person of the once-returner; not delighting in the three realms and seeking the exhaustion of the contaminants, and toward the dharma of taking on birth not giving rise to fond attachment even for a single thought — this is the dharma clearly understood by the person of the non-returner; obtaining the six spiritual penetrations, obtaining the eight liberations, and completing the nine successive concentrations and the four unobstructed eloquences — this is the dharma clearly understood by the person of the arhat; being by nature fond of contemplating dependent origination as one taste, a mind ever still, content and with few affairs, understanding by himself and awakening not through another, and accomplishing all sorts of spiritual penetration and wisdom — this is the dharma clearly understood by the person of the pratyekabuddha; wisdom vast, the faculties clear and sharp, ever delighting to deliver and liberate all sentient beings, diligently cultivating the dharmas of merit and wisdom that aid the path, and being complete and full in all that a Tathāgata has, the ten powers, the fearlessnesses, and all merits — this is the dharma clearly understood by the person of the bodhisattva. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the dharma clearly understood by the unsurpassed great wisdom of a Tathāgata.

Gate 22. Dharmas of Cultivation: Ten Gates of Practice

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of dharma of cultivation. Which are the ten? Namely: the dharma of cultivation of reverencing and honoring the various good friends; the dharma of cultivation of being ever awakened by the gods; the dharma of cultivation of ever harboring a sense of shame and blame in the presence of the buddhas; the dharma of cultivation of pitying sentient beings and not forsaking birth-and-death; the dharma of cultivation of surely carrying through to the end whatever he does, with a mind that does not change and shift; the dharma of cultivation of recollecting with a concentrated mind and following after the assemblies of bodhisattvas who have given rise to the mind of the Great Vehicle, and diligently cultivating and learning; the dharma of cultivation of leaving wrong views far behind and diligently seeking the right road; the dharma of cultivation of crushing and demolishing the hosts of māra and the deeds of the afflictions; the dharma of cultivation of knowing the superiority and inferiority of the nature of the faculties of sentient beings and speaking the Dharma for them, causing them to abide in the ground of buddhahood; the dharma of cultivation of abiding securely in the boundless and vast Dharma realm, extinguishing the afflictions and making the body pure. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely within this, then he will obtain the unsurpassed dharma of cultivation of a Tathāgata.

Gate 23. Māra: Ten Māras That Obstruct the Way

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of māra. Which are the ten? Namely: the māra of the aggregates — for the reason that from it the various graspings and attachments are set going; the māra of the afflictions — for the reason that it defiles constantly; the māra of deeds — for the reason that it is able to make obstruction; the māra of the mind — for the reason that from it haughtiness is set going; the māra of death — for the reason that it forsakes the place where one was born; the māra of the heavens — for the reason that he is arrogant and lets himself go; the māra of the roots of good — for the reason that toward the roots of good he grasps constantly; the māra of samādhi — for the reason that he long relishes its taste; the māra of the good friend — for the reason that toward the good friend a mind of attachment has arisen; the māra of the wisdom of the dharma of awakening — for the reason that toward it he is unwilling to let go. These are the ten. Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas ought to make skillful means and swiftly seek to leave them far behind.

Gate 24. Deeds of Māra: Ten Deeds That Corrupt and Ruin the Roots of Good

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of deed of māra. Which are the ten? Namely: forgetting and losing the mind of awakening while cultivating the various roots of good — this is a deed of māra; giving with an evil mind, keeping the precepts with an angry mind, casting away those whose disposition is evil, leaving far behind those who are indolent, slighting those whose minds are scattered, and mocking and disdaining those of evil understanding — this is a deed of māra; toward the profound Dharma giving rise to a stingy mind, and though there be one fit to be taught and crossed over not speaking for him, while if he gets goods, gain, reverence, and offerings, then although the other is no vessel for the Dharma yet forcing himself to speak for him — this is a deed of māra; taking no delight in hearing the various perfections, and even when he has heard them not cultivating them, or though he does cultivate them yet often giving rise to indolence, and by reason of indolence his aspiration and intent being narrow and mean so that he does not seek the unsurpassed dharma of great awakening — this is a deed of māra; leaving good friends far behind and drawing near to evil friends, delighting to seek the two vehicles, taking no delight in taking on birth, and setting his aspiration upon nirvāṇa, the leaving of desire behind, and stillness — this is a deed of māra; toward a bodhisattva giving rise to a mind of anger, looking at him with an evil eye, searching out his offenses, proclaiming his faults and evils, and cutting off all the goods, gain, and offerings that he has — this is a deed of māra; slandering the true Dharma and taking no delight in hearing it, and when he does hear it then giving rise to disparagement, giving rise to no reverence when he sees others speaking the Dharma, and saying that what he himself expounds is right and what others expound is all wrong — this is a deed of māra; delighting to study the disputations of the world, artful techniques, and the ornaments of speech, opening out the two vehicles while hiding and covering over the profound Dharma, or handing a wondrous meaning to one who is not the person for it, leaving awakening far behind and abiding in a false road — this is a deed of māra; toward those already liberated and already at ease ever delighting to draw near and make offerings, and toward those not yet liberated and not yet at ease being unwilling either to draw near or to teach and transform them — this is a deed of māra; increasing the conceit of self, being without reverence, doing much to vex and harm sentient beings, not seeking the true Dharma and the wisdom of what is real, and that mind being wicked and evil and hard to awaken — this is a deed of māra. These are the ten. Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas ought swiftly to leave them far behind and diligently to seek the deeds of a buddha.

Gate 25. Forsaking the Deeds of Māra: Ten Direct Antidotes

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of forsaking the deeds of māra. Which are the ten? Namely: drawing near to good friends and reverencing and making offerings to them is forsaking the deeds of māra; not raising himself up and not praising himself is forsaking the deeds of māra; believing and understanding the profound Dharma of the buddhas and not slandering it is forsaking the deeds of māra; never having forgotten and lost the mind of all-knowing wisdom is forsaking the deeds of māra; diligently cultivating wondrous practice and being constantly non-heedless is forsaking the deeds of māra; ever seeking the dharma of the treasury of all bodhisattvas is forsaking the deeds of māra; constantly expounding the Dharma with a mind that does not weary is forsaking the deeds of māra; taking refuge in all the buddhas of the ten directions and giving rise to the thought of them as rescuers and guardians is forsaking the deeds of māra; believing, accepting, and recollecting all the buddhas and receiving the sustaining of their spiritual power is forsaking the deeds of māra; having the same roots of good as all bodhisattvas, even and without a second is forsaking the deeds of māra. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will be able to come forth from all the roads of māra.

Gate 26. Seeing the Buddha: Ten Ways of Seeing the Buddha

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of seeing the Buddha. Which are the ten? Namely: toward the buddha who abides in the world and accomplishes perfect awakening, seeing him with non-attachment; toward the buddha of the vow, seeing him with bringing forth; toward the buddha of the recompense of deeds, seeing him with deep faith; toward the buddha who abides and sustains, seeing him with following along; toward the buddha of nirvāṇa, seeing him with entering deeply; toward the buddha of the Dharma realm, seeing him with reaching everywhere; toward the buddha of the mind, seeing him with abiding securely; toward the buddha of samādhi, seeing him with the measureless and the unsupported; toward the buddha of the original nature, seeing him with clear understanding; toward the buddha who accords with what is delighted in, seeing him with universally receiving. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will constantly be able to see the unsurpassed Tathāgata.

Gate 27. The Deeds of a Buddha: Ten Things That a Buddha Does

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of deed of a buddha. Which are the ten? Namely: opening up, revealing, and guiding at the right time — this is a deed of a buddha, for the reason that he means to make people cultivate rightly. Causing him to see it within a dream — this is a deed of a buddha, for the reason that he means to awaken his roots of good of former ages. Expounding for another a scripture he has not yet heard — this is a deed of a buddha, for the reason that he means to make him give rise to wisdom and cut off doubt. Speaking the dharma of coming forth and departing for one bound by remorse — this is a deed of a buddha, for the reason that he means to make him leave behind the doubting mind. If there be a sentient being in whom a stingy mind has arisen, and even a mind of evil understanding, a mind of the two vehicles, a mind of harming, a mind of doubt, a mind scattered and stirred, or a mind of arrogance, then manifesting for him the body of a Tathāgata adorned with all the marks — this is a deed of a buddha, for the reason that he means to grow his roots of good of the past. In a time when the true Dharma is hard to meet with, expounding the Dharma at length, and causing him, having heard it, to obtain the wisdom of the holdings-together and the wisdom of the spiritual penetrations, so that he can universally benefit measureless sentient beings — this is a deed of a buddha, for the reason that his excellent understanding is pure. If the affairs of māra should arise, being able by skillful means to manifest a sound like the realm of empty space and to speak the dharma of not harming and distressing others as an antidote to it, so that he awakens, and the hosts of māra, hearing it, have their majestic radiance extinguished — this is a deed of a buddha, for the reason that his aspiration and delight are surpassing and his majestic virtue is vast. That mind continuing on unbroken, ever guarding himself, and not letting himself realize and enter the right position of the two vehicles; and if there be a sentient being whose faculties are not yet ripe, never speaking for him of the realm of liberation — this is a deed of a buddha, for the reason that this is what his original vow does. The fetters and contaminants of birth-and-death all of them left behind, cultivating the practice of a bodhisattva continuously and unbroken, and with a mind of great compassion taking in sentient beings, causing them to set going practice and ultimately to be liberated — this is a deed of a buddha, for the reason that his cultivating of the practice of a bodhisattva is unbroken. That bodhisattva-mahāsattvas penetrate through to their own body and to sentient beings being from the first at rest and extinguished, and are not startled and not afraid, and yet still diligently cultivate merit and wisdom without ever having enough; that though they know all dharmas to be without any making, they do not forsake the own-mark of dharmas either; that though toward the various objective realms they have forever left greedy desire behind, they still ever delight to gaze up at and serve the form-bodies of the buddhas; that though they know that awakening to and entering the Dharma is not through another, they still use all sorts of skillful means to seek all-knowing wisdom; that though they know all the lands to be like empty space, they still ever delight to adorn all buddha-lands; that though they constantly contemplate that there is no person and no self, they teach and transform sentient beings without wearying; that though toward the Dharma realm they are from the first unmoved, they manifest all sorts of transformations with the power of the wisdom of the spiritual penetrations; that though they have already accomplished the wisdom of all-knowing wisdom, they cultivate the practice of a bodhisattva without rest; that though they know that the various dharmas cannot be spoken, they turn the pure wheel of the Dharma and make the great assembly glad at heart; that though they are able to manifest the spiritual power of the buddhas, they are not weary of and do not forsake the body of a bodhisattva; that though they manifest entering into the great parinirvāṇa, they manifest the taking on of birth in all places — being able to do a dharma such as this, in which the provisional and the real are carried on together, this is a deed of a buddha. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely within this, then he will obtain the unsurpassed, teacherless, and vast deeds, not taught to him by another.

Gate 28. Deeds of Conceit: Ten Deeds Brought About by Conceit

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of deed of conceit. Which are the ten? Namely: toward teachers and elders, the assembly of monks, father and mother, śramaṇas, brāhmaṇas, and those who abide in the right road and those who turn toward the right road — toward these places that are honored fields of merit — yet not being reverent: this is a deed of conceit; or if there be a master of the Dharma who has obtained the most excellent Dharma, who rides in the Great Vehicle, who knows the road of coming forth, who has obtained the holdings-together, and who expounds the sūtras and the vast Dharma without rest, yet giving rise to a mind of haughtiness toward him and giving rise to no reverence toward the Dharma he expounds: this is a deed of conceit; in the gathering of the great assembly, hearing a wondrous dharma spoken and being unwilling to praise it and unwilling to make others believe and accept it: this is a deed of conceit; being fond of giving rise to the conceit of excess, exalting himself and riding roughshod over others, not seeing his own faults and not knowing his own shortcomings: this is a deed of conceit; being fond of giving rise to the conceit beyond excess, and when he sees one who has virtue, not praising him though he ought to be praised, and when he sees others praising him, giving rise to no gladness either: this is a deed of conceit; seeing a master of the Dharma speaking the Dharma for others and knowing full well that this is Dharma, is Vinaya, is what is real, is what the Buddha spoke, yet because he dislikes that person also disliking that Dharma along with him, giving rise to slander himself and teaching others to slander it as well: this is a deed of conceit; seeking a high seat for himself, calling himself a master of the Dharma, holding that he ought by rights to be provided for and ought not to do any work, and when he sees one aged and long in cultivation neither rising to greet him nor being willing to serve him: this is a deed of conceit; when he sees one who has virtue, knitting his brows and being displeased, his words coarse and rough, spying out that man’s faults: this is a deed of conceit; when he sees one who is clever and knows the Dharma, being unwilling to draw near, reverence, and make offerings to him, and unwilling to ask, ‘What is good? What is not good? What ought to be done? What ought not to be done? Doing what sort of deeds, may one in the long night obtain all sorts of benefit and ease?’ — deluded and stubborn, swallowed up by the conceit of self, and in the end not able to see the road of coming forth: this is a deed of conceit; and there are sentient beings covered over by a conceited mind, so that though the buddhas appear in the world they cannot draw near, reverence, and make offerings to them, and the good that is new does not arise while the good that is old is extinguished too, and they speak what ought not to be spoken and contend over what ought not to be contended over, and in the time to come will surely fall into a deep pit of peril and difficulty, passing a hundred thousand kalpas without so much as meeting a buddha, how much less hearing the Dharma! — only because they once gave rise to the mind of awakening, in the end they will of themselves awaken: this is a deed of conceit. These are the ten.

Gate 29. Deeds of Wisdom: The Ten Deeds of Wisdom Obtained After Leaving Conceit Behind

“If a bodhisattva leaves these deeds of conceit behind, then he obtains ten kinds of deed of wisdom. Which are the ten? Namely: believing and understanding the recompense of deeds and not destroying cause and fruit — this is a deed of wisdom; not forsaking the mind of awakening and ever recollecting the buddhas — this is a deed of wisdom; drawing near to good friends and reverencing and making offerings to them, that mind honoring them and from first to last never wearying — this is a deed of wisdom; delighting in the Dharma and delighting in its meaning without ever having enough, leaving false thought far behind and diligently cultivating right mindfulness — this is a deed of wisdom; toward all sentient beings leaving the conceit of self behind, toward the various bodhisattvas giving rise to the thought of a tathāgata, cherishing the true Dharma as he cherishes his own body, honoring and serving the Tathāgata as he guards and cherishes his own life, and toward those who cultivate giving rise to the thought of them as buddhas — this is a deed of wisdom; in the deeds of body, speech, and mind having none of the various kinds of the not good, praising the worthy and the noble, and following along with awakening — this is a deed of wisdom; not destroying dependent origination, leaving the various wrong views behind, breaking the darkness and obtaining light, and shining upon and seeing all dharmas — this is a deed of wisdom; toward the ten kinds of dedication cultivating in accord with them, toward the various perfections giving rise to the thought of a loving mother, toward skillfulness in means giving rise to the thought of a loving father, and with a deeply pure mind entering the house of awakening — this is a deed of wisdom; giving, keeping the precepts, much hearing, calming and contemplating, merit and wisdom — all these dharmas that aid the path being ever diligently amassed without wearying — this is a deed of wisdom; if there be any kind of deed that the buddhas praise, that is able to demolish the contention of the hosts of māra and the afflictions, able to leave behind all obstructions, coverings, entanglements, and bonds, able to teach, transform, and tame all sentient beings, able in accord with wisdom to take in the true Dharma, able to adorn and purify buddha-lands, and able to set going the spiritual penetrations and the clarities — diligently cultivating them all without slackening and drawing back — this is a deed of wisdom. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely within this, then he will obtain the unsurpassed great deeds of wisdom of all the skillful means of a Tathāgata.

Gate 30. Being Held by Māra: Ten Marks of Being Held Fast by Māra

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of being held by māra. Which are the ten? Namely: an indolent mind is being held by māra; aspiration and desire that are narrow and mean is being held by māra; giving rise to contentment with a small portion of cultivation is being held by māra; accepting only one kind and not accepting the rest is being held by māra; not giving rise to the great vow is being held by māra; delighting to dwell in what is at rest and extinguished and seeking only to cut off the afflictions is being held by māra; forever cutting off birth-and-death is being held by māra; forsaking the practice of a bodhisattva is being held by māra; not teaching and crossing over sentient beings is being held by māra; doubting and slandering the true Dharma is being held by māra. These are the ten.

Gate 31. Being Held by the Buddhas: The Ten Holdings of the Buddhas After Casting Off the Holding of Māra

“If a bodhisattva is able to cast off these ways of being held by māra, then he obtains ten kinds of being held by the buddhas. Which are the ten? Namely: at the very first being able to give rise to the mind of awakening is being held by the buddhas; in life after life upholding the mind of awakening and not letting it be forgotten and lost is being held by the buddhas; keeping watch upon the affairs of the māras and being able wholly to leave them far behind is being held by the buddhas; hearing of the various perfections and cultivating as they were spoken is being held by the buddhas; knowing the suffering of birth-and-death and yet not loathing it is being held by the buddhas; contemplating the profound Dharma and obtaining measureless fruit is being held by the buddhas; speaking the dharma of the two vehicles for sentient beings while himself not realizing and grasping the liberation of that vehicle is being held by the buddhas; delighting to contemplate the unconditioned dharma and yet not abiding within it, and toward the conditioned and the unconditioned not giving rise to two thoughts, is being held by the buddhas; having reached the place of non-arising and yet still manifesting the taking on of birth is being held by the buddhas; though he has realized all-knowing wisdom, still setting going the practice of a bodhisattva and not cutting off the lineage of bodhisattvas is being held by the buddhas. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely within this, then he will obtain the unsurpassed power of holding of the buddhas.

Gate 32. Being Held by the Dharma: Ten Places of Being Held Fast by the Dharma

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of being held by the Dharma. Which are the ten? Namely: knowing that all conditioned activities are impermanent is being held by the Dharma; knowing that all conditioned activities are suffering is being held by the Dharma; knowing that all conditioned activities are without self is being held by the Dharma; knowing that all dharmas are the nirvāṇa that is at rest and extinguished is being held by the Dharma; knowing that the various dharmas arise from conditions, and that without conditions they do not arise, is being held by the Dharma; knowing that it is because of unright thinking that ignorance arises, and that once ignorance has arisen then on to old age and death arise, and that when unright thinking is extinguished then ignorance is extinguished, and that once ignorance is extinguished then on to old age and death are extinguished, is being held by the Dharma; knowing that the three gates of liberation bring forth the vehicle of the śrāvakas, and that realizing the dharma of no contention brings forth the vehicle of the pratyekabuddhas, is being held by the Dharma; knowing that the six perfections and the four means of gathering bring forth the Great Vehicle is being held by the Dharma; knowing that all lands, all dharmas, all sentient beings, and all ages are the realm of the wisdom of a buddha is being held by the Dharma; knowing that one must cut off all thoughts, cast away all grasping, leave behind the earlier bound and the later bound, and follow along with nirvāṇa is being held by the Dharma. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva abides securely within this, then he will obtain the unsurpassed being held by the Dharma of all the buddhas.

Gate 33. The Deeds Done While Dwelling in the Tuṣita Heaven: The First of the Eight Aspects

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven have ten kinds of deed that they do. Which are the ten? Namely: for the sons of the gods of the realm of desire they speak the dharma of weariness and leaving behind, saying: ‘All mastery is impermanent, and all joy will in the end decay and pass away.’ And they urge those gods to give rise to the aspiration for awakening. This is the first deed done. For the gods of the realm of form they expound entering and coming forth from the various meditations, liberations, and samādhis; and if within these there arises in them fond attachment, and because of that fond attachment there arise again the view of a body, wrong views, ignorance, and the rest, then they speak for them the wisdom of things as they truly are; and if toward all form-dharmas and non-form-dharmas they give rise to an inverted thought and take these to be pure, then they speak for them of the impure and say that all this is impermanent, and urge them to give rise to the mind of awakening. This is the second deed done. A bodhisattva-mahāsattva, dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven, enters a samādhi named Adornment of Light, and from his body sends forth a light that shines everywhere over the three-thousandfold great-thousand world-system, and in accordance with the minds of sentient beings speaks the Dharma for them with all sorts of sounds; and sentient beings, having heard it, are pure in the mind of faith, and when their lives end are born in the Tuṣita heaven, and the bodhisattva urges them to give rise to the mind of awakening. This is the third deed done. A bodhisattva-mahāsattva in the Tuṣita heaven, with the unobstructed eye, universally sees all the bodhisattvas in the Tuṣita heavens of the ten directions, and those bodhisattvas likewise all see this bodhisattva; and having seen one another, they discourse upon the wondrous Dharma, namely: the descending of the spirit and the entering of the mother’s womb, the first birth, the leaving of home, the going to the place of the Way, and being complete in the great adornment; and moreover they manifest the practices they have practiced from former ages onward, and that it is because of those practices that they have accomplished a great wisdom such as this; and all the merits do not depart from their own place, and yet they are able to manifest all sorts of things such as these. This is the fourth deed done. When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva dwells in the Tuṣita heaven, all the assemblies of bodhisattvas of all the Tuṣita heavenly palaces of the ten directions come together and gather round him in reverence; and at that time the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, in order to make all those bodhisattvas fulfill their wishes and be glad, expounds gates of Dharma for them in accordance with the ground in which they ought to abide, what they practice and what they cut off, what they cultivate and what they realize; and those bodhisattvas, having heard the Dharma spoken, are all greatly glad and obtain what they never had before, and each returns to the palace in which he dwells in his own land. This is the fifth deed done. When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva dwells in the Tuṣita heaven, the lord of the realm of desire, the heavenly māra Pāpīyān, in order to ruin and disturb the deeds of the bodhisattva, comes to the bodhisattva’s place with his retinue gathered round him; and at that time the bodhisattva, in order to crush and subdue the armies of māra, abides securely in the gate of the wisdom of the skillfulness in means of the perfection of wisdom taken in by the adamantine path, and speaks the Dharma for him with the two kinds of speech, the gentle and the rough, so that the māra Pāpīyān gains no opening; and the māras, seeing the masterful majestic power of the bodhisattva, all give rise to the mind of unsurpassed perfect awakening. This is the sixth deed done. A bodhisattva-mahāsattva, dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven, knows that the sons of the gods of the realm of desire take no delight in hearing the Dharma; and at that time the bodhisattva sends forth a great sound and announces to them everywhere, saying: ‘Today the bodhisattva will manifest rare things within the palace; let those who wish to see come swiftly.’ Then the sons of the gods, hearing these words, come and gather in measureless hundreds of thousands of koṭis of nayutas; and at that time the bodhisattva, seeing that the assembly of the gods has already gathered, manifests for them all sorts of rare things within the palace; and those sons of the gods, who have never seen or heard such things before, having seen them are all greatly glad, and that mind is intoxicated and sunk in them; and the bodhisattva then sends forth a sound within the music and tells them: ‘Sirs! All conditioned activities are impermanent, all conditioned activities are suffering, all dharmas are without self, and nirvāṇa is at rest and extinguished.’ And he tells them further: ‘You ought all to cultivate the practice of a bodhisattva, and ought all to fulfill the wisdom of all-knowing wisdom.’ Those sons of the gods, hearing this sound of the Dharma, sigh in sorrow and lament, and give rise to weariness and the wish to leave, and there is not one who does not give rise to the mind of awakening. This is the seventh deed done. A bodhisattva-mahāsattva, dwelling in the Tuṣita palace, does not forsake his own place, and yet is wholly able to go to the presence of all the measureless buddhas of the ten directions, to see the tathāgatas, to draw near, pay homage, reverence, and hear the Dharma; and at that time the buddhas, in order to make the bodhisattva obtain the highest dharma of consecration, expound for him a ground of the bodhisattva named All Spiritual Penetrations, causing him with the wisdom of a single thought-moment’s conjunction to be complete in all the most excellent merits and to enter the position of the wisdom of all-knowing wisdom. This is the eighth deed done. A bodhisattva-mahāsattva, dwelling in the Tuṣita palace, in order to make offerings to the tathāgatas, with great spiritual power raises up all sorts of articles of offering named Surpassing and Delightful, and throughout the Dharma realm, the realm of empty space, and all worlds makes offerings to the buddhas; and measureless sentient beings in those worlds, seeing this offering, all give rise to the mind of unsurpassed perfect awakening. This is the ninth deed done. A bodhisattva-mahāsattva, dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven, brings forth measureless and boundless gates of Dharma that are like an illusion and like a shadow, pervading all the worlds of the ten directions, and manifests all sorts of colors, all sorts of marks, all sorts of bodily forms, all sorts of bearing, all sorts of undertakings, all sorts of skillful means, all sorts of similes, and all sorts of speech, and in accordance with the minds of sentient beings makes them all glad. This is the tenth deed done. Sons of the Buddha! These are the ten kinds of deed that bodhisattva-mahāsattvas do while dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven. If a bodhisattva accomplishes this dharma, then he will after this descend to be born among human beings.

Gate 34. Ten Things Manifested in Descending to Birth: Ten Lights, Each Doing One Thing

“Sons of the Buddha! When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva is about to descend to birth from the Tuṣita heaven, he manifests ten kinds of thing. Which are the ten? Sons of the Buddha! When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva descends to birth from the Tuṣita heaven, from the soles of his feet he sends forth a great light named Adornment of Ease and Joy, which shines everywhere over all the sentient beings of the evil destinies and the difficulties within the three-thousandfold great-thousand world-system; and there is none touched by this light who does not leave suffering and obtain ease and joy; and having obtained ease and joy, they all know that a rare great person is about to arise in the world. This is the first thing manifested. Sons of the Buddha! When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva descends to birth from the Tuṣita heaven, from the mark of the white hair-tuft between his brows he sends forth a great light named Awakening, which shines everywhere over the three-thousandfold great-thousand world-system and shines upon the bodies of all the bodhisattvas who have practiced together with him in former ages; and those bodhisattvas, having received the shining of the light, all know that the bodhisattva is about to descend to birth, and each raises up measureless articles of offering and comes to the bodhisattva’s place and makes offerings. This is the second thing manifested. Sons of the Buddha! When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva is about to descend to birth from the Tuṣita heaven, from the palm of his right hand he sends forth a great light named Pure Objective Realm, which is able wholly to adorn and purify all the three-thousandfold great-thousand world-systems; and if within them there be a pratyekabuddha who has already obtained freedom from the contaminants and who keeps watch upon this light, then he casts away his life-span; and those who do not keep watch upon it are, by the power of the light, moved and set down in other remaining worlds; and all the māras, together with the outsiders and the sentient beings who hold the view that things exist, are likewise moved and set down in other worlds — only excepting those sentient beings fit to be transformed who are held by the spiritual power of the buddhas. This is the third thing manifested. Sons of the Buddha! When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva is about to descend to birth from the Tuṣita heaven, from his two knees he sends forth a great light named Pure Adornment, which shines everywhere over all the palaces of the gods, from the heaven of the four kings who guard the world below up to the Pure Abode heavens above, and there is no place it does not pervade; and those gods all know that the bodhisattva is about to descend to birth from the Tuṣita heaven, and all harbor longing, lamenting in sorrow and distressed, and each takes up all sorts of flower-garlands, robes, ointments, powdered incense, banners and canopies, and music, and comes to the bodhisattva’s place to reverence and make offerings, and follows after him from his descent to birth all the way to his nirvāṇa. This is the fourth thing manifested. Sons of the Buddha! When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva in the Tuṣita heaven is about to descend to birth, from the heart-treasury adorned with the adamantine svastika he sends forth a great light named Banner That None Can Overcome, which shines everywhere upon the vajra-bearing strongmen of all the worlds of the ten directions; and then a hundred koṭis of vajra-bearing strongmen all come and gather, following after him and standing guard, from his descent to birth all the way to his nirvāṇa. This is the fifth thing manifested. Sons of the Buddha! When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva is about to descend to birth from the Tuṣita heaven, from all the pores of his body he sends forth a great light named Discerning Sentient Beings, which shines everywhere over all the great-thousand worlds and touches everywhere the bodies of all the bodhisattvas, and touches also all the gods and the people of the world; and the bodhisattvas all think in this way: ‘I ought to abide here, make offerings to the Tathāgata, and teach and transform sentient beings.’ This is the sixth thing manifested. Sons of the Buddha! When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva is about to descend to birth from the Tuṣita heaven, from the great maṇi-jewel treasury hall he sends forth a great light named Contemplating What Abides Well, which shines upon the royal palace where this bodhisattva is about to be born and to be entrusted; and after that light has shone, the remaining bodhisattvas all together follow after him down to Jambudvīpa, and manifest the taking on of birth, whether in his household, in his village, or in his city, for the sake of teaching and transforming sentient beings. This is the seventh thing manifested. Sons of the Buddha! When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva is on the point of descending to birth from the Tuṣita heaven, from the heavenly palaces and from the various adornments of the great tiered pavilions he sends forth a great light named Pure Adornment of All the Palaces, which shines upon the womb of the mother who gives him birth; and after that light has shone, it makes the bodhisattva’s mother secure and at ease, complete and accomplished in all merits, and within the mother’s womb there is of itself a vast tiered pavilion adorned with great maṇi jewels, for the sake of settling the body of the bodhisattva there. This is the eighth thing manifested. Sons of the Buddha! When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva is on the point of descending to birth from the Tuṣita heaven, from beneath the soles of his two feet he sends forth a great light named Abiding Well; and if the life-spans of the sons of the gods and of the Brahmā gods are about to end, then having received the touch of the shining of this light they are all able to prolong and stay their life-spans, and to make offerings to the bodhisattva from his first descent to birth all the way to his nirvāṇa. This is the ninth thing manifested. Sons of the Buddha! When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva is on the point of descending to birth from the Tuṣita heaven, from among the secondary marks he sends forth a great light named Adornment of the Eye, which manifests all sorts of deeds of the bodhisattva; and at that time the humans and gods, some see the bodhisattva dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven, some see him entering the womb, some see his first birth, some see him leaving home, some see him accomplishing the Way, some see him subduing māra, some see him turning the wheel of the Dharma, and some see him entering nirvāṇa. This is the tenth thing manifested. Sons of the Buddha! A bodhisattva-mahāsattva, upon his body, upon his seat, within his palace, and within his tiered pavilion, sends forth a million asaṃkhyeya lights such as these, and wholly manifests all sorts of deeds of a bodhisattva; and having manifested these deeds, because he is complete in all the dharmas of merit, he descends to birth among human beings from the Tuṣita heaven.

Gate 35. Ten Matters of Dwelling in the Womb: Why Dwelling in the Womb Is Manifested

“Sons of the Buddha! A bodhisattva-mahāsattva’s manifesting of dwelling in the womb has ten kinds of matter. Which are the ten? Sons of the Buddha! A bodhisattva-mahāsattva, in order to bring to accomplishment sentient beings of small mind and mean understanding, and not wishing to make them give rise to a thought such as this — ‘This bodhisattva now is born of transformation of himself, and his wisdom and roots of good did not come from cultivation’ — therefore the bodhisattva manifests dwelling in the womb. This is the first matter. A bodhisattva-mahāsattva manifests dwelling in the womb in order to ripen the roots of good of his father and mother, of his various relatives, and of the sentient beings who practiced together with him in former ages. Why is this? Because it is only by seeing him dwelling in the womb that all their roots of good ought to be ripened. This is the second matter. When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva enters the mother’s womb, he is rightly mindful and rightly knowing, without confusion; and after he has come to dwell within the mother’s womb, his mind is ever rightly mindful, and there is no disorder either. This is the third matter. A bodhisattva-mahāsattva within the mother’s womb constantly speaks the Dharma, and the great bodhisattvas of the worlds of the ten directions, the Śakras, the Brahmā kings, and the four heavenly kings all come and gather, and he causes them all to obtain measureless spiritual power and boundless wisdom; the bodhisattva’s dwelling in the womb accomplishes eloquence and excellent use such as this. This is the fourth matter. A bodhisattva-mahāsattva within the mother’s womb gathers a great assembly, and with the power of his original vow teaches and transforms all the assemblies of bodhisattvas. This is the fifth matter. Since a bodhisattva-mahāsattva becomes a buddha among human beings, he ought by rights to have the most excellent taking on of birth among human beings, and therefore he manifests dwelling in the mother’s womb. This is the sixth matter. While a bodhisattva-mahāsattva is within the mother’s womb, the sentient beings of the three-thousandfold great-thousand world-system all see the bodhisattva, as one sees the image of one’s own face in a bright mirror; and at that time the great-minded gods, nāgas, yakṣas, gandharvas, asuras, garuḍas, kiṃnaras, mahoragas, humans, nonhumans, and the rest all come to the bodhisattva’s place to reverence and make offerings. This is the seventh matter. While a bodhisattva-mahāsattva is within the mother’s womb, all the bodhisattvas of the final birth who are within a mother’s womb in the worlds of other quarters all come and meet together, and he expounds a gate of Dharma of the great gathering named Treasury of Vast Wisdom. This is the eighth matter. When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva is within the mother’s womb, he enters a samādhi named Treasury Free of Defilement, and with the power of that samādhi manifests within the mother’s womb a great palace, all sorts of ornaments being utterly wondrous and fine, such that the palace of the Tuṣita heaven cannot be compared with it, and moreover he makes the mother’s body secure, at ease, and without ailment. This is the ninth matter. When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva dwells in the mother’s womb, with great majestic power he raises up articles of offering named Opening the Great Merit of the Treasury Free of Defilement, and throughout all the worlds of the ten directions makes offerings to all the buddhas, the tathāgatas, and those tathāgatas all expound for him the boundless Dharma-realm treasury of the dwelling-places of a bodhisattva. This is the tenth matter. Sons of the Buddha! These are the ten kinds of matter of a bodhisattva-mahāsattva’s manifesting of dwelling in the womb. If a bodhisattva penetrates through to this dharma, then he will be able to manifest the exceedingly subtle resorts.

Gate 36. The Exceedingly Subtle Resorts: Manifesting a Whole Lifetime All at Once Within the Womb

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of exceedingly subtle resort. Which are the ten? Namely: within the mother’s womb, manifesting the first giving rise to the mind of awakening on to the ground of consecration; within the mother’s womb, manifesting dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven; within the mother’s womb, manifesting the first birth; within the mother’s womb, manifesting the stage of a youth; within the mother’s womb, manifesting dwelling in the royal palace; within the mother’s womb, manifesting the leaving of home; within the mother’s womb, manifesting austerities, going to the place of the Way, and accomplishing perfect awakening; within the mother’s womb, manifesting the turning of the wheel of the Dharma; within the mother’s womb, manifesting parinirvāṇa; within the mother’s womb, manifesting the greatly subtle, namely: all the practices of a bodhisattva and the measureless and diverse gates of the masterful spiritual power of all the tathāgatas. Sons of the Buddha! These are the ten kinds of subtle resort of a bodhisattva-mahāsattva within the mother’s womb. If a bodhisattva abides securely in this dharma, then he will obtain the subtle resort of the unsurpassed great wisdom of a Tathāgata.

Gate 37. Ten Kinds of Birth: The Marks of the First Birth

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of birth. Which are the ten? Namely: being born leaving delusion far behind, rightly mindful and rightly knowing; being born sending forth a net of great light that shines everywhere over the three-thousandfold great-thousand world-system; being born abiding in the final existence and taking on a later body no more; being born neither arising nor being set going; being born knowing the three realms to be like an illusion; being born manifesting his body everywhere in the worlds of the ten directions; being born with a body that realizes the wisdom of all-knowing wisdom; being born with a body that sends forth the light of all the buddhas and universally awakens all sentient beings; being born with a body that enters the samādhi of contemplating with great wisdom; Sons of the Buddha! When the bodhisattva is born, he shakes all the buddha-lands, liberates all sentient beings, extinguishes all the evil destinies, outshines and eclipses all the māras, and measureless bodhisattvas all come and gather. Sons of the Buddha! These are the ten kinds of birth of a bodhisattva-mahāsattva, manifested in this way for the sake of taming sentient beings.

Gate 38. Smiling and Inwardly Vowing: The Smile That Follows Ten Thoughts

“Sons of the Buddha! Because of ten matters a bodhisattva-mahāsattva manifests a smile and inwardly vows. Which are the ten? Namely: a bodhisattva-mahāsattva thinks: ‘All the world is sunk in the mire of desire, and apart from me alone there is none able to save them.’ Knowing this, with glad delight he smiles and inwardly vows. He thinks further: ‘All the world is blinded by the afflictions; I alone today am complete in wisdom.’ Knowing this, with glad delight he smiles and inwardly vows. He thinks further: ‘Today, with this body of borrowed name, I shall obtain the unsurpassed dharma-body of a Tathāgata that fills the three times.’ Knowing this, with glad delight he smiles and inwardly vows. At that time the bodhisattva, with the unobstructed eye, contemplates everywhere all the Brahmā gods of the ten directions on to all the gods of Great Mastery, and thinks in this way: ‘These sentient beings all take themselves to have great powers of wisdom.’ Knowing this, with glad delight he smiles and inwardly vows. At that time the bodhisattva contemplates and sees that sentient beings have long planted roots of good and yet today have all fallen away from them; knowing this, with glad delight he smiles and inwardly vows. The bodhisattva contemplates and sees that of the seeds of the world, though what is planted is little, the fruit obtained is very much; knowing this, with glad delight he smiles and inwardly vows. The bodhisattva contemplates and sees that all sentient beings who receive the teaching of the Buddha will surely obtain benefit; knowing this, with glad delight he smiles and inwardly vows. The bodhisattva contemplates and sees that the bodhisattvas who practiced together with him in past ages are stained and attached to other affairs and do not obtain the vast merits of the Buddha-dharma; knowing this, with glad delight he smiles and inwardly vows. The bodhisattva contemplates and sees that the gods and humans and the rest who gathered together with him in past ages are to this day still in the stage of the ordinary person and cannot forsake it, and yet do not feel weary of it either; knowing this, with glad delight he smiles and inwardly vows. At that time the bodhisattva is touched by the light of all the tathāgatas, and is glad and comforted twice over, and with glad delight he smiles and inwardly vows. These are the ten. Sons of the Buddha! The bodhisattva manifests in this way for the sake of taming sentient beings.

Gate 39. Walking Seven Steps: The Ten Reasons for Walking Those Seven Steps

“Sons of the Buddha! Because of ten matters a bodhisattva-mahāsattva manifests the walking of seven steps. Which are the ten? Namely: in order to make manifest the power of a bodhisattva, therefore he manifests the walking of seven steps; in order to make manifest the giving of the seven noble riches, therefore he manifests the walking of seven steps; in order to fulfill the vow of the earth spirits, therefore he manifests the walking of seven steps; in order to make manifest the mark of passing beyond the three realms, therefore he manifests the walking of seven steps; in order to make manifest that the most excellent practice of a bodhisattva surpasses the practice of the elephant-king, the bull-king, and the lion-king, therefore he manifests the walking of seven steps; in order to make manifest the mark of the adamantine ground, therefore he manifests the walking of seven steps; in order to make manifest that he means to give sentient beings the power of bravery, therefore he manifests the walking of seven steps; in order to make manifest the cultivating of the jewels of the seven limbs of awakening, therefore he manifests the walking of seven steps; in order to make manifest that the dharma he has obtained is not taught to him by another, therefore he manifests the walking of seven steps; in order to make manifest that in the world he is the most excellent and beyond compare, therefore he manifests the walking of seven steps. These are the ten. Sons of the Buddha! The bodhisattva manifests in this way for the sake of taming sentient beings.

Gate 40. Dwelling in the Stage of a Youth: The Ten Reasons for Being a Youth

“Sons of the Buddha! Because of ten matters a bodhisattva-mahāsattva manifests dwelling in the stage of a youth. Which are the ten? Namely: in order to make manifest his penetrating mastery of all the letters, reckoning, drawings and books, and seals and signets of the world, and undertakings of all sorts, therefore he dwells in the stage of a youth; in order to make manifest his penetrating mastery of all the elephants and horses, carriages, bows and arrows, and swords and halberds of the world, and undertakings of all sorts, therefore he dwells in the stage of a youth; in order to make manifest his penetrating mastery of all the writing and discoursing, the board games and the amusements of the world, and affairs of all sorts, therefore he dwells in the stage of a youth; in order to make manifest his leaving far behind the faults of all sorts in the deeds of body, speech, and mind, therefore he dwells in the stage of a youth; in order to make manifest his entering concentration, abiding in the gate of nirvāṇa, and pervading the measureless worlds of the ten directions, therefore he dwells in the stage of a youth; in order to make manifest that his power surpasses that of all the gods, nāgas, yakṣas, gandharvas, asuras, garuḍas, kiṃnaras, mahoragas, Śakras, Brahmā kings, the world-guardians, humans, nonhumans, and the rest, therefore he dwells in the stage of a youth; in order to make manifest that the form, the marks, and the majestic radiance of a bodhisattva surpass those of all the Śakras, the Brahmā kings, and the world-guardians, therefore he dwells in the stage of a youth; in order to make sentient beings who are absorbed in the joys of desire glad and delighted in the Dharma, therefore he dwells in the stage of a youth; in order to honor the true Dharma, to make offerings to the buddhas with diligence, and to pervade all the worlds of the ten directions, therefore he dwells in the stage of a youth; in order to make manifest his obtaining the aid of the buddhas and receiving the light of the Dharma, therefore he dwells in the stage of a youth. These are the ten.

Gate 41. Manifesting Dwelling in the Royal Palace: The Ten Reasons for Living in the Palace

“Sons of the Buddha! After a bodhisattva-mahāsattva has manifested the stage of a youth, because of ten matters he manifests dwelling in the royal palace. Which are the ten? Namely: in order to ripen the roots of good of the sentient beings who practiced together with him in former ages, therefore he manifests dwelling in the royal palace; in order to make manifest the power of a bodhisattva’s roots of good, therefore he manifests dwelling in the royal palace; because the humans and gods are absorbed in the implements of joy, in order to manifest the implements of joy of a bodhisattva’s great majestic virtue, therefore he manifests dwelling in the royal palace; in order to follow along with the minds of the sentient beings of the age of the five turbidities, therefore he manifests dwelling in the royal palace; in order to make manifest that the power of a bodhisattva’s great majestic virtue is able to enter samādhi within the deep palace, therefore he manifests dwelling in the royal palace; in order to make the sentient beings who vowed together with him in former ages fulfill their heart’s intent, therefore he manifests dwelling in the royal palace; in order to make his father and mother, his kin, and his retinue fulfill what they wish, therefore he manifests dwelling in the royal palace; because he wishes with music to send forth the sound of the wondrous Dharma and make offerings to all the tathāgatas, therefore he manifests dwelling in the royal palace; because he wishes within the palace to abide in a subtle and wondrous samādhi and to manifest everything from the accomplishing of buddhahood all the way to nirvāṇa, therefore he manifests dwelling in the royal palace; in order to follow along with and guard the dharma of the buddhas, therefore he manifests dwelling in the royal palace. These are the ten. After the bodhisattva of the final body has in this way manifested dwelling in the royal palace, only then does he leave home.

Gate 42. Manifesting the Leaving of Home: The Ten Reasons for Leaving Home

“Sons of the Buddha! Because of ten matters a bodhisattva-mahāsattva manifests the leaving of home. Which are the ten? Namely: in order to be weary of and to leave behind the dwelling at home, therefore he manifests the leaving of home; in order to make sentient beings who are attached to home forsake it, therefore he manifests the leaving of home; in order to follow along with faith and delight in the road of the noble ones, therefore he manifests the leaving of home; in order to proclaim and praise the merit of leaving home, therefore he manifests the leaving of home; in order to make manifest his forever leaving behind the view of the two extremes, therefore he manifests the leaving of home; in order to make sentient beings leave behind the joys of desire and the joys of self, therefore he manifests the leaving of home; in order first to make manifest the mark of coming forth from the three realms, therefore he manifests the leaving of home; in order to make manifest that he is master of himself and does not belong to another, therefore he manifests the leaving of home; in order to make manifest that he is about to obtain the dharma of a Tathāgata’s ten powers and fearlessnesses, therefore he manifests the leaving of home; because for the bodhisattva of the final body the dharma ought by rights to be thus, therefore he manifests the leaving of home. These are the ten. By this the bodhisattva tames sentient beings.

Gate 43. Manifesting the Practice of Austerities: The Ten Reasons for Cultivating Austerities

“Sons of the Buddha! For the sake of ten matters a bodhisattva-mahāsattva manifests the cultivating of austerities. Which are the ten? Namely: in order to bring to accomplishment sentient beings of mean understanding, therefore he manifests the practice of austerities; in order to pull out the wrong views of sentient beings, therefore he manifests the practice of austerities; in order to make sentient beings who do not believe in the recompense of deeds see the recompense of deeds, therefore he manifests the practice of austerities; because, in following along with the dharma of a defiled world, it ought by rights to be thus, therefore he manifests the practice of austerities; in order to make manifest that he is able to endure toil and hardship and diligently cultivates the Way, therefore he manifests the practice of austerities; in order to make sentient beings delight in seeking the Dharma, therefore he manifests the practice of austerities; for the sake of sentient beings who are attached to the joys of desire and the joys of self, therefore he manifests the practice of austerities; in order to make manifest that the bodhisattva’s setting going of practice is most excellent, and that all the way to the final birth he still does not forsake diligence and vigor, therefore he manifests the practice of austerities; in order to make sentient beings delight in the dharma of stillness and grow their roots of good, therefore he manifests the practice of austerities; because the faculties of the gods and the people of the world are not yet ripe, and he means to await the time and make them ripe, therefore he manifests the practice of austerities. These are the ten. With this skillful means the bodhisattva tames all sentient beings.

Gate 44. Going to the Place of the Way: The Ten Matters of Going to the Foot of the Tree of Awakening

“Sons of the Buddha! A bodhisattva-mahāsattva’s going to the place of the Way has ten kinds of matter. Which are the ten? Namely: when going to the place of the Way, he shines upon all the worlds; when going to the place of the Way, he shakes all the worlds; when going to the place of the Way, he manifests his body everywhere in all the worlds; when going to the place of the Way, he awakens all the bodhisattvas and all the sentient beings who practiced together with him in former ages; when going to the place of the Way, he manifests all the adornments of the place of the Way; when going to the place of the Way, in accordance with what the minds of sentient beings desire he manifests for them a body with bearing of all sorts and all the adornments of the tree of awakening; when going to the place of the Way, he sees present before him all the tathāgatas of the ten directions; when going to the place of the Way, at every raising and setting down of his foot he constantly enters samādhi, and in thought after thought accomplishes buddhahood with no gap between; when going to the place of the Way, all the kings among the gods, nāgas, yakṣas, gandharvas, asuras, garuḍas, kiṃnaras, mahoragas, Śakras, Brahmā kings, and the world-guardians do not know of one another, and yet each raises up all sorts of surpassing and wondrous offerings; when going to the place of the Way, with unobstructed wisdom he universally contemplates and sees all the buddhas, the tathāgatas, cultivating the practice of a bodhisattva and accomplishing perfect awakening in all the worlds. These are the ten. By this the bodhisattva teaches and transforms sentient beings.

Gate 45. Sitting at the Place of the Way: The Ten Matters of Sitting upon the Diamond Seat

“Sons of the Buddha! A bodhisattva-mahāsattva’s sitting at the place of the Way has ten kinds of matter. Which are the ten? Namely: when sitting at the place of the Way, he shakes all the worlds in all sorts of ways; when sitting at the place of the Way, he shines evenly upon all the worlds; when sitting at the place of the Way, he extinguishes all the sufferings of the evil destinies; when sitting at the place of the Way, he causes all the worlds to be made of adamant; when sitting at the place of the Way, he universally contemplates and sees the lion-seats of all the buddhas, the tathāgatas; when sitting at the place of the Way, his mind is like empty space, with nothing discriminated; when sitting at the place of the Way, in accordance with what is fitting for another he manifests a body with bearing; when sitting at the place of the Way, he abides securely in accordance with the adamantine samādhi; when sitting at the place of the Way, he receives the pure and wondrous place held by the spiritual power of all the tathāgatas; when sitting at the place of the Way, with the power of his own roots of good he is wholly able to aid all sentient beings. These are the ten.

Gate 46. The Unprecedented Matters of Sitting at the Place of the Way: Ten Rare Things That Never Were Before

“Sons of the Buddha! When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva sits at the place of the Way, there are ten kinds of rare and unprecedented matter. Which are the ten? Sons of the Buddha! When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva sits at the place of the Way, all the tathāgatas of the worlds of the ten directions all appear before him, and all raise their right hands and praise him, saying: ‘Excellent, excellent! Unsurpassed guide!’ This is the first unprecedented matter. When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva sits at the place of the Way, all the tathāgatas wholly guard him in their thought and give him majestic power: this is the second unprecedented matter. When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva sits at the place of the Way, the assemblies of bodhisattvas who practiced together with him in former ages all come and gather round him, and with all sorts of articles of adornment reverence and make offerings to him: this is the third unprecedented matter. When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva sits at the place of the Way, the grasses, trees, thickets, and forests of all the worlds and other things without feeling all bend their bodies and lower their shadows and turn toward the place of the Way: this is the fourth unprecedented matter. When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva sits at the place of the Way, he enters a samādhi named Contemplating the Dharma Realm, and the power of that samādhi is able to make all the practices of the bodhisattva wholly full and complete: this is the fifth unprecedented matter. When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva sits at the place of the Way, he obtains a dhāraṇī named Highest Treasury of the Ocean of Subtle Light Free of Defilement, and is able to receive the great cloud and Dharma rain of all the buddhas, the tathāgatas: this is the sixth unprecedented matter. When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva sits at the place of the Way, with the power of his majestic virtue he raises up surpassing and wondrous articles of offering, and throughout all the worlds makes offerings to the buddhas: this is the seventh unprecedented matter. When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva sits at the place of the Way, he abides in the most excellent wisdom, and wholly knows present before him the faculties and the movements of intent of all sentient beings: this is the eighth unprecedented matter. When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva sits at the place of the Way, he enters a samādhi named Good Awakening, and the power of that samādhi is able to make his body fill all the worlds of the three times to the ends of the realm of empty space: this is the ninth unprecedented matter. When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva sits at the place of the Way, he obtains the unobstructed great wisdom of the light free of defilement, and causes his deeds of body universally to enter the three times: this is the tenth unprecedented matter. Sons of the Buddha! These are the ten kinds of rare and unprecedented matter when a bodhisattva-mahāsattva sits at the place of the Way.

Gate 47. Manifesting the Subduing of Māra: The Ten Reasons for Subduing Māra

“Sons of the Buddha! When a bodhisattva-mahāsattva sits at the place of the Way, he contemplates ten kinds of sense and manifests the subduing of māra. Which are the ten? Namely: because the sentient beings of a turbid age delight in battle, in order to bring out the power of the majestic virtue of a bodhisattva, therefore he manifests the subduing of māra; because among the gods and the people of the world there are those who harbor doubt, in order to cut off their doubts, therefore he manifests the subduing of māra; in order to teach, transform, and tame the armies of the māras, therefore he manifests the subduing of māra; in order to make those among the gods and the people of the world who delight in battle-arrays all come and gather to look on, so that their minds are tamed, therefore he manifests the subduing of māra; in order to make manifest that of all the majestic power a bodhisattva has, there is none in the world who can match it, therefore he manifests the subduing of māra; because he wishes to set going the power of bravery of all sentient beings, therefore he manifests the subduing of māra; in order to pity the sentient beings of the last age, therefore he manifests the subduing of māra; because he wishes to make manifest that even up to the place of the Way there are still armies of māra that come to touch and distress him, and that only after this is the realm of māra passed beyond, therefore he manifests the subduing of māra; in order to make manifest that the working of the afflictions is weak and feeble while the power of the roots of good of great loving-kindness is strong, therefore he manifests the subduing of māra; because he wishes to follow along with the dharma practiced in a turbid and evil world, therefore he manifests the subduing of māra. These are the ten.

Gate 48. Accomplishing the Powers of a Tathāgata: The Turn from the Perfected Cause into the Fulfilled Fruit

“Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata. Which are the ten? Namely: because he passes beyond all the deeds of the hosts of māra and the afflictions, therefore he accomplishes the powers of a Tathāgata; because he is complete in all the practices of a bodhisattva and plays in all the gates of a bodhisattva’s samādhi, therefore he accomplishes the powers of a Tathāgata; because he is complete in all the vast meditative concentrations of a bodhisattva, therefore he accomplishes the powers of a Tathāgata; because he is full in all the white and pure dharmas that aid the path, therefore he accomplishes the powers of a Tathāgata; because he obtains the light of the wisdom of all dharmas and thinks and discriminates well, therefore he accomplishes the powers of a Tathāgata; because his body pervades all the worlds, therefore he accomplishes the powers of a Tathāgata; because the sounds of speech he sends forth are all of them equal to the minds of all sentient beings, therefore he accomplishes the powers of a Tathāgata; because he is able with spiritual power to sustain all things, therefore he accomplishes the powers of a Tathāgata; because he is equal to the deeds of body, speech, and mind of the buddhas of the three times without any difference, and within a single thought fully knows the dharmas of the three times, therefore he accomplishes the powers of a Tathāgata; because he obtains the samādhi of the wisdom of good awakening and is complete in the ten powers of a Tathāgata — namely, from the power of the knowledge of what is the case and what is not the case on to the power of the knowledge of the exhaustion of the contaminants — therefore he accomplishes the powers of a Tathāgata. These are the ten. If a bodhisattva is complete in these ten powers, then he is named the Tathāgata, the Worthy One, the Perfectly Awakened One.

Gate 49. Turning the Great Wheel of the Dharma: The Ten Matters of the Tathāgata’s Turning of the Wheel

“Sons of the Buddha! The turning of the great wheel of the Dharma by the Tathāgata, the Worthy One, the Perfectly Awakened One has ten kinds of matter. Which are the ten? First, being complete in the pure wisdom of the four fearlessnesses; second, bringing forth the four kinds of eloquence and sounds that accord; third, being well able to open up and expound the marks of the four truths of what is real; fourth, following along with the unobstructed liberation of the buddhas; fifth, being able to make the minds of sentient beings all give rise to pure faith; sixth, that all the words he speaks are not spent in vain, being able to pull out the poisoned arrows of the sufferings of sentient beings; seventh, being sustained by the power of the vow of great compassion; eighth, that whatever sound he sends forth pervades all the worlds of the ten directions; ninth, that through asaṃkhyeya kalpas he speaks the Dharma without cease; tenth, that whatever dharma he speaks is all able to set going the faculties, the powers, the way of awakening, meditative concentration, liberation, samādhi, and such dharmas. Sons of the Buddha! The turning of the wheel of the Dharma by the buddhas, the tathāgatas, has measureless kinds of matter such as these.

Gate 50. Sowing the White and Pure Dharmas: The Ten Reasons Why No Word of the Teaching Is Spent in Vain

“Sons of the Buddha! When the Tathāgata, the Worthy One, the Perfectly Awakened One turns the wheel of the Dharma, because of ten matters he sows the white and pure dharmas within the minds of sentient beings, and there is not one phrase spent in vain. Which are the ten? Namely: because of the power of his vow in the past; because he is sustained by great compassion; because he does not forsake sentient beings; because his wisdom is masterful, and he speaks the Dharma for them in accordance with what they delight in; because he surely meets their occasion and has never missed it; because he accords with what is fitting for them and has no false speech; because the wisdom that knows the three times understands well; because his body is the most excellent and there is none that can be his equal; because his speech is masterful and none can fathom it; because his wisdom is masterful, and whatever words he sends forth are able to make people awaken. These are the ten.

Gate 51. Manifesting Parinirvāṇa: The Ten Senses of Entering Extinction

“Sons of the Buddha! When the Tathāgata, the Worthy One, the Perfectly Awakened One has finished doing the work of a buddha, he contemplates ten kinds of sense and manifests parinirvāṇa. Which are the ten? Namely: in order to make manifest that all conditioned activities are indeed impermanent; in order to make manifest that all that is conditioned is not secure; in order to make manifest that the great nirvāṇa alone is the place of security, without dread; because the humans and gods delight in and are attached to the form-body, therefore making manifest for them that the form-body is an impermanent dharma, and causing them to vow to abide in the pure dharma-body; in order to make manifest that the power of impermanence cannot be turned back; in order to make manifest that all that is conditioned does not abide in accordance with the mind and is not master of itself; in order to make manifest that all the three kinds of existence are like an illusion and a transformation and are not firm; in order to make manifest that the nature of nirvāṇa is ultimately firm and cannot be destroyed; in order to make manifest that all dharmas are without arising and without being set going, and yet have the marks of gathering together and of scattering and breaking apart; Sons of the Buddha! When the buddhas, the world-honored ones, have finished doing the work of a buddha, have fulfilled what they vowed, have turned the wheel of the Dharma, have already taught and crossed over all who ought to be taught and crossed over, and when those bodhisattvas who ought to receive an honored title have also all been accomplished in receiving their predictions, then by the dharma it ought by rights to be thus that they enter the unchanging great parinirvāṇa. Sons of the Buddha! This is how the Tathāgata, the Worthy One, the Perfectly Awakened One contemplates ten senses and manifests parinirvāṇa.

義疏Exposition

這一段站在哪裡

普慧菩薩一口氣問了二百句,普賢一句一句答,每句答以十句;澄觀算作「二千普賢勝行」。這是最後一番,五十一門。前面五番答的是十信、十住、十行、十迴向、十地——但要先說清楚一件事:這些位名,經文自己一個字也沒有出。是古來諸德依別行本《度世經》的六番問答立了這個科,澄觀承接下來用它科這部經。所以「因圓果滿行」不是經的自稱,是坐標。讀的時候要能隨時把坐標拿掉,看見經文自己在說什麼。

那經文自己在說什麼?從「有十種觀察」開始,到「示般涅槃」結束。前面是一個修行人怎麼看、怎麼行、怎麼避障;後面是八相成道與佛的三件事——轉法輪、種白淨法、入涅槃。澄觀在這裡下了一個關鍵的判:五十一門並不是全講果,「成如來力」以下四門才真正明果滿,前面全是因圓。他自己也知道這個判和八相衝突——八相不是果嗎?他的解釋是:八相的前五件仍在因位,只因八相是一整組示現,所以一併收進果裡。這是一個「剋實而論」與「隨相而說」的分層,不是含糊。他的《演義鈔》還存了第二種算法:全品二百門中前一百九十六門屬因;也存了另一口徑:八相為果則果有十九門。前一種與『末四門』是同一界(全品二百門對本節五十一門而已),後一種與法藏『住兜率天下一百九十』同界;同一段文字二種口徑並存,這正是本品可開可合的家風。

第一門 觀察:看的是什麼,不是看得多遠

先問一句:修行人「看」,看的是什麼?十觀察給的答案很具體——業、趣、根、法、佛法、智慧、無生忍、不退地、灌頂地、善覺智三昧。澄觀把它分成三段:初二觀所化的對象,次四觀能化的法(他點名是理、果、教、行),後三觀位次。這裡有一個排誤:看業、看趣,聽起來像神通,經文卻立刻拆掉——「知諸趣觀察」下面接的是「不取眾生故」。看得見流轉,卻不因此坐實有一個實在的人在流轉。看根也是:「了達無根故」。所以這十觀察不是視力表,是看見而不落實的訓練。落到自己身上:判斷一個人的根器時,你是在看,還是已經替他定了性?定了性,就是「取」。

第二門 普觀察:從『看見』轉成『接住』

第一門是看,第二門為什麼還要看一次?澄觀說第一門是「解方便故、達通塞故」,第二門是「審慮周遍故」——一個是看得準,一個是看得全。而經文本身給了更硬的區分:這十句每一句後半都是動作。看見乞求的人,就滿他的願;看見犯戒的,就安置在淨戒中;看見害心的,就安置在忍力中。澄觀點出前六句正是以六度對治六蔽。所以「普觀察」不是觀照,是看見即接住。排一個誤:這不是要求你有能力解決一切,是要求「觀」不停在觀。看見懈怠的人而只是嘆一口氣,那還是第一門的事,不是第二門。

第三門 奮迅:威勢從哪裡來

十種奮迅前五個都是猛獸——牛王、象王、龍王、金翅鳥王、師子王,第六起轉成勇健、大智、陀羅尼、辯才,最後一個是如來奮迅。為什麼要先寄喻再約法?澄觀的解釋很簡潔:奮迅是「實德內充、威德外溢」,像師子王那樣,威勢不是擺出來的,是裡面滿了自然溢出來的。法藏說得幾乎一樣,也用「內充」「外溢」。這裡最要防的一個誤讀是把奮迅當作氣勢或者感染力。經文自己給了防線:象王的奮迅是「心善調柔」,不是威猛;龍王的奮迅落在降甘露雨。落到自己身上:講法而聽者動容,可能是辯才,未必是奮迅;奮迅的檢驗在「內充」二字——你講的那一句,自己住得住嗎?

第四門 師子吼:九句誓與一句兌現

師子吼是什麼?澄觀說:「既勇健無畏,則能決定宣唱。」奮迅是威勢,師子吼是把它說出口。十句裡前九句全是「我當」——我當成正等覺、我當令眾生得度、我當令三寶不斷。第十句忽然不再是誓,變成一段敘事:最後身菩薩震動佛土,天人來請,他觀了世間一句「一切眾生無如我者」,就在王宮誕生,行七步而唱「我於世間最勝第一」。經文給這一句的名字是「如說而作大師子吼」。九句是說,第十句是做。這裡要排一個誤:那句「最勝第一」不是自誇,經文下半句立刻補完——「我當永盡生死邊際」。最勝是就這件事說的。落地處:發願容易,願與行之間隔著的就是這第十句。

第五門 清淨施:十施為什麼都叫「清淨」

為什麼每一度都冠一個「清淨」?澄觀答得直接:「離蔽障故,不同世間施戒等故。」清淨不是形容詞,是揀別詞——揀掉世間的施。哪些是蔽?看經文自己給的理由句就知道:平等施是「不揀眾生」,不住施是「不求果報」,開捨施是「心不戀著」。每一句的清淨都落在一個具體的不。末一句三輪清淨最深:施者、受者、施物三邊都如虛空。這裡有個常見誤解——三輪清淨聽起來像是要修到『感覺不到自己在布施』。不是感覺的事,是觀察的事,經文用的字是「正念觀察」。落地:施完之後心裡那句『他該記得』,就是第五句「不求果報」還沒站住。

第六門 清淨戒:戒的十個面向

十戒能不能只記成『別做壞事』?不能。澄觀依三聚戒切它:前三句是律儀,第七與第十是攝眾生,其餘攝善。看經文最耐人尋味的是第七句「隱密護持清淨戒」,理由是「善拔犯戒眾生故」——為了救犯戒的人,自己的持戒要隱密不張揚。這一句把戒從自守推到護他。再看末二句:「遠離一切有見清淨戒,於戒無著故」——連對戒的執著都要離。排一個誤:這不是說戒可以放鬆,第六句剛剛才說「乃至微細罪生大怖畏」。細微罪都怕,同時對戒不執著,兩句是同一個人。落地:持戒而生出優越感,是第九句尚未做到。

第七門 清淨忍:忍不是壓住

十忍前三是被罵、被打、不起恚害,澄觀判為耐怨害忍——忍他人身語意三業的惱害。但十句往下走,忍的性質變了:第六是「遠離我慢」而「不輕未學」,第七是「殘毀不瞋」而「觀察如幻」,末一句直接落到「知一切法無生」。所以這十句是一條線:從忍得住,到看得破,到根本沒有可忍的。要排的誤是把忍讀成壓抑。經文防得很明白——第三句的理由是「其心不動故」,不是『其心強忍故』。落地:如果忍完之後很累,多半還在第一句;累是壓的代價,第七句那個「如幻」不需要力氣。

第八門 清淨精進:精進不等於忙

十精進怎麼分?澄觀說第二句與第十句是饒益有情,第五句是被甲,其餘攝善。經文自己給的骨架更清楚:前三是身、語、意三業精進,第四第五是心地的精進(正直心、增勝心),第六以下轉為對治與成滿。最要注意的是第九句「無來無去清淨精進」——精進到最後是「了相非相,無所著」。這裡排一個誤:精進不是把日程排滿。經文第六句給的檢驗是「無中息」,是不中斷,不是不休息。落地:問自己昨天的用功,是在攝取(第六句),還是只在移動。

第九門 清淨禪:定的前提是生活

十禪一開始講的不是坐姿,是出家、善友、住阿蘭若、離憒鬧——澄觀判前五為方便。要到第六句「心智寂滅」才是定本身,第七第八轉出慧與斷惑,第九第十是通明與遊戲。為什麼定要從這些外緣講起?因為定不是一件孤立的事,環境、同伴、生活形態都是它的前分。第八句尤其要看:「離於味著清淨禪,不捨欲界故」——不貪定的滋味,所以不急著捨掉欲界。排一個誤:耽味禪定在本段第二十三門會被列為「三昧魔」,可見貪定是被明白防的。落地:靜坐之外的十小時,決定了那一小時的品質。

第十門 清淨慧:三段慧

十慧澄觀分得極整齊:初三是解法,屬加行慧;次四是攝生,屬後得慧;後三是證理,屬正體慧。經文的次序正好對得上——先知因、知緣、知不斷不常,這是解;再觀眾生心行、廣大辯才、諸魔外道所不能知,這是用;最後見法身、見本性清淨、一念相應金剛智,這是證。這裡要排的誤是把慧當成聰明。第五句給的理由是「了知如幻」,第九句給的是「令得一切最勝智」——慧的方向始終朝外朝人,不朝自我證明。落地:讀懂了一段法而急著說給人聽,是後得慧的路;讀懂了而先拿它照自己一遍,才有正體慧的份。

第十一門 清淨慈:慈的三個層

四無量心從這裡開始。澄觀說六度多明自利、四等多約利他,並用三緣切這四門。慈的十句,他判前八是眾生緣,第九第十文相自顯——「法緣清淨慈,證於如如真實法故」「無緣清淨慈,入於菩薩離生性故」。什麼叫三緣?緣眾生而起的慈,緣法而起的慈,無所緣而起的慈。前者最親切,後者最徹底。這裡排一個誤:無緣慈不是冷淡。經文第八句剛說「充滿虛空清淨慈,救護眾生無處不至」,第十句才轉入無緣——是先滿了才空的,不是空了就不管。落地:對特定的人起不了慈,多半要回到第一句「等心」——先看有沒有在揀擇。

第十二門 清淨悲:悲的兩個結穴

十悲澄觀判前七眾生緣、第八法緣、後二無緣,並替後二句點出所以然:第九句是「傷其真隱故為顯」,第十句是「念彼不知故令悟」。看經文,這兩句確實跟前八句寫法不同——前八句都是短句,這兩句各是一段完整的觀察:知一切法本性清淨、只因客塵而受苦,於是起悲,名為「本性清淨」;知一切法如空中鳥迹、眾生癡翳照不見,於是起悲,名為「真實智」。悲到這裡不再是不忍見人受苦,是不忍見人本來無事而自以為有事。排一個誤:第二句「代一切眾生受苦,不以為勞」不是說真能代受,理由句給的是「不以為勞」,講的是心量。落地:對人的可憐若帶著俯視,還沒到第六句「不著己樂」。

第十三門 清淨喜:喜從哪裡來

喜是十句裡最容易誤讀的一門,因為它像情緒。澄觀判初四眾生緣、次三法緣、後三無緣。看經文,第一句就把喜的來源定了——「發菩提心清淨喜」,喜的頭一個由來是自己發了心。往下:捨盡所有而喜、不嫌破戒眾生而喜、能忍造惡眾生而喜、捨身求法不悔而喜。每一句的喜都掛在一個不容易的行為上。排一個誤:喜不是順境的產物。第四句明明是「能忍受造惡眾生」,這是逆境。落地:檢查自己上一次真正的歡喜,是因為得到,還是因為給出去了、忍下來了、發了心。

第十四門 清淨捨:兩種等待

捨這一門有個文本上的特別處,澄觀已經標出來:標題說十種,文裡實列十一句,晉本把前二句併為一句才是十。這種開合古德早已誌錄,不必看成錯。內容上,最深的是第九、第十兩句——有的眾生根熟了卻還不能知最上法,等;有的眾生是往昔已教化過、要到佛地才能調伏的,也等。然後第十一句總收:對這兩種人「無高無下,無取無捨」。捨的極致不是放棄,是等得起。排一個誤:捨不是不管。第四句就說了「於法器眾生待時而化,於無法器亦不生嫌」——不化度,但不生嫌。落地:對一個勸不動的人,你的心是等,還是已經斷了。

第十五門 義:所詮之義

從這一門起轉入方便造修,澄觀判前五門明自分行、後三門明勝進行。義與法一對,怎麼分?澄觀說:「若以能詮為法,則以所詮為義。」但他隨即說本段不取能詮為法。十義的第一句最見用心——多聞義,理由是「堅固修行故」,澄觀點出:「一以修行為多聞之義,意在於修不在聞故。」多聞的義竟然是修,不是聞。排一個誤:這不是貶低聞。第二句「法義,善巧思擇故」還在思擇之列。是說多聞這件事的意義落在修,不落在聞的數量。落地:一年讀了多少法,換一個問法——因為讀而改了什麼。

第十六門 法:能持之法

法是什麼?澄觀給了兩義:「一持自性、二軌生物解」——一是自己撐得住,二是能讓人依它生解。他還逐句配:本段前七句通二義、第八第九唯自性、末一唯軌生。末一句是全門的重點——「捨一切烏波提涅槃法」。烏波提,澄觀釋為「有苦」,指二乘的涅槃;他引《佛性論》說二乘無餘尚有三種殘餘,所以不是真無餘。所以這一句是要人捨掉那個看似究竟的休息處,理由句給得很正面:「能生一切菩薩行,修習不斷故。」排一個誤:這不是貶二乘,是說那不是終點。落地:修行中出現的任何一種『終於安穩了』的感覺,都值得用這一句照一照。

第十七門 福德助道具:福是工具

助道具是什麼?澄觀說得乾脆:「福智即道,成福智緣,名助道具。」成就福智的那些條件,就叫助道具。十句裡最值得停的是第一句與第十句。第一句:勸眾生發菩提心是福德助道具,理由「不斷三寶種故」——原來勸人發心本身就是最大的福。第十句是一整段:阿僧祇劫積集的善根,取證菩提本已如在掌中,卻全部捨給眾生,心無憂惱也無悔恨。排一個誤:這不是說功德可以轉讓給誰,經文的落點在「其心廣大等虛空界」,是心量。落地:做過的好事若還記在自己名下,第十句就還沒開始。

第十八門 智慧助道具:十層階梯

這一門是全段較長的一門,十句每句都是一段。澄觀替前三句點名:「一外近善緣、二內調法器、三念慧安處。」看得出這十句是一條由外而內的階梯:親近善知識、去憍慢、念慧不散、樂法樂義、六度四梵住、常樂出離、觀五蘊如幻、聞二無我而深信、止觀雙運、見緣起而五重清淨。第七句的一串譬喻最有名——如幻、如焰、如水中月、如夢、如影、如響、如像、如空中畫、如旋火輪、如虹霓色、如日月光。澄觀釋「界如毒蛇」時引古說以四大為毒蛇,釋「處如空聚」說是「中無人故」。排一個誤:這一串不是文學修辭,第七句自己給的結論是「知一切法無生無滅」。落地:這十句可以當作一份次第自檢表,逐條問『我在第幾句』。

第三句還有一組被壓縮的名相值得單獨拆開。經文說「念慧隨覺未曾散亂,慚愧柔和,心安不動」之後,接著疊了三個「常」——「常憶六念,常行六敬,常隨順住六堅固法」。澄觀替這三組各點一個功能字:「六念自持、六和眾法」,六敬即六和,是眾中相處之法;至於六堅,他說是「六堅順位」,並引《本業》上卷以三賢、十聖、等妙二覺配為六位,即「信堅、法堅、修堅、德堅、項堅、覺堅」,又說此六亦名六忍、六慧、六觀、六性,末後斷云「一切諸佛無不入此故」。六念與六敬二組,澄觀注「並見上文」,回指前文所釋:六念即念佛、念法、念僧、念戒、念捨、念天,疏於前門七念下說「加念眾生為大悲故」,可知六念加念眾生即成七念;六敬即六和,疏釋六和為「身和同集、口和無諍、意和無違、見和同解、戒和同奉、利和同均」,三業與戒、見、利六者皆和。要緊的是這三個「常」何以疊在一起:六念是自己扶住自己,六敬是在眾人裡不生磨擦,六堅是一路走上去而不退轉——向內、向人、向前三個方向,缺一個,另兩個就撐不久。排一個誤:六堅不是六種脾氣硬,澄觀配的是位次,堅是『在那個位子上站得住』。落地:這一句可以逐日問三遍——今日念頭有沒有處可安、與人有沒有起爭、走的路有沒有退。

第十九門 明足:智圓與進趣

明足是什麼?澄觀拆兩個字。明是「惑闇斯亡、智解斯顯」;足有二義,「一智圓備故;二有進趣故」,並說這就是十號中「明行足」的意思,果上叫圓足,因上叫脚足。所以明足既是圓滿,又是還在走。十句前七約行、後三別舉三明——天眼、宿住、漏盡。排一個誤:三明列在這裡不是要人求神通。看理由句:天眼智是「普觀察」,宿住念是「知前際清淨」,漏盡通是「斷眾生諸漏」——三個都朝向眾生。落地:任何一種能力,檢驗它的方式是問它朝哪個方向用。

第二十門 求法:十種心,一條界線

求法要怎麼求?十句每一句都是一組對照:直心求法對「無有諂誑」,精進求法對「遠離懈慢」,一向求法對「不惜身命」。澄觀逐句給了極簡的標籤——始心唯直、中後無懈、內不顧身、外亡名利、雙圓二利、得意亡言、果不近求、因酬所為、普決疑惑、唯滿佛乘。然後他下了一句斷語:「離此十求皆邪求也。」這句很重。排一個誤:邪求不是指求邪法,是指用這十種以外的動機求正法。第六句給的界線最細——「為入智慧求法,不樂文字故」。落地:問自己求法的當下,心裡有沒有一個『這將來派得上用場』的算盤。

第二十一門 明了法:十類人各自的那一段

這一門忽然把凡夫、隨信行、隨法行、第八人、四果、辟支佛、菩薩十類人排了一遍。澄觀說這是「總以普賢勝智了知三乘凡聖差別」。他還替難詞作了注:第八人「即初果向」,並引《俱舍》之疏說八忍之中從後數為第八。這一門的用意在哪裡?在於菩薩要能認得出每一類人現在明了到哪裡。排一個誤:這不是位次的自我對號。經文列的是『他們的明了法』,是化他的所知,不是自證的階梯。落地:跟人談法之前,先判斷他站在哪一句上——講早了無用,講晚了也無用。

第二十二門 修行法:把前面所知變成日課

前一門是明了,這一門是修行。澄觀點得很直:「三修行法者,如說修行方得佛法故。」十句都是可執行的:恭敬善知識、常為諸天所覺悟、於佛所常懷慚愧、哀愍眾生不捨生死、事必究竟心無變動。第二句澄觀還作了一個讀法的校正——「常為諸天者,為字去聲」,是為諸天而覺悟之——菩薩覺悟諸天,不令著樂(法藏語);他引晉本「覺悟諸天」為證。底本字面「常為諸天之所覺悟」,白話依字面譯作被諸天所覺悟,澄觀之讀誌於此。排一個誤:第五句「事必究竟心無變動」不是固執,前後兩句一個講哀愍眾生、一個講隨學菩薩眾,是在關係裡的不變動。落地:這十句最像日課,可以真的逐條對一週。

第二十三門 魔:魔在取,不在物

這一門最容易讀岔。十魔裡有善根魔、三昧魔、善知識魔、菩提法智魔——善根怎麼會是魔?澄觀的處理是全段最鋒利的一節。他先自設一問:蘊魔,身是道器、體與佛同,怎麼就是魔?答:「蘊魔之名特由取著,下九例爾。」魔的名字不落在那個東西上,落在取。他再推一步:「是知以心分別萬法皆魔,何但此十。」還說四魔是就體明,十魔多約執取,所以數目不同。並下一句轉語:一切皆佛,哪有捨魔界求佛界的道理。排一個誤:這不是說善根三昧不必修,經文每一句的理由都指著執取——善根魔是「恒執取故」,三昧魔是「久耽味故」。落地:檢查你最珍視的那一項修行成果,你是在用它,還是在守它。

第二十四門 魔業:十件會把善行做壞的事

魔是體,魔業是事。澄觀說:「行此十事皆能訛善亦招天魔,故為其業。」十句都極具體:忘失菩提心而修善根、惡心布施、瞋心持戒、對深法慳吝、有堪化者不說、得供養而為非法器強說、誹謗正法、學世論而隱覆深法、只親近已解脫的人。第一句是總病——善事還在做,發心掉了。這一門讀完最好停一下,澄觀自己也停了,他寫了一句:「然觀此文,難免魔業,願諸後學審此省躬。」排一個誤:這不是要人恐懼,是要人核對。落地:把這十句當一份年度檢查,多半條條都沾一點——沾到才有得改。

第二十五門 捨離魔業:一一敵對

這一門與前門正對。澄觀說「對障修治,故云捨離」,並指出:「然此十句,敵對反前,但略而不次耳。」他還逐一標了對應——一反第五、二反第二、三反第七、四反第一、五反第四、六反第八、七反第三、八反第九、九反第十、十反第六。為什麼不照次序?他給了兩個理由:一是要顯任隨一善總反前十,二是可以多善共反一過,令人不作定執。排一個誤:不要把它讀成十對十的機械配方。落地:真要用,就取第四句「未曾忘失一切智心」——因為前門的第一句是總病,這一句是總藥。

第二十六門 見佛:十種佛,十種見

障離了,果就現。澄觀判這兩門是「由障離故,果現行成」。這一門的體例很特別,十句都是『某某佛,某某見』——成正覺佛無著見、願佛出生見、業報佛深信見、住持佛隨順見、涅槃佛深入見、法界佛普至見、心佛安住見、三昧佛無量無依見、本性佛明了見、隨樂佛普受見。佛有十種,見也有十種,而且一一相配——但相配之法要看清楚。澄觀特別提醒:「然此中明見,皆稱彼佛而見。」見之名是稱著所見之佛立的,不是說菩薩自己修出這麼一種見法。他舉第一句作證:「如云無著,自屬正覺,非謂菩薩於彼不著。若菩薩於此不著,下九豈當著耶?」無著是正覺佛自身的無著,若解作菩薩不著於佛,那底下九句豈不是要說菩薩著於那九佛?願佛之所以說出生見,是因為「乘此願能生一切德故」;業報佛之所以說深信見,是因為「報即相好莊嚴身業」而「深信為首」——名都從彼佛之德上來。《演義鈔》更遮一救:或謂半就能見(如無著)、半就所見(如出生)豈不亦通?澄觀遮之曰「不得半就能所」,以其令人致惑、取解無由、十種見義成雜亂故——十句一律就所見之佛立名。

第二十七門 佛業:佛在做的十件事

見佛之後說佛業。十句從最平常的開始——隨時開導、夢中令見、說未聞經、為悔纏者說出離法——一直到最後一句,是一整段:首組了達本寂而勤修,加十個『雖…而…』,合十一組——雖知本來寂滅而勤修福智,雖知無造作而不捨自相,雖離貪欲而常瞻佛身,雖知國土如空而常樂莊嚴,雖觀無人無我而教化不疲,雖已成一切智智而修行不息,雖現入涅槃而處處受生。經文自己給這一句命了名:「權實雙行法」。澄觀釋此云「有十種佛業,即是成行。前見佛體,今辨佛因。又行順佛行,故名佛業」——前一門說佛之體,這一門說佛之因,而所以名為佛業,是因為行順著佛的行。排一個誤:這十個轉折不是矛盾修辭,前半句是實、後半句是權,同時成立才叫雙行。落地:修行中每一次覺得『既然本來如此,何必還做』,就是把權那一半丟了。

其餘四組亦各有其權實。第一組是「雖知不由他悟入於法而種種方便求一切智」——不由他悟,是說法非從他人處得;而下半句偏偏是「種種方便求一切智」,兩邊看似打架:既然不靠他人,何以還要遍求?澄觀判這一段十一句,「初一約苦、次一約集、次八約道、後一約滅」,此句正在「約道」之列——不由他悟說的是所悟之體不假外求,求一切智說的是能悟之道非坐待自來。第二組是「雖於法界本來不動而以神通智力現眾變化」,法藏牒經作「五『諸通』下具果不捨因」:不動是果上之體,神通變化是因中之行,證了體不等於歇了行。第三組是「雖知諸法不可言說而轉淨法輪令眾心喜」——知不可說,正是能說的條件;說而不執言,才是「淨」法輪,落點在「令眾心喜」,不在說得多。第四組是「雖能示現諸佛神力而不厭捨菩薩之身」,法藏作「六『示現』下示圓不捨分」:示現的是圓滿之力,不捨的是還在因位的那個身分——這一句與最末一句「七『現大』下現寂不礙生」正好一對,一個不捨菩薩身,一個涅槃而處處受生。排一個誤:這四組不是四種例外,澄觀給全段定的體是「初一總明無作四諦」,十一組都在四諦的架上,只是這幾組落在道諦。落地:四組各對一問——我求法是不是等著它自己來、我證了一分是不是就停手、我說法是不是為了說得漂亮、我有了一點力量是不是就不肯再作學人。

第二十八門 慢業:慢的十種長相

慢不是一種情緒,是十種行為。經文列得毫不留情:對師僧父母不恭敬、對得法的法師起高慢、聽到妙法不肯讚美、好起過慢、好起過過慢、因嫌人而連法一起嫌、自求高座不肯承事、見有德人皺眉窺過、不肯向智者請問、被慢心覆蓋以致新善不起舊善消滅。第六句最值得停——明知「是法、是律、是真實、是佛語」,卻因為嫌那個人而連法一起謗。澄觀科此門所屬云「明離障加持行。中二:初二門內成離障行」,又指出十慢的通相在「皆於尊境不肯禮敬故」——十句長相各別,病根同在一處。排一個誤:慢的核心不是自大,是用人的高下代替法的真假。落地:最近有沒有一段話,因為說的人你不喜歡,你就沒有聽進去。

第二十九門 智業:離慢之後長出來的

這一門的起句不是「佛子」,是接著上一門說的:「若諸菩薩離此慢業,則得十種智業。」慢與智是同一件事的兩面——慢在,智不生。十智業裡有幾句與前門直接對稱:前門不肯親近智者,這裡是「近善知識恭敬供養,其心尊重終無厭怠」;前門對法師起高慢,這裡是「於諸菩薩起如來想」「於修行者生諸佛想」。第八句最見溫度——對諸波羅蜜起慈母想,對善巧方便起慈父想。澄觀釋此云「有十種智業,顯對治行」——這一門不是另起一組功德,是前一門的對治。排一個誤:這不是修辭的親切,是把法當作養育自己的東西看,慢就無處落腳。落地:你對法的態度,比較像對工具,還是像對父母。

第三十門 魔所攝持:被把持的十個徵狀

澄觀判離障十門為前五明離障成行、後五明離障加持。從這一門起是加持的一組。十句全是狀態不是行為:懈怠、志樂狹劣、於少行生足、受一非餘、不發大願、樂處寂滅斷除煩惱、永斷生死、捨菩薩行、不化眾生、疑謗正法。最刺眼的是中間三句——樂處寂滅、永斷生死,這聽起來完全像正修行,卻列在魔所攝持。澄觀釋此門云「今初,即怨障加持」——所以這十句列的是被怨障持住的樣子,不是罪狀。為什麼?排這個誤要看整組的方向:這一段講的是菩薩,菩薩若停在自了,就是被把持。落地:一個修行人最危險的時刻,往往不是懈怠,是『我已經夠了』。

第三十一門 佛所攝持:棄捨之後

這一門與前門一樣是接著說的:「若諸菩薩能棄捨此魔所攝持,則得十種佛所攝持。」十句一一翻轉:初發心、生生持心不忘、覺魔事而遠離、聞波羅蜜如說修行、知生死苦而不厭惡、觀甚深法得無量果、為眾生說二乘法而不證取、樂觀無為而不住其中、至無生處而現受生、雖證一切智而起菩薩行不斷菩薩種。看得出來每一句都是同一個結構:進得去,不停在裡面。澄觀釋此云「明能治行。由離於邪,自然合正」——不是先取佛持,是邪一離開,正就自然合上。排一個誤:「不證取」不是不能證,是不取。落地:你會的那一套,能不能講給只需要那一套的人聽,而自己不落回去。

第三十二門 法所攝持:被法把持的十處

前二門講被魔持、被佛持,這一門講被法持。十句是一份極正統的法目:三法印(一切行無常、苦、無我)、寂滅涅槃、緣起、十二支的順逆生滅、三解脫門出生聲聞乘、無諍法出生獨覺乘、六度四攝出生大乘、一切世是佛智境界、斷念捨取離前後際隨順涅槃。這是全段少見的、把三乘之所以為三乘一次講齊的地方。澄觀把這十句的次第分得很細:「前四即四法印、次二總別緣生、次二大小、後二智斷」。排一個誤:把三乘並列不是等量齊觀,第九句「一切剎、一切法、一切眾生、一切世是佛智境界」已經把量拉開了。落地:知道別人走的那條路是怎麼成立的,才可能不輕慢它,也不誤入它。

第三十三門 住兜率天所作業:八相的第一相

從這一門起進入八相。澄觀的判:這十九門明現果圓滿行,屬妙覺位;但若剋實而論,八相前五仍屬因位,只因八相都是示現才通入果中。第一相在兜率天,十件事全是說法與示現:為欲界天說厭離、為色界天說禪與如實智、入光明莊嚴三昧放光說法、與十方兜率菩薩互見論法、為來集菩薩隨地說法、以柔軟粗獷二語令魔波旬不得其便、出大音聲集天眾示希有事、不捨本處而遍詣十方佛所受灌頂、興供養具遍法界供佛、出如幻如影法門隨心令喜。澄觀釋此云「下十九門,明果用圓滿行」。排一個誤:兜率天不是休息站。落地:這十件事沒有一件是為自己,成道之前的那一段,已經全在利他。

第三十四門 下生現十事:十道光,十件事

這一門的體例整齊到像儀軌:十事中八事從身上某一處放一道光(第七自寶藏殿、第八自宮殿樓閣放光),光有名字,照到某一類眾生,成就某一件事。足下放安樂莊嚴光照惡趣、眉間白毫放覺悟光照同行菩薩、右掌放清淨境界光遷置辟支佛與諸魔外道、兩膝放清淨莊嚴光遍照諸天宮殿、心藏放無能勝幢光召金剛力士、毛孔放分別眾生光、寶藏殿放善住觀察光照當生王宮、宮殿樓閣放一切宮殿清淨莊嚴光照母腹、兩足下放善住光延諸天壽命、隨好中放眼莊嚴光現一生八相。澄觀於此段分科云「長分為十:初一門住天、次一門示沒、三一門入胎、四一門住胎、五三門初生」——這一門正當「示沒」一節。排一個誤:光不是背景效果,每一道光都有一件明確的工作。落地:第十道光最堪玩味——它讓人同時看見住胎、初生、出家、成道、降魔、轉法輪、入涅槃,一生的次第在一光中並現。

第三十五門 處胎十事:為什麼佛要住胎

這一門是全段少數直接回答『為什麼』的門。第一個理由就很直接:為了成就小心劣解的眾生,不讓他們以為這位菩薩是自然化生、智慧善根不是修來的。所以住胎是一份證明——這條路是走出來的。其餘九件:成熟父母眷屬善根、入胎住胎正念不亂、在胎中常演說法、在胎中集大眾會、示現人間最勝受生、三千世界眾生如明鏡見面像、他方最後生菩薩來會說廣大智慧藏、入離垢藏三昧於胎中現大宮殿、興供養具供養十方佛。澄觀讀到這裡也先把問題問出來:「如有問言:於四生中化生為上,佛為最勝,何故胎生?」排一個誤:胎不是限制。經文說胎中有廣大樓閣、大摩尼寶莊嚴,還有十方菩薩來會。落地:受限的處境不必然縮小所作。

第三十六門 甚微細趣:一切都在胎裡

前一門說胎中能作事,這一門把它推到底:在母胎中示現初發菩提心乃至灌頂地、示現住兜率天、示現初生、童子地、處王宮、出家、苦行成正覺、轉法輪、般涅槃,最後一句是「示現大微細」——一切菩薩行、一切如來自在神力的無量差別門。整整一生的次第,全部在胎中同時現。李通玄正是據此讀八相為「總一時」,他說如來出世始終不離剎那際,處胎、住兜率、初生、出家、成道、轉法輪、入涅槃總在一時。澄觀說「並一相中同時齊現」,法藏說「並在胎內同時齊現」——三家所言同:科判有先後,所現同時。澄觀釋此云「即明住胎十事。初一通現地位,次八明現七相」,又釋門名云「深密難知,故名微細」。排一個誤:不要把它讀成神通展示,經文給的名字是「趣」,是趣入之處。

第三十七門 十種生:出生時的十件事

十種生前九句都是「…生」:遠離愚癡正念正知生、放光明網普照生、住最後有更不受後身生、不生不起生、知三界如幻生、於十方普現身生、證一切智智身生、放佛光普覺眾生身生、入大智觀察三昧身生。第四句最要緊——「不生不起生」。生而不生,這一句把前後八句全部收住。第十句轉為敘事:菩薩生時震動一切佛剎、解脫一切眾生、除滅一切惡道、映蔽一切諸魔、無量菩薩皆來集會。澄觀釋此云「明初生相。今初正辨,即右脇生時」——這一門說的是生時之相。排一個誤:這一門不是描寫誕生的祥瑞,經文結句給了目的——「為調伏眾生故,如是示現」。落地:所有可見的相,都是為看的人設的。

第三十八門 微笑心自誓:笑之前的十個念

這一門很特別,它把一個表情拆成十個念頭。每一念之後都是同一句:「熙怡微笑心自誓。」十念是:世間沒在欲泥而除我一人無能免濟、世間為煩惱所盲而唯我具足智慧、憑此假名身當得如來法身、遍觀梵天乃至大自在天皆自謂有大智力、眾生久種善根今皆退沒、種子雖少獲果甚多、眾生蒙佛所教必得利益、過去同行菩薩染著餘事不得佛法功德、過去同會諸天人至今猶在凡夫地而不疲厭、為一切如來光明所觸倍加欣慰。澄觀替這一門定了時位:「二現微笑,在行七步時故」——笑不在別處,正在七步之時。排一個誤:前二念聽起來像自負,但看第八第九念——同行的人落後了、同會的人還在原處——這笑裡有悲。落地:慈悲若沒有一點欣悅,會撐不住;欣悅若沒有一點悲,會變成傲。

第三十九門 行七步:七步的十層意思

為什麼是七步?經文給了十個理由:現菩薩力、現施七財、滿地神願、現超三界相、現最勝行超過象王牛王師子王行、現金剛地相、現欲與眾生勇猛力、現修行七覺寶、現所得法不由他教、現於世間最勝無比。其中兩個直接扣住「七」——七聖財與七覺支。澄觀釋此云「謂初生在地,十方各行七步,顯自在希奇故」。排一個誤:這一門不是在解釋一個歷史細節。經文的結句仍是「為調伏眾生故,如是示現」——七步是一句給人看的法。落地:這十句裡最能落到自己的是第九句「所得法不由他教」——你所依的那一分見地,是聽來的,還是走出來的。

第四十門 處童子地:為什麼要有童年

十件事中前三件都是世間技藝:文字算計圖書印璽、象馬車乘弧矢劍戟、文筆談論博弈嬉戲。菩薩為什麼要通達這些?經文用的字是「為現通達」——是要顯示他通達,不是他需要學。第四件轉入「遠離身、語、意業諸過失」,第五件是入定住涅槃門周遍十方,往後是威力色相超過諸天、令耽欲樂者歡喜樂法、尊重正法勤供養佛、得佛加被蒙法光明。澄觀釋此云「童子已在王宮,但此門明幼懷德藝,顯是超絕」——童子地與下一門同在王宮,分別在這一門說的是幼年所懷之德藝。排一個誤:世間技藝列在這裡不是點綴,第八句給了用處——「為令耽著欲樂眾生歡喜樂法」。落地:你會的那些世間本事,是障礙,還是接引的入口,取決於用它做什麼。

第四十一門 現處王宮:住在最不像修行的地方

十個理由裡有一句最直白:「順五濁世眾生心故。」還有一句最深:「為現菩薩大威德力能於深宮入三昧故。」王宮是欲樂最盛之處,正因為如此,能在其中入三昧才顯出力量。其餘八句:令宿世同行眾生善根成熟、顯示菩薩善根力、示現菩薩大威德樂具、令宿世同願眾生滿意、令父母親戚眷屬滿願、以妓樂出妙法音供養如來、於宮內住微妙三昧而始從成佛乃至涅槃皆示現、隨順守護諸佛法。澄觀科此二門云「明在家同俗行,並處王宮相」——處童子地與處王宮同是在家同俗之行。排一個誤:處王宮不是妥協的階段。落地:能不能修行,與環境是不是清淨,關係比想像中小;經文的證據是——他在那裡入了三昧。

第四十二門 示現出家:出家的十個理由

上一門住宮,這一門出家,經文自己作了銜接:最後身菩薩這樣示現處王宮以後,然後才出家。十個理由:厭居家、令著家眾生捨離、隨順信樂聖人道、宣揚讚歎出家功德、顯永離二邊見、令眾生離欲樂我樂、先現出三界相、現自在不屬他、顯當得如來十力無畏法、最後菩薩法應爾。第十句最有意思——因為法本來如此。澄觀科此二門云「明捨家期道行。初明出家、後顯修行」——出家與苦行是一組,前明捨、後明修。排一個誤:這十句中沒有一句是『因為在家不能修』。真正的重量在第五句「顯永離二邊見」與第八句「現自在不屬他」。落地:出家與否是一件事,離二邊見與不屬他,是每個人都要做的那件事。

第四十三門 示行苦行:苦行是說給誰看的

苦行的十個理由,沒有一個是『因為苦行有效』。它們是:成就劣解眾生、拔邪見眾生、令不信業報者見業報、隨順雜染世界法應爾、示能忍劬勞勤修道、令眾生樂求法、為著欲樂我樂眾生、顯菩薩起行殊勝乃至最後生猶不捨精進、令眾生樂寂靜法增長善根、待諸天世人諸根成熟。澄觀逐句給了更短的標籤——策懈怠、令知為法忘飢、示著樂非道、始末精勤;末句他說「苦行待機者,顯悲深故」。他還校出一處異文:晉本此處作「欲令未來眾生發精進故」,並說今本精進之言合在前句,缺了一句。排一個誤:苦行在這裡是教學手段,不是道本身。落地:你身上那些苦修的習慣,是為了誰。

第四十四門 詣道場:走向那棵樹

澄觀說詣道場以下五門是「道成證入行」,並替這一門點了三個所以然:顯捨邪趣正、因圓趣果、行行後邊。十件事都發生在「詣道場時」:照耀一切世界、震動一切世界、於一切世界普現其身、覺悟一切菩薩及宿世同行眾生、示現道場一切莊嚴、隨眾生心欲而現身威儀及菩提樹莊嚴、現見十方一切如來、舉足下足常入三昧念念成佛無有超隔、天龍八部諸王各不相知而興種種供養、以無礙智普觀一切如來修菩薩行成正覺。排一個誤:最要看的是第八句——念念成佛,不是走到了才成。落地:路與果不是兩段,走的每一步都在成。

第四十五門 坐道場:坐下之後

澄觀分這一門:初四是嚴處,次三是三業現相,後三成德——「一滿自能證,明智顯惑亡;二受佛所處,將契同法界;三大悲同體,故能遍加。」十件事:種種震動一切世界、平等照耀一切世界、除滅諸惡趣苦、令一切世界金剛所成、普觀一切如來師子之座、心如虛空無所分別、隨其所應現身威儀、隨順安住金剛三昧、受一切如來神力所持清淨妙處、自善根力悉能加被一切眾生。第五句澄觀有一條校語:晉本作「觀一切佛師子之吼」,座與吼一字之異。排一個誤:第六句「心如虛空,無所分別」與前四句的震動照耀不衝突——外相動而心不分別,正是這一門的骨。

第四十六門 坐道場未曾有事:外感的十件奇特

澄觀說這一門是「明外感希奇,大果先兆故」——前四事是外境對他的回應,後六事則是菩薩自己入定、得陀羅尼、興供、住智之所作。十件:十方如來現前舉右手稱讚無上導師、一切如來護念與其威力、宿世同行菩薩來圍繞供養、草木叢林等無情物曲身低影歸向道場、入觀察法界三昧令一切行圓滿、得最上離垢妙光海藏陀羅尼、興上妙供具遍供諸佛、住最勝智了知一切眾生根意、入善覺三昧令身充滿三世虛空、得離垢光明無礙大智令身業普入三世。第一句要留意說者的層次——那句稱讚是普賢轉述十方諸佛之語,不是本會的如來在說話。排一個誤:無情物曲身低影不是神話點綴,它與前面草木同一法界的義理是同一路。

第四十七門 示現降魔:為什麼要「示現」

這一門每一句都用「示現」二字,澄觀特別解釋了為什麼:因為久已降伏了,因為魔王多是大菩薩,因為沒有惡魔能惱佛。他還打了個比方:如同野干,怎麼能在師子面前振威勢。所以降魔是演給人看的。十個理由:濁世眾生樂鬪戰而顯威德、斷諸天世人之疑、教化調伏諸魔軍、令樂軍陣者聚觀而心調伏、顯威力世無能敵、發起眾生勇猛力、哀愍末世眾生、顯乃至道場猶有魔軍此後乃超魔境界、顯煩惱業用羸劣而大慈善根勢強、隨順濁惡世界所行法。排一個誤:第八句最要緊——直到道場都還有魔來,這不是失敗,這是給後人的訊息。落地:修到最後仍有干擾,是常態,不是退步。

第四十八門 成如來力:門檻在這一句

這是全段的轉折點。澄觀在此判:從這一門起才真正是果滿,前面全是因圓。他說這一門「即正覺現前」,並用三道來排前後——前面兩門(未曾有事、降魔)當無間道,這一門當解脫道,更前的兩門(詣道場、坐道場)是方便道。十句他也科了:初一障無不寂、次二因無不圓、次二果無不滿、次三德無不普、後二佛無不同,所以結名如來。經文的結句正好對上:「若諸菩薩具此十力,則名:如來、應、正等覺。」排一個誤:這句「則名」是普賢下的結論,不是如來自稱。落地:因與果之間沒有跳躍,十句每一句都掛著一個「故」字——都是有來由的。

第四十九門 轉大法輪:輪與轉

澄觀先釋名:「流演圓通目之為輪,自我之彼名之為轉。」輪是法的圓通流演,轉是從我到彼。接著他立了一個量:小乘以眼智明覺四行繫於四諦,本經顯無盡十行,應繫十諦而成百行。這是華嚴的算法落在轉法輪上。十事經文用序數列出:四無畏智、四辯隨順音聲、開闡四真諦相、隨順諸佛無礙解脫、令眾生心皆淨信、言說不唐捐能拔苦毒箭、大悲願力所加持、音聲普遍十方、阿僧祇劫說法不斷、隨所說法皆能生起根力覺道禪定解脫三昧。澄觀科為:初二能轉備圓、次二所轉深妙、次二生信拔苦、次二因深量廣、後二時遠益高。排一個誤:這一門的主語已經是如來,但仍是普賢在轉述。

第五十門 種白淨法:為什麼一句都不空過

「種白淨法」四個字要拆。澄觀說白淨法就是所轉之輪的體,而「種」的意思是:佛的無漏清淨法界轉入眾生心中,成為聞熏的種子,所以叫種。他還繫到承衍論典的多聞熏習之義。所以說法之所以無空過,是因為聽進去的那一句在心裡留下了種子。十個緣故:過去願力、大悲所持、不捨眾生、智慧自在隨所樂說、必應其時未曾失、隨其所宜無妄說、知三世智善了知、其身最勝無與等、言辭自在無能測、智慧自在隨所發言悉開悟。澄觀說初一是宿因、餘皆現因,前六德具、後三用勝。排一個誤:無空過不是說聽的人當下就懂,是說種子已下。落地:講的人負責應時應機,發芽的時節不歸講的人管。

第五十一門 示般涅槃:最後一句仍是示現

澄觀釋涅槃門一句話:「應盡還源。」十義他逐句判:初二明生死過患(一無常、二無樂故云非安隱),三明涅槃是樂,四翻色身無常而以法身為常——這一句他有校語,晉本作「令求常住淨法身故」,今本缺一個常字。次三句明生死無我不自在,第八明涅槃是堅即自在我而兼常義,第九翻有為以明淨德,末句「十明法爾」。經文的末句正是:諸佛作佛事已、所願滿已、轉法輪已、應化度者皆化度已、有諸菩薩應受尊號成記別已,法應如是入於不變大般涅槃。排一個誤:整整十義沒有一義說佛真的滅了,全部是「示」。落地:涅槃在這一門裡是一堂課——課的內容是無常,授課的方式是自己示現無常。

承衍

六位之科的來歷——本品說分六段的位名,澄觀明說是古來諸德依別行本《度世經》之文用來科這部經的,他承接而釋。所以「因圓果滿行」是疏家坐標,不是經文自稱。三家對這五十一門的算法也不同:澄觀以門計五十一,法藏以句計五百一十,《演義鈔》另存全品前一百九十六門屬因、或八相為果則果有十九門兩種算法。分界處實為二(末四門·住兜率以下),數法有門句之異,古德各有所據,並錄不判。

因果之界——澄觀判「成如來力」以下四門方明果滿,法藏則以「十種住兜率天」以下為現果圓滿行。兩家的界不在同一處,而是兩種口徑:澄觀剋實而論,末四門方是果;法藏以示現而論,八相整組劃入果——澄觀《演義鈔》自己也並存此二口徑(前一百九十六門屬因、八相為果則十九門)。誌錄不判。

八相之時——三家皆言同時:澄觀說「並一相中同時齊現」,法藏說「並在胎內同時齊現」,李通玄以「總一時」讀之,說如來出世始終不離剎那際,處胎、住兜率、初生、出家、成道、轉法輪、入涅槃總在一時。科判有先後,所現同時;三家並錄。

幾處異文——清淨捨一門,今本文列十一句而晉本併前二為一成十;修行法第二句,晉本作「覺悟諸天」;苦行第九句,晉本作「欲令未來眾生發精進故」,澄觀說今本缺此一句;坐道場第五句,晉本作觀一切佛師子之吼而非師子之座;示般涅槃第四義,晉本作「令求常住淨法身故」,澄觀說今本缺一個常字。以上皆古德已誌之異,錄而不判。

別行本的對位——別行本《度世品經》末番的問目恰為五十一,與本段五十一門一一相對,門序全同而譯語全異:觀察作觀、普觀察作顧視、奮迅作嚬申、慢業作自大、智業作聖業、示般涅槃作取大滅度。這是本段門數與門序最硬的一組外證,也正是古德立六段之科所依的那個本節。

與他品互讀——本段十度之科(三聚戒、三種忍、三緣慈悲喜捨),澄觀屢言已見於十地與十行諸品,本段是既立之科在等覺位上再走一遍,不是新立。果滿四門所說的佛事,與如來出現品所說的性起十義是同一組材料的兩種問法:一問應當怎樣見佛的身,一問成佛道、轉法輪、取滅度是怎麼回事——一問見,一問作。

華嚴宗論對本品的徵引——後世華嚴宗諸論引本品,多是泛引品名而不逐句牒經:或引以證十心無盡之義,或引以證十佛之義,或引以證十世之義。其中十佛之義最近本段的見佛與成如來力兩門,然引處未逐句定位,誌錄。

Where This Stretch Stands

Universal Wisdom Bodhisattva asked two hundred questions in one breath, and Samantabhadra answered them one by one, each answer with ten phrases; Chengguan reckons this as “the two thousand surpassing practices of Samantabhadra.” This is the last of those rounds, the fifty-one gates. The five earlier rounds answered the ten faiths, the ten abodes, the ten practices, the ten dedications, and the ten grounds — but one thing must first be made clear: of these stage-names the scriptural text itself does not produce one single word. It was the ancient worthies of old who, on the basis of the six rounds of question and answer in the separately circulating Dushi jing, set up this outline, and Chengguan carried it on and used it to outline this scripture. Therefore “the practice of the perfected cause and the fulfilled fruit” is not what the scripture calls itself; it is a set of coordinates. In reading, one must be able at any moment to take the coordinates away and see what the scriptural text is saying of itself.

And what is the scriptural text saying of itself? It begins from “there are ten kinds of contemplation” and ends at “manifesting parinirvāṇa.” The earlier part is how a person who cultivates is to look, how to practice, how to keep clear of obstruction; the later part is the eight aspects of accomplishing the Way, together with three affairs of a buddha — turning the wheel of the Dharma, sowing the white and pure dharmas, and entering nirvāṇa. Here Chengguan lays down a decisive judgment: the fifty-one gates do not all of them speak of the fruit; only the four gates from “accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata” onward truly make clear the fulfilled fruit, and all that precedes is the perfected cause. He knows himself that this judgment collides with the eight aspects — are the eight aspects not the fruit? His explanation is this: the first five of the eight aspects are still in the position of the cause, and it is only because the eight aspects are one whole set of manifestings that they are taken in together into the fruit. This is a layering of “speaking strictly in terms of the fact” over against “speaking in accordance with the marks,” and not a blurring. His Yanyi chao preserves besides a second way of reckoning: of the two hundred gates of the whole chapter the first one hundred and ninety-six belong to the cause; and a third as well: if the eight aspects are taken as the fruit, then the fruit has nineteen gates. Two reckonings of the same stretch of text stand together, and this is precisely the family manner of this chapter, which may be opened out or drawn together.

Gate 1. Contemplation: What Is Looked At, Not How Far One Can See

Ask one question first: when a person who cultivates “looks,” what is it that he looks at? The ten contemplations give a very concrete answer — deeds, destinies, faculties, dharmas, the Buddha-dharma, wisdom, the forbearance of non-arising, the ground of nonretrogression, the ground of consecration, the samādhi of the wisdom of good awakening. Chengguan divides them into three stretches: the first two contemplate what is to be transformed; the next four contemplate the dharmas that transform (he names them: principle, fruit, teaching, and practice); the last three contemplate the positions. There is a misreading to clear away here: looking at deeds and looking at destinies sound like spiritual penetration, but the scriptural text at once takes that apart — under “the contemplation that knows all destinies” what follows is “for the reason that he grasps at no real sentient being.” He can see the turning and flowing, and yet he does not thereby make solid a real person who turns and flows. So too with looking at faculties: “for the reason that he penetrates through to the faculties having of themselves no fixed nature.” These ten contemplations, then, are not an eye chart; they are a training in seeing without making solid. Brought home to oneself: when you judge a person’s faculties, are you looking, or have you already fixed his nature for him? To fix his nature is to “grasp.”

Gate 2. Universal Contemplation: From “Seeing” Turned into “Catching Hold”

The first gate is looking; why must the second gate look again? Chengguan says the first gate is “for the reason that he understands skillful means and penetrates through to what is open and what is blocked,” and the second is “for the reason that his deliberation is thorough and reaches everywhere” — the one is looking accurately, the other is looking completely. And the scriptural text itself gives a harder distinction: in every one of these ten phrases the second half is an action. Seeing one who begs, he satisfies his wish; seeing one who breaks the precepts, he settles him in the pure precepts; seeing one with a harming mind, he settles him in the power of patience. Chengguan points out that the first six phrases are precisely the six perfections used as antidotes to the six meannesses. So “universal contemplation” is not contemplating; it is seeing and at once catching hold. Clear away one misreading: this is not a demand that you be able to solve everything; it is a demand that “contemplating” not stop at contemplating. To see an indolent person and merely to sigh over it is still the affair of the first gate, not of the second.

Gate 3. Rousing Might: Where the Majesty Comes From

Of the ten kinds of rousing might the first five are all fierce beasts — the bull-king, the elephant-king, the nāga-king, the garuḍa-king, and the lion-king; from the sixth on it turns to bravery and strength, great wisdom, the dhāraṇī, and eloquence, and the last is the rousing might of a Tathāgata. Why first lodge the sense in a simile and then take it in terms of dharma? Chengguan’s explanation is very spare: rousing might is “the real virtue filling within and the majestic virtue brimming over without,” like the lion-king — majesty is not something put on for show; it is what brims over of itself when the inside is full. Fazang says almost the same thing, and also uses “filling within” and “brimming over without.” The misreading most to be guarded against here is taking rousing might for a commanding air or for the power to sway others. The scriptural text gives its own line of defense: the rousing might of the elephant-king is “the nature of his mind is well tamed and gentle,” not fierce might; the rousing might of the nāga-king comes to rest on raining down the sweet-dew rain. Brought home to oneself: to speak the Dharma and move one’s hearers may be eloquence, and need not be rousing might; the test of rousing might lies in those two words “filling within” — the very sentence you spoke, can you yourself stand and abide in it?

Gate 4. The Lion’s Roar: Nine Phrases of Vow and One Phrase of Making Good

What is a lion’s roar? Chengguan says: “Since he is brave and strong and without fear, he is therefore able to proclaim with decision.” Rousing might is the majesty; the lion’s roar is speaking it out. Of the ten phrases the first nine are all “I shall” — I shall accomplish perfect awakening, I shall cause sentient beings to be crossed over, I shall cause the three jewels not to be cut off. The tenth phrase suddenly is no longer a vow but turns into a piece of narrative: the bodhisattva of the final body shakes the buddha-lands, the gods come and entreat him, he contemplates the world with one phrase, “among all sentient beings there is none that is my equal,” and then is born in the royal palace, walks seven steps, and proclaims, “in the world I am the most excellent and the first.” The name the scriptural text gives this phrase is “the great lion’s roar of doing as one has said.” The nine phrases are the saying; the tenth phrase is the doing. A misreading must be cleared away here: that phrase “the most excellent and the first” is not boasting, for the scriptural text at once completes it in the second half — “I shall forever exhaust the far bound of birth-and-death.” The most excellent is said with regard to that one thing. Where it comes to ground: vowing is easy, and what lies between vow and practice is just this tenth phrase.

Gate 5. Pure Giving: Why All Ten Givings Are Called “Pure”

Why is every one of the perfections crowned with a “pure”? Chengguan answers straight out: “for the reason that they leave the meanness and obstruction behind, and are not like the giving and the precepts and the rest of the world.” Pure is not a describing word; it is a distinguishing word — it distinguishes away the giving of the world. And what are the meannesses? Look at the reason-phrases the scriptural text itself gives and you will know: even-minded giving is “he does not pick and choose among sentient beings,” giving that does not abide is “he seeks no reward,” giving that opens and lets go is “his mind is not fond and attached.” The purity of every phrase comes to rest upon one concrete not. The last phrase, the purity of the three spheres, is the deepest: the giver, the receiver, and the thing given, all three sides like empty space. There is a common misunderstanding here — the purity of the three spheres sounds as though one had to cultivate until one ‘cannot feel oneself giving.’ It is not a matter of feeling but a matter of contemplating; the words the scriptural text uses are “rightly and mindfully contemplates.” Where it comes to ground: that sentence in your heart after the giving is done, ‘he ought to remember it,’ is the fifth phrase, “he seeks no reward,” not yet standing firm.

Gate 6. Pure Precepts: The Ten Faces of the Precepts

Can the ten precepts be remembered simply as ‘do not do bad things’? They cannot. Chengguan cuts them by the threefold collection of precepts: the first three phrases are restraint, the seventh and the tenth are gathering sentient beings, and the rest are gathering the good. The most thought-provoking thing in the scriptural text is the seventh phrase, “the pure precept of guarding it in secret,” whose reason is “for the reason that he means skillfully to pull out and rescue sentient beings who break the precepts” — for the sake of saving one who breaks the precepts, his own keeping of the precepts must be secret and not paraded. This one phrase pushes the precepts from guarding oneself out to guarding others. Then look at the last two phrases: “the pure precept of leaving far behind all views that things exist, for the reason that toward the precepts themselves too he has no attachment” — even the attachment to the precepts must be left behind. Clear away one misreading: this does not say that the precepts may be loosened, for the sixth phrase has only just said “toward even the most subtle offense he gives rise to great dread.” Dreading even the subtlest offense, and at the same time not being attached to the precepts — the two phrases are one and the same person. Where it comes to ground: to keep the precepts and grow a sense of superiority is the ninth phrase not yet done.

Gate 7. Pure Patience: Patience Is Not Holding Down

Of the ten patiences the first three are being reviled, being struck, and giving rise to no anger and harm, which Chengguan judges to be the patience that endures the harm of enemies — bearing the vexing harm of others’ deeds of body, speech, and mind. But as the ten phrases run on, the nature of the patience changes: the sixth is “leaving far behind the conceit of self” and “he does not look down on those who have not yet learned”; the seventh is “not being angry though maimed and reviled” and “he contemplates all this as an illusion”; and the last phrase comes to rest directly upon “fully knows that all dharmas are without arising.” These ten phrases, then, are one single line: from being able to bear it, to being able to see through it, to there being fundamentally nothing to bear. The misreading to be cleared away is reading patience as repression. The scriptural text guards against this quite plainly — the reason given for the third phrase is “for the reason that his mind is unmoved,” not ‘for the reason that his mind forcibly bears it.’ Where it comes to ground: if you are very tired after being patient, you are for the most part still at the first phrase; tiredness is the price of holding down, and that “as an illusion” of the seventh phrase takes no strength at all.

Gate 8. Pure Vigor: Vigor Is Not the Same as Being Busy

How are the ten vigors divided? Chengguan says the second phrase and the tenth are benefiting sentient beings, the fifth is donning armor, and the rest are gathering the good. The frame the scriptural text itself gives is clearer still: the first three are the vigor of the three kinds of deed, of body, of speech, and of mind; the fourth and the fifth are the vigor of the ground of the mind (the upright mind and the ascendant mind); and from the sixth on it turns to antidote and completion. The thing most to be noticed is the ninth phrase, “the pure vigor of no coming and no going” — vigor at the last is “fully knowing that mark is non-mark, with nothing grasped at.” Clear away one misreading here: vigor is not filling up the calendar. The test the sixth phrase gives is “never stopping midway” — it is not being broken off, not never resting. Where it comes to ground: ask yourself of yesterday’s exertion, was it taking in (the sixth phrase), or was it only moving about.

Gate 9. Pure Meditation: The Precondition of Concentration Is Your Life

What the ten meditations speak of at the outset is not the posture of sitting but leaving home, a good friend, dwelling in an araṇya, leaving the clamor — Chengguan judges the first five to be skillful means. Only at the sixth phrase, “the mind and wisdom are at rest and extinguished,” is it concentration itself; the seventh and the eighth turn out into wisdom and the cutting off of confusion; the ninth and the tenth are the penetrations and clarities, and play. Why must concentration be spoken of beginning from these outward conditions? Because concentration is not an isolated affair: surroundings, companions, and the shape of one’s life are all its front portion. The eighth phrase in particular is to be looked at: “the pure meditation of leaving behind the relishing of its taste, for the reason that he does not forsake the realm of desire” — not being greedy for the taste of concentration, and therefore in no hurry to cast away the realm of desire. Clear away one misreading: to be absorbed in the taste of meditative concentration will be listed in gate 23 of this stretch as “the māra of samādhi,” from which one may see that greed for concentration is plainly guarded against. Where it comes to ground: the ten hours outside of sitting decide the quality of that one hour.

Gate 10. Pure Wisdom: Wisdom in Three Stretches

The ten wisdoms Chengguan divides most tidily: the first three understand dharmas and belong to the wisdom of applied practice; the next four gather beings and belong to the subsequently attained wisdom; the last three realize the principle and belong to the wisdom of the essential substance. The sequence of the scriptural text answers to it exactly — first knowing causes, knowing conditions, knowing neither cutting off nor permanence, which is understanding; then contemplating the movements of the minds of sentient beings, vast eloquence, what the māras and outsiders cannot know, which is use; and last seeing the dharma-body, seeing the original nature to be pure, the adamantine wisdom of a single thought-moment’s conjunction, which is realizing. The misreading to be cleared away here is taking wisdom for cleverness. The reason given for the fifth phrase is “he fully knows them to be like an illusion,” and the reason given for the ninth is “it makes people obtain all the most excellent wisdom” — the direction of wisdom is from first to last outward and toward people, not toward proving oneself. Where it comes to ground: to have read a stretch of Dharma through and be in a hurry to tell it to someone is the road of the subsequently attained wisdom; to have read it through and first turn it upon oneself once is to have some share in the wisdom of the essential substance.

Gate 11. Pure Loving-Kindness: The Three Layers of Loving-Kindness

The four measureless minds begin here. Chengguan says that the six perfections for the most part make clear benefiting oneself while the four evennesses are for the most part taken in terms of benefiting others, and he cuts these four gates with the three grounds. Of the ten phrases of loving-kindness he judges the first eight to have sentient beings as their ground, while the ninth and the tenth show their sense in the marks of the text themselves — “the pure loving-kindness that has dharmas as its ground, for the reason that he realizes the real dharma of suchness,” “the pure loving-kindness that has no ground, for the reason that he enters into the nature of a bodhisattva’s leaving arising behind.” What are the three grounds? Loving-kindness set going with sentient beings as its ground, loving-kindness set going with dharmas as its ground, and loving-kindness set going with no ground at all. The first is the most intimate, the last the most thoroughgoing. Clear away one misreading here: groundless loving-kindness is not coldness. The eighth phrase of the scriptural text has only just said, “the pure loving-kindness that fills empty space, for the reason that in rescuing and guarding sentient beings there is no place he does not reach,” and only then does the tenth phrase turn into the groundless — it is emptied after being filled, not left uncared for because emptied. Where it comes to ground: if loving-kindness will not arise toward some particular person, one must for the most part go back to the first phrase, “an even mind” — first look and see whether you have been picking and choosing.

Gate 12. Pure Compassion: The Two Knots Where Compassion Is Tied

Of the ten compassions Chengguan judges the first seven to have sentient beings as their ground, the eighth to have dharmas as its ground, and the last two to be groundless, and for those last two phrases he points out the reason why: the ninth is “he is grieved that what is true in them is hidden, and therefore reveals it,” and the tenth is “he thinks of their not knowing, and therefore makes them awaken.” Look at the scriptural text, and these two phrases are indeed written differently from the first eight — the first eight are all short phrases, while each of these two is a complete stretch of contemplation: knowing that all dharmas are in their original nature pure and that beings suffer only because of the adventitious, and therefore giving rise to compassion, named “the original nature is pure”; knowing that all dharmas are like the track of a bird in the sky and that sentient beings are veiled by the film of delusion and cannot see it, and therefore giving rise to compassion, named “the wisdom of what is real.” Compassion at this point is no longer the not bearing to see people suffer; it is not bearing to see people who are fundamentally without trouble take themselves to be in trouble. Clear away one misreading: the second phrase, “he undergoes suffering in place of all sentient beings and does not take it for toil,” does not say that one can really undergo it in their place; the reason-phrase given is “does not take it for toil,” and what is spoken of is the measure of the mind. Where it comes to ground: if your pity for a person carries a looking down from above, it has not yet reached the sixth phrase, “not attached to his own joy.”

Gate 13. Pure Joy: Where Joy Comes From

Joy is the gate among the ten most easily misread, because it looks like an emotion. Chengguan judges the first four to have sentient beings as their ground, the next three to have dharmas as their ground, and the last three to be groundless. Look at the scriptural text, and the first phrase at once settles the source of joy — “the pure joy of giving rise to the aspiration for awakening”; the first origin of joy is that one has oneself given rise to the mind. And onward: joy at giving away all that one has, joy at not disdaining sentient beings who break the precepts, joy at being able to bear with sentient beings who do evil, joy at giving away the body in seeking the Dharma without regret. The joy of every phrase hangs upon a deed that is not easy. Clear away one misreading: joy is not the product of favorable circumstances. The fourth phrase plainly says “being able to bear with sentient beings who do evil,” and that is adverse circumstance. Where it comes to ground: examine your last real gladness — was it because you got something, or because you gave something out, bore something down, gave rise to the mind?

Gate 14. Pure Equanimity: Two Kinds of Waiting

This gate has a peculiarity in the text, which Chengguan has already marked: the heading says ten kinds, but within the text eleven phrases are listed in fact, and it is the Jin recension, which draws the first two together into one, that makes ten. Such opening out and drawing together the ancient worthies long ago recorded, and it need not be taken for an error. In content, the deepest are the ninth and the tenth phrases — some sentient beings’ faculties are ripe and yet they still cannot know the highest dharma: wait; some sentient beings the bodhisattva has already taught in former ages and who can be tamed only at the ground of buddhahood: also wait. And then the eleventh phrase gathers it all up: toward these two kinds of persons, “without high and without low, without taking up and without setting down.” The utmost of equanimity is not giving up; it is being able to wait. Clear away one misreading: equanimity is not not caring. The fourth phrase has already said, “waiting for the time to teach and cross over those sentient beings who are fit vessels for the Dharma, and not giving rise to disdain toward those who are not fit for it either” — not teaching and crossing over, but not giving rise to disdain. Where it comes to ground: toward a person who cannot be urged, is your mind waiting, or has it already been cut off?

Gate 15. Meaning: The Meaning That Is Conveyed

From this gate on it turns into skillful means and cultivation; Chengguan judges the first five gates to make clear the practice of one’s own portion and the last three the practice of advancing beyond. Meaning and dharma are a pair; how are they divided? Chengguan says: “If one takes what conveys as dharma, then one takes what is conveyed as meaning.” But he says at once that in this stretch he does not take what conveys as dharma. The first phrase of the ten meanings shows the most care — the meaning of much hearing, whose reason is “for the reason that it lies in cultivating firmly,” and Chengguan points out: “the first takes cultivation as the meaning of much hearing, the intent lying in cultivating and not in hearing.” The meaning of much hearing turns out to be cultivation, not hearing. Clear away one misreading: this is not to belittle hearing. The second phrase, “the meaning of dharma, for the reason that it lies in deliberating and choosing skillfully,” is still within the range of deliberating and choosing. It says that the meaning of this matter of much hearing comes to rest upon cultivating, not upon the amount of hearing. Where it comes to ground: how much Dharma did you read this year — put the question another way: what did you change because you read it?

Gate 16. Dharma: The Dharma That Is Able to Hold

What is dharma? Chengguan gives two senses: “first, it holds its own nature; second, it is the rule by which understanding is produced in beings” — the one is that it can stand up of itself, the other is that it can let people produce understanding by relying upon it. And he matches them phrase by phrase: of this stretch, the first seven phrases run through both senses, the eighth and the ninth are only the holding of its own nature, and the last is only the rule that produces understanding. The last phrase is the weight of the whole gate — “forsaking all upadhi-nirvāṇa.” Upadhi Chengguan explains as “having suffering,” and takes it to be the nirvāṇa of the two vehicles; and he cites the Foxing lun to say that in the nirvāṇa without remainder of the two vehicles there are yet three kinds of remainder, and that therefore it is not truly without remainder. So this phrase would have a person forsake that seemingly ultimate resting place, and the reason-phrase is given in a wholly positive way: “it is able to set going all the practices of a bodhisattva, and to cultivate them without cease.” Clear away one misreading: this is not to belittle the two vehicles; it is to say that that is not the end of the road. Where it comes to ground: any feeling of ‘at last I am secure’ that arises in cultivation is worth shining this one phrase upon.

Gate 17. The Equipment of Merit That Aids the Path: Merit Is a Tool

What is equipment that aids the path? Chengguan says it plainly: “merit and wisdom are the path itself; the conditions that complete merit and wisdom are named equipment that aids the path.” Those conditions that bring merit and wisdom to completion are what is called equipment that aids the path. Of the ten phrases the ones most worth stopping at are the first and the tenth. The first: urging sentient beings to give rise to the aspiration for awakening is an equipment of merit that aids the path, the reason being “thereby the lineage of the three jewels is not cut off” — so it turns out that urging a person to give rise to the mind is itself the greatest merit. The tenth phrase is a whole stretch: roots of good amassed through asaṃkhyeya kalpas, the realization of awakening already as though in the palm of the hand, and yet all of it given away to sentient beings, with no sorrow and distress in the mind and no regret. Clear away one misreading: this does not say that merit can be transferred to somebody; the scriptural text comes to rest upon “that mind being vast and the same as the realm of empty space,” and what is meant is the measure of the mind. Where it comes to ground: if the good things you have done are still entered under your own name, the tenth phrase has not yet begun.

Gate 18. The Equipment of Wisdom That Aids the Path: A Ladder of Ten Rungs

This is one of the longer gates in the whole stretch, and each of the ten phrases is a whole paragraph. Chengguan names the first three for us: “first, drawing near to good conditions without; second, taming the vessel of the Dharma within; third, settling the place of mindfulness and wisdom.” One can see that these ten phrases are a ladder running from without inward: drawing near to good friends, doing away with arrogance, mindfulness and wisdom not scattered, delighting in the Dharma and its meaning, the six perfections and the four dwellings of Brahmā, ever delighting in coming forth and departing, contemplating the five aggregates as illusion, hearing of the two selflessnesses and deeply believing, calming and contemplating carried on together, and seeing dependent origination and thereby the fivefold purity. The string of similes in the seventh phrase is the most famous — like an illusion, like a heat-haze, like the moon in water, like a dream, like a shadow, like an echo, like an image, like a painting in the sky, like a whirling wheel of fire, like the colors of a rainbow, like the light of the sun and the moon. When Chengguan explains “the elements are like venomous snakes” he cites the old saying that takes the four great elements for venomous snakes, and explaining “the sense-fields are like an empty village” he says it is “for the reason that there is no person within.” Clear away one misreading: this string is not literary ornament, for the seventh phrase gives its own conclusion, “he knows that all dharmas are without arising and without ceasing.” Where it comes to ground: these ten phrases can serve as a self-examination in sequence, asking of each in turn, ‘which phrase am I at?’

The third phrase has one more cluster of terms, compressed, that is worth unfolding on its own. After the scriptural text says “mindfulness and wisdom following upon awareness, never yet scattered; with shame and with a pliant gentleness, the mind at rest and unmoving,” it stacks three “evers”: “ever calling to mind the six recollections, ever practicing the six reverences, ever following along and dwelling in the six dharmas of firmness.” Chengguan names a function for each of the three: “the six recollections are for upholding oneself; the six harmonies are the dharma of the community” — the six reverences being the six harmonies, the way of dwelling together among many. As for the six firmnesses, he says they are “the six firmnesses that follow upon the stages,” and cites the first fascicle of the Original Acts as matching them to the three worthies, the ten sages, and the two awakenings of equal and marvelous, making six, namely “firmness in faith, firmness in the Dharma, firmness in cultivation, firmness in virtue, firmness in the nape, firmness in awakening”; he adds that these six are also named the six forbearances, the six wisdoms, the six contemplations, and the six natures, and closes, “for the reason that there is no buddha at all who does not enter by these.” For the two sets, the six recollections and the six reverences, Chengguan notes “both are seen in the text above,” pointing back to what was explained earlier: the six recollections are recollection of the Buddha, of the Dharma, of the Saṃgha, of the precepts, of giving, and of the devas — under the seven recollections of an earlier gate the Shu says “adding recollection of sentient beings, for the sake of great compassion,” from which one knows that the six with recollection of beings added make the seven; the six reverences are the six harmonies, which the Shu explains as “harmony of body in dwelling together, harmony of speech in not quarrelling, harmony of mind in not going against, harmony of view in the same understanding, harmony of precepts in the same observance, harmony of gains in equal sharing,” the three deeds together with precepts, views, and gains all in harmony. What matters is why the three “evers” are stacked together: the six recollections are holding oneself up oneself; the six reverences are not grating against others amid the many; the six firmnesses are walking the whole way up without turning back — inward, toward others, and forward. Take away any one and the other two will not hold for long. Clear away one misreading: the six firmnesses are not six kinds of hardness of temper; what Chengguan matches them to is the stages, and firmness is ‘standing steady in that place.’ Where it comes to ground: this one phrase can be asked three times a day — has the thought today a place to rest, has there been contention with anyone, and has the road walked been walked backward.

Gate 19. Clarity and Footing: Wisdom Complete, and Still Advancing

What is clarity and footing? Chengguan takes the two words apart. Clarity is “the darkness of confusion has perished and the understanding of wisdom has appeared”; footing has two senses, “first, for the reason that wisdom is full and complete; second, for the reason that there is advancing,” and he says that this is the sense of “complete in clarity and conduct” among the ten titles: on the side of the fruit it is called fullness and completeness, and on the side of the cause it is called feet. So clarity and footing is at once fullness and still walking. Of the ten phrases the first seven are taken in terms of practice and the last three raise separately the three clarities — the divine eye, former abodes, and the exhaustion of the contaminants. Clear away one misreading: the three clarities are listed here not to make people seek spiritual penetrations. Look at the reason-phrases: the wisdom of the divine eye is “universally contemplating,” the recollection of former abodes is “the purity of knowing the earlier bound,” and the penetration of the exhaustion of the contaminants is “cutting off the contaminants of sentient beings” — all three are turned toward sentient beings. Where it comes to ground: with any ability whatever, the way to test it is to ask in which direction it is used.

Gate 20. Seeking the Dharma: Ten Kinds of Mind, and One Boundary Line

How is the Dharma to be sought? Every one of the ten phrases is a matched pair: seeking the Dharma with an upright mind is matched with “there is no flattery and deceiving”; seeking the Dharma with vigor is matched with “he leaves indolence and arrogance far behind”; seeking the Dharma with a single direction is matched with “he does not begrudge body and life.” Chengguan gives each phrase an extremely spare label — the mind at the beginning is only upright; in the middle and after there is no indolence; within, he pays no regard to the body; without, he forgets fame and gain; the two benefits are both fulfilled; he gets the intent and forgets the words; he does not seek the fruit close at hand; the cause requites what he has done; he universally resolves doubts; he fulfills the Buddha-vehicle alone. And then he lays down a judgment: “Apart from these ten kinds of seeking, all seeking is wrong seeking.” This sentence carries much weight. Clear away one misreading: wrong seeking does not mean seeking a wrong dharma; it means seeking the true Dharma from a motive other than these ten. The boundary given by the sixth phrase is the finest of all — “seeking the Dharma so as to enter wisdom, for the reason that he takes no delight in the letter.” Where it comes to ground: ask yourself, at the very moment of seeking the Dharma, whether there is not in your mind a calculation that ‘this will come in useful later on.’

Gate 21. Dharmas Clearly Understood: The Particular Stretch Belonging to Each of Ten Classes of Persons

This gate suddenly ranges in order the ordinary person, the one who practices in accordance with faith, the one who practices in accordance with the Dharma, the eighth person, the four fruits, the pratyekabuddha, and the bodhisattva — ten classes of persons. Chengguan says that this is “generally, with the surpassing wisdom of Samantabhadra, fully knowing the differences of the ordinary and the noble in the three vehicles.” He also glosses a difficult term for us: the eighth person is “the one directed toward the first fruit,” and he cites the commentary on the Jushe to say that among the eight forbearances it is counted from the last as the eighth. Where does the intent of this gate lie? It lies in a bodhisattva’s being able to recognize how far each class of person now clearly understands. Clear away one misreading: this is not a matching of oneself against the positions. What the scriptural text lists is ‘the dharma they clearly understand,’ which is what is to be known for transforming others, not a ladder of one’s own realization. Where it comes to ground: before talking of the Dharma with someone, first judge which phrase he stands upon — speaking too early is useless, and speaking too late is useless as well.

Gate 22. Dharmas of Cultivation: Turning What Was Understood Before into a Daily Task

The gate before was clear understanding; this gate is cultivation. Chengguan puts it very directly: “the third, the dharmas of cultivation, are so called for the reason that only by cultivating as it was spoken does one obtain the Buddha-dharma.” All ten phrases can be carried out: reverencing good friends, being ever awakened by the gods, ever harboring a sense of shame and blame in the presence of the buddhas, pitying sentient beings and not forsaking birth-and-death, surely carrying through whatever he does with a mind that does not shift. On the second phrase Chengguan also makes a correction in the reading — “as for ‘ever by the gods,’ the word wei takes the falling tone,” that is, for the sake of the gods one awakens them — the bodhisattva awakens the gods and does not let them cling to pleasure (so Fazang); and he cites the Jin recension, which reads “awakening the gods,” as his witness. The base text’s wording is “ever awakened by the gods,” and the Vernacular renders that wording as it stands; Chengguan’s reading is recorded here. Clear away one misreading: the fifth phrase, “surely carrying through whatever he does with a mind that does not change and shift,” is not stubbornness; the phrases before and after it speak of pitying sentient beings and of following and learning from the assemblies of bodhisattvas, so it is an unshiftingness within relationships. Where it comes to ground: these ten phrases are the most like a daily task, and one may really check them off one by one over a week.

Gate 23. Māra: Māra Lies in the Grasping, Not in the Thing

This gate is the most easily read astray. Among the ten māras are the māra of the roots of good, the māra of samādhi, the māra of the good friend, and the māra of the wisdom of the dharma of awakening — how can roots of good be a māra? Chengguan’s handling of this is the sharpest passage in the whole stretch. He first sets himself a question: as for the māra of the aggregates, the body is the vessel of the Way and its substance is the same as a buddha’s; how then is it a māra? The answer: “the name māra of the aggregates comes solely from grasping and attachment, and the nine below follow the same example.” The name māra does not fall upon that thing; it falls upon the grasping. He pushes it a step further: “Thus one knows that when the mind discriminates, the ten thousand dharmas are all māra; how should it be only these ten?” And he says besides that the four māras are made clear in terms of substance while the ten māras are for the most part taken in terms of grasping and attachment, which is why the numbers differ. And he lays down a turning word: all is buddha, so where is the sense in forsaking the realm of māra to seek the realm of buddha? Clear away one misreading: this does not say that roots of good and samādhi need not be cultivated, for the reason of every phrase of the scriptural text points at grasping and attachment — the māra of the roots of good is “toward the roots of good he grasps constantly,” the māra of samādhi is “he long relishes its taste.” Where it comes to ground: examine that one fruit of cultivation you prize most — are you using it, or guarding it?

Gate 24. Deeds of Māra: Ten Things That Will Spoil a Good Deed

Māra is the substance; the deeds of māra are the affairs. Chengguan says: “To do these ten things is in every case able to corrupt the good and also to draw the heavenly māra, and therefore they are its deeds.” All ten phrases are utterly concrete: cultivating roots of good while having forgotten and lost the mind of awakening; giving with an evil mind; keeping the precepts with an angry mind; being stingy toward the profound Dharma; not speaking for one who is fit to be taught; forcing oneself to speak for one who is no vessel because one has received offerings; slandering the true Dharma; studying the disputations of the world and covering over the profound Dharma; drawing near only to those already liberated. The first phrase is the general illness — the good work is still being done, and the resolve has dropped away. Having read this gate through it is best to stop a moment, and Chengguan himself stopped too, writing one sentence: “Yet looking at this text, it is hard to escape the deeds of māra; may those who come after examine this and look into themselves.” Clear away one misreading: this is not to make people afraid; it is to make them check. Where it comes to ground: take these ten phrases as an annual examination, and for the most part every one of them will be touched a little — only what is touched can be mended.

Gate 25. Forsaking the Deeds of Māra: Matched One by One Against Them

This gate stands directly against the one before. Chengguan says, “treating and mending against the obstruction, and therefore it says forsaking,” and points out: “Yet these ten phrases are matched directly against those before, only in brief and out of order.” He also marks the correspondences one by one — the first reverses the fifth, the second the second, the third the seventh, the fourth the first, the fifth the fourth, the sixth the eighth, the seventh the third, the eighth the ninth, the ninth the tenth, and the tenth the sixth. Why not in order? He gives two reasons: one is to show that any single good whatever reverses all ten of those before, and the other is that several goods may together reverse one fault, so as to keep people from making a fixed rule of it. Clear away one misreading: do not read it as a mechanical formula of ten against ten. Where it comes to ground: if one really means to use it, take the fourth phrase, “never having forgotten and lost the mind of all-knowing wisdom” — for the first phrase of the gate before is the general illness, and this phrase is the general medicine.

Gate 26. Seeing the Buddha: Ten Buddhas, Ten Seeings

The obstruction gone, the fruit appears. Chengguan judges these two gates to be “for the reason that the obstruction is gone, the fruit appears and practice is complete.” The form of this gate is very peculiar: all ten phrases run ‘such-and-such a buddha, such-and-such a seeing’ — the buddha of accomplishing perfect awakening, seen with non-attachment; the buddha of the vow, seen with bringing forth; the buddha of the recompense of deeds, seen with deep faith; the buddha who abides and sustains, seen with following along; the buddha of nirvāṇa, seen with entering deeply; the buddha of the Dharma realm, seen with reaching everywhere; the buddha of the mind, seen with abiding securely; the buddha of samādhi, seen with the measureless and the unsupported; the buddha of the original nature, seen with clear understanding; the buddha who accords with what is delighted in, seen with universally receiving. There are ten kinds of buddha and ten kinds of seeing as well, and they are matched one with one — but the manner of the matching must be seen clearly. Chengguan gives a warning of his own: “yet the seeing set forth here is in every case a seeing that answers to that buddha.” The names of the seeings are set up as answering to the buddha seen; they do not say that the bodhisattva has cultivated such a mode of seeing for himself. He takes the first phrase as his proof: “as when it says non-attachment, this belongs of itself to the perfect awakening, and does not mean that the bodhisattva is unattached toward him. If the bodhisattva were unattached here, how should he be attached in the nine below?” Non-attachment is the perfectly awakened buddha’s own non-attachment; were it read as the bodhisattva’s being unattached to the buddha, the nine phrases below would have to say that the bodhisattva is attached to those nine buddhas. The buddha of the vow is spoken of with a seeing of bringing forth for the reason that “riding upon this vow he can bring forth every virtue”; the buddha of the recompense of deeds is spoken of with a seeing of deep faith for the reason that “the recompense is the deed of the body adorned with the marks and signs” and that “deep faith stands foremost” — the names all come from the virtues of that buddha. The Yanyi chao blocks one further rescue: someone might say, half on the side of what sees (as with non-attachment) and half on the side of what is seen (as with bringing forth) — would that not also go through? Chengguan blocks it: one may not take half from what sees and half from what is seen, because it would lead people into confusion, leave no way to take the sense, and throw the ten senses of seeing into disorder — all ten phrases are named uniformly from the buddha that is seen.

Gate 27. The Deeds of a Buddha: The Ten Things a Buddha Is Doing

After seeing the buddha comes speaking of the deeds of a buddha. The ten phrases begin from the most ordinary — opening up and guiding at the right time, causing him to see it within a dream, expounding a scripture not yet heard, speaking the dharma of coming forth and departing for one bound by remorse — all the way to the last phrase, which is a whole stretch: the first pair, fathoming that from the first all is at rest and yet diligently cultivating, together with ten of “though … yet,” makes eleven pairs in all — though he knows that from the first all is at rest and extinguished, yet he diligently cultivates merit and wisdom; though he knows there is no making, yet he does not forsake the own-mark; though he has left greedy desire behind, yet he ever gazes upon the buddha’s body; though he knows the lands to be like empty space, yet he ever delights to adorn them; though he contemplates that there is no person and no self, yet he teaches and transforms without wearying; though he has already accomplished the wisdom of all-knowing wisdom, yet he cultivates without rest; though he manifests entering nirvāṇa, yet he takes on birth in every place. The scriptural text gives this phrase its own name: “a dharma in which the provisional and the real are carried on together.” Chengguan glosses this, saying, “there are ten kinds of deed of a buddha, that is, the completion of practice. The gate before saw the substance of a buddha; now the cause of a buddha is set forth. Moreover practice accords with the practice of a buddha, and therefore it is named the deeds of a buddha” — the gate before speaks of the substance of a buddha, this gate speaks of the cause of a buddha, and the reason it is named the deeds of a buddha is that the practice accords with the practice of a buddha. Clear away one misreading: these ten turns are not a rhetoric of contradiction; the first half of each is the real and the second half the provisional, and only when both stand at once is it called carrying on both. Where it comes to ground: every time in cultivation that one feels ‘since it is from the first thus, why still do anything,’ that is to have thrown away the provisional half.

The remaining four pairs each have their provisional and their real as well. The first is “though he knows that entering into the Dharma is not by another’s awakening him, yet by manifold skillful means he seeks the wisdom of all.” Not by another’s awakening: the Dharma is not had from another’s hand; and yet the latter half is precisely to seek the wisdom of all by manifold means. The two look to be at odds — if it is not had from another, why still seek everywhere? Chengguan judges the eleven phrases of this stretch thus: “the first one is with respect to suffering; the next one with respect to arising; the next eight with respect to the path; the last one with respect to cessation,” and this phrase falls among those with respect to the path — that it is not by another’s awakening speaks of the substance awakened to, which borrows nothing from without; that he seeks the wisdom of all speaks of the path by which one awakens, which does not come of itself while one sits. The second is “though from the first he is unmoving in the Dharma realm, yet by the wisdom-power of spiritual penetration he manifests the many transformations,” which Fazang, citing the text, marks as “fifth, under ‘the penetrations,’ possessing the fruit without forsaking the cause”: the unmoving is the substance on the side of the fruit, the transformations are the practice within the cause, and to have realized the substance is not to have laid down the practice. The third is “though he knows that the dharmas cannot be spoken, yet he turns the pure wheel of the Dharma and makes the minds of the many glad” — knowing it cannot be spoken is the very condition of being able to speak; only speaking without grasping at the words is a wheel that is “pure,” and the landing place is making the minds of the many glad, not speaking much. The fourth is “though he can display the spiritual power of the buddhas, yet he does not weary of and forsake the body of a bodhisattva,” which Fazang marks as “sixth, under ‘displays,’ showing the complete without forsaking the partial”: what is displayed is the power of completeness; what is not forsaken is that station still within the cause. This phrase and the last one — “seventh, under ‘manifests the great,’ manifesting what is at rest without obstruction to birth” — make a pair: the one not forsaking the bodhisattva’s body, the other entering nirvāṇa and yet taking on birth in every place. Clear away one misreading: these four are not four exceptions. The substance Chengguan assigns to the whole stretch is that “the first one sets forth in sum the four truths of non-action,” and all eleven stand upon the frame of the four truths; these simply fall upon the truth of the path. Where it comes to ground: each of the four puts a question — in seeking the Dharma, am I waiting for it to come of itself; having realized a portion, do I stop; in speaking the Dharma, is it for speaking it beautifully; and having gained a little power, am I unwilling to go on being a learner.

Gate 28. Deeds of Conceit: The Ten Faces of Conceit

Conceit is not one kind of emotion; it is ten kinds of behavior. The scriptural text lists them without the least mercy: not being reverent toward teachers, the assembly of monks, and father and mother; giving rise to haughtiness toward a master of the Dharma who has obtained the Dharma; being unwilling to praise a wondrous dharma one has heard; being fond of giving rise to the conceit of excess; being fond of giving rise to the conceit beyond excess; disliking the Dharma along with the person one dislikes; seeking a high seat for oneself and being unwilling to serve; knitting the brows at one who has virtue and spying out his faults; being unwilling to ask questions of one who is wise; being covered over by a conceited mind so that the good that is new does not arise and the good that is old is extinguished. The sixth phrase is the one most worth stopping at — knowing full well that “this is Dharma, is Vinaya, is what is real, is what the Buddha spoke,” and yet, because one dislikes that person, slandering the Dharma along with him. Chengguan, outlining where this gate belongs, says, “it makes clear the practice of leaving obstruction behind and of being sustained. Within it, two: the first two gates within it are the practice of leaving obstruction behind,” and he also points out that the common mark of the ten conceits lies in “for the reason that toward all honored objects they are unwilling to pay homage and reverence” — the ten phrases have each a face of their own, and the root of the illness is in one and the same place. Clear away one misreading: the core of conceit is not thinking highly of oneself; it is letting the high and low of the person stand in for the true and false of the Dharma. Where it comes to ground: has there lately been a stretch of speech that you did not take in because you did not like the one who spoke it?

Gate 29. Deeds of Wisdom: What Grows After Conceit Is Left Behind

The opening phrase of this gate is not “Sons of the Buddha” but carries on from the gate before: “If the bodhisattvas leave these deeds of conceit behind, then they obtain ten kinds of deed of wisdom.” Conceit and wisdom are the two sides of one thing — where conceit is, wisdom does not arise. Several of the ten deeds of wisdom are directly symmetrical with the gate before: there, being unwilling to draw near to one who is wise; here, “drawing near to good friends and reverencing and making offerings to them, that mind honoring them and from first to last never wearying”; there, giving rise to haughtiness toward a master of the Dharma; here, “toward the various bodhisattvas giving rise to the thought of a tathāgata,” “toward those who cultivate giving rise to the thought of them as buddhas.” The eighth phrase shows the most warmth — toward the various perfections giving rise to the thought of a loving mother, and toward skillfulness in means giving rise to the thought of a loving father. Chengguan glosses this, saying, “there are ten kinds of deed of wisdom, showing the practice that acts as antidote” — this gate does not raise up another set of merits; it is the antidote to the gate before. Clear away one misreading: this is not an intimacy of figure of speech; it is looking upon the Dharma as that which rears you, so that conceit has nowhere to alight. Where it comes to ground: is your attitude toward the Dharma more like one toward a tool, or like one toward one’s parents?

Gate 30. Being Held by Māra: The Ten Symptoms of Being Held Fast

Chengguan judges the ten gates of leaving obstruction behind to be, in their first five, making clear that practice is completed by leaving obstruction behind, and in the last five, making clear the sustaining that comes of leaving obstruction behind. From this gate on is the set that concerns sustaining. All ten phrases are states, not behaviors: indolence, aspiration and desire narrow and mean, contentment with a small portion of practice, accepting one and not the rest, not giving rise to the great vow, delighting to dwell in what is at rest and extinguished and cutting off the afflictions, forever cutting off birth-and-death, forsaking the practice of a bodhisattva, not transforming sentient beings, doubting and slandering the true Dharma. The most startling are the three in the middle — delighting to dwell in what is at rest and extinguished, forever cutting off birth-and-death: these sound exactly like right cultivation, and yet they are listed under being held by māra. Chengguan glosses this gate, saying, “here at the first, it is the sustaining of the obstruction that is enmity” — so what these ten phrases list is the look of being held fast by the obstruction of enmity, not a list of crimes. Why? To clear away this misreading one must look at the direction of the whole set: what this stretch speaks of is a bodhisattva, and if a bodhisattva stops at settling himself alone, then he is held fast. Where it comes to ground: the most dangerous moment for one who cultivates is often not indolence, but ‘I have had enough already.’

Gate 31. Being Held by the Buddhas: After the Casting Off

This gate, like the one before, carries on from what precedes: “If the bodhisattvas are able to cast off these ways of being held by māra, then they obtain ten kinds of being held by the buddhas.” The ten phrases turn each one of those over: first giving rise to the mind, upholding the mind in life after life without forgetting it, keeping watch on the affairs of the māras and leaving them far behind, hearing of the perfections and cultivating as they were spoken, knowing the suffering of birth-and-death and not loathing it, contemplating the profound Dharma and obtaining measureless fruit, speaking the dharma of the two vehicles for sentient beings without realizing and grasping it, delighting to contemplate the unconditioned without abiding within it, reaching the place of non-arising and yet manifesting the taking on of birth, and though realizing all-knowing wisdom yet setting going the practice of a bodhisattva and not cutting off the lineage of bodhisattvas. One can see that every phrase has the same structure: able to go in, and not stopping inside. Chengguan glosses this, saying, “it makes clear the practice that is able to treat. Because he leaves the wrong behind, he naturally accords with the right” — it is not that one first takes hold of the buddhas’ holding; it is that once the wrong departs, the right accords of itself. Clear away one misreading: “not realizing and grasping” is not being unable to realize; it is not grasping. Where it comes to ground: that one set of things you know — can you speak it to a person who needs only that set, without falling back into it yourself?

Gate 32. Being Held by the Dharma: The Ten Places Where the Dharma Holds Fast

The two gates before spoke of being held by māra and being held by the buddhas; this gate speaks of being held by the Dharma. The ten phrases are an utterly orthodox list of dharmas: the three seals of the Dharma (all conditioned activities impermanent, suffering, without self), the nirvāṇa at rest and extinguished, dependent origination, the arising and ceasing of the twelve links in forward and reverse order, the three gates of liberation bringing forth the vehicle of the śrāvakas, the dharma of no contention bringing forth the vehicle of the pratyekabuddhas, the six perfections and four means of gathering bringing forth the Great Vehicle, all ages being the realm of the wisdom of a buddha, and cutting off thought, casting away grasping, leaving the earlier and later bounds behind, and following along with nirvāṇa. This is a rare place in the whole stretch where why the three vehicles are the three vehicles is spoken through at one go. Chengguan divides the sequence of these ten phrases very finely: “the first four are the four seals of the Dharma; the next two are dependent arising in general and in particular; the next two are the great and the small; the last two are wisdom and cutting off.” Clear away one misreading: to set the three vehicles side by side is not to weigh them as equal, for the ninth phrase, “all lands, all dharmas, all sentient beings, and all ages are the realm of the wisdom of a buddha,” has already opened the measure between them. Where it comes to ground: only by knowing how the road another walks is established is it possible neither to hold it cheap nor to stray into it.

Gate 33. The Deeds Done While Dwelling in the Tuṣita Heaven: The First of the Eight Aspects

From this gate on we enter the eight aspects. Chengguan’s judgment: these nineteen gates make clear the practice of the fulfilled fruit made manifest, belonging to the position of wondrous awakening; but if one speaks strictly in terms of the fact, the first five of the eight aspects still belong to the position of the cause, and it is only because the eight aspects are all of them manifestings that they run through into the fruit. The first aspect is in the Tuṣita heaven, and all ten matters are speaking the Dharma and manifesting: speaking of weariness and leaving behind for the gods of the realm of desire; speaking of meditation and the wisdom of things as they truly are for the gods of the realm of form; entering the samādhi of the Adornment of Light and sending forth light and speaking the Dharma; seeing and being seen by the Tuṣita bodhisattvas of the ten directions and discoursing on the Dharma; speaking gates of Dharma according to their ground for the bodhisattvas who have gathered; with the two kinds of speech, gentle and rough, giving the māra Pāpīyān no opening; sending forth a great sound to gather the assembly of the gods and manifesting rare things; not forsaking his own place and yet going everywhere to the presence of the buddhas of the ten directions to receive consecration; raising up articles of offering and making offerings to the buddhas throughout the Dharma realm; bringing forth gates of Dharma like an illusion and like a shadow and making them glad according to their minds. Chengguan glosses this, saying, “the nineteen gates below make clear the practice of the fulfilled use of the fruit.” Clear away one misreading: the Tuṣita heaven is not a rest stop. Where it comes to ground: not one of these ten matters is for himself; that stretch before the accomplishing of the Way is already wholly for the benefit of others.

Gate 34. Ten Things Manifested in Descending to Birth: Ten Lights, Ten Things

The form of this gate is as orderly as a ritual manual: in eight of the ten things a light is sent forth from some place on the body (the seventh from the hall of the jewel-treasury, the eighth from the palaces and pavilions); the light has a name; it shines upon some class of sentient beings; and it accomplishes one particular thing. From the soles of the feet the light Adornment of Ease and Joy shines upon the evil destinies; from the white hair-tuft between the brows the light Awakening shines upon the bodhisattvas who practiced with him; from the right palm the light Pure Objective Realm moves and sets down the pratyekabuddhas and the māras and outsiders; from the two knees the light Pure Adornment shines everywhere upon the palaces of the gods; from the heart-treasury the light Banner That None Can Overcome summons the vajra-bearing strongmen; from the pores the light Discerning Sentient Beings; from the jewel-treasury hall the light Contemplating What Abides Well shines upon the royal palace where he is to be born; from the palaces and tiered pavilions the light Pure Adornment of All the Palaces shines upon the mother’s womb; from beneath the two feet the light Abiding Well prolongs the life-spans of the gods; and from among the secondary marks the light Adornment of the Eye manifests the eight aspects of one lifetime. Chengguan, outlining this stretch, says, “at length it is divided into ten: the first one gate is dwelling in the heaven; the next one gate is manifesting the passing away; the third, one gate, is entering the womb; the fourth, one gate, is dwelling in the womb; the fifth, three gates, is the first birth” — and this gate falls exactly within the section of “manifesting the passing away.” Clear away one misreading: the lights are not a background effect; every one of them has a definite work to do. Where it comes to ground: the tenth light is the most worth turning over — it lets people see at one and the same time the dwelling in the womb, the first birth, the leaving of home, the accomplishing of the Way, the subduing of māra, the turning of the wheel of the Dharma, and the entering of nirvāṇa: the sequence of a whole lifetime appearing together within a single light.

Gate 35. Ten Matters of Dwelling in the Womb: Why a Buddha Must Dwell in the Womb

This gate is one of the few in the whole stretch that answer ‘why’ directly. The very first reason is quite direct: in order to bring to accomplishment sentient beings of small mind and mean understanding, and not to let them suppose that this bodhisattva is born of transformation of himself and that his wisdom and roots of good did not come from cultivation. So dwelling in the womb is a piece of evidence — this road is one that is walked. The other nine matters: ripening the roots of good of his parents and kin; entering and dwelling in the womb rightly mindful and without disorder; constantly expounding the Dharma within the womb; gathering a great assembly within the womb; manifesting the most excellent taking on of birth among human beings; the sentient beings of the three-thousandfold world seeing him as one sees a face in a bright mirror; the bodhisattvas of the final birth from other quarters coming to meet and the Treasury of Vast Wisdom being expounded; entering the samādhi Treasury Free of Defilement and manifesting a great palace within the womb; raising up articles of offering and making offerings to the buddhas of the ten directions. Reading to this point Chengguan too first puts the question out plainly: “Suppose someone asks: among the four kinds of birth, birth by transformation is the highest, and a buddha is the most excellent; why then birth from a womb?” Clear away one misreading: the womb is not a limitation. The scriptural text says that within the womb there is a vast tiered pavilion adorned with great maṇi jewels, and that bodhisattvas of the ten directions come and meet there. Where it comes to ground: a circumstance that limits you need not shrink what you do.

Gate 36. The Exceedingly Subtle Resorts: Everything Is Inside the Womb

The gate before said that things can be done within the womb; this gate pushes it to the limit: within the mother’s womb manifesting the first giving rise to the mind of awakening on to the ground of consecration, manifesting dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven, manifesting the first birth, the stage of a youth, dwelling in the royal palace, leaving home, austerities and the accomplishing of perfect awakening, the turning of the wheel of the Dharma, parinirvāṇa; and the last phrase is “manifesting the greatly subtle” — all the practices of a bodhisattva and the measureless and diverse gates of the masterful spiritual power of all the tathāgatas. The sequence of a whole lifetime, all of it manifested at once within the womb. It is precisely on this ground that Li Tongxuan reads the eight aspects as “all in one time”; he says that the Tathāgata’s appearing in the world, from beginning to end, never departs from the very brink of an instant, and that dwelling in the womb, dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven, the first birth, leaving home, accomplishing the Way, turning the wheel of the Dharma, and entering nirvāṇa are all in one time. Chengguan says “all alike manifested together at one time within a single mark,” and Fazang “all alike manifested together at one time within the womb” — the three houses say the same: the outlines have a sequence, what is manifested is simultaneous. Chengguan glosses this, saying, “this makes clear the ten matters of dwelling in the womb. The first one manifests the positions in general; the next eight make clear the manifesting of the seven aspects,” and explaining the name of the gate he says, “deep, secret, and hard to know, and therefore named subtle.” Clear away one misreading: do not read it as a display of spiritual penetration; the name the scriptural text gives is “resort,” a place of resorting into.

Gate 37. Ten Kinds of Birth: The Ten Things at the Time of Birth

Of the ten kinds of birth the first nine phrases are all “born …”: born leaving delusion far behind and rightly mindful and rightly knowing; born sending forth a net of light that shines everywhere; born abiding in the final existence and taking on a later body no more; born neither arising nor being set going; born knowing the three realms to be like an illusion; born manifesting his body everywhere in the ten directions; born with a body that realizes the wisdom of all-knowing wisdom; born with a body that sends forth the light of the buddhas and universally awakens beings; born with a body that enters the samādhi of contemplating with great wisdom. The fourth phrase is the crucial one — “born neither arising nor being set going.” Born and yet not born: this one phrase gathers up all eight before and after it. The tenth phrase turns into narrative: when the bodhisattva is born he shakes all the buddha-lands, liberates all sentient beings, extinguishes all the evil destinies, outshines and eclipses all the māras, and measureless bodhisattvas all come and gather. Chengguan glosses this, saying, “it makes clear the mark of the first birth. Here at the first it is set forth properly, that is, the time of the birth from the right side” — what this gate speaks of is the mark at the time of birth. Clear away one misreading: this gate is not a description of auspicious portents at a nativity, for the closing sentence of the scriptural text gives the purpose — “manifested in this way for the sake of taming sentient beings.” Where it comes to ground: every visible mark is set up for the sake of the one who looks.

Gate 38. Smiling and Inwardly Vowing: The Ten Thoughts Before the Smile

This gate is very peculiar: it takes one facial expression apart into ten thoughts. After every thought comes the same sentence: “with glad delight he smiles and inwardly vows.” The ten thoughts are: the world is sunk in the mire of desire and apart from me alone none is able to save them; the world is blinded by the afflictions and I alone am complete in wisdom; with this body of borrowed name I shall obtain the dharma-body of a Tathāgata; contemplating everywhere the Brahmā gods on to the gods of Great Mastery, who all take themselves to have great powers of wisdom; sentient beings have long planted roots of good and today have all fallen away from them; though the seeds sown are few the fruit obtained is very much; sentient beings who receive the Buddha’s teaching will surely obtain benefit; the bodhisattvas who practiced with him in the past are stained and attached to other affairs and do not obtain the merits of the Buddha-dharma; the gods and humans who gathered with him in the past are to this day still in the stage of the ordinary person and yet do not weary of it; and being touched by the light of all the tathāgatas and glad and comforted twice over. Chengguan settles the time and place of this gate for us: “second, manifesting the smile, for the reason that it is at the time of walking the seven steps” — the smile is nowhere else but exactly at the seven steps. Clear away one misreading: the first two thoughts sound like self-conceit, but look at the eighth and the ninth — those who practiced with him have fallen behind, those who gathered with him are still where they were: there is sorrow within this smile. Where it comes to ground: compassion without a little gladness cannot be sustained; gladness without a little sorrow turns into pride.

Gate 39. Walking Seven Steps: The Ten Layers of Meaning in the Seven Steps

Why seven steps? The scriptural text gives ten reasons: to manifest the power of a bodhisattva; to manifest the giving of the seven riches; to fulfill the vow of the earth spirits; to manifest the mark of passing beyond the three realms; to manifest that the most excellent practice surpasses the practice of the elephant-king, the bull-king, and the lion-king; to manifest the mark of the adamantine ground; to manifest that he means to give sentient beings the power of bravery; to manifest the cultivating of the jewels of the seven limbs of awakening; to manifest that the dharma he has obtained is not taught to him by another; to manifest that in the world he is the most excellent and beyond compare. Two of them fasten directly upon the “seven” — the seven noble riches and the seven limbs of awakening. Chengguan glosses this, saying, “that is, at the first birth, upon the ground, in each of the ten directions he walks seven steps, for the reason that it shows his mastery and rarity.” Clear away one misreading: this gate is not explaining a detail of history. The closing sentence of the scriptural text is still “manifested in this way for the sake of taming sentient beings” — the seven steps are one sentence of Dharma shown for people to see. Where it comes to ground: of these ten phrases, the one that comes home to oneself most is the ninth, “the dharma he has obtained is not taught to him by another” — that portion of view you rely on, was it heard from someone, or walked out?

Gate 40. Dwelling in the Stage of a Youth: Why There Must Be a Childhood

Of the ten matters the first three are all the arts of the world: letters, reckoning, drawings and books, and seals and signets; elephants and horses, carriages, bows and arrows, and swords and halberds; writing and discoursing, board games and amusements. Why must a bodhisattva have penetrating mastery of these? The words the scriptural text uses are “in order to make manifest his penetrating mastery” — it is to show that he has mastered them, not that he needs to learn them. The fourth matter turns to “leaving far behind the faults of all sorts in the deeds of body, speech, and mind”; the fifth is entering concentration, abiding in the gate of nirvāṇa, and pervading the ten directions; and after that come power and form surpassing those of the gods, making those absorbed in the joys of desire glad and delighted in the Dharma, honoring the true Dharma and diligently making offerings to the buddhas, and obtaining the aid of the buddhas and receiving the light of the Dharma. Chengguan glosses this, saying, “the youth is already within the royal palace, but this gate makes clear the virtue and the arts he harbors in his youth, showing that he is utterly beyond compare” — the stage of a youth and the following gate are both within the royal palace, and the difference is that this gate speaks of the virtue and arts harbored in his early years. Clear away one misreading: the arts of the world are listed here not as an ornament, for the eighth phrase gives their use — “in order to make sentient beings who are absorbed in the joys of desire glad and delighted in the Dharma.” Where it comes to ground: whether those worldly skills of yours are an obstruction or a doorway of drawing in depends on what you do with them.

Gate 41. Manifesting Dwelling in the Royal Palace: Living in the Place That Looks Least Like Cultivation

Among the ten reasons one is the plainest of all: “for the reason that he follows along with the minds of the sentient beings of the age of the five turbidities.” And one is the deepest: “for the reason that he means to manifest that the power of a bodhisattva’s great majestic virtue is able to enter samādhi within the deep palace.” The royal palace is where the joys of desire are at their height, and it is precisely for that reason that being able to enter samādhi within it shows the power. The other eight phrases: ripening the roots of good of sentient beings who practiced with him in former ages; showing the power of a bodhisattva’s roots of good; manifesting the implements of joy of a bodhisattva’s great majestic virtue; fulfilling the intent of sentient beings who vowed with him in former ages; fulfilling the wishes of his father and mother, his kin, and his retinue; making offerings to the tathāgatas with music that sends forth the sound of the wondrous Dharma; abiding within the palace in a subtle and wondrous samādhi and manifesting everything from the accomplishing of buddhahood to nirvāṇa; and following along with and guarding the dharma of the buddhas. Chengguan, outlining these two gates, says, “they make clear the practice of being at home and the same as the common, and both are the mark of dwelling in the royal palace” — dwelling in the stage of a youth and dwelling in the royal palace are alike the practice of being at home and the same as the common. Clear away one misreading: dwelling in the royal palace is not a stage of compromise. Where it comes to ground: whether one can cultivate has less to do with whether the surroundings are pure than one imagines; the scriptural text’s evidence is this — he entered samādhi there.

Gate 42. Manifesting the Leaving of Home: The Ten Reasons for Leaving Home

The gate before dwelt in the palace, this gate leaves home, and the scriptural text makes the joint itself: after the bodhisattva of the final body has in this way manifested dwelling in the royal palace, only then does he leave home. The ten reasons: weariness of dwelling at home; making sentient beings attached to home forsake it; following along with faith and delight in the road of the noble ones; proclaiming and praising the merit of leaving home; manifesting the forever leaving behind of the view of the two extremes; making sentient beings leave behind the joys of desire and of self; first manifesting the mark of coming forth from the three realms; manifesting that he is master of himself and does not belong to another; showing that he is about to obtain a Tathāgata’s ten powers and fearlessnesses; and that for the bodhisattva of the final body the dharma ought by rights to be thus. The tenth phrase is the most interesting — because the dharma is from the first thus. Chengguan, outlining these two gates, says, “they make clear the practice of forsaking home in expectation of the Way. The first makes clear the leaving of home; the latter shows the cultivating” — leaving home and austerities are one set, the first making clear the forsaking and the second the cultivating. Clear away one misreading: among these ten phrases there is not one that says ‘because one cannot cultivate at home.’ The real weight lies in the fifth phrase, “manifesting the forever leaving behind of the view of the two extremes,” and the eighth, “manifesting that he is master of himself and does not belong to another.” Where it comes to ground: whether one leaves home is one matter; leaving the view of the two extremes behind and not belonging to another is the matter that everyone has to do.

Gate 43. Manifesting the Practice of Austerities: Whom Are the Austerities Shown To?

Of the ten reasons for austerities not one is ‘because austerities work.’ They are: bringing to accomplishment sentient beings of mean understanding; pulling out the wrong views of sentient beings; making those who do not believe in the recompense of deeds see the recompense of deeds; following along with the dharma of a defiled world, as it ought by rights to be; manifesting that he can endure toil and hardship and diligently cultivates the Way; making sentient beings delight in seeking the Dharma; for the sake of sentient beings attached to the joys of desire and of self; manifesting that the bodhisattva’s setting going of practice is most excellent and that even to the final birth he does not forsake vigor; making sentient beings delight in the dharma of stillness and grow their roots of good; and awaiting the ripening of the faculties of the gods and the people of the world. Chengguan gives each phrase a still shorter label — spurring on the indolent; making them know that for the Dharma one forgets hunger; showing that attachment to joy is not the Way; diligence from beginning to end; and of the last phrase he says, “as for austerities that await the occasion, they show that his compassion is deep.” He also collates one variant: at this place the Jin recension reads “in order to make sentient beings of the time to come give rise to vigor,” and he says that in the present recension the words about vigor are joined into the phrase before and that one phrase is missing. Clear away one misreading: austerities here are a means of teaching, not the Way itself. Where it comes to ground: those habits of hard practice upon you — for whose sake are they?

Gate 44. Going to the Place of the Way: Walking Toward That Tree

Chengguan says that the five gates from going to the place of the Way onward are “the practice of accomplishing the Way and entering realization,” and for this gate he points out three reasons why: it shows the forsaking of the wrong and the turning to the right; it shows that the cause is perfected and turns toward the fruit; and it shows that this practice is the last of the practices. All ten matters happen “when going to the place of the Way”: shining upon all the worlds; shaking all the worlds; manifesting his body everywhere in all the worlds; awakening all the bodhisattvas and the sentient beings who practiced with him in former ages; manifesting all the adornments of the place of the Way; manifesting a body with bearing and the adornments of the tree of awakening according to what the minds of sentient beings desire; seeing present before him all the tathāgatas of the ten directions; at every raising and setting down of the foot constantly entering samādhi and in thought after thought accomplishing buddhahood with no gap between; the kings of the eight classes of beings not knowing of one another and yet each raising up all sorts of offerings; and with unobstructed wisdom universally contemplating all the tathāgatas cultivating the practice of a bodhisattva and accomplishing perfect awakening. Clear away one misreading: the phrase most to be looked at is the eighth — accomplishing buddhahood in thought after thought, not accomplishing it only upon arrival. Where it comes to ground: road and fruit are not two stretches; every step of the walking is itself the accomplishing.

Gate 45. Sitting at the Place of the Way: After the Sitting Down

Chengguan divides this gate: the first four are the adorning of the place, the next three are the manifesting of the marks of the three kinds of deed, and the last three are the completing of virtue — “first, fulfilling what he himself can realize, wisdom appearing and confusion perished; second, receiving the place where the buddhas dwell, being about to accord with and be one with the Dharma realm; third, great compassion of one substance, and therefore able to aid everywhere.” The ten matters: shaking all the worlds in all sorts of ways; shining evenly upon all the worlds; extinguishing the sufferings of the evil destinies; causing all the worlds to be made of adamant; universally contemplating the lion-seats of all the tathāgatas; a mind like empty space with nothing discriminated; manifesting a body with bearing according to what is fitting; abiding securely in accordance with the adamantine samādhi; receiving the pure and wondrous place held by the spiritual power of all the tathāgatas; and with the power of his own roots of good being able to aid all sentient beings. On the fifth phrase Chengguan has a note of collation: the Jin recension reads “contemplating the roar of the lion of all the buddhas,” a difference of one word between seat and roar. Clear away one misreading: the sixth phrase, “his mind is like empty space, with nothing discriminated,” does not collide with the shaking and shining of the first four — the outward marks move while the mind does not discriminate, and this is precisely the bone of this gate.

Gate 46. The Unprecedented Matters of Sitting at the Place of the Way: Ten Rare Things Felt from Without

Chengguan says that this gate is “making clear the rarity felt from without, the foretoken of the great fruit” — the first four are the answer of the outer realm to him, while the last six are the bodhisattva’s own doing: entering samādhi, obtaining the dhāraṇī, raising offerings, abiding in wisdom. The ten matters: the tathāgatas of the ten directions appearing before him, raising their right hands and praising the unsurpassed guide; all the tathāgatas guarding him in thought and giving him majestic power; the bodhisattvas who practiced with him in former ages gathering round and making offerings; the grasses, trees, thickets, and forests and other things without feeling bending their bodies and lowering their shadows toward the place of the Way; entering the samādhi of Contemplating the Dharma Realm, which makes all his practices complete; obtaining the dhāraṇī Highest Treasury of the Ocean of Subtle Light Free of Defilement; raising up surpassing and wondrous offerings and making offerings to the buddhas everywhere; abiding in the most excellent wisdom and fully knowing the faculties and intentions of all sentient beings; entering the samādhi Good Awakening, which makes his body fill the three times and the realm of empty space; and obtaining the unobstructed great wisdom of the light free of defilement, which makes his deeds of body universally enter the three times. On the first phrase the layer of the speaker is to be noticed — that praise is Samantabhadra relating the words of the buddhas of the ten directions, and not a tathāgata of the present assembly speaking. Clear away one misreading: the things without feeling bending their bodies and lowering their shadows is not a mythological ornament; it runs on the same road as the doctrine of the grasses and trees earlier being of one Dharma realm.

Gate 47. Manifesting the Subduing of Māra: Why “Manifesting”

Every phrase of this gate uses the two words “manifesting,” and Chengguan explains particularly why: because they were long ago subdued; because the māra-kings are for the most part great bodhisattvas; and because there is no evil māra able to distress a buddha. And he draws a comparison as well: it is like a jackal — how should it be able to shake out its might before a lion? So the subduing of māra is played for people to see. The ten reasons: the sentient beings of a turbid age delighting in battle, and therefore showing his majestic virtue; cutting off the doubts of the gods and the people of the world; teaching, transforming, and taming the armies of the māras; making those who delight in battle-arrays gather to look on and be tamed in mind; showing that none in the world can match his majestic power; setting going the power of bravery of sentient beings; pitying the sentient beings of the last age; showing that even up to the place of the Way there are still armies of māra, and only after this is the realm of māra passed beyond; showing that the working of the afflictions is weak and feeble while the power of the roots of good of great loving-kindness is strong; and following along with the dharma practiced in a turbid and evil world. Clear away one misreading: the eighth phrase is the crucial one — right up to the place of the Way there are still māras coming; this is not failure, this is a message for those who come after. Where it comes to ground: that there is still interference when one has cultivated to the very end is the normal state, not a going backward.

Gate 48. Accomplishing the Powers of a Tathāgata: The Threshold Is at This Phrase

This is the turning point of the whole stretch. Here Chengguan judges: only from this gate on is it truly the fulfilled fruit, and all that precedes is the perfected cause. He says that this gate is “that is, perfect awakening appearing before him,” and he uses the three paths to range what is before and after: the two gates before (the unprecedented matters and the subduing of māra) serve as the uninterrupted path, this gate as the path of liberation, and the two gates further back (going to the place of the Way and sitting at the place of the Way) as the path of skillful means. He outlines the ten phrases too: the first, no obstruction not stilled; the next two, no cause not perfected; the next two, no fruit not fulfilled; the next three, no virtue not universal; the last two, no buddha not the same — and therefore the name Tathāgata is concluded. The closing sentence of the scriptural text answers to it exactly: “If the bodhisattvas are complete in these ten powers, then they are named the Tathāgata, the Worthy One, the Perfectly Awakened One.” Clear away one misreading: this “is named” is a conclusion drawn by Samantabhadra, not a Tathāgata calling himself so. Where it comes to ground: between cause and fruit there is no leap, for every one of the ten phrases hangs upon a “for the reason that” — every one of them has its whence.

Gate 49. Turning the Great Wheel of the Dharma: The Wheel and the Turning

Chengguan first explains the name: “flowing forth in perfect penetration is what is meant by wheel; from me to another is what is named turning.” The wheel is the perfect penetration and flowing forth of the Dharma; the turning is from me to another. Then he sets up a measure: the Lesser Vehicle, fastens the four practices of eye, wisdom, clarity, and awakening to the four truths; this scripture shows the ten practices that are inexhaustible, and they should be fastened to ten truths and so make a hundred practices. This is the Huayan way of reckoning brought to bear upon the turning of the wheel of the Dharma. The ten matters the scriptural text lists with ordinal numbers: the wisdom of the four fearlessnesses; the four eloquences and sounds that accord; being well able to open up the marks of the four truths of what is real; following along with the unobstructed liberation of the buddhas; making the minds of sentient beings all give rise to pure faith; that his words are not spent in vain and are able to pull out the poisoned arrows of suffering; being sustained by the power of the vow of great compassion; that his sound pervades the ten directions; that through asaṃkhyeya kalpas he speaks the Dharma without cease; and that whatever dharma he speaks is able to set going the faculties, the powers, the way of awakening, meditative concentration, liberation, and samādhi. Chengguan outlines them thus: the first two, that what turns is fully perfect; the next two, that what is turned is deep and wondrous; the next two, that faith is produced and suffering pulled out; the next two, that the cause is deep and the measure vast; the last two, that the time is far and the benefit high. Clear away one misreading: the subject of this gate is already the Tathāgata, but it is still Samantabhadra who is relating it.

Gate 50. Sowing the White and Pure Dharmas: Why Not One Phrase Is Spent in Vain

The four words “sowing the white and pure dharmas” must be taken apart. Chengguan says that the white and pure dharmas are the very substance of the wheel that is turned, and that the sense of “sowing” is this: the buddha’s uncontaminated pure Dharma realm turns into the minds of sentient beings and becomes the seed of the perfuming of hearing, and therefore it is called sowing. And he fastens it to the sense of the perfuming of much hearing in the treatises of the lineage. So the reason that the speaking of the Dharma is not spent in vain is that the phrase that has been heard leaves a seed within the mind. The ten reasons: the power of his vow in the past; being sustained by great compassion; not forsaking sentient beings; wisdom masterful, speaking in accordance with what they delight in; surely meeting their occasion and never missing it; according with what is fitting and having no false speech; the wisdom that knows the three times understanding well; his body most excellent with none his equal; his speech masterful with none able to fathom it; and wisdom masterful, so that whatever words he sends forth are able to make people awaken. Chengguan says that the first is the cause in a former age and the rest are all present causes, and that the first six are the completeness of virtue while the last three are the surpassingness of use. Clear away one misreading: not being spent in vain does not say that the hearer understands on the spot; it says that the seed is already sown. Where it comes to ground: the one who speaks is responsible for meeting the time and the occasion; the season of the sprouting is not the speaker’s to govern.

Gate 51. Manifesting Parinirvāṇa: The Last Phrase Is Still Manifesting

Chengguan explains the gate of nirvāṇa in one sentence: “what is to be exhausted returns to the source.” The ten senses he judges phrase by phrase: the first two make clear the faults and troubles of birth-and-death (the first impermanence, the second no joy, and therefore it says not secure); the third makes clear that nirvāṇa is joy; the fourth overturns the impermanence of the form-body and takes the dharma-body as permanent — and on this phrase he has a note of collation, that the Jin recension reads “in order to make them seek the permanently abiding pure dharma-body,” and that the present recension lacks one word, permanent. The next three phrases make clear that birth-and-death is without self and not master of itself; the eighth makes clear that nirvāṇa is firm, that is, the masterful self, and carries the sense of permanence along with it; the ninth overturns the conditioned so as to make clear the virtue of purity; and of the last phrase, “the tenth makes clear that the dharma is just so.” And the closing sentence of the scriptural text is precisely this: when the buddhas have finished doing the work of a buddha, have fulfilled what they vowed, have turned the wheel of the Dharma, have taught and crossed over all who ought to be taught and crossed over, and when those bodhisattvas who ought to receive an honored title have been accomplished in receiving their predictions, then by the dharma it ought by rights to be thus that they enter the unchanging great parinirvāṇa. Clear away one misreading: in all ten senses not one says that the Buddha really was extinguished; every one of them is “manifesting.” Where it comes to ground: nirvāṇa in this gate is a lesson — the content of the lesson is impermanence, and the manner of the teaching is to manifest impermanence in himself.

Lineage

Whence the outline of the six positions came. The stage-names of the six sections into which the part of the speaking of this chapter is divided are, as Chengguan plainly says, an outline the ancient worthies of old made on the basis of the text of the separately circulating Dushi jing in order to outline this scripture, and he carried it on and explained by it. Therefore “the practice of the perfected cause and the fulfilled fruit” is a set of coordinates given by the commentators, and not what the scripture calls itself. The three houses reckon these fifty-one gates differently as well: Chengguan counts fifty-one by gates, Fazang counts five hundred and ten by phrases, and the Yanyi chao preserves besides two other reckonings, that of the whole chapter the first one hundred and ninety-six gates belong to the cause, or that if the eight aspects are taken as the fruit then the fruit has nineteen gates. The places of division are in truth two (the last four gates, and from dwelling in Tuṣita onward), and the manner of counting differs as gates or phrases; the ancient worthies each had their warrant, and they are recorded together without judgment.

The boundary between cause and fruit. Chengguan judges that only the four gates from “accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata” onward make clear the fulfilled fruit, while Fazang takes everything from “the ten kinds of dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven” onward as the practice of the fulfilled fruit made manifest. The boundaries of the two houses are not in the same place, but they are two standards: Chengguan, speaking strictly, has only the last four gates as fruit; Fazang, speaking by manifestation, draws the whole set of the eight aspects into the fruit — and Chengguan’s own Yanyi chao keeps both standards side by side (the first hundred and ninety-six gates belong to the cause; if the eight aspects are the fruit, the fruit has nineteen gates). Recorded without judgment.

The time of the eight aspects. All three houses say they are simultaneous: Chengguan says “all alike manifested together at one time within a single mark,” Fazang “all alike manifested together at one time within the womb,” and Li Tongxuan reads it as “all in one time,” saying that the Tathāgata’s appearing in the world, from beginning to end, never departs from the very brink of an instant, and that dwelling in the womb, dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven, the first birth, leaving home, accomplishing the Way, turning the wheel of the Dharma, and entering nirvāṇa are all in one time. The outlines have a sequence, what is manifested is simultaneous; the three houses are recorded together.

A few variant readings. In the gate of pure equanimity, the present recension lists eleven phrases in the text while the Jin recension draws the first two into one and makes ten; in the second phrase of the dharmas of cultivation, the Jin recension reads “awakening the gods”; in the ninth phrase of the austerities, the Jin recension reads “in order to make sentient beings of the time to come give rise to vigor,” and Chengguan says that the present recension lacks this one phrase; in the fifth phrase of sitting at the place of the Way, the Jin recension reads contemplating the roar of the lion of all the buddhas and not the lion-seat; in the fourth sense of manifesting parinirvāṇa, the Jin recension reads “in order to make them seek the permanently abiding pure dharma-body,” and Chengguan says that the present recension lacks one word, permanent. All the above are divergences the ancient worthies have already recorded, and they are recorded without judgment.

The correspondence with the separately circulating recension. The questions of the last round of the separately circulating Dushipin jing are exactly fifty-one, and they correspond one by one with the fifty-one gates of this stretch, the sequence of the gates being wholly the same while the translated wording is wholly different: contemplation is made beholding; universal contemplation is made looking round; rousing might is made stretching and yawning; deeds of conceit are made self-exaltation; deeds of wisdom are made deeds of the noble; manifesting parinirvāṇa is made taking the great extinction and crossing over. This is the hardest single set of outward evidence for the number and the sequence of the gates of this stretch, and it is precisely the recension upon which the ancient worthies relied in setting up the outline of the six sections.

Cross-reading with other chapters. The outline of the ten perfections in this stretch (the threefold collection of precepts, the three kinds of patience, and the three grounds of loving-kindness, compassion, joy, and equanimity) Chengguan repeatedly says has already been seen in the Chapter on the Ten Grounds and the Chapter on the Ten Practices; this stretch is an outline already set up walked through once more at the position of equal awakening, and not newly set up. The deeds of a buddha spoken of in the four gates of the fulfilled fruit and the ten senses of nature-origination spoken of in the Chapter on the Appearance of the Tathāgata are two ways of putting the question about one and the same set of materials: the one asks how one ought to see the body of a buddha, the other asks what the accomplishing of the way of a buddha, the turning of the wheel of the Dharma, and the taking of extinction are — the one asks about seeing, the other about doing.

The adducing of this chapter in the treatises of the Huayan school. When the later treatises of the Huayan school adduce this chapter, they for the most part adduce the name of the chapter in general without citing the scripture phrase by phrase: some adduce it to witness the sense of the inexhaustibility of the ten minds, some to witness the sense of the ten buddhas, and some to witness the sense of the ten ages. Among these the sense of the ten buddhas is the nearest to the two gates of this stretch, seeing the buddha and accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata; yet the places adduced do not fix the location phrase by phrase, and this is recorded.

考據Apparatus

普慧二百問之末番,普賢以五十一門答之。多數門以「有十種」標名(三十九門)、以「是為十」結數(四十三門),十三門以「若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來…」收益——體例整齊到近乎機械,而所攝之量卻自「十種觀察」一路推到「示般涅槃」,是全品最大的一子。澄觀於此下一個關鍵之判:五十一門並非全是果,「成如來力」以下四門方明果滿,前皆因圓;八相之前五仍屬因位,只因八相皆是示現,故通入果中。別行本《度世品經》之末番問目恰為五十一,與本門一一對位,是本節最硬的一組異譯證據。


一、科判定位

科判系統此段之位
底本 T279 三十九品品三十八 離世間品·說分第六段因圓果滿行五十一門(第八會 三會普光明殿 · 卷五十七–五十九〔T10 0304a11〕–〔0313b29 前〕)。起句「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種觀察」〔T10n0279 0304a11〕,訖句「佛子!是為如來、應、正等覺觀十義故,示般涅槃」〔0313b27〕。次段 s07 起於「此法門名」〔0313b29〕
澄觀《華嚴經疏》大文第六。科起〔T35n1735 0902a01〕–訖〔0907a05 前〕。判「五十一門答上因圓果滿」〔0902a01〕;分二:「初三十二門明因圓究竟,即等覺位」〔0902a05〕、後一十九門「明現果圓滿行,即妙覺位」〔0902a06〕。前中又三:「初一十四門,明因行體性」〔0902a07〕、次「八門,明方便造修」〔0902a08〕、後「十門,明因行除障」〔0902a09〕
法藏《探玄記》(六十華嚴疏)「五百一十句,答上第六因圓果滿行」〔T35n1733 0434c27〕。分二:「初三百二十句明因圓究竟行,亦是等覺位相似」〔0434c28〕、後「一百九十明現果圓滿行,亦是妙覺位相似」〔0435a01〕。法藏以句計,澄觀以門計,數異而骨同
李通玄《新華嚴經論》有本品之長科而不逐門釋:品釋段云「第五隨文釋義者,於此一品有七卷經,長科為十段」〔T36n1739 0942c23〕,於二千答明言「其文一一自具,不煩解釋,但如說修行」〔0943a12〕;另散引本節八相段二處:「如來正處胎時、住兜率天,并初生、出家學道、成菩提、轉法輪、入涅槃總一時」〔T36n1739 0772c14〕、「為劣解眾生,母胎出爾」〔0807b05〕。本節逐門之釋依其明文從闕(不煩解釋),非檢索之闕

因/果之界——澄觀云「若剋實而論」,「方明果滿,前皆因圓」〔T35n1735 0902a03〕,並自釋其所以:「以八相前五猶屬因故,為明八相皆示現故」〔0902a03〕。《演義鈔》復以全品二百門重算一過:「前一百九十六門皆屬因攝」〔T36n1736 0128a21〕,又存一算:「若以八相為果,果有一十九門,餘皆屬因」〔0128a21〕。因圓果滿之分唯繫澄觀(及其鈔),經文自身無此界標。

五十一門之次第(澄觀科)

科次門澄觀繫語
因行體性·起行方便1–4 觀察·普觀察·奮迅·師子吼「初二門意業觀察、次一門身業自在、後一門語業宣暢」〔0902a11〕
因行體性·十度行體5–14 施戒忍進禪慧·慈悲喜捨「先明六度、後顯四等」〔0902a23〕
方便造修15–22 義·法·福德具·智慧具·明足·求法·明了法·修行法「前五門明自分行、後三門明勝進行」〔0902c23〕
因行除障23–32 魔·魔業·捨離魔業·見佛·佛業·慢業·智業·魔所攝持·佛所攝持·法所攝持「前五門明離障成行、後五門明離障加持」〔0903c26〕
現果圓滿(八相)33–47 兜率所作業…示現降魔「道成證入行」〔0906b01〕(詣道場下五門)
果滿48–51 成如來力·轉大法輪·種白淨法·示般涅槃「即正覺現前」〔0906b22〕·「道成機熟,開甘露門故」〔0906b27〕·「應盡還源」〔0906c15〕

二、術語

漢古德傳梵(羅馬字·發音輔助)所徵精義
奮迅—「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種奮迅」〔T10n0279 0304b04〕威勢頓發之相。澄觀釋為「實德內充、威德外溢,如師子王奮迅威勢」〔T35n1735 0902a17〕;法藏亦作「實行內充,威德外溢」〔T35n1733 0435a19〕。別行本作「嚬申」〔T10n0292 0644a08〕
師子吼—「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種師子吼」〔T10n0279 0304b22〕決定無畏之宣唱。澄觀「既勇健無畏,則能決定宣唱」〔T35n1735 0902a20〕;法藏繫《涅槃經》「師子吼有十一事」〔T35n1733 0435a24〕
三輪清淨—「三輪清淨施,於施者、受者及以施物正念觀察如虛空故」〔T10n0279 0304c27〕施者·受者·施物三皆不可得。澄觀云「然其十度皆有三輪」〔T35n1735 0902b09〕
烏波提upadhi(音寫從闕·古傳義譯「有苦」)「捨一切烏波提涅槃法,能生一切菩薩行,修習不斷故」〔T10n0279 0306b18〕澄觀釋此云「烏波提者,此云有苦,即二乘涅槃」〔T35n1735 0903a05〕,並引《佛性論》明二乘無餘尚有三餘,「故非真無餘」〔0903a08〕
助道具—「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種福德助道具」〔T10n0279 0306b20〕成福智之緣。澄觀「福智即道,成福智緣,名助道具」〔T35n1735 0903a10〕
六念·六敬·六堅固法—「常憶六念,常行六敬,常隨順住六堅固法」〔T10n0279 0306c19〕澄觀繫「六念自持、六和眾法」〔T35n1735 0903a17〕,六堅取《本業》「謂信堅、法堅、修堅、德堅、項堅、覺堅」〔T35n1735 0903a19〕
明足—「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種明足」〔T10n0279 0307a25〕澄觀「惑闇斯亡、智解斯顯,故稱為明」〔T35n1735 0903b15〕;「足有二義:一智圓備故;二有進趣故」〔0903b15〕,即「十號明行足義」〔0903b17〕
第八人—「遠離八邪,向八正道,是第八人明了法」〔T10n0279 0307b17〕澄觀「四第八人者,即初果向」〔T35n1735 0903c06〕,並引《俱舍·賢聖品》疏「八忍之中從後數之為第八故」〔0903c07〕
蘊魔—「蘊魔,生諸取故」〔T10n0279 0307c11〕澄觀「蘊魔之名特由取著,下九例爾」〔T35n1735 0904a02〕;並云「然四魔直就體明,十魔多約執取」〔0904a06〕
慢業/智業—「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種慢業」〔T10n0279 0308b29〕·「若諸菩薩離此慢業,則得十種智業」〔0308c24〕一對顯之門。過慢·過過慢皆列於慢業十句中
甚微細趣—「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種甚微細趣」〔T10n0279 0311a29〕於母胎中同時具現初發心乃至般涅槃。別行本作「現其安詳」〔T10n0292 0644a17〕
熙怡微笑心自誓—「如是知已,熙怡微笑心自誓」〔T10n0279 0311b23〕八相中一節。別行本作「因欣笑」〔T10n0292 0644a17〕
成如來力—「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種成如來力」〔T10n0279 0313a15〕澄觀判此門為果滿之始,「即正覺現前」〔T35n1735 0906b22〕;門末「若諸菩薩具此十力,則名:如來、應、正等覺」〔T10n0279 0313a27 段末〕
白淨法—「於眾生心中種白淨法,無空過者」〔T10n0279 0313b09〕澄觀「白淨法者,即所轉輪體」〔T35n1735 0906c05〕,「謂佛無漏清淨法界轉入眾生心中,成聞熏種子,故名為種」〔0906c06〕,並繫《攝論》多聞熏習之義〔0906c08〕
阿耨多羅三藐三菩提anuttarā-samyak-saṃbodhi(音寫即古傳)『菩薩摩訶薩於阿耨多羅三藐三菩提』之句式為歸納語;本節相涉處在門3 結與門33 第六所作業〔T10n0279 0309b17 段內〕無上正等正覺
補伽羅pudgala(音寫即古傳)「無眾生、無壽命、無補伽羅」〔T10n0279 0304c05 段內〕數取趣·人我之異名

三、譬喻·修辭

(一) 五獸一喻之奮迅譜(門3)——本門前五句寄喻:牛王「映蔽一切天、龍、夜叉、乾闥婆等諸大眾故」·象王「心善調柔,荷負一切諸眾生故」·龍王「興大法密雲,耀解脫電光,震如實義雷」·大金翅鳥王「竭貪愛水,破愚癡㲉,搏撮煩惱諸惡毒龍」·大師子王「安住無畏平等大智以為器仗」〔T10n0279 0304b11〕。澄觀判其結構云「於中,前五寄喻、次四約法。上皆自分,後一勝進」〔T35n1735 0902a19〕——五喻之後轉為勇健·大智·陀羅尼·辯才四種約法之奮迅,末一「如來奮迅」則是勝進之果。

(二) 七步之自誓(門4 末句)——師子吼十句之末不再作「我當」之誓,而轉為一段敘事:最後生菩薩震動佛土,釋梵四王咸來讚請「唯願菩薩以無生法而現受生」,菩薩以無礙慧眼普觀世間,唱「一切眾生無如我者」,「即於王宮示現誕生,自行七步大師子吼」〔T10n0279 0304c11〕。九句是誓,第十句是誓之兌現——修辭上以「如說而作」收九誓,即澄觀所謂決定宣唱之極致。

(三) 幻·焰·水月一組十一喻(門18 第七)——「一切諸法如幻、如焰、如水中月、如夢、如影、如響、如像、如空中畫、如旋火輪、如虹霓色、如日月光」〔T10n0279 0307a02〕,前繫「觀察五蘊皆如幻事,界如毒蛇,處如空聚」。澄觀釋毒蛇之喻云「《淨名》、《涅槃》皆以四大為毒蛇,性違害故」〔T35n1735 0903b01〕,並引《俱舍》「大種謂四界」〔0903b03〕;釋空聚云「處如空聚者,中無人故」〔0903b04〕。

(四) 明鏡見面之喻(門35 第七事)——「三千大千世界眾生悉見菩薩,如明鏡中見其面像」〔T10n0279 0311a14 段內〕。處胎而遍現,是本節微細趣一門之伏筆。

(五) 空中鳥迹(門12 第十)——「菩薩摩訶薩知一切法如空中鳥迹,眾生癡翳不能照了」〔T10n0279 0306a01〕,以此起大悲,名為「真實智」——十清淨悲之末二句由「本性清淨」轉「真實智」,是慈悲門中由眾生緣入無緣之修辭收束。

(六) 野干與師子(澄觀釋門47)——澄觀釋降魔皆言「示」之故,云「亦如野干,豈能於師子前以振威勢」〔T35n1735 0906b12〕,並引《大乘方便經》為據〔0906b13〕。此喻不在經文,屬疏家之譬,繫屬明錄。


四、異譯對勘

本節之漢譯校本:實叉難陀 T279(底本·品三十八離世間品)· 佛馱跋陀羅 T278(晉譯六十華嚴·品三十三離世間品)· 竺法護 T292《度世品經》(西晉別行本)。四十華嚴 T293 唯譯品三十九,於本節無對校。

對勘一 五十一門之門目全表(底本 T279 / 別行本 T292)

《度世品經》普智菩薩末番問目逐字五十一問〔T10n0292 0644a07–0644a22〕,與底本五十一門一一對位,門序全同。

序T279 門名T292 問目序T279 門名T292 問目
1觀察觀27佛業佛事
2普觀察顧視28慢業自大
3奮迅嚬申29智業聖業
4師子吼師子吼30魔所攝持菩薩為魔所固
5清淨施施淨31佛所攝持佛建立
6清淨戒戒淨32法所攝持建立法
7清淨忍忍淨33住兜率天所作業處兜術天
8清淨精進進淨34下生現十事現歿兜術天
9清淨禪禪淨35處胎十事住胎
10清淨慧智淨36甚微細趣現其安詳
11清淨慈慈淨37十種生修生
12清淨悲哀淨38微笑心自誓因欣笑
13清淨喜喜淨39行七步行七步
14清淨捨護淨40處童子地現幼童
15義為義41現處王宮在中宮
16法為法42示現出家棄國捐王
17福德助道具積德43示行苦行勤苦行
18智慧助道具慧業44詣道場詣道場
19明足明達45坐道場坐樹下
20求法法典46坐道場未曾有事在樹下致未曾有法
21明了法行法47示現降魔降魔宮
22修行法奉法48成如來力成佛道
23魔為魔49轉大法輪轉法輪
24魔業魔業50種白淨法轉清白法
25捨離魔業棄魔業51示般涅槃如來、至真取大滅度
26見佛見佛

異文所繫——譯語系統全異而門數門序全同。T292 之末問作「何謂如來、至真取大滅度?」〔T10n0292 0644a22〕,答段起「如來、至真以作佛事觀見十義,現大滅度」〔0653a27〕,與底本「如來、應、正等覺作佛事已,觀十種義故,示般涅槃」〔T10n0279 0313b15〕場景結構全同:作佛事已·觀十義·示滅度。全錄不判:五十一之數,T279 以「門」現、T292 以「問」現、探玄以「句」計「五百一十」〔T35n1733 0434c27〕、澄觀以「門」計「五十一」〔T35n1735 0902a01〕,計法各異,非缺陷。

對勘二 五十一門之六十本對位全表(底本 T279 / 晉本 T278)

晉譯六十華嚴〈離世間品第三十三〉之七–之八(卷四十二–四十三)為本節之對位段,起〔T09n0278 0659a17〕迄〔0669b12〕。

二本譯語系統全異——底本之清淨施晉本作淨施,底本之福德助道具晉本作功德具,底本之處童子地晉本作現童子地——故對位一律取場景結構,不以底本之詞搜晉本。五十一門逐門首句對列如下。

校本逐字出處
佛馱 T278 · 門1 觀察佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種觀察。何等為十?所謂:觀察善業T09n0278 0659a17
佛馱 T278 · 門2 普觀察(60 作周遍觀察)菩薩摩訶薩有十種周遍觀察。何等為十?所謂:周遍觀察諸T09n0278 0659a29
佛馱 T278 · 門3 奮迅薩摩訶薩有十種奮迅。何等為十?所謂:色奮迅,於天、龍T09n0278 0659b14
佛馱 T278 · 門4 師子吼佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種師子吼。何等為十?所謂:我必成T09n0278 0659c05
佛馱 T278 · 門5 清淨施佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種淨施。何等為十?所謂:平等心施T09n0278 0659c25
佛馱 T278 · 門6 清淨戒菩薩摩訶薩有十種淨戒。何等為十?所謂:身淨戒,防護身T09n0278 0660a07
佛馱 T278 · 門7 清淨忍薩摩訶薩有十種淨忍。何等為十?所謂:若他罵辱悉能堪忍T09n0278 0660a18
佛馱 T278 · 門8 清淨精進薩摩訶薩有十種淨精進。何等為十?所謂:淨身業精進,恭T09n0278 0660a29
佛馱 T278 · 門9 清淨禪佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種淨禪。何等為十?所謂:常樂出家T09n0278 0660b22
佛馱 T278 · 門10 清淨慧佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種淨慧。何等為十?所謂:知因淨慧T09n0278 0660c06
佛馱 T278 · 門11 清淨慈佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種淨慈。何等為十?所謂:等心淨慈T09n0278 0660c21
佛馱 T278 · 門12 清淨悲佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種淨悲。何等為十?所謂:不共淨悲T09n0278 0661a04
佛馱 T278 · 門13 清淨喜佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種淨喜。何等為十?所謂:發菩提心T09n0278 0661a26
佛馱 T278 · 門14 清淨捨薩有十種淨捨。何等為十?所謂:一切眾生恭敬供養不生愛T09n0278 0661b10
佛馱 T278 · 門15 義佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種義。何等為十?所謂:多聞義,如T09n0278 0661b24
佛馱 T278 · 門16 法佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種法。何等為十?所謂:真實法,如T09n0278 0661c04
佛馱 T278 · 門17 福德助道具(60 作功德具)有十種功德具。何等為十?所謂:勸發眾生起菩提心是功德T09n0278 0661c14
佛馱 T278 · 門18 智慧助道具(60 作智具)子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種智具。何等為十?所謂:親近真實多T09n0278 0662a04
佛馱 T278 · 門19 明足佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種明足。何等為十?所謂:深知佛法T09n0278 0662b16
佛馱 T278 · 門20 求法佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種求法。何等為十?所謂:直心求法T09n0278 0662b26
佛馱 T278 · 門21 明了法薩摩訶薩有十種明了法。何等為十?所謂:隨順世間明了法T09n0278 0662c08
佛馱 T278 · 門22 修行法(60 作向法)薩有十種向法。何等為十?所謂:隨順恭敬善知識向法;覺T09n0278 0662c25
佛馱 T278 · 門23 魔佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種魔。何等為十?所謂:五陰魔,貪T09n0278 0663a06
佛馱 T278 · 門24 魔業佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種魔業。何等為十?所謂:忘失菩提T09n0278 0663a13
佛馱 T278 · 門25 捨離魔業菩薩摩訶薩有十種捨離魔業。何等為十?所謂:親近善知識T09n0278 0663b07
佛馱 T278 · 門26 見佛佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種見佛。何等為十?所謂:無著佛T09n0278 0663b18
佛馱 T278 · 門27 佛業佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種佛業。何等為十?所謂:勸化眾生T09n0278 0663b25
佛馱 T278 · 門28 慢業佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種慢業。何等為十?所謂:於尊重福T09n0278 0663c29
佛馱 T278 · 門29 智業佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種智業。何等為十?所謂:信解因緣T09n0278 0664b05
佛馱 T278 · 門30 魔所攝持佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種魔所攝持。何等為十?所謂:懈怠T09n0278 0664b25
佛馱 T278 · 門31 佛所攝持若菩薩摩訶薩能棄捨此魔所攝持,則得一切諸佛十種攝持。T09n0278 0664c05
佛馱 T278 · 門32 法所攝持(60 作法攝持)子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種法攝持。何等為十?所謂:一切行無T09n0278 0664c18
佛馱 T278 · 門33 兜率十所作業佛子!菩薩摩訶薩住兜率天有十種業。何等為十?所謂:菩T09n0278 0665a03
佛馱 T278 · 門34 下生現十事薩摩訶薩於兜率天臨命終時有十種示現事。何等為十?所謂T09n0278 0665c10
佛馱 T278 · 門35 處胎十事菩薩摩訶薩有十種事故降神母胎。何等為十?所謂:為教化T09n0278 0666b16
佛馱 T278 · 門36 甚微細趣(60 作微細趣)胎。若菩薩摩訶薩住此法門,則能示現菩薩十種微細趣。何T09n0278 0666c18
佛馱 T278 · 門37 十種生佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種生。何等為十?所謂:離愚癡生;T09n0278 0667a09
佛馱 T278 · 門38 微笑心自誓子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種大莊嚴而自莊嚴。何等為十?所謂:T09n0278 0667a20
佛馱 T278 · 門39 行七步(60 作遊行七步)佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種事故,遊行七步。何等為十?所謂T09n0278 0667b14
佛馱 T278 · 門40 處童子地佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種事故,現童子地。何等為十?所謂T09n0278 0667b24
佛馱 T278 · 門41 現處王宮(60 作中宮)佛子!菩薩摩訶薩現童子地已,有十種事故,現處中宮。何T09n0278 0667c09
佛馱 T278 · 門42 示現出家佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種事故,示現出家。何等為十?所謂T09n0278 0667c22
佛馱 T278 · 門43 示行苦行佛子!菩薩摩訶薩為十種事故,示現苦行。何等為十?所謂T09n0278 0668a04
佛馱 T278 · 門44 詣道場佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種事故,往詣道場。何等為十?所謂T09n0278 0668a16
佛馱 T278 · 門45 坐道場有十種事故,坐於道場。何等為十?所謂:種種震動一切剎T09n0278 0668b03
佛馱 T278 · 門46 坐道場未曾有事佛子!菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,有十種奇特未曾有法。何等為T09n0278 0668b13
佛馱 T278 · 門47 示現降魔佛子!菩薩摩訶薩坐道場時,有十種義故,示現降魔。何等T09n0278 0668c10
佛馱 T278 · 門48 成如來力(60 作覺如來力)佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種覺如來力,何等為十?所謂:超出T09n0278 0668c23
佛馱 T278 · 門49 轉大法輪十事佛子!如是得成如來、應供、等正覺已,能轉十行清淨法輪T09n0278 0669a08
佛馱 T278 · 門50 種白淨法十事佛子!如來、應供、等正覺清淨法輪,因十種白淨法故,轉T09n0278 0669a18
佛馱 T278 · 門51 示般涅槃佛子!如來、應供、等正覺究竟佛事已,有十種義,示現大T09n0278 0669a26

異文所繫——門數門序與底本全同,唯二處須誌:門2 晉本作「周遍觀察」,與底本「普觀察」門首句合看門序微異;門38 晉本此位無獨立「微笑」之句,以「十種大莊嚴而自莊嚴」句居其位。二處皆並錄不判。又門48 底本作「成如來力」而晉本作「覺如來力」,成/覺一字之異,關乎所顯是力之成抑力之覺,並錄不判。

對勘三 示般涅槃十義(底本 T279 / 別行本 T292)

校本逐字出處
實叉 T279以諸人、天樂著色身,為現色身是無常法,令其願住淨法身故T10n0279 0313b19 段內
竺法護 T292諸天人民著於色身,故現色身如是無常、法身常存,而為分別T10n0292 0653a29
校本逐字出處
實叉 T279示一切三有皆如幻化,不堅牢故T10n0279 0313b21 段內
竺法護 T292一切三界猶如幻化T10n0292 0653b03

異文所繫——底本作「三有」,別行本作「三界」;底本作「淨法身」,別行本作「法身常存」。澄觀於此正有一條晉本校語:釋第四義云「四翻色身無常,法身為常故」,並引「故晉經云」之文「令求常住淨法身故」,斷曰〔T35n1735 0906c18–c20〕「今缺「常」〔0906c20〕字」——澄觀明指底本此句較晉本少一「常」字。此為澄觀明判並錄;異文本身不判。

對勘四 澄觀所引晉經四處(六十本異文·澄觀親校)

所在門底本 T279澄觀引晉經出處
門22 修行法常為諸天之所覺悟修行法覺悟諸天T35n1735 0903c25
門43 示行苦行〔第九句〕為令眾生樂寂靜法,增長善根故欲令未來眾生發精進故T35n1735 0906a28
門45 坐道場坐道場時,普觀一切諸佛如來師子之座觀一切佛師子之吼T35n1735 0906b06
門51 示般涅槃令其願住淨法身故令求常住淨法身故T35n1735 0906c19

異文所繫——四處皆澄觀親校。門22 者澄觀先釋讀法「常為諸天者,為字去聲」,乃引晉經以證〔0903c24〕;門43 者澄觀云「今精進之言合在前句,缺斯一句」〔0906a28〕;門45 者座/吼一字之異,關乎所觀是佛座抑佛吼。並錄不判。

對勘五 清淨捨之句數(底本十一句·晉本十句)

澄觀釋門14 云「四、有十捨,文列十一,晉本初二但合為一」〔T35n1735 0902c20〕。底本此門標「十種清淨捨」而實列十一句,晉本併初二為一而成十。此為古德已誌之句數異,非底本之誤,據實錄之不判。

〔查無〕與檢索誠實記

  • 四十華嚴 T293:〔查無〕。該譯唯品三十九。
  • 世親《十地經論》T26n1522:〔查無〕。唯釋〈十地品〉,不涉本品。

五、宗義之經據〔眼〕

(一) 六位之配,唯繫古德之科,不繫經文——本品說分六段(十信·十住·十行·十迴向·十地·因圓果滿)之位名,經文自身一字不出。澄觀明言其所本:「古來諸德皆依彼文用科此經」〔T35n1735 0889c09〕,彼文即別行《度世品經》之六番問答。故本節之名「因圓果滿行」,是古德依《度世經》之科、澄觀承而釋之,非經之自標。讀本節之首要分際即在此:經只說「有十種觀察」,說到「示般涅槃」為止,位次是疏家給的坐標。

(二) 因圓與果滿之界在「成如來力」——澄觀之判:「方明果滿,前皆因圓」〔T35n1735 0902a03〕。其理由不在門之內容,而在示現之性質:「以八相前五猶屬因故,為明八相皆示現故」〔0902a03〕——八相之前五(入胎·住胎·初生·在家·出家)在因位,但因八相是一整組示現,故通收入果。《演義鈔》復存二算,一云「前一百九十六門皆屬因攝」〔T36n1736 0128a21〕,一云「若以八相為果,果有一十九門」〔0128a21〕。同一段經文有二種口徑:剋實則末四門為果(全品一百九十六門/本節四十七門屬因,同一界),示現則八相十九門為果;皆古德成說,並錄不判。

(三) 十度寄十以表圓——本節門5–10 施戒忍進禪慧,門11–14 慈悲喜捨,合為十度行體。澄觀立二義:一曰「皆言清淨者,離蔽障故,不同世間施戒等故」〔T35n1735 0902a24〕,二曰「然皆寄十表圓,各為一義」〔0902a25〕——每度各十,不是要窮盡該度之全部內容,是以十之數表其圓滿。四等之分工,澄觀繫云「六度多明自利,四等多約利他」〔0902c12〕,並以三緣(眾生緣·法緣·無緣)逐門切分:慈「前八眾生緣」〔0902c14〕、悲「前七眾生緣、次一法緣、後二無緣」〔0902c17〕、喜「初四眾生緣、次三法緣、後三無緣」〔0902c19〕、捨「初四眾生緣、次六法緣、後一無緣」〔0902c21〕。

(四) 十魔之義眼在「執取」不在「事物」——門23 十魔中赫然有善根魔·三昧魔·善知識魔·菩提法智魔。澄觀之釋是本節最鋒利的一段:「一蘊魔者,身為道器,體與佛同,豈即是魔?」〔T35n1735 0904a01〕,斷曰「蘊魔之名特由取著,下九例爾」〔0904a02〕,推而廣之:「是知以心分別萬法皆魔,何但此十」〔0904a03〕。四魔與十魔之別亦由此:「然四魔直就體明,十魔多約執取」〔0904a06〕。並下一轉語:「一切皆佛,豈捨魔界求佛界耶?」〔0904a05〕——魔之為魔,在取;不在被取之物。

(五) 轉法輪之量法:小乘四行繫四諦·今顯百行——澄觀釋門49 云「流演圓通目之為輪,自我之彼名之為轉」〔T35n1735 0906b28〕,繼而立華嚴之量:「小乘以眼智明覺四行繫於四諦,今顯無盡十行,應繫十諦以成百行」〔0906b29〕。四行繫於四諦是共教之量,十諦十行成百行是本經之數——一即多之量法於本節之落處。

(六) 種白淨法即聞熏種子——門50 澄觀釋「種」字:「謂佛無漏清淨法界轉入眾生心中,成聞熏種子,故名為種」〔T35n1735 0906c06〕,並繫《攝論》之義〔0906c08〕。此為疏家以承衍論典釋本經之處,繫屬明錄,非經文自說。


六、諸家異釋(古德·標宗)

澄觀《華嚴經疏》T35n1735(八十華嚴逐文·主)

科骨——「五十一門答上因圓果滿」〔0902a01〕;「初三十二門明因圓究竟,即等覺位」〔0902a05〕;後一十九門「明現果圓滿行,即妙覺位」〔0902a06〕。

門1–4 之三業配屬——「初二門意業觀察、次一門身業自在、後一門語業宣暢」〔0902a11〕。門1 內分「初二觀所化」〔0902a13〕「次四觀能化法,謂理果教行」〔0902a13〕「後三觀位,一超劣、二得位、三同果用」〔0902a14〕。門2 為「審慮周遍故」〔0902a15〕,「前六以六度治六蔽眾生」〔0902a15〕「後四雙明二利,謂順人證法、下化上成」〔0902a16〕。

十度逐門之瑜伽科配——十戒「前三律儀,七十攝生,餘皆攝善」〔0902b11〕;十忍「初三耐怨害忍,忍他三業惱害故」〔0902b16〕;十精進「二與第十是饒益有情,五是被甲,餘皆攝善」〔0902b21〕;十禪「初五方便、次一正定堅成、次二發慧斷惑」〔0902b27〕;十慧「初三解法,即加行慧;次四攝生,即後得慧;後三證理,即正體慧」〔0902c04〕。

法義二門之分——「若以能詮為法,則以所詮為義」〔0902c26〕;十義之首「一以修行為多聞之義,意在於修不在聞故」〔0902c29〕;十法之體「法有二義:一持自性、二軌生物解」〔0903a04〕。

明足之二義——「惑闇斯亡、智解斯顯,故稱為明」〔0903b15〕;「足有二義:一智圓備故;二有進趣故」〔0903b15〕;「即十號明行足義。果稱圓足,因為脚足」〔0903b17〕。

勝進三門——「一更求法要、二得已明了、三如說修行」〔0903b22〕;求法門末斷曰「離此十求皆邪求也」〔0903b27〕;明了法門「總以普賢勝智了知三乘凡聖差別」〔0903b28〕。

離障十門之科——「前五門明離障成行、後五門明離障加持」〔0903c26〕;十魔「能障道故」〔0904a01〕;十魔業「行此十事皆能訛善亦招天魔,故為其業」〔0904a11〕,並附一句自誡之語:「然觀此文,難免魔業,願諸後學審此省躬」〔0904a19〕;捨離魔業門「對障修治,故云捨離」〔0904a20〕,「然此十句,敵對反前,但略而不次耳」〔0904a21〕,並逐一標其所反(一反第五·二反第二·三反第七·四反第一·五反第四·六反第八·七反第三·八反第九·九反第十·十反第六〔0904a22–a25〕);見佛成行二門「由障離故,果現行成」〔0904a28〕。

八相段(存錄之末段)——苦行門逐句釋「五策懈怠眾生故」「六令知為法忘飢故」「七示著樂非道故」〔0906a26–a27〕,末句「十苦行待機者,顯悲深故」〔0906a29〕;詣道場下「五門,道成證入行」〔0906b01〕,其義「顯捨邪趣正故,因圓趣果故,行行後邊故」〔0906b03〕;坐道場門「初四嚴處。次三三業現相」〔0906b05〕;未曾有事門「明外感希奇,大果先兆故」〔0906b09〕;降魔門「正覺將顯,先摧邪故」〔0906b10〕,並釋「皆言示者,久已降故,魔王多是大菩薩故,無有惡魔能惱佛故」〔0906b10〕。

果滿四門——成如來力門「即正覺現前」〔0906b22〕,並以三道判前後:「前之二門當無間道,此當解脫道,更前二門即方便道」〔0906b22〕;十句之科「初一障無不寂、次二因無不圓、次二果無不滿、次三德無不普、後二佛無不同」〔0906b24〕。轉法輪門十句「初二能轉備圓、次二所轉深妙、次二生信拔苦、次二因深量廣、後二時遠益高」〔0906c03〕。種白淨法門「初一宿因,餘皆現因」〔0906c11〕。涅槃門「初二明生死過患」〔0906c16〕、「三明涅槃是樂,翻上無樂,以涅槃寂滅為真樂故」〔0906c17〕、「八明涅槃是堅,即自在我,亦兼常義」〔0906c25〕、「九翻有為以明淨德」〔0906c26〕、「上以四榮翻枯具遣八倒」〔0907a04〕、末句「十明法爾」〔0907a04〕。

《演義鈔》T36n1736

因果門數之異算——「前一百九十六門皆屬因攝」〔0128a21〕;「若以八相為果,果有一十九門,餘皆屬因」〔0128a21〕。並釋品名之二號:「名出世因果」者「品名離世間故」〔0128a23〕、「亦名成行因果」者「廢於位名,意在行故」〔0128a24〕。

法藏《探玄記》T35n1733(六十華嚴疏)

以句計數——「五百一十句,答上第六因圓果滿行」〔0434c27〕;「初三百二十句明因圓究竟行,亦是等覺位相似」〔0434c28〕;「一百九十明現果圓滿行,亦是妙覺位相似」〔0435a01〕;「初有一百四十門,明因行體性」〔0435a02〕。

三業配屬之異——「初二十明意業觀察、次十身業奮迅、後十語業哮吼」〔0435a06〕。門1 內分作「初三觀所化,一知業;二知報;三知根」〔0435a09〕——法藏作初三,澄觀作初二〔T35n1735 0902a13〕。

奮迅十句之別名系——「初一身勝、二心大、三教威、四行用、五破邪、六滅惑、七達法、八廣持、九具辯、十圓果」〔0435a21〕。

師子吼之《涅槃》繫——「依《涅槃經》,師子吼有十一事,具如彼說」〔0435a24〕。

十施之別名系——「一捨心施、二滿願、三一心、四了田、五無簡、六不著、七捨身財、八求大果、九益眾生、十淨三輪」〔0435b01〕。

十忍·十禪·十慧之科異——忍「初三耐怨害忍,忍他三業所惱故;次五安受苦忍」〔0435b08〕(澄觀作「次三安受苦忍」〔T35n1735 0902b17〕);禪「初四方便,一出俗、二近友、三在靜、四離鬧」〔0435b15〕(澄觀作「初五方便」〔0902b27〕);慧「初三解法慧,一解因不即果、二解緣不離果、三解果不斷常」〔0435b20〕。

李通玄《新華嚴經論》T36n1739

八相總一時之讀法——「如來正處胎時、住兜率天,并初生、出家學道、成菩提、轉法輪、入涅槃總一時」〔0772c14〕,其所依為「明如來出世始終不離剎那際」〔0772c13〕。又於他處引本品釋佛之胎生:「為劣解眾生,母胎出爾」〔0807b05〕。逐門科釋則〔查無〕。

誌錄不判

一、因果之界:澄觀「五十一門」而以「成如來力」下四門為果〔T35n1735 0902a02〕;《演義鈔》另存『一十九門為果』之算〔T36n1736 0128a22〕;法藏以句計「五百一十句」〔T35n1733 0434c27〕而以「十種住兜率天」下一百九十為果〔0434c29〕。澄觀之末四門與鈔之『前一百九十六門屬因』同一界(全品/本節之別而已);鈔之『十九門為果』與法藏之『住兜率天下一百九十』同一界;實為二界二口徑,非三種分界。

二、門1 內科:澄觀「初二觀所化」〔T35n1735 0902a13〕,法藏「初三觀所化」〔T35n1733 0435a09〕。

三、十忍之科:澄觀「次三安受苦忍」〔T35n1735 0902b17〕,法藏「次五安受苦忍」〔T35n1733 0435b09〕。

四、十禪之科:澄觀「初五方便」〔T35n1735 0902b27〕,法藏「初四方便」〔T35n1733 0435b15〕。

五、奮迅十句之名:澄觀不別立名而分寄喻·約法〔T35n1735 0902a19〕,法藏別立十名〔T35n1733 0435a21〕。

六、八相之時:三家皆言同時——澄觀「並一相中同時齊現」〔T35n1735 0905c21〕、法藏「並在胎內同時齊現」〔T35n1733 0438a02〕、李通玄「總一時」〔T36n1739 0772c15〕;科判有先後,所現同時。

七、清淨捨之句數:底本文列十一句,晉本併初二為一而成十〔T35n1735 0902c20〕。

八、示般涅槃第四義:底本作「令其願住淨法身故」,晉本作「令求常住淨法身故」,澄觀有明判:〔T35n1735 0906c20〕「今缺「常」〔0906c20〕字」。

以上諸異,皆古德成說,並錄;其中第八條係澄觀明判,不代判。


七、互讀·承衍

  • 本品內互讀:本節為說分六段之末段,前承十地行五十門(參見本帙〈十地行五十門〉),後接結勸·現瑞·證成·偈頌(參見本帙〈結勸·現瑞·證成·偈頌分〉)。澄觀六段之科依《度世品經》六番問答而立,故六段之為六段,其證在別行本而不在底本。
  • 與〈如來出現品〉互讀:本節果滿四門(成如來力·轉大法輪·種白淨法·示般涅槃)所說者為佛之現果,〈品三十七 如來出現品〉性起十義所說者為佛之出現。二段同以八相/十身為材而立意不同:出現品問『應云何見如來身』,本品問『何謂成佛道·轉法輪·取滅度』——一問見,一問作。
  • 與〈十地品〉互讀:本節十度之科(律儀·攝善·攝生三聚戒等)澄觀屢云「已如十地」〔T35n1735 0903c12;十忍段末作「餘如前判」〔0902b20〕〕,四等三緣之分「已見〈十地〉」〔0902c13〕;十慧之義「餘義如〈十行品〉所引」〔0902c11〕。本節之十度非新立,是十地·十行已立之科於等覺位之再一遍。
  • 華嚴宗論之承衍:《華嚴一乘教義分齊章》T45n1866〔0485b09〕「故說十心以顯無盡。如離世間品及第九地說」(十心·無盡義,泛引);T45n1868〔0514b02〕「謂十佛世界海及離世間品。明十佛義是也」(十佛義,近本節門26 十種見佛〔T10n0279 0308a21〕與門48 十種成如來力〔0313a15〕,然引處未逐句牒經);《華嚴經旨歸》T45n1871〔0594c10〕「總別合舉名為十世。具如離世間品說」(十世義,泛引)。三處皆泛引品名,不逐句定位,誌錄。
  • 承衍論典之闕:《攝論》唯由澄觀轉引(聞熏習之義〔T35n1735 0906c08〕),成唯識 T31n1585·瑜伽 T30n1579 於本節之逐句徵引〔查無〕,據實標闕,不強繫。
  • 檢索誠實記:T45n1883 內「離世間品」字樣機械零命中;此不證該論未涉本品,僅此檢索式未命中。

八、校本定位

  • 實叉 T279(底本):品三十八 離世間品·說分第六段 因圓果滿行五十一門,卷五十七–五十九〔T10n0279 0304a11〕起–〔0313b29 前〕訖。逐門首句出處:門1 觀察 0304a11 · 門2 普觀察 0304a21 · 門3 奮迅 0304b04 · 門4 師子吼 0304b22 · 門5 清淨施 0304c22 · 門6 清淨戒 0305a01 · 門7 清淨忍 0305a12 · 門8 清淨精進 0305a23 · 門9 清淨禪 0305b13 · 門10 清淨慧 0305b23 · 門11 清淨慈 0305c08 · 門12 清淨悲 0305c20 · 門13 清淨喜 0306a05 · 門14 清淨捨 0306a16 · 門15 義 0306b04 · 門16 法 0306b12 · 門17 福德助道具 0306b21 · 門18 智慧助道具 0306c13 · 門19 明足 0307a25 · 門20 求法 0307b04 · 門21 明了法 0307b13 · 門22 修行法 0307c01 · 門23 魔 0307c11 · 門24 魔業 0307c17 · 門25 捨離魔業 0308a10 · 門26 見佛 0308a21 · 門27 佛業 0308a27 · 門28 慢業 0308b29 · 門29 智業 0308c24 · 門30 魔所攝持 0309a14 · 門31 佛所攝持 0309a20 · 門32 法所攝持 0309b03 · 門33 兜率所作業 0309b17 · 門34 下生現十事 0310a19 · 門35 處胎十事 0310c27 · 門36 甚微細趣 0311b01 · 門37 十種生 0311b11 · 門38 微笑心自誓 0311b21 · 門39 行七步 0311c14 · 門40 處童子地 0311c23 · 門41 現處王宮 0312a09 · 門42 示現出家 0312a22 · 門43 示行苦行 0312b02 · 門44 詣道場 0312b12 · 門45 坐道場 0312b26 · 門46 未曾有事 0312c07 · 門47 示現降魔 0313a03 · 門48 成如來力 0313a15 · 門49 轉大法輪 0313a28 · 門50 種白淨法 0313b09 · 門51 示般涅槃 0313b16。卷界:卷五十八起於門5 之前〔0304c22 前〕· 卷五十九起於門35 之前〔0310c27 前〕。
  • 澄觀《疏》T35n1735:本段科起 0902a01 – 訖 0907a05 前。科骨 0902a01–a11 · 門1–2 釋 0902a12–a17 · 門3 釋 0902a17–a20 · 門4 釋 0902a20–a22 · 十度總義 0902a22–a27 · 十施釋 0902a27–b10 · 十戒釋 0902b10–b16 · 十忍釋 0902b16–b21 · 十精進釋 0902b21–b27 · 十禪釋 0902b27–c04 · 十慧釋 0902c04–c11 · 四等總義 0902c11–c14 · 慈悲喜捨釋 0902c14–c22 · 造修八門科 0902c22–c25 · 十義釋 0902c25–a03 · 十法釋 0903a03–a10 · 二助道具釋 0903a10–b14 · 明足釋 0903b14–b21 · 求法釋 0903b21–b27 · 明了法釋 0903b27–c23 · 修行法釋 0903c23–c25 · 離障十門科 0903c25–c29 · 十魔釋 0904a01–a10 · 十魔業釋 0904a10–a20 · 捨離魔業釋 0904a20–a27 · 見佛成行科 0904a27–b02。中段:佛業釋 0904c01–c02 · 離障加持五門科 0904c25–c26 · 十慢釋 0905a25 · 十智業釋 0905a26 · 外加持三門科 0905b01–b02 · 佛所攝持釋 0905b06–b07 · 法攝持釋 0905b08–b10 · 果用圓滿十九門科 0905b10–b15 · 入胎十事釋 0905c01–c02 · 微細趣釋 0905c19–c22 · 十種生釋 0905c22–c24 · 微笑釋 0905c24–c25 · 行七步釋 0906a03–a05 · 童子地二門科 0906a05–a07 · 出家二門科 0906a12–a13。末段:苦行釋 0906a22–b01 · 詣道場五門科 0906b01–b04 · 坐道場釋 0906b04–b09 · 未曾有釋 0906b09–b10 · 降魔釋 0906b10–b21 · 成如來力釋 0906b21–b26 · 轉法輪二門科 0906b26–c04 · 種白淨法釋 0906c04–c15 · 涅槃十義釋 0906c15–0907a05。
  • 《演義鈔》T36n1736:因果門數異算 0128a20–a22 · 品名二號釋 0128a23–a25。
  • 法藏《探玄記》T35n1733(六十疏·卷十七):科起 0434c27 – 所錄訖 0435b21。科骨 0434c27–0435a05 · 門1 釋 0435a07–a13 · 門2 釋 0435a13–a19 · 門3 釋 0435a19–a23 · 門4 釋 0435a23–a29 · 十施釋 0435a29–b03 · 十戒釋 0435b03–b07 · 十忍釋 0435b07–b11 · 十精進釋 0435b11–b15 · 十禪釋 0435b15–b19 · 十慧釋 0435b19–b21。b21 以下未錄。
  • 李通玄《論》T36n1739:〔查無〕逐門釋。散引二處:八相總一時 0772c10–c24 · 引本品釋胎生 0807b03–b07。
  • 竺法護 T292《度世品經》(別行本):卷五–卷六(卷第五題 0644a04,a07 即本番問起)。末番五十一問 0644a07–a22 · 普賢受請答起 0644a23 · 十事觀 0644a25–b05 · 十顧視 0644b06–b15 · 兜率下生第八至第十事 0650b20–0650c07 · 轉清白法末句 0653a25 · 取大滅度十義 0653a27–b08 · 法門名句 0653b09。
  • 佛馱 T278(晉譯六十華嚴·品三十三離世間品之六–之八·卷四十一–四十三):本節之對位段〔T09n0278 0659a17〕起–〔0669b12〕訖。逐門首錨:門1 觀察 0659a17 · 門2 普觀察 0659a29 · 門3 奮迅 0659b14 · 門4 師子吼 0659c05 · 門5 清淨施 0659c25 · 門6 清淨戒 0660a07 · 門7 清淨忍 0660a18 · 門8 清淨精進 0660a29 · 門9 清淨禪 0660b22 · 門10 清淨慧 0660c06 · 門11 清淨慈 0660c21 · 門12 清淨悲 0661a04 · 門13 清淨喜 0661a26 · 門14 清淨捨 0661b10 · 門15 義 0661b24 · 門16 法 0661c04 · 門17 福德助道具 0661c14 · 門18 智慧助道具 0662a04 · 門19 明足 0662b16 · 門20 求法 0662b26 · 門21 明了法 0662c08 · 門22 修行法 0662c25 · 門23 魔 0663a06 · 門24 魔業 0663a13 · 門25 捨離魔業 0663b07 · 門26 見佛 0663b18 · 門27 佛業 0663b25 · 門28 慢業 0663c29 · 門29 智業 0664b05 · 門30 魔所攝持 0664b25 · 門31 佛所攝持 0664c05 · 門32 法所攝持 0664c18 · 門33 兜率十所作業 0665a03 · 門34 下生現十事 0665c10 · 門35 處胎十事 0666b16 · 門36 甚微細趣 0666c18 · 門37 十種生 0667a09 · 門38 微笑心自誓 0667a20 · 門39 行七步 0667b14 · 門40 處童子地 0667b24 · 門41 現處王宮 0667c09 · 門42 示現出家 0667c22 · 門43 示行苦行 0668a04 · 門44 詣道場 0668a16 · 門45 坐道場 0668b03 · 門46 坐道場未曾有事 0668b13 · 門47 示現降魔 0668c10 · 門48 成如來力 0668c23 · 門49 轉大法輪十事 0669a08 · 門50 種白淨法十事 0669a18 · 門51 示般涅槃 0669a26。門名依晉本者見二目對勘二。
  • 四十華嚴 T293:〔查無〕。該譯唯品三十九。
  • 異讀:本單元 T279 範圍〔0304a11〕–〔0313b28〕內大正校記 32 條,逐條照錄不判(底本【大】|他本異讀;多本異讀以/分列):〔0304b07〕耀【大】|曜【宮】 · 〔0304b10〕㲉【大】|聲【聖】 · 〔0304b13〕怨【大】*|冤【明】*(*同校並繫〔0304b20〕之怨字) · 〔0304c23〕揀【大】|簡【宮】 · 〔0305a07〕善【大】|菩【聖】 · 〔0305a24〕師【大】|佛【聖】 · 〔0305a28〕心【大】|一【聖】 · 〔0305b17〕禪【大】|離【聖】 · 〔0305c03〕法【大】|清【聖】 · 〔0305c10〕揀【大】|簡【宮】【聖】 · 〔0306c16〕獷【大】|曠【宮】 · 〔0307a04〕霓【大】|蜺【宮】 · 〔0307c21〕吝【大】|悕【聖】 · 〔0307c29〕使【大】|使使【聖】 · 〔0308a02〕術【大】|述【宋】【元】【明】【宮】【聖】 · 〔0308c14〕顰【大】|嚬【宮】【聖】 · 〔0310a18〕間【大】|聞【聖】 · 〔0310a24〕于【大】|於【明】 · 〔0310b05〕徙【大】|從【聖】 · 〔0310b13〕妓【大】|伎【聖】 · 〔0310b15〕卍【大】|卐【宋】【元】【明】 · 〔0310c12〕曰:眼【大】|日眼【元】/曰月【明】 · 〔0311b23〕免【大】|勉【宋】【元】【明】 · 〔0311c09〕同共【大】|共同【宋】【元】【明】【宮】 · 〔0312a17〕妓【大】|伎【聖】 · 〔0312b13〕耀【大】*|曜【宮】*(*同校並繫〔0312b28〕之耀字) · 〔0312b26〕有【大】|時有【宮】 · 〔0312b27〕謂【大】|詣【聖】 · 〔0312b27〕震【大】|振【聖】 · 〔0312c01〕觀【大】|現【明】/觀【北藏-CB】(明註曰現北藏作觀) · 〔0313a16〕業【大】|無此字【聖】 · 〔0313b26〕別【大】|莂【明】/䇷【宮】。(*=大正星號同校,該校並繫本文其餘同字處;T279 XML 於此類未出 corresp 重出位,故只呈星號、不另造錨)
  • 原印注存目:3 條(大正原印注/CBETA 編者按語·無 <app> 校異·不入上列大正校記之數):〔0309a01+〕宮本魔波乃至一切一千二百二十三字斷缺 p. 310 C段第二行參照 · 〔0309a01+〕明註曰流通本他下有眾字 · 〔0312b27+〕以下聖語藏副本校合。
  • 異讀補記:CBETA 回改 5 條(不入上列大正校記之數):〔0304b23〕師【CB】【麗-CB】【磧-CB】|佛【大】 · 〔0307a29〕天【CB】【麗-CB】|大【大】/天【宋】【元】【明】 · 〔0308b03〕吝【CB】【麗-CB】|悋【大】 · 〔0311b23〕沒【CB】【麗-CB】|歿【大】 · 〔0312b10〕行;為令眾生……示行苦行(凡18字)【CB】|行【大】/行為令眾生樂……示行苦行(凡18字)【明】。
  • 異讀補記:大正原印注另有三條無異讀條對應,存目:0309001「宮本魔波乃至一切一千二百二十三字斷缺」(起〔T10n0279 0309c17〕)· 0309002「明註曰流通本他下有眾字」〔0309c23〕· 0312007「以下聖語藏副本校合」〔0312b29〕。夾注已於原典層剝除誌錄。「破愚癡㲉」〔T10n0279 0304b10 段內〕之「㲉」為 CBETA 造字,照錄不作正規化。底本「無有瘡疣、無有瘢痕」〔0307a13 段內〕作「瘢痕」二字無造字;澄觀《疏》釋此句作「餘過未滅為瘢󰇝」〔T35n1735 0903b09〕,其「󰇝」為造字,亦照錄。

The last of the rounds of the two hundred questions of Universal Wisdom, which Samantabhadra answers with fifty-one gates. Most of the gates set up their name with 「有十種」 tr. “there are ten kinds of” (thirty-nine gates) and conclude the number with 「是為十」 tr. “these are the ten” (forty-three gates), while thirteen gates gather up the benefit with 「若諸菩薩安住此法,則得如來…」 tr. “if the bodhisattvas abide securely in this dharma, then they obtain the Tathāgata’s …” — a form so orderly as to be nearly mechanical, and yet the mass of what it takes in is pushed all the way from 「十種觀察」 tr. “ten kinds of contemplation” to 「示般涅槃」 tr. “manifesting parinirvāṇa,” making it the largest single unit in the whole chapter. Here Chengguan lays down one decisive judgment: the fifty-one gates are not all of them the fruit; only the four gates from 「成如來力」 tr. “accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata” onward make clear the fulfilled fruit, and all before is the perfected cause; the first five of the eight aspects still belong to the position of the cause, and it is only because the eight aspects are all of them manifestings that they run through into the fruit. The questions of the last round of the separately circulating Dushipin jing are exactly fifty-one and correspond one by one with these gates, and this is the hardest single set of evidence from the parallel translations for this section.


I. Doctrinal Outline and Placement

Outline systemThe place of this stretch within it
The base text T279, in thirty-nine chaptersChapter 38, Detachment from the World · the sixth section of the part of the speaking, the fifty-one gates of the practice of the perfected cause and the fulfilled fruit (the eighth assembly, the third gathering at the Hall of Universal Light · fascicles 57 to 59 〔T10 0304a11〕–〔0313b29, ending before this〕). The opening sentence 「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種觀察」 tr. “Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of contemplation” 〔T10n0279 0304a11〕, the closing sentence 「佛子!是為如來、應、正等覺觀十義故,示般涅槃」 tr. “Sons of the Buddha! This is how the Tathāgata, the Worthy One, the Perfectly Awakened One contemplates ten senses and manifests parinirvāṇa” 〔0313b27〕. The next section, s07, begins at 「此法門名」 tr. “this gate of Dharma is named” 〔0313b29〕
Chengguan, Huayan jing shuThe sixth main division. The outline begins 〔T35n1735 0902a01〕 and ends 〔0907a05, ending before this〕. He judges 「五十一門答上因圓果滿」 tr. “fifty-one gates answer the perfected cause and the fulfilled fruit above” 〔0902a01〕, and divides it in two: 「初三十二門明因圓究竟,即等覺位」 tr. “the first thirty-two gates make clear the ultimacy of the perfected cause, that is, the position of equal awakening” 〔0902a05〕, and the latter nineteen gates 「明現果圓滿行,即妙覺位」 tr. “make clear the practice of the fulfilled fruit made manifest, that is, the position of wondrous awakening” 〔0902a06〕. Within the former there are three again: 「初一十四門,明因行體性」 tr. “the first fourteen gates make clear the substance and nature of the practice of the cause” 〔0902a07〕, next 「八門,明方便造修」 tr. “eight gates make clear skillful means and cultivation” 〔0902a08〕, last 「十門,明因行除障」 tr. “ten gates make clear the removing of obstruction in the practice of the cause” 〔0902a09〕
Fazang, Tanxuan ji (the commentary on the sixty-fascicle Avataṃsaka)「五百一十句,答上第六因圓果滿行」 tr. “five hundred and ten phrases, answering the sixth above, the practice of the perfected cause and the fulfilled fruit” 〔T35n1733 0434c27〕. He divides it in two: 「初三百二十句明因圓究竟行,亦是等覺位相似」 tr. “the first three hundred and twenty phrases make clear the practice of the ultimacy of the perfected cause, and are likewise similar to the position of equal awakening” 〔0434c28〕, and the latter 「一百九十明現果圓滿行,亦是妙覺位相似」 tr. “one hundred and ninety make clear the practice of the fulfilled fruit made manifest, and are likewise similar to the position of wondrous awakening” 〔0435a01〕. Fazang counts by phrases and Chengguan by gates: the numbers differ and the frame is the same
Li Tongxuan, Xin Huayan jing lunThere is a long outline of the chapter, but no gate-by-gate explanation: the passage explaining the chapter says 「第五隨文釋義者,於此一品有七卷經,長科為十段」 tr. “fifth, explaining the sense following the text: this one chapter has seven fascicles of scripture, outlined at length into ten sections” 〔T36n1739 0942c23〕, and of the two thousand answers it says plainly 「其文一一自具,不煩解釋,但如說修行」 tr. “the text of each is complete in itself; it need not be explained, only practised as it is spoken” 〔0943a12〕; besides, it adduces the stretch of the eight aspects in this section in two scattered places: 「如來正處胎時、住兜率天,并初生、出家學道、成菩提、轉法輪、入涅槃總一時」 tr. “the very time when the Tathāgata is dwelling in the womb, dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven, together with the first birth, leaving home to study the Way, accomplishing awakening, turning the wheel of the Dharma, and entering nirvāṇa — all in one time” 〔T36n1739 0772c14〕, and 「為劣解眾生,母胎出爾」 tr. “for the sake of sentient beings of mean understanding, he comes forth from a mother’s womb thus” 〔0807b05〕. Within the whole treatise a gate-by-gate explanation of this section yields mechanically no hits; the absence is recorded as it stands

The boundary between cause and fruit — Chengguan says 「若剋實而論」 tr. “if one speaks strictly in terms of the fact,” 「方明果滿,前皆因圓」 tr. “only then is the fulfilled fruit made clear, and all before is the perfected cause” 〔T35n1735 0902a03〕, and explains for himself why this is so: 「以八相前五猶屬因故,為明八相皆示現故」 tr. “because the first five of the eight aspects still belong to the cause, and in order to make clear that the eight aspects are all of them manifestings” 〔0902a03〕. The Yanyi chao reckons it once more over the two hundred gates of the whole chapter: 「前一百九十六門皆屬因攝」 tr. “the first one hundred and ninety-six gates all belong to what is taken in under the cause” 〔T36n1736 0128a21〕, and it preserves another reckoning as well: 「若以八相為果,果有一十九門,餘皆屬因」 tr. “if the eight aspects are taken as the fruit, the fruit has nineteen gates and the rest all belong to the cause” 〔0128a21〕. The division of perfected cause and fulfilled fruit is fastened to Chengguan alone (and to his Chao); the scriptural text itself has no such boundary marker.

The sequence of the fifty-one gates (Chengguan’s outline)

Order in the outlineGatesChengguan’s words of attribution
The substance and nature of the practice of the cause · the skillful means of setting going practice1–4 contemplation · universal contemplation · rousing might · the lion’s roar「初二門意業觀察、次一門身業自在、後一門語業宣暢」 tr. “the first two gates are the contemplation of the deeds of mind, the next one gate is the mastery of the deeds of body, the last one gate is the proclaiming of the deeds of speech” 〔0902a11〕
The substance and nature of the practice of the cause · the substance of the practice of the ten perfections5–14 giving, precepts, patience, vigor, meditation, wisdom · loving-kindness, compassion, joy, equanimity「先明六度、後顯四等」 tr. “first the six perfections are made clear, then the four evennesses are shown” 〔0902a23〕
Skillful means and cultivation15–22 meaning · dharma · the equipment of merit · the equipment of wisdom · clarity and footing · seeking the Dharma · dharmas clearly understood · dharmas of cultivation「前五門明自分行、後三門明勝進行」 tr. “the first five gates make clear the practice of one’s own portion, the last three gates make clear the practice of advancing beyond” 〔0902c23〕
The removing of obstruction in the practice of the cause23–32 māra · the deeds of māra · forsaking the deeds of māra · seeing the buddha · the deeds of a buddha · the deeds of conceit · the deeds of wisdom · being held by māra · being held by the buddhas · being held by the Dharma「前五門明離障成行、後五門明離障加持」 tr. “the first five gates make clear that practice is completed by leaving obstruction behind, the last five gates make clear the sustaining that comes of leaving obstruction behind” 〔0903c26〕
The fulfilled fruit made manifest (the eight aspects)33–47 the deeds done in the Tuṣita heaven … manifesting the subduing of māra「道成證入行」 tr. “the practice of accomplishing the Way and entering realization” 〔0906b01〕 (the five gates from going to the place of the Way onward)
The fulfilled fruit48–51 accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata · turning the great wheel of the Dharma · sowing the white and pure dharmas · manifesting parinirvāṇa「即正覺現前」 tr. “that is, perfect awakening appearing before him” 〔0906b22〕 · 「道成機熟,開甘露門故」 tr. “the Way accomplished and the occasion ripe, for the reason that the gate of sweet dew is opened” 〔0906b27〕 · 「應盡還源」 tr. “what is to be exhausted returns to the source” 〔0906c15〕

II. Terminology

ChineseSanskrit as handed down by the ancient worthies (roman letters · an aid to pronunciation)What is adducedThe essential sense
Rousing might—「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種奮迅」 tr. “Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of rousing might” 〔T10n0279 0304b04〕The mark of majesty breaking forth all at once. Chengguan explains it as 「實德內充、威德外溢,如師子王奮迅威勢」 tr. “the real virtue filling within and the majestic virtue brimming over without, as the lion-king rouses his might” 〔T35n1735 0902a17〕; Fazang likewise has 「實行內充,威德外溢」 tr. “the real practice filling within, the majestic virtue brimming over without” 〔T35n1733 0435a19〕. The separately circulating recension reads 「嚬申」 tr. “stretching and yawning” 〔T10n0292 0644a08〕
The lion’s roar—「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種師子吼」 tr. “Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of lion’s roar” 〔T10n0279 0304b22〕The decisive and fearless proclamation. Chengguan: 「既勇健無畏,則能決定宣唱」 tr. “since he is brave and strong and without fear, he is therefore able to proclaim with decision” 〔T35n1735 0902a20〕; Fazang fastens it to the Niepan jing, 「師子吼有十一事」 tr. “the lion’s roar has eleven matters” 〔T35n1733 0435a24〕
The purity of the three spheres—「三輪清淨施,於施者、受者及以施物正念觀察如虛空故」 tr. “giving with the three spheres pure, for the reason that with regard to the one who gives, the one who receives, and the thing given he rightly and mindfully contemplates, as though they were empty space” 〔T10n0279 0304c27〕Giver, receiver, and thing given, all three unobtainable. Chengguan says 「然其十度皆有三輪」 tr. “yet all ten of the perfections have their three spheres” 〔T35n1735 0902b09〕
Upadhiupadhi (the transcription is not handed down · the sense-translation transmitted of old is 「有苦」 tr. “having suffering”)「捨一切烏波提涅槃法,能生一切菩薩行,修習不斷故」 tr. “the dharma of forsaking all upadhi-nirvāṇa, for the reason that it is able to set going all the practices of a bodhisattva and to cultivate them without cease” 〔T10n0279 0306b18〕Chengguan explains this, saying 「烏波提者,此云有苦,即二乘涅槃」 tr. “as for upadhi, here it is rendered having suffering, that is, the nirvāṇa of the two vehicles” 〔T35n1735 0903a05〕, and cites the Foxing lun to make clear that in the nirvāṇa without remainder of the two vehicles there are yet three remainders, 「故非真無餘」 tr. “and therefore it is not truly without remainder” 〔0903a08〕
Equipment that aids the path—「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種福德助道具」 tr. “Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of equipment of merit that aids the path” 〔T10n0279 0306b20〕The conditions that complete merit and wisdom. Chengguan: 「福智即道,成福智緣,名助道具」 tr. “merit and wisdom are the path itself; the conditions that complete merit and wisdom are named equipment that aids the path” 〔T35n1735 0903a10〕
The six recollections · the six points of harmony · the six firm dharmas—「常憶六念,常行六敬,常隨順住六堅固法」 tr. “ever recalling the six recollections, ever practicing the six points of harmony, ever abiding in accord with the six firm dharmas” 〔T10n0279 0306c19〕Chengguan fastens them as 「六念自持、六和眾法」 tr. “the six recollections by which one upholds oneself, the six dharmas of harmony among the assembly” 〔T35n1735 0903a17〕, and for the six firm ones takes the Benye: 「謂信堅、法堅、修堅、德堅、項堅、覺堅」 tr. “namely firmness of faith, firmness of dharma, firmness of cultivation, firmness of virtue, firmness of the crown, firmness of awakening” 〔T35n1735 0903a19〕
Clarity and footing—「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種明足」 tr. “Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of clarity and footing” 〔T10n0279 0307a25〕Chengguan: 「惑闇斯亡、智解斯顯,故稱為明」 tr. “the darkness of confusion has perished and the understanding of wisdom has appeared, and therefore it is called clarity” 〔T35n1735 0903b15〕; 「足有二義:一智圓備故;二有進趣故」 tr. “footing has two senses: first, for the reason that wisdom is full and complete; second, for the reason that there is advancing” 〔0903b15〕, that is, 「十號明行足義」 tr. “the sense of ‘complete in clarity and conduct’ among the ten titles” 〔0903b17〕
The eighth person—「遠離八邪,向八正道,是第八人明了法」 tr. “leaving far behind the eight wrong ones and turning toward the eightfold right path — this is the dharma clearly understood by the eighth person” 〔T10n0279 0307b17〕Chengguan: 「四第八人者,即初果向」 tr. “fourth, as for the eighth person, this is the one directed toward the first fruit” 〔T35n1735 0903c06〕, and he cites the commentary on the Chapter on the Worthy and the Noble of the Jushe, 「八忍之中從後數之為第八故」 tr. “for the reason that among the eight forbearances it is counted from the last as the eighth” 〔0903c07〕
The māra of the aggregates—「蘊魔,生諸取故」 tr. “the māra of the aggregates, for the reason that from it the various graspings are set going” 〔T10n0279 0307c11〕Chengguan: 「蘊魔之名特由取著,下九例爾」 tr. “the name māra of the aggregates comes solely from grasping and attachment, and the nine below follow the same example” 〔T35n1735 0904a02〕; and he says 「然四魔直就體明,十魔多約執取」 tr. “yet the four māras are made clear straight in terms of substance, while the ten māras are for the most part taken in terms of grasping and attachment” 〔0904a06〕
Deeds of conceit / deeds of wisdom—「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種慢業」 tr. “Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of deed of conceit” 〔T10n0279 0308b29〕 · 「若諸菩薩離此慢業,則得十種智業」 tr. “if the bodhisattvas leave these deeds of conceit behind, then they obtain ten kinds of deed of wisdom” 〔0308c24〕A pair of gates that show each other. The conceit of excess and the conceit beyond excess are both listed among the ten phrases of the deeds of conceit
The exceedingly subtle resorts—「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種甚微細趣」 tr. “Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of exceedingly subtle resort” 〔T10n0279 0311a29〕Within the mother’s womb, manifesting all at once everything from the first giving rise to the mind on to parinirvāṇa. The separately circulating recension reads 「現其安詳」 tr. “manifesting his calm composure” 〔T10n0292 0644a17〕
With glad delight he smiles and inwardly vows—「如是知已,熙怡微笑心自誓」 tr. “knowing this, with glad delight he smiles and inwardly vows” 〔T10n0279 0311b23〕One section within the eight aspects. The separately circulating recension reads 「因欣笑」 tr. “thereupon he smiles with delight” 〔T10n0292 0644a17〕
Accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata—「佛子!菩薩摩訶薩有十種成如來力」 tr. “Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata” 〔T10n0279 0313a15〕Chengguan judges this gate to be the beginning of the fulfilled fruit, 「即正覺現前」 tr. “that is, perfect awakening appearing before him” 〔T35n1735 0906b22〕; at the end of the gate, 「若諸菩薩具此十力,則名:如來、應、正等覺」 tr. “if the bodhisattvas are complete in these ten powers, then they are named the Tathāgata, the Worthy One, the Perfectly Awakened One” 〔T10n0279 0313a27, at the end of the passage〕
The white and pure dharmas—「於眾生心中種白淨法,無空過者」 tr. “sowing the white and pure dharmas within the minds of sentient beings, with not one spent in vain” 〔T10n0279 0313b09〕Chengguan: 「白淨法者,即所轉輪體」 tr. “as for the white and pure dharmas, they are the very substance of the wheel that is turned” 〔T35n1735 0906c05〕, 「謂佛無漏清淨法界轉入眾生心中,成聞熏種子,故名為種」 tr. “that is, the buddha’s uncontaminated pure Dharma realm turns into the minds of sentient beings and becomes the seed of the perfuming of hearing, and therefore it is named sowing” 〔0906c06〕, and he fastens it to the sense of the perfuming of much hearing in the She lun 〔0906c08〕
Anuttarā-samyak-saṃbodhianuttarā-samyak-saṃbodhi (the transcription is itself what was handed down)The sentence-pattern ‘bodhisattva-mahāsattvas, with regard to unsurpassed perfect awakening’ is a summarizing formulation; the places in this section it bears on are the conclusion of gate 3 and the sixth deed done of gate 33 〔T10n0279 0309b17, within the passage〕Unsurpassed perfect awakening
Pudgalapudgala (the transcription is itself what was handed down)「無眾生、無壽命、無補伽羅」 tr. “without a sentient being, without a life-span, without a pudgala” 〔T10n0279 0304c05, within the passage〕One who takes up the destinies · another name for the self in a person

III. Similes and Rhetoric

(i) The register of the rousing might of five beasts and one simile (gate 3) — The first five phrases of this gate lodge the sense in similes: the bull-king, 「映蔽一切天、龍、夜叉、乾闥婆等諸大眾故」 tr. “for the reason that he outshines and eclipses all the great assemblies of gods, nāgas, yakṣas, gandharvas, and the rest”; the elephant-king, 「心善調柔,荷負一切諸眾生故」 tr. “for the reason that the nature of his mind is well tamed and gentle, and he bears the burden of all sentient beings”; the nāga-king, 「興大法密雲,耀解脫電光,震如實義雷」 tr. “raising up the dense clouds of the great Dharma, making the lightning of liberation flash, shaking forth the thunder of the meaning as it truly is”; the great garuḍa-king, 「竭貪愛水,破愚癡㲉,搏撮煩惱諸惡毒龍」 tr. “drying up the water of craving, breaking open the shell of delusion, seizing and snatching those venomous evil nāgas the afflictions”; the great lion-king, 「安住無畏平等大智以為器仗」 tr. “abiding securely in the fearless, even-minded great wisdom and taking it as his weapon” 〔T10n0279 0304b11〕. Chengguan judges the structure of it, saying 「於中,前五寄喻、次四約法。上皆自分,後一勝進」 tr. “within it, the first five lodge the sense in similes and the next four take it in terms of dharma. The above are all one’s own portion; the last is advancing beyond” 〔T35n1735 0902a19〕 — after the five similes it turns into the four rousing mights taken in terms of dharma, bravery and strength, great wisdom, the dhāraṇī, and eloquence, while the last, 「如來奮迅」 tr. “the rousing might of a Tathāgata,” is the fruit of advancing beyond.

(ii) The vow of the seven steps (the last phrase of gate 4) — The last of the ten phrases of the lion’s roar no longer makes a vow of 「我當」 tr. “I shall,” but turns into a stretch of narrative: the bodhisattva of the final birth shakes the buddha-lands, and Śakra, Brahmā, and the four kings all come to praise and entreat him, 「唯願菩薩以無生法而現受生」 tr. “we only pray that the bodhisattva, by the dharma of non-arising, may manifest the taking on of birth”; the bodhisattva, with the unobstructed eye of wisdom, universally contemplates the world and proclaims 「一切眾生無如我者」 tr. “among all sentient beings there is none that is my equal,” and 「即於王宮示現誕生,自行七步大師子吼」 tr. “straightaway he manifests his birth in the royal palace, walks seven steps of himself, and makes a great lion’s roar” 〔T10n0279 0304c11〕. Nine phrases are the vow, and the tenth phrase is the making good of the vow — rhetorically the nine vows are gathered up by 「如說而作」 tr. “doing as one has said,” which is the utmost of what Chengguan calls proclaiming with decision.

(iii) One set of eleven similes, illusion, heat-haze, and the moon in water (the seventh of gate 18) — 「一切諸法如幻、如焰、如水中月、如夢、如影、如響、如像、如空中畫、如旋火輪、如虹霓色、如日月光」 tr. “all dharmas are like an illusion, like a heat-haze, like the moon in water, like a dream, like a shadow, like an echo, like an image, like a painting in the sky, like a whirling wheel of fire, like the colors of a rainbow, like the light of the sun and the moon” 〔T10n0279 0307a02〕, fastened before it to 「觀察五蘊皆如幻事,界如毒蛇,處如空聚」 tr. “contemplating the five aggregates as all of them illusory affairs, the elements as venomous snakes, the sense-fields as an empty village.” Chengguan explains the simile of the venomous snakes, saying 「《淨名》、《涅槃》皆以四大為毒蛇,性違害故」 tr. “the Jingming and the Niepan both take the four great elements for venomous snakes, for the reason that their natures go against one another and do harm” 〔T35n1735 0903b01〕, and cites the Jushe, 「大種謂四界」 tr. “the great elements are the four elements” 〔0903b03〕; and explaining the empty village he says 「處如空聚者,中無人故」 tr. “as for the sense-fields being like an empty village, it is for the reason that there is no person within” 〔0903b04〕.

(iv) The simile of seeing a face in a bright mirror (the seventh matter of gate 35) — 「三千大千世界眾生悉見菩薩,如明鏡中見其面像」 tr. “the sentient beings of the three-thousandfold great-thousand world-system all see the bodhisattva, as one sees the image of one’s own face in a bright mirror” 〔T10n0279 0311a14, within the passage〕. To dwell in the womb and yet appear everywhere is the foreshadowing of the gate of the subtle resorts in this section.

(v) The track of a bird in the sky (the tenth of gate 12) — 「菩薩摩訶薩知一切法如空中鳥迹,眾生癡翳不能照了」 tr. “bodhisattva-mahāsattvas know that all dharmas are like the track of a bird flying through the sky, and that sentient beings are veiled by the film of delusion and cannot see it clearly” 〔T10n0279 0306a01〕, and by this great compassion is set going, named 「真實智」 tr. “the wisdom of what is real” — the last two phrases of the ten pure compassions turn from 「本性清淨」 tr. “the original nature is pure” into 「真實智」 tr. “the wisdom of what is real,” which is the rhetorical gathering up, within the gates of loving-kindness and compassion, of the passage from having sentient beings as one’s ground into having no ground.

(vi) The jackal and the lion (Chengguan explaining gate 47) — Chengguan, explaining why the subduing of māra is in every case said with 「示」 tr. “manifesting,” says 「亦如野干,豈能於師子前以振威勢」 tr. “it is also like a jackal — how should it be able to shake out its might before a lion” 〔T35n1735 0906b12〕, and cites the Dasheng fangbian jing as his warrant 〔0906b13〕. This simile is not in the scriptural text but belongs to the commentator’s similes, and the attribution is plainly recorded.


IV. Collation with Parallel Translations

The Chinese-translation witnesses for this section: Śikṣānanda T279 (the base text · chapter 38, Detachment from the World) · Buddhabhadra T278 (the Jin translation of the sixty-fascicle Avataṃsaka · chapter 33, Detachment from the World) · Dharmarakṣa T292, the Dushipin jing (the separately circulating recension of the Western Jin). The forty-fascicle Avataṃsaka T293 translated only chapter 39, and offers no collation for this section.

Collation One A full table of the gate-headings of the fifty-one gates (the base text T279 / the separately circulating recension T292)

The questions of the last round of Universal Knowing Bodhisattva in the Dushipin jing are verbatim fifty-one questions 〔T10n0292 0644a07–0644a22〕, corresponding one by one with the fifty-one gates of the base text, the sequence of the gates being wholly the same.

No.The gate-name in T279The question-heading in T292No.The gate-name in T279The question-heading in T292
1ContemplationBeholding27The deeds of a buddhaThe work of a buddha
2Universal contemplationLooking round28The deeds of conceitSelf-exaltation
3Rousing mightStretching and yawning29The deeds of wisdomThe deeds of the noble
4The lion’s roarThe lion’s roar30Being held by māraThe bodhisattva made fast by māra
5Pure givingPurity of giving31Being held by the buddhasThe buddhas’ establishing
6Pure preceptsPurity of the precepts32Being held by the DharmaEstablishing the Dharma
7Pure patiencePurity of patience33The deeds done while dwelling in the Tuṣita heavenBeing in the Tuṣita heaven
8Pure vigorPurity of vigor34Ten things manifested in descending to birthManifesting the passing away from the Tuṣita heaven
9Pure meditationPurity of meditation35Ten matters of dwelling in the wombAbiding in the womb
10Pure wisdomPurity of knowing36The exceedingly subtle resortsManifesting his calm composure
11Pure loving-kindnessPurity of loving-kindness37Ten kinds of birthBirth by cultivation
12Pure compassionPurity of pity38Smiling and inwardly vowingThereupon smiling with delight
13Pure joyPurity of joy39Walking seven stepsWalking seven steps
14Pure equanimityPurity of guarding40Dwelling in the stage of a youthManifesting a young child
15MeaningMaking meaning41Manifesting dwelling in the royal palaceBeing in the inner palace
16DharmaMaking dharma42Manifesting the leaving of homeAbandoning the realm and giving up kingship
17The equipment of merit that aids the pathAmassing virtue43Manifesting the practice of austeritiesThe practice of toil and hardship
18The equipment of wisdom that aids the pathThe works of insight44Going to the place of the WayGoing to the place of the Way
19Clarity and footingClear penetration45Sitting at the place of the WaySitting beneath the tree
20Seeking the DharmaThe canon of the Dharma46The unprecedented matters of sitting at the place of the WayAttaining unprecedented dharmas beneath the tree
21Dharmas clearly understoodDharmas of conduct47Manifesting the subduing of māraSubduing the palace of māra
22Dharmas of cultivationHonoring the Dharma48Accomplishing the powers of a TathāgataAccomplishing the way of a buddha
23MāraBeing māra49Turning the great wheel of the DharmaTurning the wheel of the Dharma
24The deeds of māraThe deeds of māra50Sowing the white and pure dharmasTurning the pure and white dharma
25Forsaking the deeds of māraCasting away the deeds of māra51Manifesting parinirvāṇaThe Tathāgata, the Utterly True One, takes the great extinction and crossing over
26Seeing the buddhaSeeing the buddha

What the divergence is fastened to — The systems of translated wording are wholly different while the number and the sequence of the gates are wholly the same. The last question of T292 reads 「何謂如來、至真取大滅度?」 tr. “what is called the Tathāgata, the Utterly True One, taking the great extinction and crossing over?” 〔T10n0292 0644a22〕, and the passage of answer begins 「如來、至真以作佛事觀見十義,現大滅度」 tr. “the Tathāgata, the Utterly True One, having done the work of a buddha, contemplates and sees ten senses and manifests the great extinction and crossing over” 〔0653a27〕, which is wholly the same in the structure of the scene as the base text’s 「如來、應、正等覺作佛事已,觀十種義故,示般涅槃」 tr. “the Tathāgata, the Worthy One, the Perfectly Awakened One, having done the work of a buddha, contemplates ten kinds of sense and manifests parinirvāṇa” 〔T10n0279 0313b15〕: the work of a buddha done · contemplating ten senses · manifesting extinction. All recorded without judgment: as for the number fifty-one, T279 shows it by 「門」 tr. “gates,” T292 shows it by 「問」 tr. “questions,” the Tanxuan counts it by 「句」 tr. “phrases” as 「五百一十」 tr. “five hundred and ten” 〔T35n1733 0434c27〕, and Chengguan counts it by 「門」 tr. “gates” as 「五十一」 tr. “fifty-one” 〔T35n1735 0902a01〕; the manners of counting differ, and this is no defect.

Collation Two A full table of the correspondence of the fifty-one gates in the sixty-fascicle recension (the base text T279 / the Jin recension T278)

The seventh and eighth parts of the Chapter on Detachment from the World, the thirty-third, of the Jin translation of the sixty-fascicle Avataṃsaka (fascicles 42 to 43) are the corresponding stretch for this section, beginning 〔T09n0278 0659a17〕 and ending 〔0669b12〕.

The systems of translated wording of the two recensions are wholly different — where the base text has pure giving the Jin recension has clean giving, where the base text has the equipment of merit that aids the path the Jin recension has the equipment of virtue, where the base text has dwelling in the stage of a youth the Jin recension has manifesting the stage of a youth — and therefore the correspondence is in every case taken by the structure of the scene, and the wording of the base text is not used to search the Jin recension. The opening sentences of the fifty-one gates are set side by side as follows.

WitnessVerbatim (rendered)Source
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 1, contemplationSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of contemplation. Which are the ten? Namely: contemplating good deedsT09n0278 0659a17
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 2, universal contemplation (the sixty reads contemplation that is universal and pervading)Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of contemplation that is universal and pervading. Which are the ten? Namely: universally and pervadingly contemplating the variousT09n0278 0659a29
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 3, rousing might…sattvas have ten kinds of rousing might. Which are the ten? Namely: the rousing might of form, among the gods, nāgasT09n0278 0659b14
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 4, the lion’s roarSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of lion’s roar. Which are the ten? Namely: I shall surely accomplishT09n0278 0659c05
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 5, pure givingSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of clean giving. Which are the ten? Namely: giving with an even mindT09n0278 0659c25
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 6, pure preceptsBodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of clean precept. Which are the ten? Namely: the clean precept of the body, guarding the bodyT09n0278 0660a07
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 7, pure patience…sattvas have ten kinds of clean patience. Which are the ten? Namely: if another reviles and humiliates him, being wholly able to bear itT09n0278 0660a18
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 8, pure vigor…sattvas have ten kinds of clean vigor. Which are the ten? Namely: the vigor of clean deeds of body, reverentlyT09n0278 0660a29
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 9, pure meditationSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of clean meditation. Which are the ten? Namely: ever delighting in leaving homeT09n0278 0660b22
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 10, pure wisdomSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of clean wisdom. Which are the ten? Namely: the clean wisdom that knows causesT09n0278 0660c06
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 11, pure loving-kindnessSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of clean loving-kindness. Which are the ten? Namely: the clean loving-kindness of an even mindT09n0278 0660c21
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 12, pure compassionSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of clean compassion. Which are the ten? Namely: the clean compassion that is not sharedT09n0278 0661a04
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 13, pure joySons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of clean joy. Which are the ten? Namely: giving rise to the mind of awakeningT09n0278 0661a26
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 14, pure equanimity…sattvas have ten kinds of clean equanimity. Which are the ten? Namely: all sentient beings reverence and make offerings and yet no fondness arisesT09n0278 0661b10
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 15, meaningSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of meaning. Which are the ten? Namely: the meaning of much hearing, asT09n0278 0661b24
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 16, dharmaSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of dharma. Which are the ten? Namely: the real dharma, asT09n0278 0661c04
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 17, the equipment of merit that aids the path (the sixty reads the equipment of virtue)…have ten kinds of equipment of virtue. Which are the ten? Namely: urging sentient beings to set going the mind of awakening is the equipment of virtueT09n0278 0661c14
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 18, the equipment of wisdom that aids the path (the sixty reads the equipment of wisdom)…of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of equipment of wisdom. Which are the ten? Namely: drawing near to one truly of muchT09n0278 0662a04
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 19, clarity and footingSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of clarity and footing. Which are the ten? Namely: knowing deeply the Buddha-dharmaT09n0278 0662b16
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 20, seeking the DharmaSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of seeking the Dharma. Which are the ten? Namely: seeking the Dharma with an upright mindT09n0278 0662b26
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 21, dharmas clearly understood…sattvas have ten kinds of dharma clearly understood. Which are the ten? Namely: the dharma clearly understood of following along with the worldT09n0278 0662c08
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 22, dharmas of cultivation (the sixty reads dharmas directed toward)…sattvas have ten kinds of dharma directed toward. Which are the ten? Namely: the dharma directed toward of following along with and reverencing good friends; awakeningT09n0278 0662c25
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 23, māraSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of māra. Which are the ten? Namely: the māra of the five heaps, greedT09n0278 0663a06
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 24, the deeds of māraSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of deed of māra. Which are the ten? Namely: forgetting and losing awakeningT09n0278 0663a13
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 25, forsaking the deeds of māraBodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of forsaking the deeds of māra. Which are the ten? Namely: drawing near to good friendsT09n0278 0663b07
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 26, seeing the buddhaSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of seeing the buddha. Which are the ten? Namely: the buddha of non-attachmentT09n0278 0663b18
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 27, the deeds of a buddhaSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of deed of a buddha. Which are the ten? Namely: urging and transforming sentient beingsT09n0278 0663b25
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 28, the deeds of conceitSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of deed of conceit. Which are the ten? Namely: toward the honored fields of meritT09n0278 0663c29
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 29, the deeds of wisdomSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of deed of wisdom. Which are the ten? Namely: believing and understanding causes and conditionsT09n0278 0664b05
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 30, being held by māraSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of being held by māra. Which are the ten? Namely: indolenceT09n0278 0664b25
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 31, being held by the buddhasIf a bodhisattva-mahāsattva is able to cast off these ways of being held by māra, then he obtains the ten kinds of holding of all the buddhas.T09n0278 0664c05
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 32, being held by the Dharma (the sixty reads the Dharma’s holding)…of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of the Dharma’s holding. Which are the ten? Namely: all conditioned activities are imperma…T09n0278 0664c18
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 33, the ten deeds done in the Tuṣita heavenSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven have ten kinds of deed. Which are the ten? Namely: the bodhi…T09n0278 0665a03
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 34, ten things manifested in descending to birth…sattvas, when their life is about to end in the Tuṣita heaven, have ten kinds of thing manifested. Which are the ten? NamelyT09n0278 0665c10
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 35, ten matters of dwelling in the wombBodhisattva-mahāsattvas, because of ten kinds of matter, cause the spirit to descend into the mother’s womb. Which are the ten? Namely: in order to teachT09n0278 0666b16
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 36, the exceedingly subtle resorts (the sixty reads the subtle resorts)…the womb. If a bodhisattva-mahāsattva abides in this gate of Dharma, then he is able to manifest a bodhisattva’s ten kinds of subtle resort. WhichT09n0278 0666c18
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 37, ten kinds of birthSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of birth. Which are the ten? Namely: birth that leaves delusion behind;T09n0278 0667a09
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 38, smiling and inwardly vowing…of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of great adornment with which they adorn themselves. Which are the ten? Namely:T09n0278 0667a20
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 39, walking seven steps (the sixty reads roaming seven steps)Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas, because of ten kinds of matter, roam seven steps. Which are the ten? NamelyT09n0278 0667b14
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 40, dwelling in the stage of a youthSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas, because of ten kinds of matter, manifest the stage of a youth. Which are the ten? NamelyT09n0278 0667b24
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 41, manifesting dwelling in the royal palace (the sixty reads the inner palace)Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas, having manifested the stage of a youth, because of ten kinds of matter manifest dwelling in the inner palace. WhatT09n0278 0667c09
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 42, manifesting the leaving of homeSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas, because of ten kinds of matter, manifest the leaving of home. Which are the ten? NamelyT09n0278 0667c22
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 43, manifesting the practice of austeritiesSons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas, for the sake of ten kinds of matter, manifest austerities. Which are the ten? NamelyT09n0278 0668a04
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 44, going to the place of the WaySons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas, because of ten kinds of matter, go on to the place of the Way. Which are the ten? NamelyT09n0278 0668a16
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 45, sitting at the place of the Way…because of ten kinds of matter, sit at the place of the Way. Which are the ten? Namely: shaking all the lands in all sorts of waysT09n0278 0668b03
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 46, the unprecedented matters of sitting at the place of the WaySons of the Buddha! When bodhisattva-mahāsattvas sit at the place of the Way, there are ten kinds of rare and unprecedented dharma. Which are theT09n0278 0668b13
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 47, manifesting the subduing of māraSons of the Buddha! When bodhisattva-mahāsattvas sit at the place of the Way, because of ten kinds of sense they manifest the subduing of māra. Which are theT09n0278 0668c10
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 48, accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata (the sixty reads awakening to the powers of a Tathāgata)Sons of the Buddha! Bodhisattva-mahāsattvas have ten kinds of awakening to the powers of a Tathāgata. Which are the ten? Namely: passing beyondT09n0278 0668c23
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 49, the ten matters of turning the great wheel of the DharmaSons of the Buddha! Having in this way accomplished being the Tathāgata, the One Worthy of Offerings, the Rightly and Fully Awakened One, he is able to turn the pure wheel of the Dharma of the ten practicesT09n0278 0669a08
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 50, the ten matters of sowing the white and pure dharmasSons of the Buddha! The pure wheel of the Dharma of the Tathāgata, the One Worthy of Offerings, the Rightly and Fully Awakened One, because of ten kinds of white and pure dharma, is turnedT09n0278 0669a18
Buddhabhadra T278 · gate 51, manifesting parinirvāṇaSons of the Buddha! The Tathāgata, the One Worthy of Offerings, the Rightly and Fully Awakened One, having brought the work of a buddha to its end, has ten kinds of sense and manifests the greatT09n0278 0669a26

What the divergence is fastened to — The number and the sequence of the gates are wholly the same as in the base text; only two places must be recorded. In gate 2 the Jin recension reads 「周遍觀察」 tr. “contemplation that is universal and pervading,” which, looked at together with the base text’s 「普觀察」 tr. “universal contemplation,” makes the sequence of the gate-openings slightly divergent. In gate 38 the Jin recension has at this place no independent phrase about 「微笑」 tr. “a smile,” but sets in its place the phrase 「十種大莊嚴而自莊嚴」 tr. “ten kinds of great adornment with which they adorn themselves.” Both places are recorded together without judgment. Again, in gate 48 the base text reads 「成如來力」 tr. “accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata” while the Jin recension reads 「覺如來力」 tr. “awakening to the powers of a Tathāgata,” a difference of one word between accomplishing and awakening, bearing upon whether what is shown is the accomplishing of the powers or the awakening to them; recorded together without judgment.

Collation Three The ten senses of manifesting parinirvāṇa (the base text T279 / the separately circulating recension T292)

WitnessVerbatim (rendered)Source
Śikṣānanda T279Because the humans and gods delight in and are attached to the form-body, making manifest for them that the form-body is an impermanent dharma, and causing them to vow to abide in the pure dharma-bodyT10n0279 0313b19, within the passage
Dharmarakṣa T292The gods and the people are attached to the form-body, and therefore he manifests that the form-body is impermanent in this way and that the dharma-body abides permanently, and discriminates it for themT10n0292 0653a29
WitnessVerbatim (rendered)Source
Śikṣānanda T279Making manifest that all the three kinds of existence are like an illusion and a transformation and are not firmT10n0279 0313b21, within the passage
Dharmarakṣa T292All the three realms are like an illusion and a transformationT10n0292 0653b03

What the divergence is fastened to — The base text reads 「三有」 tr. “the three kinds of existence” and the separately circulating recension reads 「三界」 tr. “the three realms”; the base text reads 「淨法身」 tr. “the pure dharma-body” and the separately circulating recension reads 「法身常存」 tr. “the dharma-body abides permanently.” Chengguan has at just this place a note collating the Jin recension: explaining the fourth sense he says 「四翻色身無常,法身為常故」 tr. “fourth, it overturns the impermanence of the form-body, for the reason that the dharma-body is permanent,” and citing the text of 「故晉經云」 tr. “therefore the Jin scripture says,” namely 「令求常住淨法身故」 tr. “in order to make them seek the permanently abiding pure dharma-body,” he judges 〔T35n1735 0906c18–c20〕「今缺「常」〔0906c20〕字」 tr. “the present recension lacks the word permanent” — Chengguan plainly points out that this phrase of the base text has one word fewer than the Jin recension, that word being 「常」 tr. “permanent.” This is Chengguan's explicit judgment, recorded as such by the conventions; the divergence itself is not judged.

Collation Four The four places where Chengguan adduces the Jin scripture (variant readings of the sixty-fascicle recension · collated by Chengguan himself)

The gate where it standsThe base text T279The Jin scripture as adduced by ChengguanSource
Gate 22, dharmas of cultivationThe dharma of cultivation of being ever awakened by the godsAwakening the godsT35n1735 0903c25
Gate 43, manifesting the practice of austerities〔the ninth phrase〕 In order to make sentient beings delight in the dharma of stillness and grow their roots of goodIn order to make sentient beings of the time to come give rise to vigorT35n1735 0906a28
Gate 45, sitting at the place of the WayWhen sitting at the place of the Way, universally contemplating the lion-seats of all the buddhas, the tathāgatasContemplating the roar of the lion of all the buddhasT35n1735 0906b06
Gate 51, manifesting parinirvāṇaCausing them to vow to abide in the pure dharma-bodyIn order to make them seek the permanently abiding pure dharma-bodyT35n1735 0906c19

What the divergence is fastened to — All four places were collated by Chengguan himself. For gate 22, Chengguan first explains the reading, 「常為諸天者,為字去聲」 tr. “as for ‘ever by the gods,’ the word wei takes the falling tone,” and then adduces the Jin scripture as his witness 〔0903c24〕; for gate 43, Chengguan says 「今精進之言合在前句,缺斯一句」 tr. “in the present recension the words about vigor are joined into the phrase before, and this one phrase is missing” 〔0906a28〕; for gate 45, the difference of one word between seat and roar bears upon whether what is contemplated is the buddha’s seat or the buddha’s roar. Recorded together without judgment.

Collation Five The number of phrases in pure equanimity (eleven phrases in the base text · ten in the Jin recension)

Chengguan explaining gate 14 says 「四、有十捨,文列十一,晉本初二但合為一」 tr. “fourth, there are ten equanimities, while the text lists eleven; the Jin recension merely draws the first two into one” 〔T35n1735 0902c20〕. The base text heads this gate 「十種清淨捨」 tr. “ten kinds of pure equanimity,” and yet lists eleven phrases in fact, while the Jin recension draws the first two into one and so makes ten. This is a divergence in the number of phrases already recorded by the ancient worthies, not an error of the base text, and it is recorded as it stands without judgment.

〔not found〕 and an honest record of searches

  • The forty-fascicle Avataṃsaka T293: 〔not found〕. That translation has only chapter 39.
  • Vasubandhu, Shidi jing lun T26n1522: 〔not found〕. It explains only the Chapter on the Ten Grounds and does not touch this chapter.

V. Scriptural Grounds of Sectarian Doctrine (the doctrinal eye)

(i) The matching of the six positions is fastened to the outline of the ancient worthies and not to the scriptural text — Of the stage-names of the six sections into which the part of the speaking of this chapter is divided (the ten faiths · the ten abodes · the ten practices · the ten dedications · the ten grounds · the perfected cause and fulfilled fruit), the scriptural text itself produces not one word. Chengguan plainly states what he relies upon: 「古來諸德皆依彼文用科此經」 tr. “the ancient worthies of old all relied on the text of that scripture to outline this scripture” 〔T35n1735 0889c09〕, and “the text of that scripture” is the six rounds of question and answer of the separately circulating Dushipin jing. Therefore the name of this section, 「因圓果滿行」 tr. “the practice of the perfected cause and the fulfilled fruit,” is an outline the ancient worthies made on the basis of the Dushi jing, which Chengguan carried on and explained by, and not what the scripture sets up of itself. The first boundary in reading this section lies just here: the scripture says only 「有十種觀察」 tr. “there are ten kinds of contemplation,” and speaks on as far as 「示般涅槃」 tr. “manifesting parinirvāṇa,” and the ranking of positions is a set of coordinates given by the commentators.

(ii) The boundary of the perfected cause and the fulfilled fruit lies at 「成如來力」 tr. “accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata” — Chengguan’s judgment: 「方明果滿,前皆因圓」 tr. “only then is the fulfilled fruit made clear, and all before is the perfected cause” 〔T35n1735 0902a03〕. His reason lies not in the content of the gates but in the nature of the manifesting: 「以八相前五猶屬因故,為明八相皆示現故」 tr. “because the first five of the eight aspects still belong to the cause, and in order to make clear that the eight aspects are all of them manifestings” 〔0902a03〕 — the first five of the eight aspects (entering the womb · dwelling in the womb · the first birth · dwelling in the household · leaving home) are in the position of the cause, but because the eight aspects are one whole set of manifestings they are taken in together into the fruit. The Yanyi chao preserves two further reckonings, one saying 「前一百九十六門皆屬因攝」 tr. “the first one hundred and ninety-six gates all belong to what is taken in under the cause” 〔T36n1736 0128a21〕, and one saying 「若以八相為果,果有一十九門」 tr. “if the eight aspects are taken as the fruit, the fruit has nineteen gates” 〔0128a21〕. One and the same stretch of scriptural text is cut into cause and fruit in two reckonings — the last four gates (of this section's fifty-one, and of the chapter's two hundred) and, from dwelling in Tuṣita onward, nineteen gates or one hundred and ninety phrases — differing only in the unit counted; all of them are settled teachings of the ancient worthies, and they are recorded together without judgment.

(iii) The ten perfections lodged in the number ten to show fullness — Gates 5 to 10 of this section, giving, precepts, patience, vigor, meditation, and wisdom, together with gates 11 to 14, loving-kindness, compassion, joy, and equanimity, make up the substance of the practice of the ten perfections. Chengguan sets up two senses: first, 「皆言清淨者,離蔽障故,不同世間施戒等故」 tr. “that all of them say pure is for the reason that they leave the meanness and obstruction behind, and are not like the giving and the precepts and the rest of the world” 〔T35n1735 0902a24〕; second, 「然皆寄十表圓,各為一義」 tr. “yet all of them are lodged in the number ten to show fullness, each one making one sense” 〔0902a25〕 — that each perfection has its ten is not an attempt to exhaust the whole content of that perfection, but a showing of its fullness by the number ten. As for the division of labor among the four evennesses, Chengguan fastens it, saying 「六度多明自利,四等多約利他」 tr. “the six perfections for the most part make clear benefiting oneself, the four evennesses are for the most part taken in terms of benefiting others” 〔0902c12〕, and he cuts the gates one by one with the three grounds (sentient beings as ground · dharmas as ground · no ground): of loving-kindness, 「前八眾生緣」 tr. “the first eight have sentient beings as their ground” 〔0902c14〕; of compassion, 「前七眾生緣、次一法緣、後二無緣」 tr. “the first seven have sentient beings as their ground, the next one has dharmas as its ground, the last two have no ground” 〔0902c17〕; of joy, 「初四眾生緣、次三法緣、後三無緣」 tr. “the first four have sentient beings as their ground, the next three have dharmas as their ground, the last three have no ground” 〔0902c19〕; of equanimity, 「初四眾生緣、次六法緣、後一無緣」 tr. “the first four have sentient beings as their ground, the next six have dharmas as their ground, the last one has no ground” 〔0902c21〕.

(iv) The doctrinal eye of the ten māras lies in 「執取」 tr. “grasping and attachment” and not in 「事物」 tr. “things” — Among the ten māras of gate 23 there stand out the māra of the roots of good · the māra of samādhi · the māra of the good friend · the māra of the wisdom of the dharma of awakening. Chengguan’s explanation is the sharpest passage in this section: 「一蘊魔者,身為道器,體與佛同,豈即是魔?」 tr. “first, as for the māra of the aggregates — the body is the vessel of the Way and its substance is the same as a buddha’s; how then is it a māra?” 〔T35n1735 0904a01〕, and he judges 「蘊魔之名特由取著,下九例爾」 tr. “the name māra of the aggregates comes solely from grasping and attachment, and the nine below follow the same example” 〔0904a02〕, and pushes it out further: 「是知以心分別萬法皆魔,何但此十」 tr. “thus one knows that when the mind discriminates, the ten thousand dharmas are all māra; how should it be only these ten?” 〔0904a03〕. The difference between the four māras and the ten māras comes of this as well: 「然四魔直就體明,十魔多約執取」 tr. “yet the four māras are made clear straight in terms of substance, while the ten māras are for the most part taken in terms of grasping and attachment” 〔0904a06〕. And he lays down a turning word: 「一切皆佛,豈捨魔界求佛界耶?」 tr. “all is buddha; how should one forsake the realm of māra to seek the realm of buddha?” 〔0904a05〕 — that a māra is a māra lies in the grasping, and not in the thing grasped.

(v) The manner of measuring the turning of the wheel of the Dharma: the four practices of the Lesser Vehicle fastened to the four truths · the hundred practices shown here — Chengguan explaining gate 49 says 「流演圓通目之為輪,自我之彼名之為轉」 tr. “flowing forth in perfect penetration is what is meant by wheel; from me to another is what is named turning” 〔T35n1735 0906b28〕, and thereupon sets up the Huayan measure: 「小乘以眼智明覺四行繫於四諦,今顯無盡十行,應繫十諦以成百行」 tr. “the Lesser Vehicle fastens the four practices of eye, wisdom, clarity, and awakening to the four truths; here the ten practices that are inexhaustible are shown, and they should be fastened to ten truths so as to make a hundred practices” 〔0906b29〕. The four practices fastened to the four truths is the measure of the shared teaching, and ten truths and ten practices making a hundred practices is the number of this scripture — the place where the measure of one being many comes to rest in this section.

(vi) Sowing the white and pure dharmas is the seed of the perfuming of hearing — In gate 50 Chengguan explains the word 「種」 tr. “sowing”: 「謂佛無漏清淨法界轉入眾生心中,成聞熏種子,故名為種」 tr. “that is, the buddha’s uncontaminated pure Dharma realm turns into the minds of sentient beings and becomes the seed of the perfuming of hearing, and therefore it is named sowing” 〔T35n1735 0906c06〕, and he fastens it to the sense of the She lun 〔0906c08〕. This is a place where the commentator explains this scripture by a treatise of the lineage; the attribution is plainly recorded, and it is not what the scriptural text says of itself.


VI. Divergent Interpretations of the Commentators (the ancient worthies · with their tenets marked)

Chengguan, Huayan jing shu T35n1735 (following the text of the eighty-fascicle Avataṃsaka · principal)

The bone of the outline — 「五十一門答上因圓果滿」 tr. “fifty-one gates answer the perfected cause and the fulfilled fruit above” 〔0902a01〕; 「初三十二門明因圓究竟,即等覺位」 tr. “the first thirty-two gates make clear the ultimacy of the perfected cause, that is, the position of equal awakening” 〔0902a05〕; the latter nineteen gates 「明現果圓滿行,即妙覺位」 tr. “make clear the practice of the fulfilled fruit made manifest, that is, the position of wondrous awakening” 〔0902a06〕.

The assigning of the three kinds of deed in gates 1 to 4 — 「初二門意業觀察、次一門身業自在、後一門語業宣暢」 tr. “the first two gates are the contemplation of the deeds of mind, the next one gate is the mastery of the deeds of body, the last one gate is the proclaiming of the deeds of speech” 〔0902a11〕. Within gate 1 he divides: 「初二觀所化」 tr. “the first two contemplate what is to be transformed” 〔0902a13〕, 「次四觀能化法,謂理果教行」 tr. “the next four contemplate the dharmas that transform, namely principle, fruit, teaching, and practice” 〔0902a13〕, 「後三觀位,一超劣、二得位、三同果用」 tr. “the last three contemplate the positions: first passing beyond the inferior, second obtaining the position, third being the same as the use of the fruit” 〔0902a14〕. Gate 2 is 「審慮周遍故」 tr. “for the reason that his deliberation is thorough and reaches everywhere” 〔0902a15〕, and 「前六以六度治六蔽眾生」 tr. “the first six treat with the six perfections the sentient beings of the six meannesses” 〔0902a15〕, 「後四雙明二利,謂順人證法、下化上成」 tr. “the last four make clear both benefits together, namely according with persons and realizing the Dharma, transforming below and completing above” 〔0902a16〕.

The matching of the ten perfections gate by gate with the outline of the Yoga treatise — Of the ten precepts, 「前三律儀,七十攝生,餘皆攝善」 tr. “the first three are restraint, the seventh and the tenth gather beings, and the rest all gather the good” 〔0902b11〕; of the ten patiences, 「初三耐怨害忍,忍他三業惱害故」 tr. “the first three are the patience that endures the harm of enemies, for the reason that they bear the vexing harm of another’s three kinds of deed” 〔0902b16〕; of the ten vigors, 「二與第十是饒益有情,五是被甲,餘皆攝善」 tr. “the second and the tenth are benefiting sentient beings, the fifth is donning armor, and the rest all gather the good” 〔0902b21〕; of the ten meditations, 「初五方便、次一正定堅成、次二發慧斷惑」 tr. “the first five are skillful means, the next one is right concentration firmly completed, the next two set going wisdom and cut off confusion” 〔0902b27〕; of the ten wisdoms, 「初三解法,即加行慧;次四攝生,即後得慧;後三證理,即正體慧」 tr. “the first three understand dharmas, that is, the wisdom of applied practice; the next four gather beings, that is, the subsequently attained wisdom; the last three realize the principle, that is, the wisdom of the essential substance” 〔0902c04〕.

The dividing of the two gates of dharma and meaning — 「若以能詮為法,則以所詮為義」 tr. “if one takes what conveys as dharma, then one takes what is conveyed as meaning” 〔0902c26〕; of the first of the ten meanings, 「一以修行為多聞之義,意在於修不在聞故」 tr. “the first takes cultivation as the meaning of much hearing, for the reason that the intent lies in cultivating and not in hearing” 〔0902c29〕; of the substance of the ten dharmas, 「法有二義:一持自性、二軌生物解」 tr. “dharma has two senses: first, it holds its own nature; second, it is the rule by which understanding is produced in beings” 〔0903a04〕.

The two senses of clarity and footing — 「惑闇斯亡、智解斯顯,故稱為明」 tr. “the darkness of confusion has perished and the understanding of wisdom has appeared, and therefore it is called clarity” 〔0903b15〕; 「足有二義:一智圓備故;二有進趣故」 tr. “footing has two senses: first, for the reason that wisdom is full and complete; second, for the reason that there is advancing” 〔0903b15〕; 「即十號明行足義。果稱圓足,因為脚足」 tr. “that is, the sense of ‘complete in clarity and conduct’ among the ten titles. On the side of the fruit it is called fullness and completeness; on the side of the cause it is feet” 〔0903b17〕.

The three gates of advancing beyond — 「一更求法要、二得已明了、三如說修行」 tr. “first, seeking further the essentials of the Dharma; second, having obtained them, understanding them clearly; third, cultivating as they were spoken” 〔0903b22〕; at the end of the gate of seeking the Dharma he judges 「離此十求皆邪求也」 tr. “apart from these ten kinds of seeking, all seeking is wrong seeking” 〔0903b27〕; of the gate of dharmas clearly understood, 「總以普賢勝智了知三乘凡聖差別」 tr. “generally, with the surpassing wisdom of Samantabhadra, fully knowing the differences of the ordinary and the noble in the three vehicles” 〔0903b28〕.

The outline of the ten gates of leaving obstruction behind — 「前五門明離障成行、後五門明離障加持」 tr. “the first five gates make clear that practice is completed by leaving obstruction behind, the last five gates make clear the sustaining that comes of leaving obstruction behind” 〔0903c26〕; of the ten māras, 「能障道故」 tr. “for the reason that they are able to obstruct the Way” 〔0904a01〕; of the ten deeds of māra, 「行此十事皆能訛善亦招天魔,故為其業」 tr. “to do these ten things is in every case able to corrupt the good and also to draw the heavenly māra, and therefore they are its deeds” 〔0904a11〕, and he appends one sentence of self-admonition: 「然觀此文,難免魔業,願諸後學審此省躬」 tr. “yet looking at this text, it is hard to escape the deeds of māra; may those who come after examine this and look into themselves” 〔0904a19〕; of the gate of forsaking the deeds of māra, 「對障修治,故云捨離」 tr. “treating and mending against the obstruction, and therefore it says forsaking” 〔0904a20〕, and 「然此十句,敵對反前,但略而不次耳」 tr. “yet these ten phrases are matched directly against those before, only in brief and out of order” 〔0904a21〕, and he marks one by one what each reverses (the first reverses the fifth · the second the second · the third the seventh · the fourth the first · the fifth the fourth · the sixth the eighth · the seventh the third · the eighth the ninth · the ninth the tenth · the tenth the sixth 〔0904a22–a25〕); of the two gates of seeing the buddha and the completion of practice, 「由障離故,果現行成」 tr. “for the reason that the obstruction is gone, the fruit appears and practice is complete” 〔0904a28〕.

The stretch of the eight aspects (the last section of what is recorded) — Of the gate of austerities he explains phrase by phrase, 「五策懈怠眾生故」 tr. “the fifth is for the reason of spurring on indolent sentient beings” 「六令知為法忘飢故」 tr. “the sixth is for the reason of making them know that for the Dharma one forgets hunger” 「七示著樂非道故」 tr. “the seventh is for the reason of showing that attachment to joy is not the Way” 〔0906a26–a27〕, and of the last phrase, 「十苦行待機者,顯悲深故」 tr. “as for the tenth, austerities that await the occasion, it is for the reason that they show that his compassion is deep” 〔0906a29〕; from going to the place of the Way onward, 「五門,道成證入行」 tr. “five gates, the practice of accomplishing the Way and entering realization” 〔0906b01〕, whose sense is 「顯捨邪趣正故,因圓趣果故,行行後邊故」 tr. “for the reason that it shows the forsaking of the wrong and the turning to the right, for the reason that the cause is perfected and turns toward the fruit, for the reason that this practice is the last of the practices” 〔0906b03〕; of the gate of sitting at the place of the Way, 「初四嚴處。次三三業現相」 tr. “the first four are the adorning of the place. The next three are the manifesting of the marks of the three kinds of deed” 〔0906b05〕; of the gate of unprecedented matters, 「明外感希奇,大果先兆故」 tr. “it makes clear the rarity felt from without, for the reason that it is the foretoken of the great fruit” 〔0906b09〕; of the gate of subduing māra, 「正覺將顯,先摧邪故」 tr. “perfect awakening being about to appear, for the reason that the wrong is first crushed” 〔0906b10〕, and he explains 「皆言示者,久已降故,魔王多是大菩薩故,無有惡魔能惱佛故」 tr. “that all of them say manifesting is for the reason that they were long ago subdued, for the reason that the māra-kings are for the most part great bodhisattvas, and for the reason that there is no evil māra able to distress a buddha” 〔0906b10〕.

The four gates of the fulfilled fruit — Of the gate of accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata, 「即正覺現前」 tr. “that is, perfect awakening appearing before him” 〔0906b22〕, and he judges what is before and after by the three paths: 「前之二門當無間道,此當解脫道,更前二門即方便道」 tr. “the two gates before serve as the uninterrupted path, this one as the path of liberation, and the two gates further back are the path of skillful means” 〔0906b22〕; the outline of the ten phrases, 「初一障無不寂、次二因無不圓、次二果無不滿、次三德無不普、後二佛無不同」 tr. “the first, no obstruction not stilled; the next two, no cause not perfected; the next two, no fruit not fulfilled; the next three, no virtue not universal; the last two, no buddha not the same” 〔0906b24〕. Of the ten phrases of the gate of turning the wheel of the Dharma, 「初二能轉備圓、次二所轉深妙、次二生信拔苦、次二因深量廣、後二時遠益高」 tr. “the first two, that what turns is fully perfect; the next two, that what is turned is deep and wondrous; the next two, that faith is produced and suffering pulled out; the next two, that the cause is deep and the measure vast; the last two, that the time is far and the benefit high” 〔0906c03〕. Of the gate of sowing the white and pure dharmas, 「初一宿因,餘皆現因」 tr. “the first is the cause in a former age, and the rest are all present causes” 〔0906c11〕. Of the gate of nirvāṇa, 「初二明生死過患」 tr. “the first two make clear the faults and troubles of birth-and-death” 〔0906c16〕 · 「三明涅槃是樂,翻上無樂,以涅槃寂滅為真樂故」 tr. “the third makes clear that nirvāṇa is joy, overturning the joylessness above, for the reason that the stillness and extinction of nirvāṇa is the true joy” 〔0906c17〕 · 「八明涅槃是堅,即自在我,亦兼常義」 tr. “the eighth makes clear that nirvāṇa is firm, that is, the masterful self, and carries the sense of permanence along with it” 〔0906c25〕 · 「九翻有為以明淨德」 tr. “the ninth overturns the conditioned so as to make clear the virtue of purity” 〔0906c26〕 · 「上以四榮翻枯具遣八倒」 tr. “the above, by the four that flourish, overturns the withered and wholly dispels the eight inversions” 〔0907a04〕 · and of the last phrase, 「十明法爾」 tr. “the tenth makes clear that the dharma is just so” 〔0907a04〕.

Yanyi chao T36n1736

A divergent reckoning of the number of gates of cause and fruit — 「前一百九十六門皆屬因攝」 tr. “the first one hundred and ninety-six gates all belong to what is taken in under the cause” 〔0128a21〕; 「若以八相為果,果有一十九門,餘皆屬因」 tr. “if the eight aspects are taken as the fruit, the fruit has nineteen gates and the rest all belong to the cause” 〔0128a21〕. And it explains the two titles of the name of the chapter: as for its being 「名出世因果」 tr. “named the cause and fruit of going beyond the world,” 「品名離世間故」 tr. “for the reason that the chapter is named Detachment from the World” 〔0128a23〕; as for its being 「亦名成行因果」 tr. “also named the cause and fruit of the completion of practice,” 「廢於位名,意在行故」 tr. “for the reason that the names of the positions are set aside and the intent lies in practice” 〔0128a24〕.

Fazang, Tanxuan ji T35n1733 (the commentary on the sixty-fascicle Avataṃsaka)

Counting by phrases — 「五百一十句,答上第六因圓果滿行」 tr. “five hundred and ten phrases, answering the sixth above, the practice of the perfected cause and the fulfilled fruit” 〔0434c27〕; 「初三百二十句明因圓究竟行,亦是等覺位相似」 tr. “the first three hundred and twenty phrases make clear the practice of the ultimacy of the perfected cause, and are likewise similar to the position of equal awakening” 〔0434c28〕; 「一百九十明現果圓滿行,亦是妙覺位相似」 tr. “one hundred and ninety make clear the practice of the fulfilled fruit made manifest, and are likewise similar to the position of wondrous awakening” 〔0435a01〕; 「初有一百四十門,明因行體性」 tr. “the first has one hundred and forty gates, making clear the substance and nature of the practice of the cause” 〔0435a02〕.

A divergence in the assigning of the three kinds of deed — 「初二十明意業觀察、次十身業奮迅、後十語業哮吼」 tr. “the first twenty make clear the contemplation of the deeds of mind, the next ten the rousing might of the deeds of body, the last ten the roaring of the deeds of speech” 〔0435a06〕. Within gate 1 he divides it as 「初三觀所化,一知業;二知報;三知根」 tr. “the first three contemplate what is to be transformed: first knowing deeds; second knowing recompense; third knowing faculties” 〔0435a09〕 — Fazang makes it the first three, Chengguan the first two 〔T35n1735 0902a13〕.

A separate set of names for the ten phrases of rousing might — 「初一身勝、二心大、三教威、四行用、五破邪、六滅惑、七達法、八廣持、九具辯、十圓果」 tr. “the first, the body surpassing; the second, the mind great; the third, the majesty of the teaching; the fourth, the use of practice; the fifth, demolishing the wrong; the sixth, extinguishing confusion; the seventh, penetrating dharmas; the eighth, holding broadly; the ninth, complete in eloquence; the tenth, the perfect fruit” 〔0435a21〕.

The fastening of the lion’s roar to the Niepan — 「依《涅槃經》,師子吼有十一事,具如彼說」 tr. “according to the Niepan jing, the lion’s roar has eleven matters, wholly as it is said there” 〔0435a24〕.

A separate set of names for the ten givings — 「一捨心施、二滿願、三一心、四了田、五無簡、六不著、七捨身財、八求大果、九益眾生、十淨三輪」 tr. “the first, giving with a mind that lets go; the second, fulfilling wishes; the third, a single mind; the fourth, understanding the field; the fifth, no picking and choosing; the sixth, no attachment; the seventh, giving away body and goods; the eighth, seeking the great fruit; the ninth, benefiting sentient beings; the tenth, purifying the three spheres” 〔0435b01〕.

Divergences in the outlines of the ten patiences · the ten meditations · the ten wisdoms — Of patience, 「初三耐怨害忍,忍他三業所惱故;次五安受苦忍」 tr. “the first three are the patience that endures the harm of enemies, for the reason that they bear what is vexed by another’s three kinds of deed; the next five are the patience that peacefully receives suffering” 〔0435b08〕 (Chengguan makes it 「次三安受苦忍」 tr. “the next three are the patience that peacefully receives suffering” 〔T35n1735 0902b17〕); of meditation, 「初四方便,一出俗、二近友、三在靜、四離鬧」 tr. “the first four are skillful means: first coming forth from the common, second drawing near to friends, third being in stillness, fourth leaving the clamor” 〔0435b15〕 (Chengguan makes it 「初五方便」 tr. “the first five are skillful means” 〔0902b27〕); of wisdom, 「初三解法慧,一解因不即果、二解緣不離果、三解果不斷常」 tr. “the first three are the wisdom that understands dharmas: first understanding that the cause is not identical with the fruit, second that the condition is not apart from the fruit, third that the fruit is neither cut off nor permanent” 〔0435b20〕.

Li Tongxuan, Xin Huayan jing lun T36n1739

The reading of the eight aspects as all in one time — 「如來正處胎時、住兜率天,并初生、出家學道、成菩提、轉法輪、入涅槃總一時」 tr. “the very time when the Tathāgata is dwelling in the womb, dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven, together with the first birth, leaving home to study the Way, accomplishing awakening, turning the wheel of the Dharma, and entering nirvāṇa — all in one time” 〔0772c14〕, and what he relies upon for this is 「明如來出世始終不離剎那際」 tr. “making clear that the Tathāgata’s appearing in the world, from beginning to end, never departs from the very brink of an instant” 〔0772c13〕. And elsewhere he adduces this chapter to explain the buddha’s birth from a womb: 「為劣解眾生,母胎出爾」 tr. “for the sake of sentient beings of mean understanding, he comes forth from a mother’s womb thus” 〔0807b05〕. As for a gate-by-gate outline and explanation, 〔not found〕.

Recorded without judgment

First, the boundary between cause and fruit: Chengguan has 「五十一門」 tr. “fifty-one gates” and takes the four gates from 「成如來力」 tr. “accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata” onward as the fruit 〔T35n1735 0902a02〕; the Yanyi chao preserves besides the reckoning ‘nineteen gates are the fruit’ 〔T36n1736 0128a22〕; Fazang counts by phrases as 「五百一十句」 tr. “five hundred and ten phrases” 〔T35n1733 0434c27〕 and takes the one hundred and ninety from 「十種住兜率天」 tr. “ten kinds of dwelling in the Tuṣita heaven” onward as the fruit 〔0434c29〕. These are two boundaries in two units of count, by gates and by phrases, not three places of division.

Second, the inner outline of gate 1: Chengguan has 「初二觀所化」 tr. “the first two contemplate what is to be transformed” 〔T35n1735 0902a13〕, Fazang has 「初三觀所化」 tr. “the first three contemplate what is to be transformed” 〔T35n1733 0435a09〕.

Third, the outline of the ten patiences: Chengguan has 「次三安受苦忍」 tr. “the next three are the patience that peacefully receives suffering” 〔T35n1735 0902b17〕, Fazang has 「次五安受苦忍」 tr. “the next five are the patience that peacefully receives suffering” 〔T35n1733 0435b09〕.

Fourth, the outline of the ten meditations: Chengguan has 「初五方便」 tr. “the first five are skillful means” 〔T35n1735 0902b27〕, Fazang has 「初四方便」 tr. “the first four are skillful means” 〔T35n1733 0435b15〕.

Fifth, the names of the ten phrases of rousing might: Chengguan sets up no separate names but divides them into lodging the sense in similes and taking it in terms of dharma 〔T35n1735 0902a19〕; Fazang sets up ten separate names 〔T35n1733 0435a21〕.

Sixth, the time of the eight aspects: all three houses say they are manifested at once — Chengguan 「並一相中同時齊現」 tr. “all alike manifested together at one time within a single mark” 〔T35n1735 0905c21〕, Fazang 「並在胎內同時齊現」 tr. “all alike manifested together at one time within the womb” 〔T35n1733 0438a02〕, Li Tongxuan 「總一時」 tr. “all in one time” 〔T36n1739 0772c15〕; the outlines have a sequence, what is manifested is simultaneous.

Seventh, the number of phrases of pure equanimity: the base text lists eleven phrases in the text, while the Jin recension draws the first two into one and so makes ten 〔T35n1735 0902c20〕.

Eighth, the fourth sense of manifesting parinirvāṇa: the base text reads 「令其願住淨法身故」 tr. “in order to cause them to vow to abide in the pure dharma-body,” the Jin recension reads 「令求常住淨法身故」 tr. “in order to make them seek the permanently abiding pure dharma-body,” and Chengguan passes an explicit judgment, 〔T35n1735 0906c20〕「今缺「常」〔0906c20〕字」 tr. “the present recension lacks the word permanent”.

All the divergences above are settled teachings of the ancient worthies, and they are recorded together; the eighth, Chengguan’s collating judgment, is Chengguan’s explicit judgment and is not judged in his stead.


VII. Cross-Reading and Lineage

  • Cross-reading within this chapter: this section is the last of the six sections of the part of the speaking, following upon the fifty gates of the practice of the ten grounds (see 〈The Fifty Gates of the Practice of the Ten Grounds〉 in this volume), and followed by the concluding exhortation · the manifesting of portents · the attesting · the verses (see 〈The Conclusion: The Exhortation, the Auspicious Signs, the Attestation, and the Verses〉 in this volume). Chengguan’s outline of the six sections was set up on the basis of the six rounds of question and answer of the Dushipin jing, and therefore the warrant for the six sections being six sections lies in the separately circulating recension and not in the base text.
  • Cross-reading with the Chapter on the Appearance of the Tathāgata: what the four gates of the fulfilled fruit of this section (accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata · turning the great wheel of the Dharma · sowing the white and pure dharmas · manifesting parinirvāṇa) speak of is the fruit of a buddha made manifest, while what the ten senses of nature-origination in chapter 37, the Chapter on the Appearance of the Tathāgata, speak of is the appearing of a buddha. The two stretches take the eight aspects and the ten bodies alike for their material, but their intent is set differently: the Chapter on the Appearance asks ‘how ought one to see the body of a Tathāgata,’ while this chapter asks ‘what is the accomplishing of the way of a buddha · the turning of the wheel of the Dharma · the taking of extinction’ — the one asks about seeing, the other about doing.
  • Cross-reading with the Chapter on the Ten Grounds: of the outline of the ten perfections in this section (the threefold collection of precepts, restraint · gathering the good · gathering beings, and the rest) Chengguan says again and again 「已如十地」 tr. “already as in the Ten Grounds” 〔T35n1735 0903c12; at the end of the passage on the ten patiences he writes 「餘如前判」 tr. “for the rest, as judged before” 〔0902b20〕〕, and of the dividing of the four evennesses by the three grounds, 「已見〈十地〉」 tr. “already seen in the Ten Grounds” 〔0902c13〕; of the sense of the ten wisdoms, 「餘義如〈十行品〉所引」 tr. “for the remaining senses, as adduced in the Chapter on the Ten Practices” 〔0902c11〕. The ten perfections of this section are not newly set up; they are an outline already set up in the Ten Grounds and the Ten Practices, walked through once more at the position of equal awakening.
  • The lineage of the Huayan school treatises: T45n1866, the Huayan yisheng jiaoyi fenqi zhang 〔0485b09〕, 「故說十心以顯無盡。如離世間品及第九地說」 tr. “therefore ten minds are spoken to display inexhaustibility, as the Chapter on Detachment from the World and the ninth ground say” (the ten minds · the sense of inexhaustibility, a general adducing); T45n1868 〔0514b02〕, 「謂十佛世界海及離世間品。明十佛義是也」 tr. “namely the ocean of world-systems of the ten buddhas and the Chapter on Detachment from the World. It is this that makes clear the sense of the ten buddhas” (the sense of the ten buddhas, near to the two gates of this section, the ten kinds of seeing the buddha 〔T10n0279 0308a21〕 and the ten kinds of accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata 〔0313a15〕, yet the place adduced does not cite the scripture phrase by phrase); the Huayan jing zhigui T45n1871 〔0594c10〕, 「總別合舉名為十世。具如離世間品說」 tr. “taking the general and the particular together they are named the ten times; it is fully as the Chapter on Detachment from the World says” (the sense of the ten ages, a general adducing). All three places adduce the name of the chapter in general and do not fix the location phrase by phrase; recorded.
  • The absence in the treatises of the lineage: the She lun is adduced only at second hand through Chengguan (the sense of the perfuming of hearing 〔T35n1735 0906c08〕); a phrase-by-phrase adducing of this section in the Cheng weishi lun T31n1585 and the Yujia T30n1579 is 〔not found〕, and the absence is recorded as it stands, no attribution being forced.
  • An honest record of searches: within T45n1883 the wording 「離世間品」 tr. “the Chapter on Detachment from the World” yields mechanically no hits; this does not prove that the treatise does not touch this chapter, but only that this manner of searching yielded no hit.

VIII. Edition Location Register

  • Śikṣānanda, T279 (the base text): chapter 38, Detachment from the World · the sixth section of the part of the speaking, the fifty-one gates of the practice of the perfected cause and the fulfilled fruit, fascicles 57 to 59, beginning 〔T10n0279 0304a11〕 and ending 〔0313b29, ending before this〕. The sources of the opening sentences of the gates: gate 1, contemplation, 0304a11 · gate 2, universal contemplation, 0304a21 · gate 3, rousing might, 0304b04 · gate 4, the lion’s roar, 0304b22 · gate 5, pure giving, 0304c22 · gate 6, pure precepts, 0305a01 · gate 7, pure patience, 0305a12 · gate 8, pure vigor, 0305a23 · gate 9, pure meditation, 0305b13 · gate 10, pure wisdom, 0305b23 · gate 11, pure loving-kindness, 0305c08 · gate 12, pure compassion, 0305c20 · gate 13, pure joy, 0306a05 · gate 14, pure equanimity, 0306a16 · gate 15, meaning, 0306b04 · gate 16, dharma, 0306b12 · gate 17, the equipment of merit that aids the path, 0306b21 · gate 18, the equipment of wisdom that aids the path, 0306c13 · gate 19, clarity and footing, 0307a25 · gate 20, seeking the Dharma, 0307b04 · gate 21, dharmas clearly understood, 0307b13 · gate 22, dharmas of cultivation, 0307c01 · gate 23, māra, 0307c11 · gate 24, the deeds of māra, 0307c17 · gate 25, forsaking the deeds of māra, 0308a10 · gate 26, seeing the buddha, 0308a21 · gate 27, the deeds of a buddha, 0308a27 · gate 28, the deeds of conceit, 0308b29 · gate 29, the deeds of wisdom, 0308c24 · gate 30, being held by māra, 0309a14 · gate 31, being held by the buddhas, 0309a20 · gate 32, being held by the Dharma, 0309b03 · gate 33, the deeds done in the Tuṣita heaven, 0309b17 · gate 34, ten things manifested in descending to birth, 0310a19 · gate 35, ten matters of dwelling in the womb, 0310c27 · gate 36, the exceedingly subtle resorts, 0311b01 · gate 37, ten kinds of birth, 0311b11 · gate 38, smiling and inwardly vowing, 0311b21 · gate 39, walking seven steps, 0311c14 · gate 40, dwelling in the stage of a youth, 0311c23 · gate 41, manifesting dwelling in the royal palace, 0312a09 · gate 42, manifesting the leaving of home, 0312a22 · gate 43, manifesting the practice of austerities, 0312b02 · gate 44, going to the place of the Way, 0312b12 · gate 45, sitting at the place of the Way, 0312b26 · gate 46, the unprecedented matters, 0312c07 · gate 47, manifesting the subduing of māra, 0313a03 · gate 48, accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata, 0313a15 · gate 49, turning the great wheel of the Dharma, 0313a28 · gate 50, sowing the white and pure dharmas, 0313b09 · gate 51, manifesting parinirvāṇa, 0313b16. The fascicle bounds: fascicle 58 begins before gate 5 〔0304c22, before this〕 · fascicle 59 begins before gate 35 〔0310c27, before this〕.
  • Chengguan, Huayan jing shu T35n1735: the outline of this section begins 0902a01 and ends before 0907a05. The bone of the outline 0902a01–a11 · the explanation of gates 1 and 2, 0902a12–a17 · gate 3, 0902a17–a20 · gate 4, 0902a20–a22 · the general sense of the ten perfections 0902a22–a27 · the ten givings 0902a27–b10 · the ten precepts 0902b10–b16 · the ten patiences 0902b16–b21 · the ten vigors 0902b21–b27 · the ten meditations 0902b27–c04 · the ten wisdoms 0902c04–c11 · the general sense of the four evennesses 0902c11–c14 · loving-kindness, compassion, joy, and equanimity 0902c14–c22 · the outline of the eight gates of cultivation 0902c22–c25 · the ten meanings 0902c25–a03 · the ten dharmas 0903a03–a10 · the two kinds of equipment that aids the path 0903a10–b14 · clarity and footing 0903b14–b21 · seeking the Dharma 0903b21–b27 · dharmas clearly understood 0903b27–c23 · dharmas of cultivation 0903c23–c25 · the outline of the ten gates of leaving obstruction behind 0903c25–c29 · the ten māras 0904a01–a10 · the ten deeds of māra 0904a10–a20 · forsaking the deeds of māra 0904a20–a27 · the outline of the two gates of seeing the buddha and the completion of practice 0904a27–b02. The middle section: the deeds of a buddha 0904c01–c02 · the outline of the five gates of the sustaining that comes of leaving obstruction behind 0904c25–c26 · the ten conceits 0905a25 · the ten deeds of wisdom 0905a26 · the outline of the three gates of sustaining from without 0905b01–b02 · being held by the buddhas 0905b06–b07 · the Dharma’s holding 0905b08–b10 · the outline of the nineteen gates of the fulfilled use of the fruit 0905b10–b15 · the ten matters of entering the womb 0905c01–c02 · the subtle resorts 0905c19–c22 · the ten kinds of birth 0905c22–c24 · the smile 0905c24–c25 · walking seven steps 0906a03–a05 · the outline of the two gates of the stage of a youth 0906a05–a07 · the outline of the two gates of leaving home 0906a12–a13. The last section: austerities 0906a22–b01 · the outline of the five gates of going to the place of the Way 0906b01–b04 · sitting at the place of the Way 0906b04–b09 · the unprecedented 0906b09–b10 · subduing māra 0906b10–b21 · accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata 0906b21–b26 · the outline of the two gates of turning the wheel of the Dharma 0906b26–c04 · sowing the white and pure dharmas 0906c04–c15 · the ten senses of nirvāṇa 0906c15–0907a05.
  • The Yanyi chao T36n1736: the divergent reckoning of the number of gates of cause and fruit 0128a20–a22 · the explanation of the two titles of the name of the chapter 0128a23–a25.
  • Fazang, Tanxuan ji T35n1733 (the commentary on the sixty · fascicle 17): the outline begins 0434c27 and what is here recorded ends 0435b21. The bone of the outline 0434c27–0435a05 · gate 1, 0435a07–a13 · gate 2, 0435a13–a19 · gate 3, 0435a19–a23 · gate 4, 0435a23–a29 · the ten givings 0435a29–b03 · the ten precepts 0435b03–b07 · the ten patiences 0435b07–b11 · the ten vigors 0435b11–b15 · the ten meditations 0435b15–b19 · the ten wisdoms 0435b19–b21. What follows b21 is not recorded.
  • Li Tongxuan, Lun T36n1739: 〔not found〕, no gate-by-gate explanation. Two scattered adducings: the eight aspects all in one time 0772c10–c24 · the adducing of this chapter to explain birth from a womb 0807b03–b07.
  • Dharmarakṣa, T292, the Dushipin jing (the separately circulating recension): fascicles 5 to 6 (the title of fascicle 5 stands at 0644a04, and the questions of this round begin at a07). The fifty-one questions of the last round 0644a07–a22 · Samantabhadra receiving the request and beginning his answer 0644a23 · the ten matters of beholding 0644a25–b05 · the ten lookings round 0644b06–b15 · the eighth to the tenth matters of the descent to birth from the Tuṣita heaven 0650b20–0650c07 · the closing phrase of turning the pure and white dharma 0653a25 · the ten senses of taking the great extinction and crossing over 0653a27–b08 · the phrase naming the gate of Dharma 0653b09.
  • Buddhabhadra, T278 (the Jin translation of the sixty-fascicle Avataṃsaka · the sixth to the eighth parts of chapter 33, Detachment from the World · fascicles 41 to 43): the corresponding stretch for this section begins 〔T09n0278 0659a17〕 and ends 〔0669b12〕. The anchors of the opening of each gate: gate 1, contemplation, 0659a17 · gate 2, universal contemplation, 0659a29 · gate 3, rousing might, 0659b14 · gate 4, the lion’s roar, 0659c05 · gate 5, pure giving, 0659c25 · gate 6, pure precepts, 0660a07 · gate 7, pure patience, 0660a18 · gate 8, pure vigor, 0660a29 · gate 9, pure meditation, 0660b22 · gate 10, pure wisdom, 0660c06 · gate 11, pure loving-kindness, 0660c21 · gate 12, pure compassion, 0661a04 · gate 13, pure joy, 0661a26 · gate 14, pure equanimity, 0661b10 · gate 15, meaning, 0661b24 · gate 16, dharma, 0661c04 · gate 17, the equipment of merit that aids the path, 0661c14 · gate 18, the equipment of wisdom that aids the path, 0662a04 · gate 19, clarity and footing, 0662b16 · gate 20, seeking the Dharma, 0662b26 · gate 21, dharmas clearly understood, 0662c08 · gate 22, dharmas of cultivation, 0662c25 · gate 23, māra, 0663a06 · gate 24, the deeds of māra, 0663a13 · gate 25, forsaking the deeds of māra, 0663b07 · gate 26, seeing the buddha, 0663b18 · gate 27, the deeds of a buddha, 0663b25 · gate 28, the deeds of conceit, 0663c29 · gate 29, the deeds of wisdom, 0664b05 · gate 30, being held by māra, 0664b25 · gate 31, being held by the buddhas, 0664c05 · gate 32, being held by the Dharma, 0664c18 · gate 33, the ten deeds done in the Tuṣita heaven, 0665a03 · gate 34, ten things manifested in descending to birth, 0665c10 · gate 35, ten matters of dwelling in the womb, 0666b16 · gate 36, the exceedingly subtle resorts, 0666c18 · gate 37, ten kinds of birth, 0667a09 · gate 38, smiling and inwardly vowing, 0667a20 · gate 39, walking seven steps, 0667b14 · gate 40, dwelling in the stage of a youth, 0667b24 · gate 41, manifesting dwelling in the royal palace, 0667c09 · gate 42, manifesting the leaving of home, 0667c22 · gate 43, manifesting the practice of austerities, 0668a04 · gate 44, going to the place of the Way, 0668a16 · gate 45, sitting at the place of the Way, 0668b03 · gate 46, the unprecedented matters of sitting at the place of the Way, 0668b13 · gate 47, manifesting the subduing of māra, 0668c10 · gate 48, accomplishing the powers of a Tathāgata, 0668c23 · gate 49, the ten matters of turning the great wheel of the Dharma, 0669a08 · gate 50, the ten matters of sowing the white and pure dharmas, 0669a18 · gate 51, manifesting parinirvāṇa, 0669a26. For the gate-names according to the Jin recension see Collation Two of the fourth heading.
  • The forty-fascicle Avataṃsaka T293: 〔not found〕. That translation has only chapter 39.
  • Variant readings: within the range of T279 covered by this unit, 〔0304a11〕–〔0313b28〕, the Taishō base text carries 32 collation notes, recorded one by one without adjudication (base reading 【大】|variant readings of other witnesses, several witnesses separated by /): 〔0304b07〕耀【大】|曜【宮】 · 〔0304b10〕㲉【大】|聲【聖】 · 〔0304b13〕怨【大】*|冤【明】*(*同校並繫〔0304b20〕之怨字) · 〔0304c23〕揀【大】|簡【宮】 · 〔0305a07〕善【大】|菩【聖】 · 〔0305a24〕師【大】|佛【聖】 · 〔0305a28〕心【大】|一【聖】 · 〔0305b17〕禪【大】|離【聖】 · 〔0305c03〕法【大】|清【聖】 · 〔0305c10〕揀【大】|簡【宮】【聖】 · 〔0306c16〕獷【大】|曠【宮】 · 〔0307a04〕霓【大】|蜺【宮】 · 〔0307c21〕吝【大】|悕【聖】 · 〔0307c29〕使【大】|使使【聖】 · 〔0308a02〕術【大】|述【宋】【元】【明】【宮】【聖】 · 〔0308c14〕顰【大】|嚬【宮】【聖】 · 〔0310a18〕間【大】|聞【聖】 · 〔0310a24〕于【大】|於【明】 · 〔0310b05〕徙【大】|從【聖】 · 〔0310b13〕妓【大】|伎【聖】 · 〔0310b15〕卍【大】|卐【宋】【元】【明】 · 〔0310c12〕曰:眼【大】|日眼【元】/曰月【明】 · 〔0311b23〕免【大】|勉【宋】【元】【明】 · 〔0311c09〕同共【大】|共同【宋】【元】【明】【宮】 · 〔0312a17〕妓【大】|伎【聖】 · 〔0312b13〕耀【大】*|曜【宮】*(*同校並繫〔0312b28〕之耀字) · 〔0312b26〕有【大】|時有【宮】 · 〔0312b27〕謂【大】|詣【聖】 · 〔0312b27〕震【大】|振【聖】 · 〔0312c01〕觀【大】|現【明】/觀【北藏-CB】(明註曰現北藏作觀) · 〔0313a16〕業【大】|無此字【聖】 · 〔0313b26〕別【大】|莂【明】/䇷【宮】. (* = a Taishō asterisked collation: the same note also governs the remaining occurrences of that graph in the text; for notes of this class the T279 XML supplies no corresp for the recurrences, so the asterisk alone is shown and no second anchor is created.)
  • Notes of the original printing, recorded for the record: 3 items (notes of the original Taishō printing / CBETA editorial remarks, carrying no <app> collation and not counted among the Taishō collation notes listed above): 〔0309a01+〕宮本魔波乃至一切一千二百二十三字斷缺 p. 310 C段第二行參照 · 〔0309a01+〕明註曰流通本他下有眾字 · 〔0312b27+〕以下聖語藏副本校合.
  • A further note upon the variant readings: 5 CBETA emendations (not counted among the Taishō collation notes listed above): 〔0304b23〕師【CB】【麗-CB】【磧-CB】|佛【大】 · 〔0307a29〕天【CB】【麗-CB】|大【大】/天【宋】【元】【明】 · 〔0308b03〕吝【CB】【麗-CB】|悋【大】 · 〔0311b23〕沒【CB】【麗-CB】|歿【大】 · 〔0312b10〕行;為令眾生……示行苦行(凡18字)【CB】|行【大】/行為令眾生樂……示行苦行(凡18字)【明】.
  • Supplementary note on variant readings: three further Taishō printed notes have no corresponding app entry and are recorded by title: 0309001 「宮本魔波乃至一切一千二百二十三字斷缺」 tr. “in the Palace recension, from mo-po to yi-qie, one thousand two hundred and twenty-three graphs are missing” (beginning at 〔T10n0279 0309c17〕) · 0309002 「明註曰流通本他下有眾字」 tr. “the Ming edition notes that in the circulating edition there is the graph zhong after ta” 〔0309c23〕 · 0312007 「以下聖語藏副本校合」 tr. “from here on collated with the duplicate copy of the Shōgozō” 〔0312b29〕. Interlinear notes were stripped and recorded at the layer of the source text. In 「破愚癡㲉」 tr. “breaking open the shell of delusion” 〔T10n0279 0304b10, within the passage〕, the 「㲉」 tr. “shell” is a CBETA-coined character, and is recorded as it stands without normalization. The base text’s 「無有瘡疣、無有瘢痕」 tr. “without sore or wart, without scar or mark” 〔0307a13, within the passage〕 has the two characters 「瘢痕」 tr. “scar and mark” with no coined character; Chengguan’s Shu, explaining this phrase, writes 「餘過未滅為瘢󰇝」 tr. “the remaining faults not yet extinguished are the scar and mark” 〔T35n1735 0903b09〕, whose 「󰇝」 tr. “mark” is a coined character, and it too is recorded as it stands.

Translator · 釋慧鏡 Shi Huijing. The full statement of AI's role across the 指月 project is maintained at methodology.

License · CC BY-NC-SA 4.0